"If we understand the mechanisms and motives of the group mind it is now possible to control and regiment the masses according to our will without their knowing it. from Propaganda by Edward Bernays quoted on page 58
This book is both disturbing, comforting, and probably the most controversial book I've read this year. It's written by a highly opinionated journalist and her biases come out at times which is a clear flaw BUT despite that I think it is still a very important book.
The average person will strongly disagree with the conclusions of this book and the points I state below summarising it, but please pause and reflect on the figures and the context and the facts, don't take your initial reaction as your conclusion.
The thesis of the book is that (1) from March 2020 until the present day the UK government has intentionally worked to keep the population terrified in order to keep us compliant with guidance and regulations. AND (2) this has been extremely harmful, unjustifiable and morally reprehensible.
In the UK in 2020 we had our highest death rate since.... 2008, and yet many thought we were living through an apocalypse - an attitude no one had in 2008. Why such a difference in perception?
Covid-19 is an unpleasant virus BUT if you're under 65 your risk of death upon catching it was less than 1%, shrinking as low as 0.1% for under 40s (numbers from Imperial college London Covid-19 report 34, quoted on page 268).
Why have we been told Covid death numbers every day for 16 months almost never with the context of the 1500+ deaths that would occur on a normal non-covid day in the UK? Why do we all suddenly want the government to keep us safe from death, something they're not capable of doing? As Laura says on page 267 "If you don't accept that you will die one day, that you can never be safe, then you are a sitting duck for authoritarian policies which purport to be for your safety."
For this book Laura interviewed scientists, government advisors, politicians, civil liberty campaigners, doctors and normal individuals affected in various ways; she has also read a lot of the literature from every side.
This book documents:
1. How the media and the UK government worked to make the British people terrified of Covid
2. The use of bad science, exaggerations, guesses and outright lies to produce compliance with Covid regulations.
3. The censorship and suppression of highly qualified scientists who disagreed with the narrative.
4. The repeated breaches of normal ethical standards for the use of psychology and advertising to influence people.
5. The religious nature of it - from the government sponsored "clap for carers" (started "spontaneously" by a lady with a friend at 10 downing street...) to the use of masks often more as a visual cue of adherence than any medical purpose.
6. The effects and serious harms done by all of this - adding up all of the "side effects" of covid measures used in the UK and the knock-ons they will have over the coming years they are likely to kill several times the number of people who've died of the virus. In fact the Covid measures are likely (over some years) to cost more lives than even the early worst case estimates of Covid deaths.
The personal touch
After each chapter there's a personal story recounting how an individual has been affected, in some ways these are a propaganda trick, telling you that some percentage of our youth are now on anti-depressants who weren't before doesn't strike home the same as reading the account of a mother finding her son after he attempted suicide, page 194.
Using personal stories like this is manipulative and pushes you to make an emotional response rather than just responding to the presented facts. But - for the last 16 months the media has been full of stories of individuals suffering from or dying of covid, stories cynically used to increase compliance with regulations, to reduce complaints and to persuade us to overlook the suffering caused by the regulations and guidance.
Why you should read this:
- this is the single biggest issue of our time
- unless you've been living under a rock you've been served a hefty dose of propaganda daily for over a year - this book gives you the other side
- this gives you some interesting insight into how group psychology works
Questions not answered
- why did our government implement such policies?
- why did they carry on with them for over a year when there is no solid evidence they worked?
- why did they lie to us, and manipulate data to make lockdowns look far more effective than the actual evidence says?
Laura doesn't answer these questions - as there are no certain answers, the best guess is an initial panic followed by an extreme case of the sunk cost fallacy.