What do you think?
Rate this book
The Invisible Library #8
The Untold Story
Librarian Spy Irene is heading into danger. Not for the first time, but could this be her last? She’s tasked with a terrifyingly dangerous solo mission to eliminate an old enemy, which must be kept secret at all costs. But even more troubling news emerges. Multiple worlds are disappearing – and the Library may have something to do with it.
Determined to uncover the truth behind the vanished worlds, Irene and her friends must descend into the unplumbed depths of the Library. And what they find will change everything they know. This may be Irene’s most dangerous assignment of her hazardous career.
Determined to uncover the truth behind the vanished worlds, Irene and her friends must descend into the unplumbed depths of the Library. And what they find will change everything they know. This may be Irene’s most dangerous assignment of her hazardous career.
387 pages, Paperback
First published December 9, 2021
268 people are currently reading
5984 people want to read
About the author
Genevieve Cogman
44 books4,568 followersGenevieve Cogman got started on Tolkien and Sherlock Holmes at an early age, and has never looked back. But on a perhaps more prosaic note, she has an MSC in Statistics with Medical Applications and has wielded this in an assortment of jobs: clinical coder, data analyst and classifications specialist. Although The Invisible Library is her debut novel, she has also previously worked as a freelance roleplaying game writer. Genevieve Cogman’s hobbies include patchwork, beading, knitting and gaming, and she lives in the north of England.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 817 reviews
January 29, 2022
In this final (for now at least) installment of the Invisible Library series, Irene and her friends delve deep into the history of the Library itself, discovering the truth behind its creation. Of course such a quest is bound to be filled with danger and excitement, the group encountering many old friends, and a few old enemies along the way.
I've been a fan of the Invisible Library series since I discovered it a few years ago. It's a fun and light-hearted series with some great characters, who I have over the years become rather attached to. The books are usually quite fast-paced and action-filled, intertwining mystery, magic and adventure, and of course always at the series' heart a deep love and appreciation for books and stories in themselves.
An eight book series, there has been a sense of a change in course as the books have progressed. Where they started off with Irene usually assigned a particular mission for a book retrieval, as the series has gone on, the Library has definitely assumed a more political role in the ongoing power struggle between Dragons and Fae; Irene herself being assigned the role of a peace treaty representative. In the last few books there have been hints that there may be more to the origins of the Library than its Librarians have generally been led to believe, and here at last the secrets of the Library are finally revealed. With a familiar face returning in the last book, and the revelation that went with this, there are of course other loose strands to tie up here with Alberich; with Cogman very much interconnecting Alberich's past with the discoveries about the Library itself.
Having been such a fan of the series overall, and also having very much looked forward to previously teased mysteries finally being revealed, I have to say that overall I was rather disappointed with this final installment. For a start it just took so long to really get to the real story here, with a lot of procrastinating and just going round in circles. It wasn't that there wasn't action going on, but I found myself getting rather bored of people constantly showing up and threatening Irene and the gang, and interrupting the more interesting driving narrative of the story. All these threats seemed rather excessive and repetitive, and there just to stretch out the story. Then there was all Irene's internal monologue and deliberation, not to mention the amount of time the gang spent just talking and theorizing about what was going on.
It seemed that the story only really got going after the half way mark, and certainly there were some interesting elements here, such as the eventual meeting with Alberich. I also liked Aunt Isra's part, and certainly the later parts of the book picked up. However it was all just a bit too late, and even then it didn't quite pack the punch I had been hoping for. I don't want to give too much away about the revelations of the origins of the Library, but overall I thought this aspect of the story was told rather dis-jointedly, and whilst not bad, didn't for me personally live up to expectations. I did appreciate the idea that the founders' intentions may have started off well, but that they had lost sight of their original motivations over time.
I would have liked more interaction between Alberich and Irene, as I thought the dynamic between them was interesting and that more could have been done with it. We do see a lot of characters from the series within this book, and some certainly have some very memorable moments such as Bradamant. Lord Silver, as always is delightful, and there was an interesting reveal regarding Melusine that I hadn't seen coming.
As for our main group, whilst by now I love them as characters just for the time we have spent with them overall, (Catherine less so, as she only appeared in the last book, and I still maintain can be a trifle irritating), I'm not sure that this book in itself really added much to their characters for me. There were perhaps a few moments between Irene and Kai where they do for the first time at least properly acknowledge their feelings for each other, which was nice to see. Obviously by now it is clear to see how much they all mean to each other, and the extent to which each one is willing to risk their lives for the others, the bond between them all certainly resonating.
Overall, I think I would have liked this book much better had it been a bit more character-driven, and really there was no excuse for it not to be given Irene's personal relationship with Alberich, which could have been explored much better in my opinion. Also the story itself was told in too convoluted a fashion, with a lot of action just for action's sake.
Given how much I have enjoyed this series overall, I found my experience of this last book a pity, but I still appreciate the series as a whole. I do think it probably a good thing that Cogman is leaving this world and these characters (for now at least), as I think the series has come to a logical conclusion, and I will certainly be checking out her next planned series that comes out later this year.
I've been a fan of the Invisible Library series since I discovered it a few years ago. It's a fun and light-hearted series with some great characters, who I have over the years become rather attached to. The books are usually quite fast-paced and action-filled, intertwining mystery, magic and adventure, and of course always at the series' heart a deep love and appreciation for books and stories in themselves.
An eight book series, there has been a sense of a change in course as the books have progressed. Where they started off with Irene usually assigned a particular mission for a book retrieval, as the series has gone on, the Library has definitely assumed a more political role in the ongoing power struggle between Dragons and Fae; Irene herself being assigned the role of a peace treaty representative. In the last few books there have been hints that there may be more to the origins of the Library than its Librarians have generally been led to believe, and here at last the secrets of the Library are finally revealed. With a familiar face returning in the last book, and the revelation that went with this, there are of course other loose strands to tie up here with Alberich; with Cogman very much interconnecting Alberich's past with the discoveries about the Library itself.
Having been such a fan of the series overall, and also having very much looked forward to previously teased mysteries finally being revealed, I have to say that overall I was rather disappointed with this final installment. For a start it just took so long to really get to the real story here, with a lot of procrastinating and just going round in circles. It wasn't that there wasn't action going on, but I found myself getting rather bored of people constantly showing up and threatening Irene and the gang, and interrupting the more interesting driving narrative of the story. All these threats seemed rather excessive and repetitive, and there just to stretch out the story. Then there was all Irene's internal monologue and deliberation, not to mention the amount of time the gang spent just talking and theorizing about what was going on.
It seemed that the story only really got going after the half way mark, and certainly there were some interesting elements here, such as the eventual meeting with Alberich. I also liked Aunt Isra's part, and certainly the later parts of the book picked up. However it was all just a bit too late, and even then it didn't quite pack the punch I had been hoping for. I don't want to give too much away about the revelations of the origins of the Library, but overall I thought this aspect of the story was told rather dis-jointedly, and whilst not bad, didn't for me personally live up to expectations. I did appreciate the idea that the founders' intentions may have started off well, but that they had lost sight of their original motivations over time.
I would have liked more interaction between Alberich and Irene, as I thought the dynamic between them was interesting and that more could have been done with it. We do see a lot of characters from the series within this book, and some certainly have some very memorable moments such as Bradamant. Lord Silver, as always is delightful, and there was an interesting reveal regarding Melusine that I hadn't seen coming.
As for our main group, whilst by now I love them as characters just for the time we have spent with them overall, (Catherine less so, as she only appeared in the last book, and I still maintain can be a trifle irritating), I'm not sure that this book in itself really added much to their characters for me. There were perhaps a few moments between Irene and Kai where they do for the first time at least properly acknowledge their feelings for each other, which was nice to see. Obviously by now it is clear to see how much they all mean to each other, and the extent to which each one is willing to risk their lives for the others, the bond between them all certainly resonating.
Overall, I think I would have liked this book much better had it been a bit more character-driven, and really there was no excuse for it not to be given Irene's personal relationship with Alberich, which could have been explored much better in my opinion. Also the story itself was told in too convoluted a fashion, with a lot of action just for action's sake.
Given how much I have enjoyed this series overall, I found my experience of this last book a pity, but I still appreciate the series as a whole. I do think it probably a good thing that Cogman is leaving this world and these characters (for now at least), as I think the series has come to a logical conclusion, and I will certainly be checking out her next planned series that comes out later this year.
January 21, 2022
Excellent! Irene returns to prominence within the Library, forced away from her diplomatic mission by mysterious rumblings within her home institution. Armed with knowledge of her true parentage, the Language, and a secret assignment from the elder Librarians, Irene sets out with Kai and Vale to deal with Alberich, enemy of the Library and Irene's natural father.
Some familiar stumbling blocks exist—Librarian Bradamant, Irene's nemesis, is determined to put an end to Irene's flight out of the library, considering her arrogant and acting on impulse. Apprentice Catharine wants conflicting things, both to spend time in the Library and to be included in Irene's mission. Alberich seems to want some kind of relationship with his daughter. Kai's older brother seems to be determined to have Kai's diplomatic position by hook or by crook.
As per usual, Irene must wiggle her way out of several tight places and think on her feet, desperately putting facts and hints together to come to the correct conclusion. The tension is good and Irene, Kai, and Vale feel more like a real team than they did in the previous book. Irene has learned to lean on other people, an extremely important skill for all of us.
This particular plotline gets more or less resolved, but from the afterword I gather that there will be new adventures for Irene and company. I hope this is the case, as I am still enamoured by Irene and Kai, not to mention the Invisible Library.
Some familiar stumbling blocks exist—Librarian Bradamant, Irene's nemesis, is determined to put an end to Irene's flight out of the library, considering her arrogant and acting on impulse. Apprentice Catharine wants conflicting things, both to spend time in the Library and to be included in Irene's mission. Alberich seems to want some kind of relationship with his daughter. Kai's older brother seems to be determined to have Kai's diplomatic position by hook or by crook.
As per usual, Irene must wiggle her way out of several tight places and think on her feet, desperately putting facts and hints together to come to the correct conclusion. The tension is good and Irene, Kai, and Vale feel more like a real team than they did in the previous book. Irene has learned to lean on other people, an extremely important skill for all of us.
This particular plotline gets more or less resolved, but from the afterword I gather that there will be new adventures for Irene and company. I hope this is the case, as I am still enamoured by Irene and Kai, not to mention the Invisible Library.
December 28, 2021
Thanks to Netgalley and Berkley for providing me with an advanced copy in exchange for an honest review.
Wow, now that is what I call fun... for me, that is. Not really all that much fun for Irene and her motley crew. No, not fun at all for them. Really, the exact opposite of fun.
Big developments in this one. HUGE ones. Like super uber ginormous. With vast repercussions for the library and every single world.
I really want to be a Librarian, just so I can explore worlds and use the Language. But maybe I'd like it a little more AFTER the events of this book, considering.
I know, I know, I'm beating around the bush a lot. But I really don't want to spoil anything.
Pick this one up as soon as you can, but only if you've read the rest. This one is the culmination of a SERIES WORTH of storyline.
Highly recommended.
Wow, now that is what I call fun... for me, that is. Not really all that much fun for Irene and her motley crew. No, not fun at all for them. Really, the exact opposite of fun.
Big developments in this one. HUGE ones. Like super uber ginormous. With vast repercussions for the library and every single world.
I really want to be a Librarian, just so I can explore worlds and use the Language. But maybe I'd like it a little more AFTER the events of this book, considering.
I know, I know, I'm beating around the bush a lot. But I really don't want to spoil anything.
Pick this one up as soon as you can, but only if you've read the rest. This one is the culmination of a SERIES WORTH of storyline.
Highly recommended.
December 28, 2021
Real Rating: 4.5* of five, because 92%
My first official 2022 review (calendars are arbitrary, I'm making my own) is posted at Expendable Mudge Muses Aloud.
My first official 2022 review (calendars are arbitrary, I'm making my own) is posted at Expendable Mudge Muses Aloud.
December 28, 2021
I have been a big fan of this series from the beginning. It has become of the books that I look forward to reading every year. I had no idea that the series was drawing to a close but as I read I just kept thinking how final everything felt. From what I read on the author’s website, the series may resume again in the future but this is the end for now. This book was just as good as I had hoped that it would be and I am so thankful for the hours of entertainment this series has given me over the years.
This series is one that I do suggest be read in order. Fans of the series will love that they will finally get all the answers they have been waiting for over the course of the series. This book had all of the excitement that I have come to expect from this series. It really seemed like the odds were stacked against Irene and her friends but they always seem to find a way to come out okay in the end. Irene is trying to learn the truth about Alberich, the Library wants her to kill him, and Alberich claims to be ready to sign a truce. To say things are complicated is an understatement and Irene’s task will take her to the very core of the Library.
I loved the characters in this book. It has been great to see this group of characters grow throughout the series. Irene is such a strong character and the bonds that she has formed with her close friends are even stronger. I really liked seeing Irene, Kai, and Vale work together as a team. They all are very good at thinking quickly and can usually find the best way out of a situation. I loved the fact that so many characters that made appearances in previous installments were featured in this book.
I highly recommend this series to others. This is a very exciting addition to an imaginative series filled with fantastic characters. I cannot wait to read more of this author’s work in the future.
I received a digital review copy of this book from Berkley Publishing Group via NetGalley.
This series is one that I do suggest be read in order. Fans of the series will love that they will finally get all the answers they have been waiting for over the course of the series. This book had all of the excitement that I have come to expect from this series. It really seemed like the odds were stacked against Irene and her friends but they always seem to find a way to come out okay in the end. Irene is trying to learn the truth about Alberich, the Library wants her to kill him, and Alberich claims to be ready to sign a truce. To say things are complicated is an understatement and Irene’s task will take her to the very core of the Library.
I loved the characters in this book. It has been great to see this group of characters grow throughout the series. Irene is such a strong character and the bonds that she has formed with her close friends are even stronger. I really liked seeing Irene, Kai, and Vale work together as a team. They all are very good at thinking quickly and can usually find the best way out of a situation. I loved the fact that so many characters that made appearances in previous installments were featured in this book.
I highly recommend this series to others. This is a very exciting addition to an imaginative series filled with fantastic characters. I cannot wait to read more of this author’s work in the future.
I received a digital review copy of this book from Berkley Publishing Group via NetGalley.
December 17, 2021
I received a gifted ARC of this book to read in exchange for an honest review via Black Crow PR as part of the book tour.
The Untold Story is the final installment in the Invisible Library series.
I don't actually realise this was part of a series and can't wait to delve into the previous books ASAP!
Kai and Vale are the main characters in this installment and have been put in danger as the library tries to be rid if Alberichs influence for good.
This book had a great mix of magic, mystery and adventure and kept me interested from the first few chapters when I got to grips with who was who and what was what. This book felt like an episode from a Netflix series and I can see this series at some point being adapted as such. The descriptive language was interesting and visual and I honestly wish I had cone across this series a lot sooner.
The Untold Story is the final installment in the Invisible Library series.
I don't actually realise this was part of a series and can't wait to delve into the previous books ASAP!
Kai and Vale are the main characters in this installment and have been put in danger as the library tries to be rid if Alberichs influence for good.
This book had a great mix of magic, mystery and adventure and kept me interested from the first few chapters when I got to grips with who was who and what was what. This book felt like an episode from a Netflix series and I can see this series at some point being adapted as such. The descriptive language was interesting and visual and I honestly wish I had cone across this series a lot sooner.
February 12, 2022
An unremarkable end to a remarkable series
I really enjoyed the Invisible Library series- up until this finale. I tore through the prior seven books and eagerly awaited the release of this eighth book. But sadly it fell flat for me. The plot was not very engaging- I was so bored reading it that it took me almost two months to finish! And unlike the other books, the details were not that interesting or fantastical. The story behind the Library’s creation and Alberich’s betrayal was bland and lacked the creativity Cogman presented in the prior novels. The climax was confusing and the end-result unsatisfying. All in all, a disappointing conclusion.
I really enjoyed the Invisible Library series- up until this finale. I tore through the prior seven books and eagerly awaited the release of this eighth book. But sadly it fell flat for me. The plot was not very engaging- I was so bored reading it that it took me almost two months to finish! And unlike the other books, the details were not that interesting or fantastical. The story behind the Library’s creation and Alberich’s betrayal was bland and lacked the creativity Cogman presented in the prior novels. The climax was confusing and the end-result unsatisfying. All in all, a disappointing conclusion.
January 9, 2022
Ugghhhh I can't believe this series has come to its end. Gonna miss my preciouses Irene, Kai, Vale and Silver so much
May 25, 2024
I knew I didn't need to finish this series, which has always been about a three star one for me, but there was just one left. The Untold Story took me three weeks to finish, never quite catching my interest beyond the few pages I could read at night before conking out. With long series, I often feel that the final books are beginning to collapse under the weight of previous events and characters, and book the eighth - of a series I started reading a decade ago - suffers from this kind of red giant star progression. There's some self-awareness of the tropes it indulges in, and there's minor amusement to be had at the hijinks of our intrepid heroes, but I was uninvested in the big showdown and the events leading up to it. There's not much emotional impact, I think - at this point, Irene has established relationships with her friends and has even reached a certain level of familiarity with her enemies.
Meh. Not a fix for a book slump.
Meh. Not a fix for a book slump.
January 1, 2022
There are times when I'm interested in a series because of the brilliant idea behind it, but then I also get attached to the characters and so the fact that it may be a bit boring or not particularly compelling takes a back seat. For several books in the "Invisible Library" it was like that in my case, for this last one, I admit I managed to get to the end only because in the introduction the author made it clear that it would be the last.
Ci sono delle volte in cui una serie mi interessa per l'idea geniale di fondo, ma poi mi affeziono anche ai personaggi e quindi il fatto che magari sia un po' noiosa o non particolarmente avvincente passa in secondo piano. Per parecchi libri della "Invisible Library" é stato cosí nel mio caso, per quest'ultimo, ammetto di essere riuscita ad arrivare alla fine solo perché nell'introduzione l'autrice ha chiarito che sarebbe stato l'ultimo.
Ci sono delle volte in cui una serie mi interessa per l'idea geniale di fondo, ma poi mi affeziono anche ai personaggi e quindi il fatto che magari sia un po' noiosa o non particolarmente avvincente passa in secondo piano. Per parecchi libri della "Invisible Library" é stato cosí nel mio caso, per quest'ultimo, ammetto di essere riuscita ad arrivare alla fine solo perché nell'introduzione l'autrice ha chiarito che sarebbe stato l'ultimo.
December 27, 2021
The plot thickens in the latest (last??) entry in the Invisible Library series. Shocking disclosures about Irene's past have come to light, and the Library is not above using them to put her and her allies, Kai and Vale, in harm's way if they can get rid of Alberich's influence once and for all. This book follows the same general structure as previous books in the series: some interesting setup followed by a breakneck adventure. In addition, at this point in the series, we are so well-acquainted with the characters that it feels like reading about friends. We were very pleased that Vale takes on a starring role here (we have to admit that we were Vale shippers - no offense to Kai!) after his absence from some of the previous books.
What The Untold Story does that's new is a further exploration of the Library's origins. It turns out that it's not as neutral as Irene (and we readers) have thought. Since this is an adventure with a bit of mystery, we won't give away what happens, but it's a satisfying read with familiar characters and some new shocking reveals.
This objective review is based on a complimentary copy of the novel.
What The Untold Story does that's new is a further exploration of the Library's origins. It turns out that it's not as neutral as Irene (and we readers) have thought. Since this is an adventure with a bit of mystery, we won't give away what happens, but it's a satisfying read with familiar characters and some new shocking reveals.
This objective review is based on a complimentary copy of the novel.
June 5, 2022
My relationship with Irene have come to an end ...
Not that I wanted it to, but her narrator made the decision that after much hard work Irene is in need of a holiday, most likely a prolonged one.
It has been my guilty pleasure to follow a bad-ass librarian on her journeys across worlds and time zones, through dragon fire and political turmoil and deceit and I will miss her.
The conclusive (?) installment did bring some light on a lot of previously not explained details of the history of The Library, but there are still mysteries waiting for a thorough explanation.
Enjoy :-)
Not that I wanted it to, but her narrator made the decision that after much hard work Irene is in need of a holiday, most likely a prolonged one.
It has been my guilty pleasure to follow a bad-ass librarian on her journeys across worlds and time zones, through dragon fire and political turmoil and deceit and I will miss her.
The conclusive (?) installment did bring some light on a lot of previously not explained details of the history of The Library, but there are still mysteries waiting for a thorough explanation.
Enjoy :-)
February 24, 2023
I read the last three books of this series, almost back to back, and loved immersing myself in this fantasy world. In this the last book, Irene is thrust into danger when the Library tasks her with bringing down Alberich off-books. According to them, she has gone rogue. Danger, betrayal and untold stories await you in this action-packed adventure that will ultimately take us into the heart of the library.
Outside forces from older dragon brothers to someone trying to stop Irene from learning the origins of the library kept Irene, Kai, and Vale on their toes. The story was fascinating and Cogman did a wonderful job of closing threads. I loved the untold stories and different ways that it was told. The trip to the library’s heart was well done, and I could see it all unfolding.
I loved the relationship growth we witnessed between Kai and Irene. Vale and Kathryn were great help and loyal friends. We gain help from a familiar fae and travel to several alternate universes.
Because of the overall story arc and character development, I recommend reading this series in the order of its release. While each book contains a case, we gain knowledge that brought all the books together.
While things wrapped up, Cogman left the door open for more adventures and I am ready to travel back to the library but also excited to see what she brings us next. This review was originally posted at Caffeinated Reviewer
Outside forces from older dragon brothers to someone trying to stop Irene from learning the origins of the library kept Irene, Kai, and Vale on their toes. The story was fascinating and Cogman did a wonderful job of closing threads. I loved the untold stories and different ways that it was told. The trip to the library’s heart was well done, and I could see it all unfolding.
I loved the relationship growth we witnessed between Kai and Irene. Vale and Kathryn were great help and loyal friends. We gain help from a familiar fae and travel to several alternate universes.
Because of the overall story arc and character development, I recommend reading this series in the order of its release. While each book contains a case, we gain knowledge that brought all the books together.
While things wrapped up, Cogman left the door open for more adventures and I am ready to travel back to the library but also excited to see what she brings us next. This review was originally posted at Caffeinated Reviewer
September 18, 2021
Irene and Kai are back after that bombshell at the end of the last book. And yet somehow the story gets even crazier as we learn more about The Library and where it came from. As Spinal Tap would say this takes things up to 11! I wonder now though if this is the final book. It could easily end here if the author wanted too.
April 30, 2023
I would think this is the conclusion to the story if the author hadn’t specifically said that she has more in story for Irene, Kai, Vale and Catherine. I will be extremely vague because I do not want to spoil the story but I would say that The Untold Story has so many huge reveals and resolutions in it if this was the end of the series I would not be surprised. It does seem to be the end of the arc with Alberich though and that did not go at all like I would have expected so a well done to Genevieve Cogman on that.
Irene and team are trying to again save the Library and have also discovered some worlds at the far ends of chaos and order have just disappeared, probably destroyed. Irene thought the goals of the library were to store books from worlds to tie them and help keep them stable. But if that is the case why aren’t librarians focused on books and instead they are more involved with politics and getting worlds to sign the peace treaty between the dragons, fae and the library?
These questions and more will be answered as Irene and team work to save worlds, the library and solidify Irene and Kia’s relationship from outside forces.
Honestly, I think this was one of the best stories in this series and would be a great one to go out on. But I will be interested to see where the series goes next after all the revelations in The Untold Story.
“You mean me entering the Library may have destroyed the universe?” Catherine asked. “You don’t need to sound quite so impressed by it,” Irene chided. “It’s not something you want on your yearly performance review.”
Irene and team are trying to again save the Library and have also discovered some worlds at the far ends of chaos and order have just disappeared, probably destroyed. Irene thought the goals of the library were to store books from worlds to tie them and help keep them stable. But if that is the case why aren’t librarians focused on books and instead they are more involved with politics and getting worlds to sign the peace treaty between the dragons, fae and the library?
These questions and more will be answered as Irene and team work to save worlds, the library and solidify Irene and Kia’s relationship from outside forces.
“Irene realized she was on the point of shouting. Worse, of being ungrammatical. She took a deep breath.”
Honestly, I think this was one of the best stories in this series and would be a great one to go out on. But I will be interested to see where the series goes next after all the revelations in The Untold Story.
December 15, 2021
(Disclaimer: I received this book from the publisher. This has not impacted my review which is unbiased and honest.)
I have thoroughly loved the Invisible Library series. These characters have made such a home in my heart and it's in my top list of longer fantasy series to recommend. It's perfect for new fantasy fans, for ones who love mystery almost spy-like stories, and who enjoy an episodic approach (like a TV show). One of my favorite elements have to be this world of archetypes and stories. How we, even in our lives, want to believe in character types. In sweet and noble heroes, in grump and gruff but secretly sweet love interests.
And I love that Cogman not only leans into this idea - this premise of us all wanting to be the main character of our story - and the ways our lives deviates. From a world building perspective, I am obsessed. In The Untold Story, Irene, Kai, and Vale have to face the wide reaching consequences, danger, and intrigue from the previous books. This latest installment delves into Irene's revelations about her parenthood and her relationship with Kai. It also deeply dives into the past, into the very foundational building blocks of our world, selves, and loved ones.
full review: https://utopia-state-of-mind.com/revi...
I have thoroughly loved the Invisible Library series. These characters have made such a home in my heart and it's in my top list of longer fantasy series to recommend. It's perfect for new fantasy fans, for ones who love mystery almost spy-like stories, and who enjoy an episodic approach (like a TV show). One of my favorite elements have to be this world of archetypes and stories. How we, even in our lives, want to believe in character types. In sweet and noble heroes, in grump and gruff but secretly sweet love interests.
And I love that Cogman not only leans into this idea - this premise of us all wanting to be the main character of our story - and the ways our lives deviates. From a world building perspective, I am obsessed. In The Untold Story, Irene, Kai, and Vale have to face the wide reaching consequences, danger, and intrigue from the previous books. This latest installment delves into Irene's revelations about her parenthood and her relationship with Kai. It also deeply dives into the past, into the very foundational building blocks of our world, selves, and loved ones.
full review: https://utopia-state-of-mind.com/revi...
March 10, 2022
I was quite underwhelmed by the finale to the Invisible Library series. I've followed along with Irene, Kai, and Vale's for a couple years now, and the ending felt very anticlimactic.
I had a hard time finishing the book because most of it moves at a slow pace. I'd stop reading for the day and not have any motivation to pick it up for another couple days, which is very rare for me.
**Warning: Spoilers Ahead**
They've been building up Alberich as the big bad guy for multiple books, so I didn't like how his character was redeemed a bit and his actions explained in this book. Instead, it turns out there's another group of bad guys for Irene and co to go up against that are the real bad guys. It's been hinted at in the last book or two, but it felt quite rushed to go from learning the truth from Alberich right before he dies, at around 60-70% into the book, to finding and defeating the mysterious powers behind the Library. Alberich's death was also very sudden and unexpected, and didn't have the oomph that I was expecting.
The truth behind the Library's origins was also not that exciting. We learn that way back when, a human, a Fae called the Story Teller, and Kai's grandfather collaborated together to create the Library. Recently they've been very unsatisfied with how the world has been going and with the political tensions between all groups, so they decide to take things into their own hands by destroying some of the more dangerous worlds. To do so, they control Librarians through their brands, without them ever being aware of it. It's an interesting if not original premise, but it's not fleshed out nearly enough given that all of these discoveries happen in the last 40% of the book.
Irene and co travel to the depths of the Library to confront the three founders, and Irene drips blood onto the part of the Language used to form the basis of the Library, and in particular to preserve the Founders' existences, thereby removing them from the world. It was all a bit silly, to be honest. I wasn't a fan of how Alberich died, and I didn't like how the author handled the Founders' deaths as well.
At least Irene and Kai finally say the L word to each other! It's something I never thought would happen and was happy to see happen.
I had a hard time finishing the book because most of it moves at a slow pace. I'd stop reading for the day and not have any motivation to pick it up for another couple days, which is very rare for me.
**Warning: Spoilers Ahead**
They've been building up Alberich as the big bad guy for multiple books, so I didn't like how his character was redeemed a bit and his actions explained in this book. Instead, it turns out there's another group of bad guys for Irene and co to go up against that are the real bad guys. It's been hinted at in the last book or two, but it felt quite rushed to go from learning the truth from Alberich right before he dies, at around 60-70% into the book, to finding and defeating the mysterious powers behind the Library. Alberich's death was also very sudden and unexpected, and didn't have the oomph that I was expecting.
The truth behind the Library's origins was also not that exciting. We learn that way back when, a human, a Fae called the Story Teller, and Kai's grandfather collaborated together to create the Library. Recently they've been very unsatisfied with how the world has been going and with the political tensions between all groups, so they decide to take things into their own hands by destroying some of the more dangerous worlds. To do so, they control Librarians through their brands, without them ever being aware of it. It's an interesting if not original premise, but it's not fleshed out nearly enough given that all of these discoveries happen in the last 40% of the book.
Irene and co travel to the depths of the Library to confront the three founders, and Irene drips blood onto the part of the Language used to form the basis of the Library, and in particular to preserve the Founders' existences, thereby removing them from the world. It was all a bit silly, to be honest. I wasn't a fan of how Alberich died, and I didn't like how the author handled the Founders' deaths as well.
At least Irene and Kai finally say the L word to each other! It's something I never thought would happen and was happy to see happen.
December 16, 2021
This feels like it's going to be the last book in the series, which makes me quite sad, but it was again a hell of a ride and I enjoyed this very much.
If you (like me!) thought that some of the previous books were entertaining but also pretty random (overall plotline missing? where does it all lead?), you will enjoy this book as it brings all major storylines to a conclusion and also answers vital questions like: What is the Library? How was it founded? Who are Irene's parents?
I read it in two sittings. If you enjoyed the previous books, you will also enjoy this one. I kinda low key want to reread the books before now, because I am sure they are full of clues which I overlooked.
Oh and don't worry if you don't remember what happened in the last few books. Cogman is quite good at explaining the important bits again!
5 Stars because FUN
If you (like me!) thought that some of the previous books were entertaining but also pretty random (overall plotline missing? where does it all lead?), you will enjoy this book as it brings all major storylines to a conclusion and also answers vital questions like: What is the Library? How was it founded? Who are Irene's parents?
I read it in two sittings. If you enjoyed the previous books, you will also enjoy this one. I kinda low key want to reread the books before now, because I am sure they are full of clues which I overlooked.
Oh and don't worry if you don't remember what happened in the last few books. Cogman is quite good at explaining the important bits again!
5 Stars because FUN
February 19, 2025
The Untold Story stands out in its ability to blend historical events with a deep, character-driven narrative. the book takes readers on a journey through pivotal moments of history with a particular focus on the impact of personal choices within larger societal frameworks. one of the book’s greatest strengths is the development of its protagonist, whose growth over the course of the novel feels authentic. the emotional struggles and moral dilemmas faced by the character are well-written, offering a complex portrayal of human nature.
the plot is engaging with a few standout twists that catch the reader off guard. however, I believe that there are moments when the story slows down, particularly in the middle of the book, where the focus shifts a little too heavily on exposition or background details. while these moments are rich with information, they sometimes detract from the overall flow of the narrative.
the writing is generally sharp, though there are occasional sections that feel repetitive or overly detailed, particularly in the descriptions of certain settings or secondary characters. these moments could have been tightened up to keep the pacing more consistent. the resolution of the book is satisfying, though the conclusion leaves some questions unanswered, which may leave readers eager for the next installment but also slightly frustrated by the lack of closure.
the series as a whole demonstrates strong storytelling with a unique blend of historical fiction and personal drama. each book builds on the previous one, adding layers to the overarching narrative, but this one is perhaps the most focused in terms of character development. the protagonist’s arc continues to evolve throughout the series with each new challenge providing more insight into their motivations and growth.
the author does an excellent job of using history as a backdrop while making the characters’ personal journeys the heart of the story. the themes of power, identity and the consequences of one's actions are explored with depth and nuance. however, there are some pacing issues across the series. Some books take longer to get to the point, and there are sections that could have benefited from more focused editing to cut down on unnecessary filler.
that being said, I think that the series is still highly engaging and its strengths far outweigh its flaws. the historical depth, combined with well-executed character development and intriguing plotlines, makes it a rewarding read for those who enjoy immersive stories with complex, evolving characters.
the plot is engaging with a few standout twists that catch the reader off guard. however, I believe that there are moments when the story slows down, particularly in the middle of the book, where the focus shifts a little too heavily on exposition or background details. while these moments are rich with information, they sometimes detract from the overall flow of the narrative.
the writing is generally sharp, though there are occasional sections that feel repetitive or overly detailed, particularly in the descriptions of certain settings or secondary characters. these moments could have been tightened up to keep the pacing more consistent. the resolution of the book is satisfying, though the conclusion leaves some questions unanswered, which may leave readers eager for the next installment but also slightly frustrated by the lack of closure.
the series as a whole demonstrates strong storytelling with a unique blend of historical fiction and personal drama. each book builds on the previous one, adding layers to the overarching narrative, but this one is perhaps the most focused in terms of character development. the protagonist’s arc continues to evolve throughout the series with each new challenge providing more insight into their motivations and growth.
the author does an excellent job of using history as a backdrop while making the characters’ personal journeys the heart of the story. the themes of power, identity and the consequences of one's actions are explored with depth and nuance. however, there are some pacing issues across the series. Some books take longer to get to the point, and there are sections that could have benefited from more focused editing to cut down on unnecessary filler.
that being said, I think that the series is still highly engaging and its strengths far outweigh its flaws. the historical depth, combined with well-executed character development and intriguing plotlines, makes it a rewarding read for those who enjoy immersive stories with complex, evolving characters.
November 9, 2023
Ein würdiger Abschluss!
November 13, 2021
A marvellous conclusion to the Invisible Library series, where we finally get the answers we have been delving for - what are the origins of the Library? what is the Library? what role does it play in anchoring the linked worlds?
Over the series Irene has developed from her original naive state to one of a deft manipulator and first class agent for the Library. Her core friends, Kai and Vale are integral to the journey as are Silver and her Fae library apprentice Catherine.
The Fae, Dragon, Human, Library charter has been agreed and more signatories are coming forward, However Irene has begun to wonder why she has less book retrieval assignments, and now her missions have political dimensions. Adding to this unease is the news that worlds have disappeared, Albriech has survived and making overtures to the library...
This finale is deftly written with loose ends tied leading to a very suitable ending. I would highly recommend this series and I am slightly envious if you are yet to find it as treats are in store.
My thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for access to this ARC, all opinions are my own.
Over the series Irene has developed from her original naive state to one of a deft manipulator and first class agent for the Library. Her core friends, Kai and Vale are integral to the journey as are Silver and her Fae library apprentice Catherine.
The Fae, Dragon, Human, Library charter has been agreed and more signatories are coming forward, However Irene has begun to wonder why she has less book retrieval assignments, and now her missions have political dimensions. Adding to this unease is the news that worlds have disappeared, Albriech has survived and making overtures to the library...
This finale is deftly written with loose ends tied leading to a very suitable ending. I would highly recommend this series and I am slightly envious if you are yet to find it as treats are in store.
My thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for access to this ARC, all opinions are my own.
January 27, 2022
I am sad that the series end but I am more sad because of the last book is totally disappointing.
I feel the characters lost their charm and also the plot become bit boring with some-kind of none-sense plot just to make the ending super dramatic.
I feel the characters lost their charm and also the plot become bit boring with some-kind of none-sense plot just to make the ending super dramatic.
December 9, 2021
As (possibly) the last in the series the book does exactly what it needs to by tying all the loose ends in a particularly tidy bow and giving the reader the conclusion it deserves. The world building and character development has always been top notch throughout the series and continues here.
Now, I must say, I have been following this series from the beginning and waited enthusiasticly for each 'next episode' to be published and I do think that is the best way to approach the series - as a whole entity. With Librarians, the Library itself, Dragons, Fae, A Sherlock Holmes type and a machiavellian enemy (among many others) this has been a fun ride (and it really ought to be picked up for television) and I highly recommend it.
Now, I must say, I have been following this series from the beginning and waited enthusiasticly for each 'next episode' to be published and I do think that is the best way to approach the series - as a whole entity. With Librarians, the Library itself, Dragons, Fae, A Sherlock Holmes type and a machiavellian enemy (among many others) this has been a fun ride (and it really ought to be picked up for television) and I highly recommend it.
December 9, 2021
The ending of an eight part storyline but not the ending of the series! Many plots wrapped, many old characters return and answers are finally given a nice set off to this arc!
Full review - https://www.runalongtheshelves.net/bl...
Full review - https://www.runalongtheshelves.net/bl...
March 13, 2024
I hope Genevieve Cogman doesn't intend to revive this series, because I think the ending was quite satisfactory, addressing many of my questions about Irene's lineage and the origins of the Library. While the series has been engaging and enjoyable, it has overstretched and, despite its charm, has grown repetitive and lost its freshness.
In the final book, Irene, who had discovered that her true father is not the man she grew up with, but instead the main antagonist of the series, sets out to uncover the identity of her mother, her own origins, and the genesis of the Library, the institution she has served unquestioningly her whole life. Accompanying her in these revelations are her love interest, Kai; Vale, the Sherlock Holmes of this world, and Catherine, her fae assistant.
This volume is still as action-packed as its predecessors, maintaining a brisk pace that kept me engaged. However, with the Library assuming a more politicized role in the power dynamics between Dragons and Fae, the narrative has transitioned from the classic "librarian" plot, focusing on Irene's missions to acquire rare books, to an exploration of origins. Which is not necessarily bad, but I felt nostalgic for the earlier sense of adventure.
I enjoyed it, but it also felt like the last season of a show that overstayed its welcome, where it seemed the creators weren't quite sure how to wrap things up, leading to a less-than-satisfactory conclusion. The revelation about Irene's mother turned out to be predictable and lacked impact. Additionally, Cogman's attempts to somewhat redeem Alberich, after establishing him as the antagonist over many volumes, felt forced to me.
This last volume suffers from the sin of "previously on...", which I always hate for the way it bogs down the narrative. Cogman has a tendency to reiterate the lore in multiple volumes, recycling explanations of how order and chaos operate in this universe, which feels like unnecessary filler by this stage. While I generally appreciate lore (for instance, my main qualm with the Harry Potter series was its scarcity), and have thoroughly enjoyed the story of the creation of the Library, I found the repeated exposition of concepts introduced as early as the first book to be redundant and somewhat condescending.
As for character development, there's not much of it by now. Everyone is quite established in their roles and personality and the only one with an arc was Alberich. I found myself wishing for deeper exploration of the dynamics between him and Irene, as their relationship presented a ripe field for further development. And I was saddened by Lord Silver barely making a few episodic appearances - he's the most delightful character of the series and I missed his snarkiness.
I'm still happy about the lack of sexual content in this book (and series) - Cogman proves that one can introduce romance into a fantasy book without the nakedness and I appreciate her for that.
Overall, I've had fun with this series and I'm glad it got to a satisfying(ish) conclusion. I know the author wants to expand the universe, but to me, this was enough.
In the final book, Irene, who had discovered that her true father is not the man she grew up with, but instead the main antagonist of the series, sets out to uncover the identity of her mother, her own origins, and the genesis of the Library, the institution she has served unquestioningly her whole life. Accompanying her in these revelations are her love interest, Kai; Vale, the Sherlock Holmes of this world, and Catherine, her fae assistant.
This volume is still as action-packed as its predecessors, maintaining a brisk pace that kept me engaged. However, with the Library assuming a more politicized role in the power dynamics between Dragons and Fae, the narrative has transitioned from the classic "librarian" plot, focusing on Irene's missions to acquire rare books, to an exploration of origins. Which is not necessarily bad, but I felt nostalgic for the earlier sense of adventure.
I enjoyed it, but it also felt like the last season of a show that overstayed its welcome, where it seemed the creators weren't quite sure how to wrap things up, leading to a less-than-satisfactory conclusion. The revelation about Irene's mother turned out to be predictable and lacked impact. Additionally, Cogman's attempts to somewhat redeem Alberich, after establishing him as the antagonist over many volumes, felt forced to me.
This last volume suffers from the sin of "previously on...", which I always hate for the way it bogs down the narrative. Cogman has a tendency to reiterate the lore in multiple volumes, recycling explanations of how order and chaos operate in this universe, which feels like unnecessary filler by this stage. While I generally appreciate lore (for instance, my main qualm with the Harry Potter series was its scarcity), and have thoroughly enjoyed the story of the creation of the Library, I found the repeated exposition of concepts introduced as early as the first book to be redundant and somewhat condescending.
As for character development, there's not much of it by now. Everyone is quite established in their roles and personality and the only one with an arc was Alberich. I found myself wishing for deeper exploration of the dynamics between him and Irene, as their relationship presented a ripe field for further development. And I was saddened by Lord Silver barely making a few episodic appearances - he's the most delightful character of the series and I missed his snarkiness.
I'm still happy about the lack of sexual content in this book (and series) - Cogman proves that one can introduce romance into a fantasy book without the nakedness and I appreciate her for that.
Overall, I've had fun with this series and I'm glad it got to a satisfying(ish) conclusion. I know the author wants to expand the universe, but to me, this was enough.
May 17, 2022
A solid ending to the overarching mystery/plot in the INVISIBLE LIBRARY series. Irene, a Librarian for the Invisible Library, finally penetrates layers of deception and betrayal to confront the rottenness at the core of her beloved institution. She can't do it without her friends, the mortal Great Detective Vale, her lover and dragon prince, (and former apprentice), Kai, and her current, troublesome apprentice, the Fae Catherine. Like all of these books, it's filled with action and high-drama set pieces.
At the end, Irene is left with only her intelligence, knowledge and courage--and her friends-- to fight the villains.
I enjoyed the book even though I thought it slowed down in the middle. It's a fine ending to an entertaining series.
At the end, Irene is left with only her intelligence, knowledge and courage--and her friends-- to fight the villains.
I enjoyed the book even though I thought it slowed down in the middle. It's a fine ending to an entertaining series.
December 30, 2021
T.T Since the author, Genevieve Cogman, said that this book isn't necessarily the end of the series (she wrote it in her blog), I try not to think of it at the end, even though it feels like it. I want to read more of Irene and her world!! I really love this series and this book captured me.
Beside the world building and the characters, I realised that I really like the way the characters are talking, it's so smooth and realistic like an actual conversation I'm part of. Moreover, Irene, with her thoughts, feelings and choices, is such a realistic character (just my opinion) and it made it so easy to follow her through her journey and emotional dilemma (- I wished the would talk more about it with other people, but I know this is part of her personality).
I gave this book five stars because it deserved it, even though there are some aspects I missed. For example, I liked the ending but it felt so abrupt. I wished that some characters appeared at least at the end again because there were somewhat present or mentioned throughout this book. Additionally, I prefered it when there were more Librarians present at the final fight and not only Irene and her crew.
In conclusion: I'm happy. The series, especially this book, always encourages me to puzzle over this story while reading, while I'm always asking: where is it going? Who is behind everything? Why? How? And and and. I love it.
Beside the world building and the characters, I realised that I really like the way the characters are talking, it's so smooth and realistic like an actual conversation I'm part of. Moreover, Irene, with her thoughts, feelings and choices, is such a realistic character (just my opinion) and it made it so easy to follow her through her journey and emotional dilemma (- I wished the would talk more about it with other people, but I know this is part of her personality).
I gave this book five stars because it deserved it, even though there are some aspects I missed. For example, I liked the ending but it felt so abrupt. I wished that some characters appeared at least at the end again because there were somewhat present or mentioned throughout this book. Additionally, I prefered it when there were more Librarians present at the final fight and not only Irene and her crew.
In conclusion: I'm happy. The series, especially this book, always encourages me to puzzle over this story while reading, while I'm always asking: where is it going? Who is behind everything? Why? How? And and and. I love it.
January 6, 2022
Overall, this has been a great series. (Although this is the end for now, with questions answered and loose ends tied up, Ms. Cogman says she will likely write more IL stories in the future.) However, it took a direction in these last couple books that I didn't see coming and which got a little too fantasy for my taste. I was having a better time watching Irene and her companions (especially Peregrine Vale, one world's version of Sherlock Holmes) solve mysteries and retrieve books. If a continuation of the series has more of that , I will be delighted.
January 31, 2022
A fitting end to the series. Now the books started getting a little stretched out (kind of like padding out an American television series that has 22 episodes, but could have told the story in 10 episodes) after book 5. This one was definitely a return to previous form and the ending was satisfying.
January 1, 2022
Not only does this story have to deliver yet another interesting and twisty plot featuring Irene and her comrades in her ongoing task to carry out the Library’s wishes – it also has to successfully wrap up this series. Irene has intrigued me, as being admirably self possessed. And throughout all her entanglements with both fae and dragons, she has kept her head and dealt with life-threatening emergencies with a capable coolness. This sets her apart from those heroines, who flap around in a soup of self doubt and end up backing into situations they’re not prepared for.
However, the previous adventure in The Dark Archive finally punctured her confidence, as she was told a shocking fact that has her questioning all her core beliefs. This is the book where she has to deal with the fallout. So Irene sets out on an adventure, with the support of Kai, Vale and Catherine to discover the truth of what is going on. And yes – it’s a somewhat far-fetched story, but Cogman tells it with skill and conviction and I’m quite happy to suspend my disbelief. Partly because in amongst all the adventures and unexpected discoveries, Cogman looks at the human drive to tell stories and how it can affect the way the the world is formed. As I have always been fascinated by the way some small children start weaving imaginative narratives almost before they are able to talk, this theme really chimed with me.
Even more importantly, Cogman brings this series to a successful close. I was happy with the future stretching before Irene and Kai, which doesn’t prevent further adventures, if Cogman wants to revisit the Library again at some stage. Indeed, I hope she does. I’ve loved this series and I’ll particularly miss dashing between worlds alongside Irene, while she sorts out book-related problems. Or mediating between the Fae and dragons. In the meantime, I can always reread this delightful portal fantasy series and if you haven’t yet had the pleasure – it comes highly recommended. While I obtained an arc of The Untold Story from Netgalley via the publishers, the opinions I have expressed are unbiased and my own.
9/10
However, the previous adventure in The Dark Archive finally punctured her confidence, as she was told a shocking fact that has her questioning all her core beliefs. This is the book where she has to deal with the fallout. So Irene sets out on an adventure, with the support of Kai, Vale and Catherine to discover the truth of what is going on. And yes – it’s a somewhat far-fetched story, but Cogman tells it with skill and conviction and I’m quite happy to suspend my disbelief. Partly because in amongst all the adventures and unexpected discoveries, Cogman looks at the human drive to tell stories and how it can affect the way the the world is formed. As I have always been fascinated by the way some small children start weaving imaginative narratives almost before they are able to talk, this theme really chimed with me.
Even more importantly, Cogman brings this series to a successful close. I was happy with the future stretching before Irene and Kai, which doesn’t prevent further adventures, if Cogman wants to revisit the Library again at some stage. Indeed, I hope she does. I’ve loved this series and I’ll particularly miss dashing between worlds alongside Irene, while she sorts out book-related problems. Or mediating between the Fae and dragons. In the meantime, I can always reread this delightful portal fantasy series and if you haven’t yet had the pleasure – it comes highly recommended. While I obtained an arc of The Untold Story from Netgalley via the publishers, the opinions I have expressed are unbiased and my own.
9/10
Displaying 1 - 30 of 817 reviews