Rave reviews for “The Reynolds Pamphlet” from some of the author's contemporaries:
“If you have not seen it, no anticipation can equal the infamy of this piece.”
--James Thomson Callender, September 28, 1797
“The publication under all its characters is a curious specimen of the ingenious folly of its author.”
--James Madison, 4th President of the United States
October 20, 1797
“Can talents atone for such turpitude? Can wisdom reside with such gullibility?”
--John Adams, 2nd President of the United States
September 17, 1797
“Beware of that Spair Cassius, has always occured to me when I have seen that cock Sparrow. O I have read his Heart in his Wicked Eyes many a time the very Devil is in them.”
--Abigail Adams, First Lady of the United States
January 28, 1797
“The ‘precious confessions’ of Hamilton are very salutary, and equally as sincere as if he had made them in the broad aisle of a Church.”
--Anonymous, Greenleaf’s New York Journal
October 7, 1797
“I have not yet seen Hamilton’s pamphlet: but I understand that finding the straight between Scylla and Charybdis too narrow for his steerage, he has preferred running plump on one of them.”
--Thomas Jefferson, 3rd President of the United States
October 8, 1797
“His ill-judged pamphlet has done him incomparable injury.”
--Robert Troup, June 3, 1798
“I sent you a pamphlet worth perusing; it is colonel Hamilton's, and such a one as, it would seem, he would not have written had he not previously taken leave of his senses. . .[his] book came out here this morning; and now, at six o'clock in the evening, the whole town rings with it. The women cry out against him, as if its publication was high treason against the rights of women.”
--Extract of a letter from New-York, Aurora General Advertiser
October 10, 1797
“If the work possesses merit, it is in the undisguised manner in which you confess the crime alleged against you, of having a criminal connection with the property of another man.”
--“Juno”, Greenleaf’s New York Journal
September 20, 1797
“But what shall we say to the conduct of a man who has borne some of the highest civil and military employments, who could deliberately write and publish a history of his private intrigues, degrade himself in the estimation of all good men, and scandalize a family, to clear himself of charges which no man believed; to vindicate integrity which a legislative act had pronounced unimpeachable, and which scarcely a man in America suspected!”
--Noah Webster, 1800
“Such another piece of ridiculous folly: sure, never Man was guilty of.”
--John Barnes, October 3, 1797
“In truth I have no desire to persecute this man, tho’ he justly merits it.”
--James Monroe, 5th President of the United States
August 6, 1797
“Congratulations. You have invented a new kind of stupid.”
--Angelica Schuyler Church, sister-in-law
December 2, 2016
“Dear Col'nel did you never hear,
(If you did not, I think ’tis queer)
That only fools do ‘kiss and tell’
Ev’n tho’ they tell their story well.”
--Jemima Spinningwheel, Greenleaf’s New York Journal
October 18, 1797
“See him. . . lolling in the lap of an harlot!!”
--“Justice”, The Centinel of Freedom
October 18, 1797