What do you think?
Rate this book
The Bennet Wardrobe #1
The Keeper: Mary Bennet's Extraordinary Journey
Mary Bennet has spent her entire life fighting to be herself. If only she knew just what that was. For years she buried her nose in the musty musing of Fordyce’s Sermons to Young Women trying to be exceptional. She suffered under her mother’s withering criticism of her looks. She was tormented by both her older as well as her younger sisters. Her father ignored everything and did nothing to guide her or encourage her.
Now, both Jane and Lizzy have married, and it is time for Miss Bennet to emerge from her cocoon. Soon, a young woman of deep faith and inquisitive mind appears. Yet, even as Mary Bennet rises from her troubled teenage years, she is challenged by her sudden and total love for a man who mysteriously appears on the night of a great calamity. And his secret grows out of a remarkable device—The Bennet Wardrobe!
Follow the story of Mary Bennet as she matures from the prosy, moralizing caricature found in Jane Austen’s classic Pride and Prejudice into a confident young woman looking to make her mark in the rapidly changing world of the Industrial Revolution. And, see how the amazing Bennet Wardrobe makes life for all Bennets very interesting.
This is Volume 1 of a planned four volume series. The Exile (Vol 2) will watch Kitty Bennet navigate the world from 1886 to 1944. The Pilgrim (vol 3) will explore the story of Lydia Bennet. The Avenger (Vol. 4) will show how Thomas Bennet assumes his rightful role as head of the Bennet family.
Now, both Jane and Lizzy have married, and it is time for Miss Bennet to emerge from her cocoon. Soon, a young woman of deep faith and inquisitive mind appears. Yet, even as Mary Bennet rises from her troubled teenage years, she is challenged by her sudden and total love for a man who mysteriously appears on the night of a great calamity. And his secret grows out of a remarkable device—The Bennet Wardrobe!
Follow the story of Mary Bennet as she matures from the prosy, moralizing caricature found in Jane Austen’s classic Pride and Prejudice into a confident young woman looking to make her mark in the rapidly changing world of the Industrial Revolution. And, see how the amazing Bennet Wardrobe makes life for all Bennets very interesting.
This is Volume 1 of a planned four volume series. The Exile (Vol 2) will watch Kitty Bennet navigate the world from 1886 to 1944. The Pilgrim (vol 3) will explore the story of Lydia Bennet. The Avenger (Vol. 4) will show how Thomas Bennet assumes his rightful role as head of the Bennet family.
392 pages, Kindle Edition
First published May 16, 2017
82 people are currently reading
149 people want to read
About the author
Don Jacobson
22 books111 followersDon Jacobson has written professionally for forty years. His output has ranged from news and features to advertising, television, and radio. His work has been nominated for Emmys and other awards. He has previously published five books, all non-fiction.
He now exclusively writes Austenesque fiction. In 2016, he published The Keeper: Mary Bennet’s Extraordinary Journey which began the Bennet Wardrobe saga.
Subsequent books in the series include:
Henry Fitzwilliam's War (e-novelette) (2016)
The Exile: Kitty Bennet and the Belle Epoch (2017)
Lizzy Bennet Meets the Countess (2017)
The Exile: The countess Visits Longbourn (2018)
The Avenger: Thomas Bennet and a Father's Lament (2018)
The Pilgrim: Lydia Bennet and a Soldier's Portion (2019)
The Grail: The Saving of Elizabeth Darcy (2022)
His entry in the North and South Anthology...Falling for Mr. Thornton entitled Cinders and Smokewas released in November 2019.
In 2018, he also published Lessers and Betters a novel-length Pride and Prejudice variation which contains the paired novellas Of Fortune's Reversal and The Maid and The Footman. These two works examine the same event (the mysterious attack on Kitty Bennet in Hyde Park on Guy Fawkes Day 1815) from two different perspectives: that of the gentry and that of the servants.
Meryton Press published two of his books in 2020--In Plain Sight (June) and The Longbourn Quarantine (August). Meryton Press also agreed to republish his entire self-published catalog (The Bennet Wardrobe series and Lessers and Betters) throughout 2021.
Meryton Press has published new editions of all of the Bennet Wardrobe books.
Jacobson holds an advanced degree in History with a specialty in American Foreign Relations. As a college instructor, Don taught United States History, World History, the History of Western Civilization and Research Writing.
He is a member of the Jane Austen Society of North America. He is also a member of the Regency Romance writers' collective Austen Authors.
He lives in Las Vegas, NV with his wife and co-author, Pam ( Roadcookin': A long-haul driver's guide to healthy eating), a woman Ms. Austen would have been hard-pressed to categorize, and their rather assertive four-and-twenty pound cat, Bear. Besides thoroughly immersing himself in the JAFF world, Don also enjoys cooking (Poulet au vinaigre is a particular favorite), dining out, fine wine, and well-aged scotch whiskey (Glenmorangie 18-Year-Old single malt--the water of life).
His other passion is cycling. Most days from April through October will find him “putting in the miles”. He has ridden several “centuries” (100 mile days). Don is especially proud that he successfully completed the AIDS Ride—Midwest (500 miles from Minneapolis to Chicago) and the Make-A-Wish Miracle Ride (300 miles from Traverse City, MI to Brooklyn, MI).
He now exclusively writes Austenesque fiction. In 2016, he published The Keeper: Mary Bennet’s Extraordinary Journey which began the Bennet Wardrobe saga.
Subsequent books in the series include:
Henry Fitzwilliam's War (e-novelette) (2016)
The Exile: Kitty Bennet and the Belle Epoch (2017)
Lizzy Bennet Meets the Countess (2017)
The Exile: The countess Visits Longbourn (2018)
The Avenger: Thomas Bennet and a Father's Lament (2018)
The Pilgrim: Lydia Bennet and a Soldier's Portion (2019)
The Grail: The Saving of Elizabeth Darcy (2022)
His entry in the North and South Anthology...Falling for Mr. Thornton entitled Cinders and Smokewas released in November 2019.
In 2018, he also published Lessers and Betters a novel-length Pride and Prejudice variation which contains the paired novellas Of Fortune's Reversal and The Maid and The Footman. These two works examine the same event (the mysterious attack on Kitty Bennet in Hyde Park on Guy Fawkes Day 1815) from two different perspectives: that of the gentry and that of the servants.
Meryton Press published two of his books in 2020--In Plain Sight (June) and The Longbourn Quarantine (August). Meryton Press also agreed to republish his entire self-published catalog (The Bennet Wardrobe series and Lessers and Betters) throughout 2021.
Meryton Press has published new editions of all of the Bennet Wardrobe books.
Jacobson holds an advanced degree in History with a specialty in American Foreign Relations. As a college instructor, Don taught United States History, World History, the History of Western Civilization and Research Writing.
He is a member of the Jane Austen Society of North America. He is also a member of the Regency Romance writers' collective Austen Authors.
He lives in Las Vegas, NV with his wife and co-author, Pam ( Roadcookin': A long-haul driver's guide to healthy eating), a woman Ms. Austen would have been hard-pressed to categorize, and their rather assertive four-and-twenty pound cat, Bear. Besides thoroughly immersing himself in the JAFF world, Don also enjoys cooking (Poulet au vinaigre is a particular favorite), dining out, fine wine, and well-aged scotch whiskey (Glenmorangie 18-Year-Old single malt--the water of life).
His other passion is cycling. Most days from April through October will find him “putting in the miles”. He has ridden several “centuries” (100 mile days). Don is especially proud that he successfully completed the AIDS Ride—Midwest (500 miles from Minneapolis to Chicago) and the Make-A-Wish Miracle Ride (300 miles from Traverse City, MI to Brooklyn, MI).
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 45 reviews
December 8, 2016
The world of Austenesque fiction is huge and diverse, and I have especially welcomed an increase in male contributors to the genre. They tend to bring a different focus to the material, often incorporating political and social elements that are generally only latent in the original novels. For modern readers who might overlook these layers of meaning in Jane Austen’s work, stories of this type can be an enriching overlay on the canon. Mr. Jacobson’s first novel in the Bennet Wardrobe series is comfortably ensconced in this category.
The novel begins with the famous seventeenth-century wood carver Grinling Gibbons fashioning a wardrobe for the patriarch of the Bennet clan. Under Jacobson’s pen, Gibbons becomes a philosopher of the arcane, who builds properties into the wardrobe that allow people of Bennet blood to travel in time—under certain rules and restrictions. These rules are never given a rational basis; they seem to have been created to further and direct the plot. This opening premise, however, presented opportunities for magical elements in the story that were mostly missed—Bennets do travel in time, but for the most part we don’t travel with them.
We glance over a few generations of Bennets before alighting in the early nineteenth century and narrowing our focus to the overlooked middle child of canon, Mary Bennet. The action begins where Pride and Prejudice ends, and immediately Mary’s character takes a sharp turn. The novel follows her life through a Forrest Gump–style series of close encounters with history that span about half the nineteenth century.
This is not drawing-room comedy by any manner of means. We see little of the social interactions of the ladies, as most of the characters act in the public sphere. It is also not romance, though there is a love element (of a rather instantaneous kind that will not satisfy those who crave longing glances and long-drawn-out misunderstandings). Some characters from the original become gothic caricatures of themselves and others “find” themselves in ways more modern than period. But the action is swashbuckling and almost nonstop, so the book will keep you moving smartly from scene to scene.
My personal enjoyment of this novel outstripped the rating I have given it. I liked the historical contexts and the wealth of incident, and I was engaged by many of the new characters. The groundedness in Church-of-England religiosity was true to the period and an element often shirked by modern adapters. I knocked off a star because the author’s grasp of Regency language, manners, and mores was not up to the level of his grasp of history. And I knocked off another star because the plot felt rambling and episodic, not tightly constructed along thematic lines. I admire the enthusiasm that brought so many elements and events into the tale, but wish some had been saved for another book and others had felt less like a catalog of moments. The climactic scene is straight out of a different genre of fiction, and I would have preferred a more euphemistic approach.
Despite these cavils, I believed the characters (mostly) and was eager to take this ride with them. A very unusual contribution to the Austenesque genre!
The novel begins with the famous seventeenth-century wood carver Grinling Gibbons fashioning a wardrobe for the patriarch of the Bennet clan. Under Jacobson’s pen, Gibbons becomes a philosopher of the arcane, who builds properties into the wardrobe that allow people of Bennet blood to travel in time—under certain rules and restrictions. These rules are never given a rational basis; they seem to have been created to further and direct the plot. This opening premise, however, presented opportunities for magical elements in the story that were mostly missed—Bennets do travel in time, but for the most part we don’t travel with them.
We glance over a few generations of Bennets before alighting in the early nineteenth century and narrowing our focus to the overlooked middle child of canon, Mary Bennet. The action begins where Pride and Prejudice ends, and immediately Mary’s character takes a sharp turn. The novel follows her life through a Forrest Gump–style series of close encounters with history that span about half the nineteenth century.
This is not drawing-room comedy by any manner of means. We see little of the social interactions of the ladies, as most of the characters act in the public sphere. It is also not romance, though there is a love element (of a rather instantaneous kind that will not satisfy those who crave longing glances and long-drawn-out misunderstandings). Some characters from the original become gothic caricatures of themselves and others “find” themselves in ways more modern than period. But the action is swashbuckling and almost nonstop, so the book will keep you moving smartly from scene to scene.
My personal enjoyment of this novel outstripped the rating I have given it. I liked the historical contexts and the wealth of incident, and I was engaged by many of the new characters. The groundedness in Church-of-England religiosity was true to the period and an element often shirked by modern adapters. I knocked off a star because the author’s grasp of Regency language, manners, and mores was not up to the level of his grasp of history. And I knocked off another star because the plot felt rambling and episodic, not tightly constructed along thematic lines. I admire the enthusiasm that brought so many elements and events into the tale, but wish some had been saved for another book and others had felt less like a catalog of moments. The climactic scene is straight out of a different genre of fiction, and I would have preferred a more euphemistic approach.
Despite these cavils, I believed the characters (mostly) and was eager to take this ride with them. A very unusual contribution to the Austenesque genre!
February 6, 2018
There are books that come along and seem imbued with magic. Whether it is the world of the story, the characters, the connections between characters, or just that little something extra, there is magic. Now, wasn't I pleasantly surprised when The Keeper turned out to be something of all this and had actual time-travel magic for good measure.
The Bennet Wardrobe much in the spirit of other great literary means of magical travel offers one family an opportunity to experience the world of the future just by making a wish and stepping forward. There are regulations and it all isn't roses and unicorns just because they can sally forth into the future through their magical wardrobe. Quite the possibilities, though...
In essence, this first book had the ponderous job of introducing the reader to a new world, the characters, and bring home a solid story. The Keeper managed to do all these things. It took a bit to get going as it wove through the history of the wardrobe and set up the family situation for the moment the heroine appeared on the scene. It was something of a telling rather than showing in the early pages, but I didn't mind. It suited things to bring over a hundred years of history and the backdrop together in this way and I was still able to emotionally connect and, yes, gulp back a few tears for some of the sorrows of the past.
Once, Mary Bennet that more obscure and pedantic third Bennet daughter of Pride & Prejudice fame entered stage left, I was fully engaged with the story. I've always had a soft spot for our Mary so I enjoyed seeing the duckling to swan routine take place before my eyes as Mary finds herself and settles comfortably in her own skin and within her own family.
The timing of this one when it becomes Mary's story is right after the events of Austen's Pride & Prejudice so its something of a sequel variation. There are a blend of Austen's characters and the author's original ones. The author's take on Austen's characters are rather original without going too far so that I couldn't recognize them. I loved that balance. There is a blend of sequel story taking the reader through the events of lives living the events of history in Napoleonic then Industrial Revolution era England. Historic details are there and added flavor and color to the setting without taking over and distracting from the plot.
There are plenty of pages to The Keeper that allow for the narration to develop not only the story of the family legacy with the Wardrobe and Mary, herself, but further to the whole family and its extending connections into a family saga.
I enjoyed the time of Mary making her own family connections for the first time, particularly as a daughter with her father and then strengthening her relationship with sisters and friends. Her epiphany moment on top of Oakham Mount was marvelous and so her remaking was believable as was the woman who emerged from then on. She has a romance that stays in the background as she matures into a woman of inner strength and beauty while pondering the secret her Edward is keeping. I loved seeing her stand up for herself and for others. Mary taking on Lady Catherine and Mr. Collins was a particularly triumphant. And speaking of that pair? They gave me the heebie jeebies like a good villain will do.
As I said, this felt more like a family saga and it most certainly was the foundation story to launch a series. Mary's story is there, but other stories are more than hinted at. I look forward to getting each of those fascinating younger Bennet sister's stories. I was taken with the blend of magical time travel and Austenesque sequel. The Keeper was engaging, emotionally touching, and well-written making me eager to push forward with what comes next. I can heartily recommend this book to those who love a little magic and a good grasp of historical context in their Austenesque.
The Bennet Wardrobe much in the spirit of other great literary means of magical travel offers one family an opportunity to experience the world of the future just by making a wish and stepping forward. There are regulations and it all isn't roses and unicorns just because they can sally forth into the future through their magical wardrobe. Quite the possibilities, though...
In essence, this first book had the ponderous job of introducing the reader to a new world, the characters, and bring home a solid story. The Keeper managed to do all these things. It took a bit to get going as it wove through the history of the wardrobe and set up the family situation for the moment the heroine appeared on the scene. It was something of a telling rather than showing in the early pages, but I didn't mind. It suited things to bring over a hundred years of history and the backdrop together in this way and I was still able to emotionally connect and, yes, gulp back a few tears for some of the sorrows of the past.
Once, Mary Bennet that more obscure and pedantic third Bennet daughter of Pride & Prejudice fame entered stage left, I was fully engaged with the story. I've always had a soft spot for our Mary so I enjoyed seeing the duckling to swan routine take place before my eyes as Mary finds herself and settles comfortably in her own skin and within her own family.
The timing of this one when it becomes Mary's story is right after the events of Austen's Pride & Prejudice so its something of a sequel variation. There are a blend of Austen's characters and the author's original ones. The author's take on Austen's characters are rather original without going too far so that I couldn't recognize them. I loved that balance. There is a blend of sequel story taking the reader through the events of lives living the events of history in Napoleonic then Industrial Revolution era England. Historic details are there and added flavor and color to the setting without taking over and distracting from the plot.
There are plenty of pages to The Keeper that allow for the narration to develop not only the story of the family legacy with the Wardrobe and Mary, herself, but further to the whole family and its extending connections into a family saga.
I enjoyed the time of Mary making her own family connections for the first time, particularly as a daughter with her father and then strengthening her relationship with sisters and friends. Her epiphany moment on top of Oakham Mount was marvelous and so her remaking was believable as was the woman who emerged from then on. She has a romance that stays in the background as she matures into a woman of inner strength and beauty while pondering the secret her Edward is keeping. I loved seeing her stand up for herself and for others. Mary taking on Lady Catherine and Mr. Collins was a particularly triumphant. And speaking of that pair? They gave me the heebie jeebies like a good villain will do.
As I said, this felt more like a family saga and it most certainly was the foundation story to launch a series. Mary's story is there, but other stories are more than hinted at. I look forward to getting each of those fascinating younger Bennet sister's stories. I was taken with the blend of magical time travel and Austenesque sequel. The Keeper was engaging, emotionally touching, and well-written making me eager to push forward with what comes next. I can heartily recommend this book to those who love a little magic and a good grasp of historical context in their Austenesque.
May 6, 2019
The time-travel element of this Jane Austen Fan Fiction was intriguing. Having written a historical fiction of my own which incorporates a mythical tarot card that transports the protagonist to her great great-grandmother’s house, I was sold on the author’s concept. In fact, he echoed my philosophy quite succinctly when he wrote; “Somewhere deep inside, we pray to hear those voices of the future saying ‘my great grandfather built this.’ It is that legacy that will ensure that we will never be forgotten…for is that not the deepest of all human worries—that we will have lived a life that leaves no mark deep enough to be remembered once we are no longer here?” Everything I have ever written, good or bad, is based on this idea of being connected to our roots—of honoring our ancestors and commemorating their achievements. But this review is not about my work, it’s about Don Jacobson’s work and I digress!
Mary coming into her own was endearing. I especially loved her heart wrenching epiphany on Oakham Mount. Watching her shed the heavy yokes that shaped and formed her miserable life was quite moving—inspiring, really. Once she took ownership of her life and refused to allow blame and ridicule to manipulate her actions, the concept of “Mary Alone” was laid to rest once and for all. I enjoyed Edward Benton’s story line and was heartened by Thomas Bennet’s. The author’s research and understanding of history was evident and much appreciated—making this more than simply a fan fiction but rather, an historical fiction chock-full of delightful tidbits, historical characters, and events.
There were a few cringe-worthy scenes. I didn’t care for Mr. Collins or Lady Catherine…far too depraved for my taste. And I couldn’t help but grapple with the Time/Space Continuum and ‘The Prime Directive,’ which—as any Trekkie knows—prohibits the interference with the natural development of a given time, place or situation. I’m not sure that the traveling Bennets adhered to this concept but, then again, they weren’t members of Starfleet and I am not an astrophysicist.
All in all, I was enchanted. Jacobson has given us something creative and engaging. I had placed it on my “Want to Read” list quite some time ago. I regret not having read it sooner. 4.5 stars round to 5.
Mary coming into her own was endearing. I especially loved her heart wrenching epiphany on Oakham Mount. Watching her shed the heavy yokes that shaped and formed her miserable life was quite moving—inspiring, really. Once she took ownership of her life and refused to allow blame and ridicule to manipulate her actions, the concept of “Mary Alone” was laid to rest once and for all. I enjoyed Edward Benton’s story line and was heartened by Thomas Bennet’s. The author’s research and understanding of history was evident and much appreciated—making this more than simply a fan fiction but rather, an historical fiction chock-full of delightful tidbits, historical characters, and events.
There were a few cringe-worthy scenes. I didn’t care for Mr. Collins or Lady Catherine…far too depraved for my taste. And I couldn’t help but grapple with the Time/Space Continuum and ‘The Prime Directive,’ which—as any Trekkie knows—prohibits the interference with the natural development of a given time, place or situation. I’m not sure that the traveling Bennets adhered to this concept but, then again, they weren’t members of Starfleet and I am not an astrophysicist.
All in all, I was enchanted. Jacobson has given us something creative and engaging. I had placed it on my “Want to Read” list quite some time ago. I regret not having read it sooner. 4.5 stars round to 5.
September 8, 2016
I thoroughly enjoyed this book. I was a little confused over the generations of the Bennet family at the beginning and slightly nonplussed about the relationship between Mary and her intended, I wish it had been a little more removed, but this is a piece of fiction, so who cares!
The book actually made me cry...twice!! So you can tell that I appreciated the writing. I enjoyed Mary's journey with her growing but still staying true to her inner character. I really grew to admire her in this novel. I do love this sort of book anyway, my inner Dr Who will always out, and this one was a pleasure for me. If I had the wardrobe I think I would want to use it far more than the characters in the book seem to! I am definitely going to read the others in the series; glimpses of Kitty's story are very tempting and I just have to know what on Earth happened to Lydia when she travelled in the wardrobe. The throw-away line about her appearance on return just left me screaming, "Where has she been?"
The book actually made me cry...twice!! So you can tell that I appreciated the writing. I enjoyed Mary's journey with her growing but still staying true to her inner character. I really grew to admire her in this novel. I do love this sort of book anyway, my inner Dr Who will always out, and this one was a pleasure for me. If I had the wardrobe I think I would want to use it far more than the characters in the book seem to! I am definitely going to read the others in the series; glimpses of Kitty's story are very tempting and I just have to know what on Earth happened to Lydia when she travelled in the wardrobe. The throw-away line about her appearance on return just left me screaming, "Where has she been?"
December 27, 2020
"While there are many rules that govern the use of the Bennet Wardrobe, there seem to be two that are superior to all others. The first is that there can be no travel to the past... This will prevent altering the present... The second rule is... Once a Bennet has travelled to the future, they either must remain in that future or return to the original cabinet in the past … (in the same instant) whence and where her journey began… There is more… much more… but perhaps... it is best revealed by a history of the Wardrobe as it assists Bennets in the here/now by sending them to the where/when."
The Keeper: Mary Bennet's Extraordinary Journey (2016, Createspace Independent Publishing Platform) is first in The Bennet Wardrobe series by Don Jacobson. It's a Pride and Prejudice sequel with a time travel twist. The novel is very good as a standalone, but the adventures with the Wardrobe continue on in the series. I haven't listened to book two yet, but I don't know when I'm going to resume listening to audiobooks. My kids are now officially home for the rest of the school year, so I have to decide whether I'm not going to listen to any audiobooks until September. I chose to read this book because I've seen this series recommended by other readers, and because it was available as a free audio book a few weeks ago! (Happy dance!) My husband listened to it as well.
Rating: 4 1/2 stars
Narration: 5 stars
Notes on the organization of the book: This book has a bit of (worthwhile) background information to read before delving into the story. I liked this a lot. Every once in a while, when I read a book with information at the end of the book, I'm a little frustrated that it wasn't at the beginning.
First, there's a family tree, which is worth examining at the beginning of the Kindle or the paperback edition. If I remember correctly, the information wasn't included in the Audible version, so here are the bare bones of the family tree for the benefit of audiobook listeners:
Samuel Bennet married Martha Lucas and had one son, Edward Bennet.
Samuel Bennet later married Elizabeth Johnson and had a second son, Thomas Bennet.
Thomas Bennet married Frances Gardiner, and had the five sisters found in Pride and Prejudice canon: Jane, Elizabeth, Mary, Catherine (Kitty), and Lydia. This story is about Mary.
The second section has a list of characters. I have the Kindle version of this book, which I did refer to a couple of times, since my deaf ears couldn't process the character list on the audio book. Being able to put eyes on the list made me so happy. It's long, but neatly organized and easy to follow.
The third section reads like an article a professor might write. I enjoyed it, and I do recommend reading it, but if it's too dry, feel free to skip over this part of the book. It contains some "Excerpts from a Monograph," which makes me think of Sherlock Holmes with all his talk of the many monographs he's written. THIS monograph introduces the topic of the wardrobe.
"...wardrobes eventually became quaint relics… But, they did not lose their powers…. Professor C.S. Lewis incisively revealed the power of the wardrobe with his groundbreaking Chronicles of Narnia.... The Bennet Wardrobe... discerns the true desires or needs of the Bennet user and ascertains what is required to meet that need. Then the Wardrobe transports the Bennet to a future time where that requirement can be fulfilled… Bennets are routed in a manner similar to Rowling's sorting hat (another magical device which is outside the scope of this work) to the where/when that would best suit the user."
Back to my normal review features….
The heroine: Mary Bennet. She has very few lines in Pride and Prejudice. I've found that when reading P&P, it's easy to forget about Mary. But when I watch a movie adaptation, I frequently feel badly for her. I was glad to read this book, therefore, and Mary was quite a sensible character - one I can admire.
The hero: There is a romantic interest in the story, but that element is pretty mild. The gentleman is missing in action for a good portion of the story.
Historical background: I enjoyed the historical figures featured in this story.
Christian elements: There are definitely some references to God and the Bible, which seemed in-character and period-appropriate. There might be more than a non-Christian would prefer, but as for me, having my book friends acknowledge God makes me happy.
Is it clean/chaste? Yes, but there are one or two bits that caused my husband and I to agree that it's not appropriate for my 14-year-old daughter, which I thought was really unfortunate. Particularly since there are more references to God than I was expecting. She likes time travel, and the book was clean otherwise. Oh, well! My husband has continued to listen to the series, and has told me that the series gets worse as it progresses in content that is more mature than we feel is appropriate for our daughter. I'm wondering what's going to happen in the future. Will it be too much for me?
Update 7/20/20: Yes, it's definitely too much for me. Had I known, I wouldn't have invested the time in this one, even though I enjoyed book #1. See my review of Henry Fitzwilliam's War.)
What I liked:
*I loved the pre-story information at the beginning.
*I loved the references to God and/or the Bible. (I don't remember specifically at this point.)
*I liked references to real-life historical figures in the stories.
What I didn’t like:
*I might be crazy, but I felt like the beginning of the story was pedagogical. At the beginning, I felt as though I were writing the book - like I knew what was going to be said sometimes. But after a while, it wasn't as predictable. So…. just take this with a grain of salt. I might just have had a weird insight into the path this book was taking for some reason.
*I'm going to list the following here even though it's not a personal dislike. My husband said that as a time-travel story, there should have been more timey-wimey elements. I do understand that point-of-view, but don't feel the same way. I appreciated the fact that the time-travel aspect was there, but wasn't hyper-focused on in the book. I could keep it straight, unlike some of the time travel movies my husband has had me watch with him!
Audiobook: Narrated by Amanda Berry, I thought her British accent sounded lovely. It sounds cultured, and puts me in mind of Stevie Zimmerman if I am remembering Zimmerman's narration style correctly.
***********
The bottom line: This time-travel Pride and Prejudice variation was fun to read. I recommend this book to fans of Pride and Prejudice with the caveat that readers of exclusively clean books will probably be better off not reading this series at all.
The Keeper: Mary Bennet's Extraordinary Journey (2016, Createspace Independent Publishing Platform) is first in The Bennet Wardrobe series by Don Jacobson. It's a Pride and Prejudice sequel with a time travel twist. The novel is very good as a standalone, but the adventures with the Wardrobe continue on in the series. I haven't listened to book two yet, but I don't know when I'm going to resume listening to audiobooks. My kids are now officially home for the rest of the school year, so I have to decide whether I'm not going to listen to any audiobooks until September. I chose to read this book because I've seen this series recommended by other readers, and because it was available as a free audio book a few weeks ago! (Happy dance!) My husband listened to it as well.
Rating: 4 1/2 stars
Narration: 5 stars
Notes on the organization of the book: This book has a bit of (worthwhile) background information to read before delving into the story. I liked this a lot. Every once in a while, when I read a book with information at the end of the book, I'm a little frustrated that it wasn't at the beginning.
First, there's a family tree, which is worth examining at the beginning of the Kindle or the paperback edition. If I remember correctly, the information wasn't included in the Audible version, so here are the bare bones of the family tree for the benefit of audiobook listeners:
Samuel Bennet married Martha Lucas and had one son, Edward Bennet.
Samuel Bennet later married Elizabeth Johnson and had a second son, Thomas Bennet.
Thomas Bennet married Frances Gardiner, and had the five sisters found in Pride and Prejudice canon: Jane, Elizabeth, Mary, Catherine (Kitty), and Lydia. This story is about Mary.
The second section has a list of characters. I have the Kindle version of this book, which I did refer to a couple of times, since my deaf ears couldn't process the character list on the audio book. Being able to put eyes on the list made me so happy. It's long, but neatly organized and easy to follow.
The third section reads like an article a professor might write. I enjoyed it, and I do recommend reading it, but if it's too dry, feel free to skip over this part of the book. It contains some "Excerpts from a Monograph," which makes me think of Sherlock Holmes with all his talk of the many monographs he's written. THIS monograph introduces the topic of the wardrobe.
"...wardrobes eventually became quaint relics… But, they did not lose their powers…. Professor C.S. Lewis incisively revealed the power of the wardrobe with his groundbreaking Chronicles of Narnia.... The Bennet Wardrobe... discerns the true desires or needs of the Bennet user and ascertains what is required to meet that need. Then the Wardrobe transports the Bennet to a future time where that requirement can be fulfilled… Bennets are routed in a manner similar to Rowling's sorting hat (another magical device which is outside the scope of this work) to the where/when that would best suit the user."
Back to my normal review features….
The heroine: Mary Bennet. She has very few lines in Pride and Prejudice. I've found that when reading P&P, it's easy to forget about Mary. But when I watch a movie adaptation, I frequently feel badly for her. I was glad to read this book, therefore, and Mary was quite a sensible character - one I can admire.
The hero: There is a romantic interest in the story, but that element is pretty mild. The gentleman is missing in action for a good portion of the story.
Historical background: I enjoyed the historical figures featured in this story.
Christian elements: There are definitely some references to God and the Bible, which seemed in-character and period-appropriate. There might be more than a non-Christian would prefer, but as for me, having my book friends acknowledge God makes me happy.
Is it clean/chaste? Yes, but there are one or two bits that caused my husband and I to agree that it's not appropriate for my 14-year-old daughter, which I thought was really unfortunate. Particularly since there are more references to God than I was expecting. She likes time travel, and the book was clean otherwise. Oh, well! My husband has continued to listen to the series, and has told me that the series gets worse as it progresses in content that is more mature than we feel is appropriate for our daughter. I'm wondering what's going to happen in the future. Will it be too much for me?
Update 7/20/20: Yes, it's definitely too much for me. Had I known, I wouldn't have invested the time in this one, even though I enjoyed book #1. See my review of Henry Fitzwilliam's War.)
What I liked:
*I loved the pre-story information at the beginning.
*I loved the references to God and/or the Bible. (I don't remember specifically at this point.)
*I liked references to real-life historical figures in the stories.
What I didn’t like:
*I might be crazy, but I felt like the beginning of the story was pedagogical. At the beginning, I felt as though I were writing the book - like I knew what was going to be said sometimes. But after a while, it wasn't as predictable. So…. just take this with a grain of salt. I might just have had a weird insight into the path this book was taking for some reason.
*I'm going to list the following here even though it's not a personal dislike. My husband said that as a time-travel story, there should have been more timey-wimey elements. I do understand that point-of-view, but don't feel the same way. I appreciated the fact that the time-travel aspect was there, but wasn't hyper-focused on in the book. I could keep it straight, unlike some of the time travel movies my husband has had me watch with him!
Audiobook: Narrated by Amanda Berry, I thought her British accent sounded lovely. It sounds cultured, and puts me in mind of Stevie Zimmerman if I am remembering Zimmerman's narration style correctly.
***********
The bottom line: This time-travel Pride and Prejudice variation was fun to read. I recommend this book to fans of Pride and Prejudice with the caveat that readers of exclusively clean books will probably be better off not reading this series at all.
October 10, 2016
3.5 rounded up to 4 stars
I am having trouble reviewing this. Unfortunately, I find my brain turns to mush and I can't process all the information when a story incorporates a great deal of historical detail, as this does. (I was an indifferent History and Social Studies student, at best.) I believe I'm in the minority in this respect, especially since Regency romance IS, by its very nature, historical. For me, it's the social customs that fascinate me, because the restricted interactions between men and women heighten the significance of every touch and kiss. Those who love reading about different events and influential figures in history along with a strong romantic tale will enjoy this more than I did.
This is a very ambitious plot with a lot of different storylines, some of which mesh together better than others. We have the development of Mary's character in the absence of the rest of her sisters at Longbourn, as well as her romance with Edward Benton, who has a secret only shared with her father and uncle. The Bennets, as a result of a tragedy in Meryton that kills much of the population, adopt an orphaned baby boy. Edward goes to America, is stuck there for several years due to the War of 1812, and ends up as secretary to John Adams. Maria Lucas begins as a silly girl but also grows and finds romance. George Wickham and Colonel Fitzwilliam are pitted in fierce battle against Napoleon and the French. There's a very surprising meeting between Lydia and the Prince Regent. Lady Catherine and Mr. Collins are shown to have a very strange, sick relationship. Mary becomes a social activist, with the political upheaval of the mid 1800s a strong story element. Lizzy, Darcy, Jane and Bingley do appear at different points, but they are simply supporting characters here.
If it sounds like this is a lot to crowd into one book... well, it is. The underlying story is the Bennet Wardrobe, which allows those of the Bennet bloodline to go to the future and return. Several use it. Some travel out of time and decide they prefer it in their future. Others leap forward and then immediately come back again, having gotten a glimpse of their destiny. It would have been less confusing if only one, or even perhaps two, characters used it, but I found the multiple jumps and jumpers difficult to keep straight at times.
My preference is for a simple, straightforward story where every element contributes to the primary plot. I admire the breadth and depth of this book, but I did not find it an easy read. Again, this may well be a case of pearls before swine (with me as the pig!), so I hesitate to penalize the author for this particular reader's shortcomings. I'm not certain where the book's major turning point is; there appear to be several, as Mary has several pivotal moments in her lifelong journey.
The extraordinary Bennet Wardrobe universe is a product of laudable creativity and imagination. Mr. Jacobson also proves his love of historical detail, weaving various factoids into his story. I do love Mary’s character, and the way she grows and changes as a result of her experiences is completely believable. Edward is also an engaging character, and his romance with Mary is sweetly depicted.
The author’s writing is very, very good. I noted only rare grammar, spelling or punctuation errors, which is always a joy to find in self-published fanfiction. However, I did think some dialogue passages were overly involved, sounding more like story narration rather than something a character would actually say. Also, "alright" is used several times; there is no such word! All right is correct, always! Otherwise, the prose is excellent.
Lovers of history and complex stories will find a lot to enjoy here. I must be honest and say, though, that this was not my cup of tea.
I am having trouble reviewing this. Unfortunately, I find my brain turns to mush and I can't process all the information when a story incorporates a great deal of historical detail, as this does. (I was an indifferent History and Social Studies student, at best.) I believe I'm in the minority in this respect, especially since Regency romance IS, by its very nature, historical. For me, it's the social customs that fascinate me, because the restricted interactions between men and women heighten the significance of every touch and kiss. Those who love reading about different events and influential figures in history along with a strong romantic tale will enjoy this more than I did.
This is a very ambitious plot with a lot of different storylines, some of which mesh together better than others. We have the development of Mary's character in the absence of the rest of her sisters at Longbourn, as well as her romance with Edward Benton, who has a secret only shared with her father and uncle. The Bennets, as a result of a tragedy in Meryton that kills much of the population, adopt an orphaned baby boy. Edward goes to America, is stuck there for several years due to the War of 1812, and ends up as secretary to John Adams. Maria Lucas begins as a silly girl but also grows and finds romance. George Wickham and Colonel Fitzwilliam are pitted in fierce battle against Napoleon and the French. There's a very surprising meeting between Lydia and the Prince Regent. Lady Catherine and Mr. Collins are shown to have a very strange, sick relationship. Mary becomes a social activist, with the political upheaval of the mid 1800s a strong story element. Lizzy, Darcy, Jane and Bingley do appear at different points, but they are simply supporting characters here.
If it sounds like this is a lot to crowd into one book... well, it is. The underlying story is the Bennet Wardrobe, which allows those of the Bennet bloodline to go to the future and return. Several use it. Some travel out of time and decide they prefer it in their future. Others leap forward and then immediately come back again, having gotten a glimpse of their destiny. It would have been less confusing if only one, or even perhaps two, characters used it, but I found the multiple jumps and jumpers difficult to keep straight at times.
My preference is for a simple, straightforward story where every element contributes to the primary plot. I admire the breadth and depth of this book, but I did not find it an easy read. Again, this may well be a case of pearls before swine (with me as the pig!), so I hesitate to penalize the author for this particular reader's shortcomings. I'm not certain where the book's major turning point is; there appear to be several, as Mary has several pivotal moments in her lifelong journey.
The extraordinary Bennet Wardrobe universe is a product of laudable creativity and imagination. Mr. Jacobson also proves his love of historical detail, weaving various factoids into his story. I do love Mary’s character, and the way she grows and changes as a result of her experiences is completely believable. Edward is also an engaging character, and his romance with Mary is sweetly depicted.
The author’s writing is very, very good. I noted only rare grammar, spelling or punctuation errors, which is always a joy to find in self-published fanfiction. However, I did think some dialogue passages were overly involved, sounding more like story narration rather than something a character would actually say. Also, "alright" is used several times; there is no such word! All right is correct, always! Otherwise, the prose is excellent.
Lovers of history and complex stories will find a lot to enjoy here. I must be honest and say, though, that this was not my cup of tea.
November 5, 2017
Mary Bennet: surely the dullest of the Bennet daughters but Jacobson bravely undertakes the challenge of writing her story past "Pride and Prejudice." Though not a love story, there is plenty to like about this and understand Mrs Bennet's plainest daughter all the more. I find it remarkable when an author takes a character the reader knows little about or maybe doesn't even like and has us cheering for her by the end...all the while remaining true to Austen characteristics. Well done.
March 30, 2022
Excellence in Writing
I am reviewing the Audiobook version, narrated by Amanda Berry, whose performance I rate as five-star outstanding. To be able to cover so many characters and emotions in one book is a huge credit to her talent. When she sobbed, so did I. Positively brilliant.
Book Review:
Don Jacobson’s Wardrobe series is one that I have been curious about, but have resisted reading for quite some time. I’m one of those readers who, if they decide to undertake a series, prefers to have it completed before starting. I also tend to stay away from books that contain any semblance of magic or alternate universe. It’s just not my thing particularly, but I am open to exceptions, especially if the writer has a respected reputation. Don Jacobson does and, since his series is now complete, I no longer have an excuse. (I should add here as a disclaimer that I accepted a gifted Audiobook code with no promise of a review when offered by the author. It ultimately was the impetus to get me started on the series.)
Since this first book in the series has been out for a few years, I won’t take the time for a summary, as there are many previous reviews that do so on Amazon and Goodreads.
Unsurprisingly, I found the writing to be exceptional, as Mr. Jacobson is a masterful wordsmith. Another of his books which I enjoyed, In Plain Sight, is a testament to this. I’m not quite sure what I expected when I began this book, but I certainly didn’t expect to cry so much. The writing moved me to tears multiple times throughout the story. Any book that can bring out so much emotion in me is always a winner in my eyes. The story is a bit complex, as the reader has to keep in mind the rules of the wardrobe, as well as recall the characters involved with it early on and how they influence the “present” in the the story. History and persons of renown are also in the mix. As such, I found it fascinating and adventurous and, even inspiring at times — Mary is a spiritual person, after all. I simply couldn’t stop listening and finished it without stopping.
There are many characters to follow in this book, but I loved the portrayals they were given, especially Mary and Mr. Bennet. With over 1000 JAFF variations read, I also don’t think I’ve ever cried so much for George Wickham in my life. I did wonder about Mary’s marriage partner. I am aware of cousins marrying in Regency, but this particular conception surprised me.
Knowing there’s more to come (I do hope to continue the series), I’m not too stuck on my disappointment with Elizabeth’s outcome at the end of this book, but I was sad for Darcy. I anticipate reading more about her specifically in future volumes.
Certainly a unique reading experience for me. If you enjoy the Jane Austen fan fiction genre, mixed with some historical fiction, you will enjoy this book very much. Even if you’re a bit unsure like I was, if nothing else, read it for the writing. It’s truly outstanding.
I am reviewing the Audiobook version, narrated by Amanda Berry, whose performance I rate as five-star outstanding. To be able to cover so many characters and emotions in one book is a huge credit to her talent. When she sobbed, so did I. Positively brilliant.
Book Review:
Don Jacobson’s Wardrobe series is one that I have been curious about, but have resisted reading for quite some time. I’m one of those readers who, if they decide to undertake a series, prefers to have it completed before starting. I also tend to stay away from books that contain any semblance of magic or alternate universe. It’s just not my thing particularly, but I am open to exceptions, especially if the writer has a respected reputation. Don Jacobson does and, since his series is now complete, I no longer have an excuse. (I should add here as a disclaimer that I accepted a gifted Audiobook code with no promise of a review when offered by the author. It ultimately was the impetus to get me started on the series.)
Since this first book in the series has been out for a few years, I won’t take the time for a summary, as there are many previous reviews that do so on Amazon and Goodreads.
Unsurprisingly, I found the writing to be exceptional, as Mr. Jacobson is a masterful wordsmith. Another of his books which I enjoyed, In Plain Sight, is a testament to this. I’m not quite sure what I expected when I began this book, but I certainly didn’t expect to cry so much. The writing moved me to tears multiple times throughout the story. Any book that can bring out so much emotion in me is always a winner in my eyes. The story is a bit complex, as the reader has to keep in mind the rules of the wardrobe, as well as recall the characters involved with it early on and how they influence the “present” in the the story. History and persons of renown are also in the mix. As such, I found it fascinating and adventurous and, even inspiring at times — Mary is a spiritual person, after all. I simply couldn’t stop listening and finished it without stopping.
There are many characters to follow in this book, but I loved the portrayals they were given, especially Mary and Mr. Bennet. With over 1000 JAFF variations read, I also don’t think I’ve ever cried so much for George Wickham in my life. I did wonder about Mary’s marriage partner. I am aware of cousins marrying in Regency, but this particular conception surprised me.
Knowing there’s more to come (I do hope to continue the series), I’m not too stuck on my disappointment with Elizabeth’s outcome at the end of this book, but I was sad for Darcy. I anticipate reading more about her specifically in future volumes.
Certainly a unique reading experience for me. If you enjoy the Jane Austen fan fiction genre, mixed with some historical fiction, you will enjoy this book very much. Even if you’re a bit unsure like I was, if nothing else, read it for the writing. It’s truly outstanding.
July 7, 2017
There is so much I could say about this first in a series that I am going to try hard not to write spoilers but forgive me if I do.
I did contact Don about the fact that in the kindle version the genealogy is first of all printed so tiny you can't easily read it and secondly that it is printed in a vertical manner. He was very obliging and send me a copy to print out which I could then read and consult. That chart was very helpful, at least to me, as the beginning of the book takes us quickly through several generations plus has similar names in several generations, i.e., an Elizabeth who marries into the Bennet family and thus is Elizabeth Bennet.
We also had a discussion about marrying between family members. Not only has JA posed the idea of first cousins marrying as Darcy and his cousin, Anne, are suppose to be engaged but many JAFF authors have cousins doing so, i.e., the colonel marrying either Anne or Georgiana. This idea is a bit repugnant to me even though it was legal in England as well as other places. I won't reveal what happens in the book that brought this discussion up but will say that for a portion of the book I kept asking myself if I had the relationship correct and if I could "like" the idea.
Why? Because this book does have blood members of the Bennet family able to travel forward in time and even to return to their original starting point or to the point to which their contemporaries have traveled. Don does a good job in the beginning of not only correlating this books to other which use time travel or traveling to other dimensions but also of having the cast set up the rules and then codicils about the Wardrobe and its ownership and use very well. Later another qualification is added when a "keeper" learns that the Bennet blood runs in certain, shall we say, persons who can not act with sense or propriety.
I was able to make notes from my Kindle app on my PC which allows me to copy and paste and then not to have to fumble through pages when I needed a name or wanted to check on a fact, even as I read, much less now as I write my review. I would suggest keeping notes in some manner but if you have an excellent memory you may not need to do so.
We know from the title that this story is about Mary. Many have bemoaned the fact that Mary is barely in the background or relegated to being a candidate to marry Mr. Collins in our minds due to her sermonizing. The author does an excellent job of having Mary step outside of herself and then make observations and dramatic changes. Mary becomes a very central part of her family and her community with lasting actions to touch the needs she sees or learns about in that area and in the broader world.
So this is not a romance. There are attractions spoken of, some kisses and embraces and more than one marriage but we are not reading about angst due separation so much as what the persons are involved in doing, even in the history of their time as they are apart. Oh, Don does write of how each misses the other but then we get on with the story.
Jane and Bingley as well as Elizabeth and Darcy are much more in the background. There are family reunions and ALL the sisters grow and learn to value each for their strengths and to cherish one another. Events in history intersect the lives of people with whom we are very familiar. While Don makes changes in certain characters, their behaviors and in the end their reputations he also has others falling in depravity and wantonness. I was repulsed by one oily person's nature and acts! And that person is going to show up again...(I am sitting here repulsed at thinking of that).
During a large portion of the book I was at loose ends to understand what was happening. It was reading like a mystery in that I didn't have the clues to know fully what was going on. People are time traveling but to or from where is not initially clear. And this book does not give us the whole story; which you can realize by reading the titles of the sequels. So going in, understand that, yes, the author does leave you wanting more of the story. That much goes without saying.
I did enjoy the book but it is very different from what I usually read in JAFF. I am binge watching Heroes with my daughter who bought the DVDs. She and her husband love Dr. Who. I have read and seen the movie about The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe. Those three stories and others are mentioned as references by the author at the beginning of this book. Thus you may get an idea of what this premise touches on in the world of literature.
I now have to take a break and get some romance under my belt but I will be back to reading the novella about Fitzwilliam and then onto Kitty's story in this series. Yes, I enjoyed this and it was challenging to read just a little slower and attempt to keep everything in order in my mind.
This book was well edited. I don't go in looking for errata but such will jump out at me and I will make a note on my kindle. In this book I found only one "an" which needed to read "and". Excellent.
I did contact Don about the fact that in the kindle version the genealogy is first of all printed so tiny you can't easily read it and secondly that it is printed in a vertical manner. He was very obliging and send me a copy to print out which I could then read and consult. That chart was very helpful, at least to me, as the beginning of the book takes us quickly through several generations plus has similar names in several generations, i.e., an Elizabeth who marries into the Bennet family and thus is Elizabeth Bennet.
We also had a discussion about marrying between family members. Not only has JA posed the idea of first cousins marrying as Darcy and his cousin, Anne, are suppose to be engaged but many JAFF authors have cousins doing so, i.e., the colonel marrying either Anne or Georgiana. This idea is a bit repugnant to me even though it was legal in England as well as other places. I won't reveal what happens in the book that brought this discussion up but will say that for a portion of the book I kept asking myself if I had the relationship correct and if I could "like" the idea.
Why? Because this book does have blood members of the Bennet family able to travel forward in time and even to return to their original starting point or to the point to which their contemporaries have traveled. Don does a good job in the beginning of not only correlating this books to other which use time travel or traveling to other dimensions but also of having the cast set up the rules and then codicils about the Wardrobe and its ownership and use very well. Later another qualification is added when a "keeper" learns that the Bennet blood runs in certain, shall we say, persons who can not act with sense or propriety.
I was able to make notes from my Kindle app on my PC which allows me to copy and paste and then not to have to fumble through pages when I needed a name or wanted to check on a fact, even as I read, much less now as I write my review. I would suggest keeping notes in some manner but if you have an excellent memory you may not need to do so.
We know from the title that this story is about Mary. Many have bemoaned the fact that Mary is barely in the background or relegated to being a candidate to marry Mr. Collins in our minds due to her sermonizing. The author does an excellent job of having Mary step outside of herself and then make observations and dramatic changes. Mary becomes a very central part of her family and her community with lasting actions to touch the needs she sees or learns about in that area and in the broader world.
So this is not a romance. There are attractions spoken of, some kisses and embraces and more than one marriage but we are not reading about angst due separation so much as what the persons are involved in doing, even in the history of their time as they are apart. Oh, Don does write of how each misses the other but then we get on with the story.
Jane and Bingley as well as Elizabeth and Darcy are much more in the background. There are family reunions and ALL the sisters grow and learn to value each for their strengths and to cherish one another. Events in history intersect the lives of people with whom we are very familiar. While Don makes changes in certain characters, their behaviors and in the end their reputations he also has others falling in depravity and wantonness. I was repulsed by one oily person's nature and acts! And that person is going to show up again...(I am sitting here repulsed at thinking of that).
During a large portion of the book I was at loose ends to understand what was happening. It was reading like a mystery in that I didn't have the clues to know fully what was going on. People are time traveling but to or from where is not initially clear. And this book does not give us the whole story; which you can realize by reading the titles of the sequels. So going in, understand that, yes, the author does leave you wanting more of the story. That much goes without saying.
I did enjoy the book but it is very different from what I usually read in JAFF. I am binge watching Heroes with my daughter who bought the DVDs. She and her husband love Dr. Who. I have read and seen the movie about The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe. Those three stories and others are mentioned as references by the author at the beginning of this book. Thus you may get an idea of what this premise touches on in the world of literature.
I now have to take a break and get some romance under my belt but I will be back to reading the novella about Fitzwilliam and then onto Kitty's story in this series. Yes, I enjoyed this and it was challenging to read just a little slower and attempt to keep everything in order in my mind.
This book was well edited. I don't go in looking for errata but such will jump out at me and I will make a note on my kindle. In this book I found only one "an" which needed to read "and". Excellent.
November 16, 2018
The Plain Daughter, The Parson, and The Wardrobe
TYPE OF AUSTENESQUE NOVEL: Pride and Prejudice Sequel, Minor Character, Time Travel/Time Slip
TIME FRAME: Prologue begins in 1690, Main story occurs between 1811-1819
WHY I WANTED TO READ THIS BOOK:
I’ll be honest, I was a bit hesitant to read being this series as I’m not typically drawn to fantasy/time-travel stories. However, many readers and friends have recommended and praised this series and Mr. Jacobson’s writing, so I decided I should stop hesitating and give it a go!
SYNOPSIS:
The first book in this series introduces readers to a specially-crafted wardrobe with mystical properties that allow members of the Bennet blood line to travel into various future times. Made and gifted to the first Bennet of Longbourn, The Bennet Wardrobe has been utilized, guarded, and kept secret for many generations. With several daughters married, Thomas Bennet looks to the future and decides that Mary should become the next Keeper of The Bennet Wardrobe. Mary, who has no idea about any of the special abilities of The Wardrobe or privileges it can provide is about to have her world dramatically changed…
WHAT I LOVED:
- Mary Bennet: First and foremost, I love that this story focused on Mary Bennet. I enjoyed how the author used the fact that she was now ‘Miss Bennet’ as an impetus to do some soul-searching and maturing. It was such a rewarding experience to see Mary grow, gain courage, make realizations about her personality and behavior, and blossom into an admirable and worthy heroine. I appreciated how the author drew attention to Mary’s feelings of neglect and pain, and gave cause to her critical and stern demeanor. And I especially enjoyed the pleasing and and heartening relationships Mary started to develop in this book with various members of her family – particularly her relationships with Mr. Bennet and Lydia Bennet.
- The Wardrobe: What an interesting device and how fun to see it in the hands of the Bennet family! I did enjoy learning more about how this wardrobe became to be in the Bennet’s possession and I loved witnessing some moments in the lives of Bennet ancestors. In addition, the rules of the Wardrobe are interesting – I enjoyed how the time-traveler cannot choose “when” they travel to, and that the Wardrobe “knows” the desires of the traveler and ascertains when or where they need to go.
- Historical Tie-Ins: Throughout the course of this novel we witness various members of the Bennet family encountering famous historical figures, such as John Adams, Queen Victoria, Mary Shelley, and The Prince Regent. As a music-lover and musician I loved the tie-ins with Maurice Ravel and George Gershwin and am wondering if we will see more of these characters in the next book of the series…
- Mary’s Love: I enjoyed seeing Mary’s relationship with the mysterious stranger who she cannot help but feel strong affection and attachment towards. I liked that he was serious-natured and focused about his calling, yet light-hearted and playful with Mary. He seemed a perfect fit for Mary.
WHAT I AM AMBIVALENT ABOUT:
- Multi-Episodic: This first book of the series establishes a lot and covers a lot of ground. And while I greatly enjoyed the action-packed eventfulness of this story, it did sometimes feel a little too fast-paced. And the series of events – while diverse and interesting – sometimes didn’t feel wholly connected under one arc. I did sometimes wish for it to feel a little more unified.
WHAT I WASN’T TOO FOND OF:
- Some Small Quibbles: While some readers may dislike a certain couple marrying, it didn’t bother me. However, I did often wish that some of the romances weren’t so fast-paced – everyone fell in love instantly. Moreover, I did find Mr. Collins character a little too skeevy (shudders), although I thoroughly enjoyed seeing him receive his just desserts. In addition, I could not help but wonder why the Wardrobe wasn’t used more by certain Bennets. Especially those that are fond of reading and exploring (but perhaps that happens in another part of this series).
CONCLUSION:
With The Keeper: Mary Bennet’s Extraordinary Adventure Don Jacobson introduces an incredibly inventive and engaging series that promises to be filled with thrilling action, unforeseen adventures, brushes with history, surprising encounters, and time-traveling Bennets! I cannot wait to see what journeys we embark on next!
Austenesque Reviews
TYPE OF AUSTENESQUE NOVEL: Pride and Prejudice Sequel, Minor Character, Time Travel/Time Slip
TIME FRAME: Prologue begins in 1690, Main story occurs between 1811-1819
WHY I WANTED TO READ THIS BOOK:
I’ll be honest, I was a bit hesitant to read being this series as I’m not typically drawn to fantasy/time-travel stories. However, many readers and friends have recommended and praised this series and Mr. Jacobson’s writing, so I decided I should stop hesitating and give it a go!
SYNOPSIS:
The first book in this series introduces readers to a specially-crafted wardrobe with mystical properties that allow members of the Bennet blood line to travel into various future times. Made and gifted to the first Bennet of Longbourn, The Bennet Wardrobe has been utilized, guarded, and kept secret for many generations. With several daughters married, Thomas Bennet looks to the future and decides that Mary should become the next Keeper of The Bennet Wardrobe. Mary, who has no idea about any of the special abilities of The Wardrobe or privileges it can provide is about to have her world dramatically changed…
WHAT I LOVED:
- Mary Bennet: First and foremost, I love that this story focused on Mary Bennet. I enjoyed how the author used the fact that she was now ‘Miss Bennet’ as an impetus to do some soul-searching and maturing. It was such a rewarding experience to see Mary grow, gain courage, make realizations about her personality and behavior, and blossom into an admirable and worthy heroine. I appreciated how the author drew attention to Mary’s feelings of neglect and pain, and gave cause to her critical and stern demeanor. And I especially enjoyed the pleasing and and heartening relationships Mary started to develop in this book with various members of her family – particularly her relationships with Mr. Bennet and Lydia Bennet.
- The Wardrobe: What an interesting device and how fun to see it in the hands of the Bennet family! I did enjoy learning more about how this wardrobe became to be in the Bennet’s possession and I loved witnessing some moments in the lives of Bennet ancestors. In addition, the rules of the Wardrobe are interesting – I enjoyed how the time-traveler cannot choose “when” they travel to, and that the Wardrobe “knows” the desires of the traveler and ascertains when or where they need to go.
- Historical Tie-Ins: Throughout the course of this novel we witness various members of the Bennet family encountering famous historical figures, such as John Adams, Queen Victoria, Mary Shelley, and The Prince Regent. As a music-lover and musician I loved the tie-ins with Maurice Ravel and George Gershwin and am wondering if we will see more of these characters in the next book of the series…
- Mary’s Love: I enjoyed seeing Mary’s relationship with the mysterious stranger who she cannot help but feel strong affection and attachment towards. I liked that he was serious-natured and focused about his calling, yet light-hearted and playful with Mary. He seemed a perfect fit for Mary.
WHAT I AM AMBIVALENT ABOUT:
- Multi-Episodic: This first book of the series establishes a lot and covers a lot of ground. And while I greatly enjoyed the action-packed eventfulness of this story, it did sometimes feel a little too fast-paced. And the series of events – while diverse and interesting – sometimes didn’t feel wholly connected under one arc. I did sometimes wish for it to feel a little more unified.
WHAT I WASN’T TOO FOND OF:
- Some Small Quibbles: While some readers may dislike a certain couple marrying, it didn’t bother me. However, I did often wish that some of the romances weren’t so fast-paced – everyone fell in love instantly. Moreover, I did find Mr. Collins character a little too skeevy (shudders), although I thoroughly enjoyed seeing him receive his just desserts. In addition, I could not help but wonder why the Wardrobe wasn’t used more by certain Bennets. Especially those that are fond of reading and exploring (but perhaps that happens in another part of this series).
CONCLUSION:
With The Keeper: Mary Bennet’s Extraordinary Adventure Don Jacobson introduces an incredibly inventive and engaging series that promises to be filled with thrilling action, unforeseen adventures, brushes with history, surprising encounters, and time-traveling Bennets! I cannot wait to see what journeys we embark on next!
Austenesque Reviews
January 11, 2017
I thoroughly enjoyed this book for many different reasons! First, it gives center stage to a secondary character in Pride & Prejudice...namely, middle sister, Mary Bennet. Second, the history woven into the story provided an added element of depth. Third, it's unique premise. A wardrobe built for the first Bennet patriarch, Christopher, by a celebrated cabinetmaker, Grinling Gibbons in 1692 with mystical properties. Hewn from an oak tree on the Bennet property and a special marquetry pattern stained with a small vial of blood from Christopher Bennet, this wardrobe allows only Bennet family members to 'pass through'. I was intrigued and my imagination was fired.
We are introduced at the beginning with the wardrobe's properties, family members and some back history prior to our canon characters. It is a critical part of the story but it was a touch slow. Things certainly pick up though.
Mary was a rather severe creature who was overlooked by both her parents and her sisters. This story takes place just after the wedding of Elizabeth and Jane Bennet. Mr. Jacobson has sympathetically written a scene between the married sisters and Mary as they say goodbye. I found it honest and extremely touching. However, for me, the most enlightening and moving experience was Mary's walk to Oakham Mount. It was eye-opening, soul-freeing and very emotional and moving. From this epiphany, the story takes off.
Much is revealed in this journey of Mary's life...finding her true calling, her love, Edward Benton, and the workings of the Wardrobe. It is a character onto itself. The Darcy's and Bingley's play a small role in this story, however, Lydia's story is larger than life, much like she is. Kitty's on the other hand has a unique twist. Many others like Colonel Fitzwilliam, Anne deBourgh and even Wickham have their part to play in this tale. And let's not forget our villains...Lady Catherine and Mr. Collins. Evil incarnate as far as I'm concerned and each got their just rewards!
This is not a quick and easy read to happily ever after. There are parts that were a bit confusing and connections that some may question. This, however, is a journey through the decades with touches of humour, joy, sadness, history and twists and turns that keep you on your toes. Looking forward to the saga continuing.
We are introduced at the beginning with the wardrobe's properties, family members and some back history prior to our canon characters. It is a critical part of the story but it was a touch slow. Things certainly pick up though.
Mary was a rather severe creature who was overlooked by both her parents and her sisters. This story takes place just after the wedding of Elizabeth and Jane Bennet. Mr. Jacobson has sympathetically written a scene between the married sisters and Mary as they say goodbye. I found it honest and extremely touching. However, for me, the most enlightening and moving experience was Mary's walk to Oakham Mount. It was eye-opening, soul-freeing and very emotional and moving. From this epiphany, the story takes off.
Much is revealed in this journey of Mary's life...finding her true calling, her love, Edward Benton, and the workings of the Wardrobe. It is a character onto itself. The Darcy's and Bingley's play a small role in this story, however, Lydia's story is larger than life, much like she is. Kitty's on the other hand has a unique twist. Many others like Colonel Fitzwilliam, Anne deBourgh and even Wickham have their part to play in this tale. And let's not forget our villains...Lady Catherine and Mr. Collins. Evil incarnate as far as I'm concerned and each got their just rewards!
This is not a quick and easy read to happily ever after. There are parts that were a bit confusing and connections that some may question. This, however, is a journey through the decades with touches of humour, joy, sadness, history and twists and turns that keep you on your toes. Looking forward to the saga continuing.
January 15, 2019
I mostly enjoyed this book. I thought it was a well-thought-out time travel novel with lots of clever references.
The good:
-The author put a lot of thought into the rules he would use to manage time travel issues.
-The story was riveting at times.
-I like a longer series of events that take place over many books. Dangling threads are appreciated.
-Lydia. I liked her in this one.
The not so good:
-The author lets us know that he had intentionally placed all the clever references which kind of ruined them for me.
-A pet peeve of mine is when the characters end up with fame and fortune. I prefer less fame and more contentment of a life-well-lived. I think becoming famous back then and if only now would have been perceived as gauche but this ending might appeal more to the modern, younger reader?
-Mr Collins, I know what I would like to say but I don't want to ruin anything.
I am not sure who the audience is for this book. It was a great fantasy story but seemed a bit self-indulgent. I would love more charm and maybe a bit of humor as well but I enjoyed most of it until the end. I appreciate the author taking the time to construct a story with many complicated components.
Reread: I found I liked it less on the second reading. I can tell that I had a concussion when I last reviewed it due to the number of errors in my old review. I am intrigued enough to try the next in the series plus I like some of this author's other books.
The good:
-The author put a lot of thought into the rules he would use to manage time travel issues.
-The story was riveting at times.
-I like a longer series of events that take place over many books. Dangling threads are appreciated.
-Lydia. I liked her in this one.
The not so good:
-The author lets us know that he had intentionally placed all the clever references which kind of ruined them for me.
-A pet peeve of mine is when the characters end up with fame and fortune. I prefer less fame and more contentment of a life-well-lived. I think becoming famous back then and if only now would have been perceived as gauche but this ending might appeal more to the modern, younger reader?
-Mr Collins, I know what I would like to say but I don't want to ruin anything.
I am not sure who the audience is for this book. It was a great fantasy story but seemed a bit self-indulgent. I would love more charm and maybe a bit of humor as well but I enjoyed most of it until the end. I appreciate the author taking the time to construct a story with many complicated components.
Reread: I found I liked it less on the second reading. I can tell that I had a concussion when I last reviewed it due to the number of errors in my old review. I am intrigued enough to try the next in the series plus I like some of this author's other books.
December 18, 2021
Second Reading: October 17, 2021
"There is that moment between being asleep and being awake in which dreamy wraiths become concrete reality and what is solid assumes the evanescent qualities of fantasy." (quote from the book)
Re-reading this book for the second time made me appreciate and understand the scope and genius of the overall story. Yes, there is still one more book coming, and that has been the impetus for me to start from the beginning, for it has been four years now since the Bennet Wardrobe saga began. I want to have it all fresh in my mind and heart when the final book is released early in the new year.
"She, Mary Bennet, always the middle one, the plain one, the bookish one, did not have to hide any more, that resolution began to drive away the pain and relieve the tension." (quote from the book)
This is Mary Bennet's story, evolution if you will, as she becomes the eldest 'Miss Bennet'. We see and experience her heartbreaking epiphany on Oakham Mount that sets her on a journey of discovery, enlightenment, and love. And, as the fire that erupts in Meryton shortly after the marriages of Jane and Elizabeth, Mary rises like a phoenix from the ashes...and my tears flowed again.
"Finally, she had to realize that building a better self-image began with appreciating others for who they were, not how she believed they should be." (quote from the book)
Since I have read all the books to date, there were so many scenes that not only made more sense, but were more poignant in this second reading...therefore, more tears. I look forward to re-reading each book in this series again.
The Bennet Wardrobe saga has been re-published/re-edited by Meryton Press, with a Preface providing a little explanation regarding the workings of the Bennet Wardrobe, a Family Tree and a Cast of Characters. I am grateful to have received a copy with no expectation for a review. I own each of the original books in this series in paperback.
I highly recommend this saga for it's originality and for the unique development of Jane Austen's secondary characters; namely, Mary, Kitty and Lydia.
"There is that moment between being asleep and being awake in which dreamy wraiths become concrete reality and what is solid assumes the evanescent qualities of fantasy." (quote from the book)
Re-reading this book for the second time made me appreciate and understand the scope and genius of the overall story. Yes, there is still one more book coming, and that has been the impetus for me to start from the beginning, for it has been four years now since the Bennet Wardrobe saga began. I want to have it all fresh in my mind and heart when the final book is released early in the new year.
"She, Mary Bennet, always the middle one, the plain one, the bookish one, did not have to hide any more, that resolution began to drive away the pain and relieve the tension." (quote from the book)
This is Mary Bennet's story, evolution if you will, as she becomes the eldest 'Miss Bennet'. We see and experience her heartbreaking epiphany on Oakham Mount that sets her on a journey of discovery, enlightenment, and love. And, as the fire that erupts in Meryton shortly after the marriages of Jane and Elizabeth, Mary rises like a phoenix from the ashes...and my tears flowed again.
"Finally, she had to realize that building a better self-image began with appreciating others for who they were, not how she believed they should be." (quote from the book)
Since I have read all the books to date, there were so many scenes that not only made more sense, but were more poignant in this second reading...therefore, more tears. I look forward to re-reading each book in this series again.
The Bennet Wardrobe saga has been re-published/re-edited by Meryton Press, with a Preface providing a little explanation regarding the workings of the Bennet Wardrobe, a Family Tree and a Cast of Characters. I am grateful to have received a copy with no expectation for a review. I own each of the original books in this series in paperback.
I highly recommend this saga for it's originality and for the unique development of Jane Austen's secondary characters; namely, Mary, Kitty and Lydia.
August 26, 2016
Once I got started, I really enjoyed this coming of age story of Mary Bennett. The time travel aspect added some interesting plot lines and twists. I look forward to the next book in the series.
August 25, 2018
Audiobook edition review
In my recent mood, I've been picking up time travel- themed books for my reading pleasure. The Keeper is actually a re-read for me and a recent one at that. On this occasion I picked up the audio version and settled in for a delightful time of Jane Austen meets CS Lewis.
In this magical time travel romance series that begins with an adventure for- not the famous Lizzy and Darcy of Pride and Prejudice fame- the dour and overlooked Mary who comes into her own and positively shows her stuff.
The story was slow to develop as it took a step back to set up the whole series and show how the Bennets came to be the keepers of the magical wardrobe, what happened in the past and led into the current story about Mary, and also introduced a few other threads left purposefully dangling. It is obvious that much is occurring beyond the surface story (mysterious elder woman whom Mary notices) and also is the set up for future stories in the series.
Time travel elements can pull me in or distract me when I read them, but I loved how the Bennet Wardrobe series fleshes out the explanation and even has rules that the time traveler must follow to use the magical wardrobe.
The historical context of this story is also carefully treated so no glaring anachronisms poke out to distract me. In fact, I had a great time with the references to not just Austen's literary characters and stories, but others as well. It was fun to spot them.
But in the end, it is always the characters who make or break a story for me and I was enchanted with this author's version of Mary Bennet and the surrounding characters.
Amanda Berry was as delightful as ever voicing the story. I find her tone and pacing, voice range, and style of narration a great fit for both the story and for me as the listener. I was glad to catch her in action once again.
All in all, my time with The Keeper was well-spent and I would recommend the book/series/narrator for those who enjoy both time travel romance and classical stories given a variation.
My thanks to the author for the opportunity to listen to this book in exchange for an honest review.
COYER Summer Birthday Bash Scavenger Hunt Clue #1 first in series
In my recent mood, I've been picking up time travel- themed books for my reading pleasure. The Keeper is actually a re-read for me and a recent one at that. On this occasion I picked up the audio version and settled in for a delightful time of Jane Austen meets CS Lewis.
In this magical time travel romance series that begins with an adventure for- not the famous Lizzy and Darcy of Pride and Prejudice fame- the dour and overlooked Mary who comes into her own and positively shows her stuff.
The story was slow to develop as it took a step back to set up the whole series and show how the Bennets came to be the keepers of the magical wardrobe, what happened in the past and led into the current story about Mary, and also introduced a few other threads left purposefully dangling. It is obvious that much is occurring beyond the surface story (mysterious elder woman whom Mary notices) and also is the set up for future stories in the series.
Time travel elements can pull me in or distract me when I read them, but I loved how the Bennet Wardrobe series fleshes out the explanation and even has rules that the time traveler must follow to use the magical wardrobe.
The historical context of this story is also carefully treated so no glaring anachronisms poke out to distract me. In fact, I had a great time with the references to not just Austen's literary characters and stories, but others as well. It was fun to spot them.
But in the end, it is always the characters who make or break a story for me and I was enchanted with this author's version of Mary Bennet and the surrounding characters.
Amanda Berry was as delightful as ever voicing the story. I find her tone and pacing, voice range, and style of narration a great fit for both the story and for me as the listener. I was glad to catch her in action once again.
All in all, my time with The Keeper was well-spent and I would recommend the book/series/narrator for those who enjoy both time travel romance and classical stories given a variation.
My thanks to the author for the opportunity to listen to this book in exchange for an honest review.
COYER Summer Birthday Bash Scavenger Hunt Clue #1 first in series
February 1, 2019
The Keeper: Mary Bennet’s Extraordinary Journey is a richly-researched and fantastically creative take on Jane Austen’s characters from Pride and Prejudice. Author Don Jacobson takes the seemingly mundane — a piece of furniture and middle-sister Mary Bennet — and transforms them into agents of great change. While time travel is, on the surface, at the root of all this change, the true transformation happens through Mary’s recognition of her strengths and weaknesses. She goes on to help other characters make similar transformations.
Jacobson is a great world builder. He weaves into his story amazing detail about Regency England, as well as other time periods and places—and does so in a way that creates a compelling alternate reality for our favorite Pride and Prejudice characters. While I felt that this level of detail sometimes pulled me out of the story emotionally, I was always intellectually engaged, thanks to Jacobson’s pure creativity.
If you’re looking for a book that is different from any other Pride and Prejudice variation out there, and you’re someone who loves thinking about the big questions of history, this is a book you’ll enjoy. I certainly did!
Jacobson is a great world builder. He weaves into his story amazing detail about Regency England, as well as other time periods and places—and does so in a way that creates a compelling alternate reality for our favorite Pride and Prejudice characters. While I felt that this level of detail sometimes pulled me out of the story emotionally, I was always intellectually engaged, thanks to Jacobson’s pure creativity.
If you’re looking for a book that is different from any other Pride and Prejudice variation out there, and you’re someone who loves thinking about the big questions of history, this is a book you’ll enjoy. I certainly did!
June 2, 2017
Bymaryannon December 10, 2016
Format: Kindle Edition
At first I didn't know what to expect and I was thoroughly amazed at the plot. It took me awhile to try and figure out what was going on as I read for I am not into time-travel and the modern view of novels of such. However, the longer I read, the more interested I got into the novel.
I thought it was a great twist of any other P & P novel that I have read. I came to appreciate the history of the keeper and the rules of living by them for the characters.
I understood why the author made Mary, Lydia, Wickham and Caroline stand out in this novel as how they have been underrated in many novels.
I did feel bad that Elizabeth left Darcy at such a young age leaving Caroline to spend so much time with Darcy. All in all, I am looking forward to Book 2 in this series to see how Kitty stands out.
The only trouble I had was going back to keep some characters straight but I did recognize when Mr. Benton came back who he was immediately. Now I am getting the jest, I said to myself!
Format: Kindle Edition
At first I didn't know what to expect and I was thoroughly amazed at the plot. It took me awhile to try and figure out what was going on as I read for I am not into time-travel and the modern view of novels of such. However, the longer I read, the more interested I got into the novel.
I thought it was a great twist of any other P & P novel that I have read. I came to appreciate the history of the keeper and the rules of living by them for the characters.
I understood why the author made Mary, Lydia, Wickham and Caroline stand out in this novel as how they have been underrated in many novels.
I did feel bad that Elizabeth left Darcy at such a young age leaving Caroline to spend so much time with Darcy. All in all, I am looking forward to Book 2 in this series to see how Kitty stands out.
The only trouble I had was going back to keep some characters straight but I did recognize when Mr. Benton came back who he was immediately. Now I am getting the jest, I said to myself!
June 18, 2016
A Wonderful Surprise!
I didn't know what to expect but how wonderful was it to read a different and original alternative PP story! The author did a masterful job of creating a unique story of the intertwining lives of a our dear characters and the timeless love of family.
I didn't know what to expect but how wonderful was it to read a different and original alternative PP story! The author did a masterful job of creating a unique story of the intertwining lives of a our dear characters and the timeless love of family.
March 13, 2018
Imaginative and great!
I really enjoyed this story. It's narrative and the plot are completely different from any other P&P variations I've ever read, and I have read a lot of them. I can't wait to read the following books!
I really enjoyed this story. It's narrative and the plot are completely different from any other P&P variations I've ever read, and I have read a lot of them. I can't wait to read the following books!
Read
August 5, 2016I am adding this book because I did read through it several times prior to publishing. Thought I deserved to add it to my "Read" shelf. (grin).
March 28, 2020
The Keeper: Mary Bennet’s Extraordinary Journey is the first book of the Bennet Wardrobe Saga, a series that explores the adventures each Bennet family member has following their interaction with the family Wardrobe.
The Bennet Wardrobe is a time travel device of sorts that transports people with the Bennet bloodline to any place in the past or future that is best for them. The Bennet family member cannot choose where they will go, it is up to the Wardrobe to understand where they need to be, and they cannot go back and forward as they please, so we will have only one adventure per Bennet family member.
The book starts a few generates prior to Thomas Bennet and his daughters existence, so the reader is able to see the Wardrobe being built and used for the first. We are also acquainted with the Wardrobe rules that will have a huge impact in the story and the evolution of the family line.
I absolutely love time travel novels and even if this isn’t a regular time travel story, I loved all aspects that were associated with the time travel, which means I loved these initial chapters. They were an introduction to the time travel story and it was amusing to learn about all the wardrobe rules, how it was created and also to learn the entire story of the Bennet family, namely how Mr. Bennet ended up as Master of Longbourn.
I felt compelled to read page after page (actually listen chapter after chapter) just to learn about what would happen to all characters, because even if this is Mary’s story, the truth is that all Bennet family will appear and have their own stories introduced in this first novel of the series.
Mary’s love interest and Kitty’s story kept me motivated to continue reading, and made me want to read the second volume of the saga immediately, but I also loved the fact that the book focuses mostly on Mary. The only quibble I had with it was that the changes in her character and in Mrs. Bennet’s were too drastic and sudden in my opinion.
This story is complex and full of small details that are crucial for the narrative; nevertheless, it is easy for the reader to follow it due to the writer’s ability to explain everything. It has many hints concerning the next stories in the saga and as the story progresses readers are pulled into it.
It is very difficult to create such a story and only a talented story teller could pull it through, so congrats are in order for Don Jacobson for crafting such a complex and appealing story. It is not every author who is able to develop such an intricate story.
The Keeper: Mary Bennet’s Extraordinary Journey is a captivating novel which is so different from anything ever written in the genre, that it occupied a place that was unexplored until this moment. I hope this is a trend that came to stay because it is indeed compelling, fresh and stimulating.
I highly recommend this book to readers who want something a little different than usual and that will stimulate them as readers. This is not the average JAFF book, and the author was able to think outside of the box, so if you’re looking for something that differs from the regular boring plot while following the entire Bennet family’s story, this is the book for you.
The Bennet Wardrobe is a time travel device of sorts that transports people with the Bennet bloodline to any place in the past or future that is best for them. The Bennet family member cannot choose where they will go, it is up to the Wardrobe to understand where they need to be, and they cannot go back and forward as they please, so we will have only one adventure per Bennet family member.
The book starts a few generates prior to Thomas Bennet and his daughters existence, so the reader is able to see the Wardrobe being built and used for the first. We are also acquainted with the Wardrobe rules that will have a huge impact in the story and the evolution of the family line.
I absolutely love time travel novels and even if this isn’t a regular time travel story, I loved all aspects that were associated with the time travel, which means I loved these initial chapters. They were an introduction to the time travel story and it was amusing to learn about all the wardrobe rules, how it was created and also to learn the entire story of the Bennet family, namely how Mr. Bennet ended up as Master of Longbourn.
I felt compelled to read page after page (actually listen chapter after chapter) just to learn about what would happen to all characters, because even if this is Mary’s story, the truth is that all Bennet family will appear and have their own stories introduced in this first novel of the series.
Mary’s love interest and Kitty’s story kept me motivated to continue reading, and made me want to read the second volume of the saga immediately, but I also loved the fact that the book focuses mostly on Mary. The only quibble I had with it was that the changes in her character and in Mrs. Bennet’s were too drastic and sudden in my opinion.
This story is complex and full of small details that are crucial for the narrative; nevertheless, it is easy for the reader to follow it due to the writer’s ability to explain everything. It has many hints concerning the next stories in the saga and as the story progresses readers are pulled into it.
It is very difficult to create such a story and only a talented story teller could pull it through, so congrats are in order for Don Jacobson for crafting such a complex and appealing story. It is not every author who is able to develop such an intricate story.
The Keeper: Mary Bennet’s Extraordinary Journey is a captivating novel which is so different from anything ever written in the genre, that it occupied a place that was unexplored until this moment. I hope this is a trend that came to stay because it is indeed compelling, fresh and stimulating.
I highly recommend this book to readers who want something a little different than usual and that will stimulate them as readers. This is not the average JAFF book, and the author was able to think outside of the box, so if you’re looking for something that differs from the regular boring plot while following the entire Bennet family’s story, this is the book for you.
February 23, 2018
The historical research added much to the validity of the events unfolding around the characters. Seeing Mary develop as a person and in character, even falling in love, was such a treat. This Mary has substance and is no longer in the shadows of her other siblings. She forges a path and comes into her own as a strong, caring and respected woman. I liked this Mary and was proud of her and for her. She’s solid!
Then there’s Edward B. What a man! His story from the beginning was one of strong faith and values. He was true to himself and upheld his destiny.
The Wardrobe became its own character in my mind. It felt as a living breathing entity and not in a bad way. It is good in that it helps each ‘visitor’ with what he or she needs most in their lives. It helps each find his/her destiny.
I read The Exile: Kitty Bennet and the Belle Époque first, but I see the value in reading them in order. Although it did not take away from my enjoyment of either book, there are things I would have understood better, had I read The Keeper: Mary Bennet’s Extraordinary Journey first, as the author intended.
This is not a light, fluffy book. It has substance and tells a story, including historical events unfolding as they did. There is so much to love about this book. I highly recommend it.
Then there’s Edward B. What a man! His story from the beginning was one of strong faith and values. He was true to himself and upheld his destiny.
The Wardrobe became its own character in my mind. It felt as a living breathing entity and not in a bad way. It is good in that it helps each ‘visitor’ with what he or she needs most in their lives. It helps each find his/her destiny.
I read The Exile: Kitty Bennet and the Belle Époque first, but I see the value in reading them in order. Although it did not take away from my enjoyment of either book, there are things I would have understood better, had I read The Keeper: Mary Bennet’s Extraordinary Journey first, as the author intended.
This is not a light, fluffy book. It has substance and tells a story, including historical events unfolding as they did. There is so much to love about this book. I highly recommend it.
June 24, 2020
In 1691 Grinling Gibbins makes a magical wardrobe for Christopher Bennet the new owner of Longbourn. A wardrobe which sends blood Bennets to the future they need. This is the story that leads to Mary Bennet becoming a Keeper of the wardrobe, and her life story. The story weaves itself around historical people and places (as a lover of history I am okay with that) while telling the story of the Bennets, and the other characters from the original.
I really enjoyed the story and I am hoping to read the adventures of the other Bennets who went through the wardrobe.
I really enjoyed the story and I am hoping to read the adventures of the other Bennets who went through the wardrobe.
September 29, 2017
For lovers of Jane Austen I'd say this is a must-read: an interesting story with a paranormal twist, Jacobson marshals the English language with grace and beauty. To wit: "He schooled his features to impassivity"; "The rays of late autumn sun caressed her, their crystalline clarity speaking soundless volumes of peace and comfort."
I was particularly enamored of Mary's epiphany scene in which she realizes what a selfish child she's been. Plus, the scene in the conflagration is gripping.
I was particularly enamored of Mary's epiphany scene in which she realizes what a selfish child she's been. Plus, the scene in the conflagration is gripping.
July 14, 2023
This one left me with such a mix of feelings. On the one hand there was much I enjoyed, but on the other there were several things I didn’t. I loved watching Mary come into her own and her family recognizing that. And I enjoyed so much of the adventures of everyone including the extended family members and all those who eventually comprise the Five Families. I never knew where the storyline was going next and it kept me hooked in!
However, as others have noted the historical details got a bit much for me and I skipped through several parts. Also the plot does feel a bit disjointed at times, like we go from one big situation and then skip a few years and spend time on another, and keeping track of who’s who outside of the P&P regulars got a little difficult. (Which is really a product of the novel spanning such a large amount of time, I think.) I’m also not a fan of instantaneous love, though I did like Mary’s love interest overall, they fit quite well together. Also the villains really got far too dramatically angsty for my tastes and I definitely skipped through their parts! So…I liked most things and the problems I had were (mostly) easy to overlook so I could continue enjoying. (Basically I put my brain on a shelf during a few parts and picked it back up later 😆) The scope of detail and thought Mr Jacobson put into his world building impressed me for sure! So I am definitely intrigued enough to want to read more in the series…
However, as others have noted the historical details got a bit much for me and I skipped through several parts. Also the plot does feel a bit disjointed at times, like we go from one big situation and then skip a few years and spend time on another, and keeping track of who’s who outside of the P&P regulars got a little difficult. (Which is really a product of the novel spanning such a large amount of time, I think.) I’m also not a fan of instantaneous love, though I did like Mary’s love interest overall, they fit quite well together. Also the villains really got far too dramatically angsty for my tastes and I definitely skipped through their parts! So…I liked most things and the problems I had were (mostly) easy to overlook so I could continue enjoying. (Basically I put my brain on a shelf during a few parts and picked it back up later 😆) The scope of detail and thought Mr Jacobson put into his world building impressed me for sure! So I am definitely intrigued enough to want to read more in the series…
October 19, 2020
It really was an extraordinary journey! I’m sad it ended and that there was so little of Lizzy and Darcy as they are my favorite couple. I also didn’t like that Lizzy was gone so young and the author kind of implied that Darcy and Caroline were together more than friends even if they were old! Ewww! Just no! 😩
Mary’s story was fascinating! Really enjoyed it and will continue with the series
Sorry for the spoiler
Mary’s story was fascinating! Really enjoyed it and will continue with the series
Sorry for the spoiler
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
July 10, 2017
Time traveling Pride and prejudice
The thought of time travel and P&P seemed like a trite convention but having read other works by the author, I decided to take a chance and read it anyway. I'm glad I did. The time travel aspect was strange but unusual enough to be an added benefit to the storyline.
The thought of time travel and P&P seemed like a trite convention but having read other works by the author, I decided to take a chance and read it anyway. I'm glad I did. The time travel aspect was strange but unusual enough to be an added benefit to the storyline.
October 21, 2020
So different
It's a bit overwhelming: not only the interweaving of magic in so understated a manner into a Pride and Prejudice novel but also the references to other novels, modern items, history. Requires a lot of suspended disbelief. At times the characters are a bit more verbose than I think a normal human would be. I think Americanisms have been mixed in, sometimes you could reason why, but not always (vacation). However, I was always eager to find our what was going to happen next. And why is a certain favorite character's lifeline so short? However, I am not convinced I wasn't too read all in the series...feels too heavy. Perhaps would change my mind after a break.
It's a bit overwhelming: not only the interweaving of magic in so understated a manner into a Pride and Prejudice novel but also the references to other novels, modern items, history. Requires a lot of suspended disbelief. At times the characters are a bit more verbose than I think a normal human would be. I think Americanisms have been mixed in, sometimes you could reason why, but not always (vacation). However, I was always eager to find our what was going to happen next. And why is a certain favorite character's lifeline so short? However, I am not convinced I wasn't too read all in the series...feels too heavy. Perhaps would change my mind after a break.
January 23, 2019
Brilliant
Having now read the Bennett Wardrobe origin book and this one about Mary, I confess that although at times the concept is confusing, I'm hooked. Who knew Mary Bennett would be so interesting? And not just Mary but practically the whole family of Bennett daughters has significant contributions to make in their lifetimes. The beginning chapters were a recap of the origin book, but necessary to establish Edward Benton at a certain place in time. His introduction is critical to Mary's future. It wasn't hard to guess just how he fit into the picture, but it's pretty brilliant how things evolved, including the direct involvement of Mary's father in the relationship between Mary and Edward Benton. What a strange twist of fate that was.
This story is pretty heavy on the religious excerpts and musings, almost to the point where it's a little preachy. However, I figured that was due to the two main characters being people of deep faith.
I recommend this book highly. It is completely unexpected and delightful.
Having now read the Bennett Wardrobe origin book and this one about Mary, I confess that although at times the concept is confusing, I'm hooked. Who knew Mary Bennett would be so interesting? And not just Mary but practically the whole family of Bennett daughters has significant contributions to make in their lifetimes. The beginning chapters were a recap of the origin book, but necessary to establish Edward Benton at a certain place in time. His introduction is critical to Mary's future. It wasn't hard to guess just how he fit into the picture, but it's pretty brilliant how things evolved, including the direct involvement of Mary's father in the relationship between Mary and Edward Benton. What a strange twist of fate that was.
This story is pretty heavy on the religious excerpts and musings, almost to the point where it's a little preachy. However, I figured that was due to the two main characters being people of deep faith.
I recommend this book highly. It is completely unexpected and delightful.
November 20, 2025
I generally don’t like time-travel novels. They way too often seem to throw a 21st century person into a previous century (or vice versa) where he/she alternately glories in the different time period or freaks out about it, all the while developing a deep romantic attachment. Not my cup of tea.
However, this one tosses a character from an earlier time period into another earlier time period and then focuses not on the time traveler but instead upon characters who continue to live in their own original era. The time travel is not, like in many books, simply a plot device to get a character into a different era where he/she can experience wildly unfamiliar situations and encounter completely unexpected challenges. It is instead embodied as a physical object that is gradually, increasingly comprehended by characters to be a possible clue to the solving of some of their puzzling, unanswered questions about, and unexpected challenges encountered in, their own here and now.
Nicely done
However, this one tosses a character from an earlier time period into another earlier time period and then focuses not on the time traveler but instead upon characters who continue to live in their own original era. The time travel is not, like in many books, simply a plot device to get a character into a different era where he/she can experience wildly unfamiliar situations and encounter completely unexpected challenges. It is instead embodied as a physical object that is gradually, increasingly comprehended by characters to be a possible clue to the solving of some of their puzzling, unanswered questions about, and unexpected challenges encountered in, their own here and now.
Nicely done
Displaying 1 - 30 of 45 reviews