Rating nonfiction books and memoirs is always difficult for me, because usually someone is writing a memoir because they have an important story to tell-- not necessarily because they are a great writer. I feel bad taking off stars, because sometimes the point of a nonfiction book is to get a message across, rather than for it to be the most beautiful thing ever written. A Girl's Life Online is a short little piece detailing a 13 year old girl's online relationship with a 41 year old man (who claimed to be 23), which lead to a sexual assault when they later met in person. This was the first federal case to be brought up against an online predator, so while we hear about these things often today, it was big news at the time. Katie's story is important to tell. Parents and young teenagers should definitely be aware that these dangers exist. I enjoyed the book, but at the same time, had a few issues with it.
Katie's story is frightening, and what happened to her was terrible. The writing, for a young adult, is pretty decent. One of my biggest issues with the book was the flow. Too much time was spent on weird details that didn't apply to the story-- such as the expensive clothes Katie wore to how she got ready in the morning, etc. She also kept emphasizing how much money she (and everyone else in her town) had, which distanced her from me a bit. It also made her hard to sympathize with. Amongst all the random filler sections, I felt like she didn't go into enough detail about her relationship with Mark/Frank. She told us about her feelings, but didn't show the development enough through their conversations. It felt a little odd that they went from small talk to wanting to meet in person so quickly. As controlling as Katie's parents and her whole hometown seemed to be, I can't help but wonder if this book was censored a bit, causing these issues.
There were a few weird things that didn't line up, as well. For instance, Katie gives a speech at the very end, which mentions that Mark/Frank threatened her not to tell anyone about the sexual assault. However, she never wrote that a single time in the book prior, which made it confusing. She would also contradict herself on minor things (she'd say she had no friends, but then introduce two girls she was supposedly close to). It made the book seem as if it were either rushed and sloppy or as if she was trying to cover something up.
Finally, Katie just made a few comments in the book that were unnecessary. She mentions how it is inappropriate for anyone over the age of 25 to watch pornography, which shouldn't really be any of her concern (as long as they're doing it legally, it doesn't affect her). And she goes on and on about how girls face online predators and societal pressures, but leaves out the fact that this can happen to guys, too. I read a few articles about the case after finishing the book, and it sounds like Frank Kufrovich targeted young boys, as well as girls, so it seems odd that she would only mention girls. Maybe I'm just nitpicking at this point.
It may sound as if I'm just complaining about this. It's not a bad book, really. Katie's story is powerful, and I definitely believe everyone should be aware of this danger. She does a great job of showing how horrific society can be, to the point that grown adults can place blame for sexual assault on the victims themselves (even if they are only teenagers). If you're interested in this book, it wouldn't hurt to give it a go. It's short and quick to get through. At the same time, though, I feel like a similarly powerful message could be sent through a fiction book, where the final product is a little more polished.
3/5 stars, but I commend the author for her courage to speak about such a difficult topic.