Life’s A Beach by Portia MacIntosh, ready by Karen Cass is a 2021 Boldwood Books publication. Cass’s narration was excellent. Male and female voices were well-defined. I especially liked the lightly accented lilt of Peach’s voice.
I can’t think of a time I’ve rated a rom-com higher than four stars, and until a little over halfway into Life’s A Beach, I was thinking I had found a unicorn and would rate this book five stars because it was so witty and entertaining with a great story and characters.
Peach – thirtyish mystery shopper – meets the man of her imagination, Matt, when she’s at the airport to pickup her younger sister, Di. When Di’s plane is delayed overnight, Peach and Matt end up getting acquainted intimately (wink, wink), but by morning he’s only a memory.
Two weeks later, She’s on the Italian coast for her sister’s impromptu wedding. Can you guess who the best man is?
And that’s only the beginning of awkward situations when the guest list bears ex-boyfriends and one-night stands in attendance.
________________
This story was everything I could want in a fantastic rom-com. Peach was funny, intelligent, and confident – an all-around likeable heroine. She was dealing with realistic situations and had relatively normal parents and sister. Matt was charming and sincere, not at all like a reprobate. Peach and Matt showed the chemistry and spark of a new couple seriously attracted to one another. The humor was fun, witty, perfect.
By the time all the characters were on the island and connections were explained, the drama had reached a level that required suspension of reality to be believable. Which wasn’t too bad, since this was a rom-com, but it was that so many characters had slept with each other in the past. I’m not talking about cheating here, just past relationships however brief they may have been. This intimate sharing among the group kind of grossed me out.
Miscommunication trope was used here. Initially it worked for the couple, but it when it was used a second time, I began to lose interest. It tainted my enjoyment of their relationship.
Secrets were kept hidden; this didn’t feel right to me. The theme seemed to be that some details or connections should not be revealed, even to someone you are close to and who would be emotionally affected by knowing that information. Had I been in this situation with a person keeping this secret from me, I would have felt grossly betrayed by the secret keeper, more so than by the fact they kept, were the secret ever revealed.
Some of the male characters were on the sleazy side. Their past behavior was accepted and forgiven too quickly and lightly for me. And the total reversal of one man from never having more than sexual encounters to fully committed to one woman in a matter of weeks seemed unlikely, and no reason was given to support this sudden change of behavior.
What started out as a fantastic promising read in the first half of the book, turned into overly dramatic partner swap reveal in the second part. This overshadowed the romance and left me feeling unsatisfied.