I'd like to think I was just not in the right mood (or the right audience) for this book. I wanted to like it, but found several things off-putting.
First, you are free to disagree with me, but I take genuine theological issue with The Message interpretation of the Bible. It is not a translation, which begs the follow-up question, Is God's Word really so inaccessible or 'uncool' that we need to dumb it down? Do we even have the right to alter The Most Holy God's Word? Keeping that in mind, when Mrs. Guckenberger quotes more from The Message than she does the actual Bible, I immediately feel disconnected from and distrustful of her faith. I can't just settle in and learn at her feet, because I have to sift each paragraph and wonder if she herself is learning from Jesus or learning from editors trying to make God more 'hip.'
Secondly, the entire book had sort of a "blog post" feel to it for me. Instead of letting the experiences and characters of her life speak for themselves (and instead of giving me the freedom in the Spirit to mull over how God wants to use these testimonies in my own life), most chapters were 40% testimony and 60% preaching at me. Because of what she has been through, she clearly felt that she had a right to tell me how to think and feel about just about everything in my Christian faith, but I never felt like she had sufficiently established that right in my eyes.
The author sought to paint a picture of faith that appeared radical and catchy, as contrasted with a stuffed-up, narrow-minded, close-fisted sort of faith. But wait... do those adjectives even apply to genuine faith, ever? Again, we're butting heads over theology here. Moreover, why does she write to me like I'm coming from that angle and am shocked at everything she has to say to the contrary? I wouldn't mind if she explained that was her background and her realizations during this time, but you lose your audience pretty quickly if you act like you know exactly who is reading your book and then try to preach at them for it.
So... I give it two stars (as opposed to one) because the stories she had to tell did have an impact on my faith with God, for the better. But I could have read those stories in an hour or two and just done away with the rest of the book; it wasn't helpful or encouraging for me.