I don't like leaving project reads like these unfinished, but from where I stand, the rewards simply don't justify the investment needed. The prospect of another eight hundred pages of Johnson's oblique cultural meanderings simply doesn't excite me like it did in August of last year.
I finished Volume One of Anniversaries about a week after the chronological date with which the author ends it, after nearly eight months of daily readings (with the occasion deviations from the it's dated sequence). In that time, I can to regard Johnson's narrators - the titular Gesine Cresspahl, her daughter Marie, and her father Heinrich - as distant acquaintances rather than close friends. Given the remarkable latitude he's given himself to explore their lives, Johnson seems surprisingly disinterested in exploring their interiority, and would rather examine the culture of two juxtaposed eras (the forties and the sixties).
Now you may read that and recognise the makings of a systems novel, and at first glance, I would agree with you. But I simply found that neither of his projects - the psychological profile and the cultural post-mortem - are delivered in an engaging way. His command of perspective is deliberately fractured and unstable, resulting in an unclear position as to what he actually thinks about the world he's cataloguing. The use of an ever shifting narratorial perspective is an interesting formal experiment, sure, but never allowed me to feel like I truly got inside the mind of any single character. The entire time I felt very distinctly like an outsider looking in...
...and maybe that's the point. Perhaps alienation was the intended position for his audience and reflects what he felt as a man of the postwar era himself; I'm in no position to confirm this. But as one of those readers, I spent over eight hundred pages looking for an entry point I never found. While there were remarkable passages and moments of clear-eyed, elevated prose, I'm going to hold off on finishing Volume Two of Anniversaries until such a time as I've knock off more a few more of my more immediate TBRs. Maybe that'll be by the end of this year, maybe next, maybe never.
To those who stuck along with me for the serialised group read, I enjoyed your company and conversation, and hope you got more out of it than I did. If you finish it and think the second volume may be more engaging than the first, drop me a line. I'd love to hear from you.