A journey through the uncomputable remains of computer history
Narrating some lesser known episodes from the deep history of digital machines, Alexander Galloway explains the technology that drives the world today, and the fascinating people who brought these machines to life. With an eye to both the computable and the uncomputable, Galloway shows how computation emerges or fails to emerge, how the digital thrives but also atrophies, how networks interconnect while also fray and fall apart. By re-building obsolete technology using today’s software, the past comes to light in new ways, from intricate algebraic patterns woven on a hand loom, to striking artificial-life simulations, to war games and back boxes. A description of the past, this book is also an assessment of all that remains uncomputable as we continue to live in the aftermath of the long digital age.
If you liked this you'll also like my mother was a computer by Katherine Hayles and On the mode of existence of technical objects by gilbert Simondon. The book does a good job of explaining uncomputable problems and factors in society (such as numbers with infinite complexity) as well as situating the trends historically.
The introduction and the end of the book are the most insightful - there are numerous quotable moments in just the first few pages. The chapters in between however are pretty descriptive, maybe not to a fault - they were probably meant to be anecdotal accounts of neglected / forgotten history. But I guess I was slightly disappointed only because the introduction had set me up for a different set of expectations. This book is not the kind of heavy deconstruction that you'd come to expect if you'd read some of Galloway's other books. I still thoroughly enjoyed it though, and I actually think that the introduction alone is worth the price of the book.
Galloway is a great thinker and writer - moreso in this book than earlier efforts IMO. Both extremely readable and dense, and thoughtfully mapping themes across various different historical moments. You have to do a little bit of work to pick out the "uncomputable" in some of these sections (and the intro + conclusion are best for actually considering it). I love to think with/against Galloway, his writing feels like it is a toolbox - a set of approaches for understanding and critiquing our world. I particularly liked his approach to the analog/digital divide
Having read Galloway's The Interface Effect previously, this book continues a similar kind of capital-T Theory with a more historical and descriptive approach. Galloway has a nice knack of theorizing *along with* the historical and anecdotal accounts that he very colourfully describes. But I think there's a limit as to how truly accurately obsolete/obscure technologies can be described in print form. There are some superb insights, though sometimes having to 'get there' by means of the technological descriptions can be a little tedious.
It's a book that demands a second or third reading, but at the same time isn't necessarily unified enough to keep someone's attention for a second or third read. A solid 3.5, but rounded up because the good parts are very good.
Note: In a stroke of serendipity, I read this book at the same time as The MANIAC by Benjamin Labatut. There's a remarkable degree of overlap in terms of historical content (von Neumann and his associates take up two of Galloway's six chapters), and it really did further my understanding of both books. I can wholeheartedly recommend that as a 'companion' read of sorts.