3.5 stars!
“It is too much to describe. I am determined to give you everything. All I have inside. That is my promise to you, and I shall not break it. But please don’t ask me to explain, for I haven’t the words.” Lady Jane Huxley is the bookish daughter of Lord and Lady Berne. With her plain looks and shy personality, she had been relegated to the status of a wallflower. When charming Colin Lacey befriended her and asked for a favor, she couldn’t help but agree to help her new found friend. But things go horribly wrong when she discovers that it was a wager between Colin and his friends, and he used her. With a ruined reputation, no one would ever offer for her, and the scandal she caused to her family’s name will greatly affect her sisters’ marriage prospects. Harrison Lacey, the Duke of Blackmore is nothing if not honor-bound. In order to make things right and to make up for his brother’s faults, he offers the only thing he knows would make things right: marriage.
The truth about Cads and Dukes is the second book from Elisa Braden’s historical romance series, Rescued from Ruin. This book is about The Duke of Blackmore and Lady Jane Huxley, both of them introduced in the first book in the series. To be honest, I don’t know what I expected from this book but I decided to just read it because I am slowly making my way through this series.
Meet Lady Jane Huxley: She is the daughter of the Earl and Countess of Berne. Jane is bespectacled, she’s very shy: like embarrassingly so. She loves reading and her nose is always in her books. Because of her personality, she has no friends except Victoria. This is the reason why she had been the target of the newest wager between Colin and his wastrel friends. One of the reasons why she agreed to Colin’s favor is because the idea of humbling the Duke of Blackmore is appealing. She deemed the Duke as an arrogant man ever since he had the audacity to scold her in her own home!
Meet Harrison Lacey: He is the Duke of Blackmore. In the first book, he’s introduced when he killed the former Viscount Atherbourne. He is honorable, loyal and kinder than what the Ton might think. Because of his good looks, wealth and title, he is a fine catch indeed. To the people who do not know him on an intimate level, he comes off as cold and stuffy. As a Duke, he is responsible for his family and their name, which is why when his brother did something to ruin a respectable lady’s good name, he steps in to marry the girl, although he disapproves of her manners at times.
Lady Jane never had much luck with making many friends and it is no surprise. She’s very shy and would rather spend all her time reading a book. Her only friend is Victoria, which is why it felt good when a man such as Colin Lacey was making an effort to befriend her, her! The Plain Jane Huxley. She knows of his bad reputation, but the lord let her believe that he was changing for the better. When he asked for a favor concerning a lost family heirloom, Jane couldn’t say no to a friend who had become dear to her. Sadly, everything had been a ruse to Colin in order to gain money for he is in great need of it because the Duke of Blackmore cut his allowance. Jane was humiliated and now her reputation is hanging by a thread. Thankfully, the Duke of Blackmore is a better man than his wastrel brother even if he comes off as an arrogant know-it-all. Blackmore is making a sacrifice by marrying a woman who he wasn’t even interested in. But because of the doings of his brother, he had to fix the mess and marry Jane for she comes from a respectable family. Jane believes that the two of them are utterly mismatched. Marriage changes everything, including the way Jane views her now husband….and she discovers many things about the man who she once thought was the coldest man ever. For now she sees a man whom she loves, who sadly does not seem to feel the same way. Could the plain and shy Jane Huxley have her happily ever after with the Duke or will they let the insecurities, uncertainties and emotional baggage come between the two of them? Clue: It’s a HEA!
The heroine was okay. To be honest, I was quite worried how Braden would make this couple work because of how shy the heroine was. I think she was very naive regarding Colin, but that’s not her fault. To be honest, I couldn’t remember much about her. I was very busy lately and am now only writing this review, so that may be the reason. I remember her as a book-loving heroine, so in that sense she’s relatable. But aside from that, and I’m sorry to say this, she was boring. The author repeatedly wrote how plain she was and now I couldn’t think of anything about her besides that. Jane trying to help Colin out on his fabricated story about the family heirloom was not daring at all but stupid. She was also very insecure. And to be honest, I’m not much for insecure heroines. Don’t get me wrong, she’s cute but it seems the author gave her no personality aside from loving reading. I think it improved later on when she was trying her best to be the mistress of a grand house and such. She was also very sweet and understanding towards the hero too, which is why when she made that decision nearing the end, it felt out of character and so random? They were literally banging moments before that and the day after she was like: I’m leaving. Damn girl, give the man a break! Take things slowly and wait for him to come around at his own pace? It is harder for other people to open up emotionally and I’m so tired of characters who have no patience for that. I feel so mean, Jane was truly the type of heroine that I enjoy most of the time but I just couldn’t find anything to really love about her.
The hero was the usual aristocrat who has daddy issues and emotional baggage. He thinks he’s different from his father who was very cold to his family and then the old Lady Wallingham goes telling stories and suddenly he’s like: I’m just like my father. Literally what. Honestly, I found the idea of Harrison ready to kill anyone who harms Jane very sweet but hey, that’s just me and perhaps I need therapy because I find things like that cute when I shouldn’t. Harrison is just like Lucien except he’s a Duke and doesn’t have a revenge plan. He’s possessive, obsessive and in denial. Actually, he’s an okay hero. When Jane first discovered why the rumors regarding her humiliation stopped, I too, was like: woah wait maybe If I was Jane, I’d love him too. Sadly, he's the type of hero wherein I just felt like: I’ve read about him before but in a different font so nothing about him was particularly exciting to me. He does not stand out. But this does not mean that he was a shitty hero. In fact, he was actually such a sweet and thoughtful husband. He cared for Jane even in the early days of their marriage. I like how thoughtful and protective he was over his wife. However, he’s also a dumbass. Of course, what would a romance novel be without a hero who would suddenly act cold in order to protect their heart and build back the wall that the heroine is slowly melting? He cares for and is very fond of Jane but somehow he has this belief that he must stay away from her which of course sends the wrong signal to the heroine. He’s sweet, thoughtful, kind, honorable but he could also be annoying. I did not fall in love with him but I did not dislike him either. He was just okay like the heroine. Bearable enough for me to keep reading.
The chemistry between the hero and heroine….Hmm. Was there any? Perhaps. But it’s not overwhelming. It wasn’t that feeling wherein you can feel your heart pounding because the chemistry is totally off the charts. I did not feel many roller coaster emotions but perhaps I’m being unfair because I’ve only recently read two books back to back with main characters whose chemistry was totally insane. So it might’ve affected my feelings towards this pair. I did not fall in love with either Jane or Harrison so it is no surprise that I did not fall in love with them as a couple.
My complaint about the first book is the pacing was so fast. Victoria and Atherbourne got married immediately and it felt like the readers were just thrown into it without further details. Now my complaint is that this book was slower in terms of pacing. The chapters containing Jane and Colin’s friendship bored me to tears. I was almost tempted to not finish this book but I persevered because it intrigued me how Jane and Blackmore would work when they clearly could not stand each other. I remember Blackmore scolding Jane in book one and I was sure she’d hold a grudge because of it. Ha, perhaps I’m not that wrong. Thankfully, it got interesting the moment the author finally decided to let the hero have his time to shine. Why did it take so many chapters before he appeared? I couldn’t care less about Jane and Colin now please move it along! The book was definitely dull in comparison to some of the books I’ve read but Jane and Blackmore make a somewhat interesting pair although they could come off as boring at times. Also, I dislike how Jane just assumes things but then it’s not her fault when Blackmore is sweet one moment and then cold the next. Still, many things could’ve been easily resolved if they just knew how to communicate and find a solution for their problems. Also, why was a Duke so mad over chocolates? He’s literally been described as someone who’s very wealthy and yet he was angry at his wife because of her sweet tooth. Does not make any sense! It was such a silly excuse for them to have sex. It’s just not believable someone as rich would be that mad because of a price increase. But, we move on.
Jane Austen’s popular quote, “If I loved you less, I might be able to talk about it more. But you know what I am.” is the perfect quote to represent these characters and their relationship dynamic. I think it’s obvious Braden got inspiration from that when she wrote this couple, especially as that specific quote was mentioned in this book. I personally loved this. You ever love someone words aren’t enough and your profound feelings scare you? Yep, that’s basically Harrison regarding his feelings for his wife. It’s one of the few things I enjoyed about this book.
Next book is Colin’s and I have no idea if I’m interested in reading it. Honestly, he’s the type of hero I enjoy. A scoundrel. That’s my shit right there. But if there’s one thing I hate, it’s penniless heroes. You can’t expect me to root for someone who doesn’t even have money of his own. Ruins the romance as all I could think about is how he would be able to feed the heroine. Love can’t pay bills! But I must say, he was an interesting character and it would be nice to see what Braden would do with him, so perhaps I might read it after all. Also, Chatham is a shitty friend but I am still intrigued and will most likely read his book because it seems like it’s a fan favorite and there must be a good reason why. As usual, the dowager marchioness of Wallingham’s quotes at the beginning are funny. I really enjoy her character.
Hmmm….I feel like I’m writing so many words yet I’m not making any sense. Many friends enjoy Elisa Braden. Sadly, I still am not that impressed. Fingers crossed that book 4 would be the book that would make me want to try more of her work. But thus far, I am lukewarm about this series. There’s just something about the way she writes that is not satisfying me but I can’t yet pinpoint what it is. But then again I read a Goodreads friend’s comment yesterday saying, “Some people's yuck is other’s yum.” In conclusion, If I don’t enjoy the next Elisa Braden book then it means she just might not be for me.
Some quotes:
“She is not plain. She is extraordinary.” The dowager dismissed his statement with the wave of her wrinkled hand. “You are clearly suffering a visual disorder of some kind. Perhaps you and Jane should wear matching spectacles.” (This was funny)
“It begins with the small things. The way she smells. A little crinkle at the corner of her eyes when she laughs. Then, you find yourself wondering if you have some kind of illness. A fever, perhaps. Surely that is the only way to explain feeling like a feral beast every time she says your name.” Harrison stared at the other man. It was all he could manage. No one knew this. How could he know? Harrison had not even told Jane. “The worst is not the wanting, although that is rather frightening in its intensity. No, the worst is when you are parted from her. The only greater agony is in knowing you are the cause of it. And that she suffers for your foolishness.”
“How she longed for him, for the strength of his arms around her, for the break in his voice as he spoke her name. She missed him as she would miss her own heart, should it be taken from her body.”
“Victoria had been right. He was easily the most honorable man she had ever known, his kindness not the easy sort, but rather the most profound. Harrison—her Harrison—had protected a woman he barely knew, shielded her not only with his name, but with every weapon at his disposal. Before he’d had any cause to feel the slightest affection for her, he had placed himself between her and the consequences of her stupidity.”
“All I have ever wanted is your love. Without restraint. Without apology. As long as you love me, my darling husband, you shall never lose me.” He groaned and clutched her harder, his head coming up slowly so she could see his eyes. There in the blue, love shone with neither shadow nor veil. For the first time, she could see clear through into his heart. “Then we will be together always, my Jane.” He brushed the backs of his fingers against her cheek, sending springles down her spine. “For, that is how long I will love you.”