CW:
Non-consensual kissing, murder, blood, death, gore, cannibalism, mind-manipulation, talking someone into suicide
2 / 5 Stars
This review containts spoilers for Cute Mutants Volume 4: The Sisterhood of Evil Mutants
This books takes place only a few days after the events of Cute Mutants: The Sisterhood of Evil Mutants . The book trys to give a summary of what happend but honestly, if I hadn't read the main series first, I would have been lost. I'll talk about that later on as well, but I just wanted you to know that before you continue reading this review, since I'll spoil the character of God for you.
Anyways:
I didn't like the way things ended in book 4 but I was still very excited for this one, because I figured
"Well, the spin-off is called godkillers, so I'm sure God will play a huge role in this one and will get the attention and love they deserve, since they got treated very poorly in the last installment given the fact that they are the most powerful mutant alive."
I was also VERY interested in the whole Maddy & Gladdy thing BECAUSE, while 99% of the fandom believed that those two had something going on, I personally thought that they were Zucchini, since it was kinda hinted at back in book 3.
In case you didn't know, I'm a huge fan of Zucchini literature (Zucchini = Partners in a Queer-Platonic Relationship) and I could not wait to read about their amazing relationship firsthand.
Now, you might have noticed the 2 star rating on this book, so clearly, something must have happend that I didn't like, which, yeah.
I'm not sure where to start so apologies if things feel out of order.
But, since the book tends to be all over the place at times as well, I guess reviewing it this way is fine.
Plot/Story:
I was dissapointed. Remember that I told you God - Heart of a Flower - was supposed to be the most powerful mutant alive? Well, it certainly doesn't feel like that. We go to where they're hold captive, tell them "Any last words?" kill them aaaaand that's it. There's the whole "They had crazy offspring and now we have to fight those too" twist, but given the fact that we defeat EVERY. SINGLE. ONE. OF. THEM. IN. ONE. BOOK, I'm not impressed. There's the B-Plot with Maddy & Gladdy, but that one's almost worse than the A-Plot, for reasons I'll get to in a second.
Some of the offspring get to show off real hard, just for our team to stumble into victory somehow. Most of the time they themselves don't really know how they managed to win, but ey, at least we get to read our team leader say "Weapon UwU" a few times. I'm sure that's gonna make up for the lack of stakes.
"But Martina, they have to fight a man-eating-house, an alien, the entire ocean and a cannibal! How can there be no stakes!!! Clearly, you're wrong!"
You see, all of that sounds cool on paper - & I really shipped the Ocean and cannibal with each other. Cute couple ♥ - but it doesn't translate into reality. Everyone who could have been a challange gets defeated way too easily. I know our team is strong, but it gets to a point where we slaughter our way through an army of zombies to fight an alien we defeat in not even 100 pages. Kinda anti-climactic :) There could have been stakes, - I'm not asking for character death left and right - but there was just no time for it. The book brings up so much cool stuff, but we sadly don't see that stuff developed to its full potential, because everything feels rushed and like the build up for the final. Instead of its own thing.
The B-Plot aka Maddy & Gladdy :
OK, so, Maddy & Gladdy are not Zucchini. And they aren't lovers either. But one of them wants to be. And, given the fact that they have been portrayed as VERY close and VERY important to each other, I would have expected for them to - you know - talk and communicate about the issue. But they don't. Oh boy, they don't. There is so much misscommunication in this one it was kind of painful to read. I was also not on board with the non-consensual kissing in this one. Which is kind of a big no no on my part.
There's a huge part in the middle of the book where those two don't talk with each other at all - because of misunderstandings slash misscommuniation.
Does writing them like that cause more drama? Sure. Was it the bestest of decisions? No.
You see, I - the reader - know that Gladdy is aro ace. But Maddy doesn't. And I'm not even sure Gladdy does - which is wild given the fact that they have two aces in their team. I'm bringing this up because neither the word ace nor the word aro get mentioned once. Like, wow, ok. Not only do you not communicate, but when you finally do, you don't really.
Other people want me to believe that those two attempt a QPR at the end of the book, but in all honesty, it's not clear that they do. They are speaking in methapors, symbols and puzzles I'm just not happy with what is said and how it's said and aksjfklasjdföl.
The characters :
They don't work as well as they should, because we spend almost all of the time with the B-Plot and a romance that I was not shipping and came kind of nowhere to be honest. I would have loved to learn more about our new members, but oh well.
They also didn't feel like a team to me. Yes, they've worked together, but this is their first real own-team-kind-of-thing thing. The way the plot was strucctered was not helping, suffocating the Cute Mutants found family dynamic I've come to love so much. There's a little bit of tension between two of our members but it gets resolved in the blink of an eye which felt kind of underwelming to me. The farther I got into the story/book, the more it became clear to me, that the books main problem was caused by it's cast. They don't work and the book isn't giving them time to work and it's sad.
There is also a romance that feels very out of place. Was not on board with it and don't feel like it deserves to be talked about. Just know: Dissapointed.
Cute Mutants Volume 4.5
This book calls itself a spin-off, but the truth is, it doesn't work that way. This book does not work as a stand-alone and you feel that in every page. The book trys to be its own thing, but it can't be because it relies on you knowing stuff from other books and it's building on stuff from other books and it's throwing in stuff from other books that would make you confused if you didn't know about them from said other books.
Summary
I didn't hate everything the book did, it's not the worst book I have read either, but it's also the worst Cute Mutant book in the series and a book that could have been really cool, but sadly didn't deliver.