What do you think?
Rate this book
Dublin Trilogy (Publication order) #5
Dead Man's Sins
How far would you go to protect a dead man?
It’s the year 2000 in Dublin and, following some traumatic events, Detective Bunny McGarry is taking a well-earned break from the force. However, just because you’re not looking for trouble doesn’t mean trouble isn’t looking for you.
Bunny’s former partner died in the line of duty under dubious circumstances but his murky background has suddenly resurfaced, threatening Bunny’s reputation as well. As if that isn’t enough, a young boy is in danger and a woman from the big fella’s past is trapped in a loveless marriage to a monster. They both need Bunny’s help, but he must get to work fast – it seems someone is trying to frame him for murder …
Dead Man’s Sins is a continuation of McDonnell’s critically acclaimed bestselling Dublin Trilogy and mixes high-octane thrills with a distinctly Irish wit.
It’s the year 2000 in Dublin and, following some traumatic events, Detective Bunny McGarry is taking a well-earned break from the force. However, just because you’re not looking for trouble doesn’t mean trouble isn’t looking for you.
Bunny’s former partner died in the line of duty under dubious circumstances but his murky background has suddenly resurfaced, threatening Bunny’s reputation as well. As if that isn’t enough, a young boy is in danger and a woman from the big fella’s past is trapped in a loveless marriage to a monster. They both need Bunny’s help, but he must get to work fast – it seems someone is trying to frame him for murder …
Dead Man’s Sins is a continuation of McDonnell’s critically acclaimed bestselling Dublin Trilogy and mixes high-octane thrills with a distinctly Irish wit.
314 pages, Kindle Edition
First published June 15, 2021
482 people are currently reading
780 people want to read
About the author
Caimh McDonnell
41 books1,718 followersIrishman Caimh McDonnell is a former professional stand-up comedian and TV writer who now concentrates all of his energies on his books. Born in Limerick and raised in Dublin, he has taken the hop across the water and calls Manchester his home.
His TV writing work has seen him work on some of the biggest topical comedy shows on British TV and has earned him a BAFTA nomination. These days he can be found happily writing his next book in the office in the back garden, with only his dog and his imagination for company.
His book 'I Have Sinned' was shortlisted for the Kindle Storyteller Award 2019. Previously, his debut novel 'A Man With One of Those Faces' was nominated for best novel at the 2017 CAP awards.
His TV writing work has seen him work on some of the biggest topical comedy shows on British TV and has earned him a BAFTA nomination. These days he can be found happily writing his next book in the office in the back garden, with only his dog and his imagination for company.
His book 'I Have Sinned' was shortlisted for the Kindle Storyteller Award 2019. Previously, his debut novel 'A Man With One of Those Faces' was nominated for best novel at the 2017 CAP awards.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 256 reviews
June 20, 2021
Caimh McDonnall is really good at what he does. Whether it is writing an episode of SHAUN THE SHEEP for children or novels for adults, you will be entertained. If not, well, feck it - what the hell do I know??
Anyway, DEAD MAN’S SINS is the fifth book in ‘The Dublin Trilogy’ and it is the sequel to the prequel (the fourth book) of the first book... Don’t worry, it is not as confusing as you think, because it is not really of great importance – it worked out pretty well for the STAR WARS movies. All the books can work as a stand-alone, but I suggest you read them in order, because when you’ve read one, you WILL want to read the rest of them.
It started with the book THE MAN WITH ONE OF THOSE FACES and it was about a guy called Paul Mulchrone. And a star was born! Whether it was intentional or not, it was one of the other characters who completely stole the show. Much like Anthony Hopkins in THE SILENCE OF THE LAMBS, or Heath Ledger in THE DARK KNIGHT, or Tom Cruise in TROPIC THUNDER, or Gary Oldman in LEON (a.k.a.THE PROFESSIONAL), or Bill Murray in the movie KINGPIN, or Sharon Stone’s moomfi in BASIC INSTINCT, or Ben Kingsley in...just about everything, the big hit was Bunny McGarry who stole the hearts of the readers.
If you are unfamiliar, Bunny is a six-foot-something cop who fights dirty and drinks hard, and he follows his own moral compass to do what is right for him and his community. Read the other books if you want to know more.
In this instalment, Bunny is on sabbatical (even though he is not Jewish) and he gets drawn into a murder case where somebody is trying to set him up as the killer. And there is no feckin’ way that kite is going to fly!
That is about all I can tell you. Some familiar favorites will be back – you will find out where Deccie gets his, um, Deccie-ness (for a lack of a better word), but is he actually going to die? Commissioner Ferguson will fight an eternal battle with being on a diet and looking after a Labradoodle (you have to hear his theory of evolution for celery and, damn, how he misses cheese...)! I can keep going, but maybe you should find out for yourself, huh?
Truth be told, I figured out who the guilty party was fairly early on, but I had no idea WHY things were going the way they were going, right up to the reveal close to the end. It detracts nothing from this story, I loved every single second of it and I will recommend it to anyone with a good sense of humor.
Brilliant!
Anyway, DEAD MAN’S SINS is the fifth book in ‘The Dublin Trilogy’ and it is the sequel to the prequel (the fourth book) of the first book... Don’t worry, it is not as confusing as you think, because it is not really of great importance – it worked out pretty well for the STAR WARS movies. All the books can work as a stand-alone, but I suggest you read them in order, because when you’ve read one, you WILL want to read the rest of them.
It started with the book THE MAN WITH ONE OF THOSE FACES and it was about a guy called Paul Mulchrone. And a star was born! Whether it was intentional or not, it was one of the other characters who completely stole the show. Much like Anthony Hopkins in THE SILENCE OF THE LAMBS, or Heath Ledger in THE DARK KNIGHT, or Tom Cruise in TROPIC THUNDER, or Gary Oldman in LEON (a.k.a.THE PROFESSIONAL), or Bill Murray in the movie KINGPIN, or Sharon Stone’s moomfi in BASIC INSTINCT, or Ben Kingsley in...just about everything, the big hit was Bunny McGarry who stole the hearts of the readers.
If you are unfamiliar, Bunny is a six-foot-something cop who fights dirty and drinks hard, and he follows his own moral compass to do what is right for him and his community. Read the other books if you want to know more.
In this instalment, Bunny is on sabbatical (even though he is not Jewish) and he gets drawn into a murder case where somebody is trying to set him up as the killer. And there is no feckin’ way that kite is going to fly!
That is about all I can tell you. Some familiar favorites will be back – you will find out where Deccie gets his, um, Deccie-ness (for a lack of a better word), but is he actually going to die? Commissioner Ferguson will fight an eternal battle with being on a diet and looking after a Labradoodle (you have to hear his theory of evolution for celery and, damn, how he misses cheese...)! I can keep going, but maybe you should find out for yourself, huh?
Truth be told, I figured out who the guilty party was fairly early on, but I had no idea WHY things were going the way they were going, right up to the reveal close to the end. It detracts nothing from this story, I loved every single second of it and I will recommend it to anyone with a good sense of humor.
Brilliant!
December 29, 2025
Bunny is the best, as always. Funny, action packed, heart warming sometimes, I love this “trilogy” and the 5th volume is no different. This is one of the few series that make me out in public.
February 12, 2025
I am really loving this series; however, I’ve been confused about the series order from the get-go. McDonnell finally explains the reason for the two different book orders in his author’s notes at the beginning of the story. Since I’m kind of fussy about starting a series from the beginning, I’m going to stick with the chronological order and this is the second installment of the chronological order. I am really enjoying (for the most part) catching up with my fave characters. However, several of the installments of some of my fave series that I have read lately have ended on such a sad note (and leaving me a little teary eyed), but not Bunny McGarry!
Anyway, Bunny is back and had me laughing within minutes. LOVE BUNNY! The book summary lays out the two different storylines. Bunny is on a sabbatical from the Gardia and finds himself dealing with the repercussions of the last installment where Bunny’s partner, Jimmy, was killed and now his secrets are coming to light (as well as his debts). This has Bunny butting heads with a nefarious loan shark, Coop Hannity, in an effort to help keep Jimmy’s mom in her home that Jimmy had leveraged before Jimmy was killed. Shortly after meeting with Bunny, where Coop threatened to expose Jimmy’s real part in the caper that got him killed, Coop is murdered. This has Bunny becoming a suspect due to Bunny being recorded at Coops home the day before, and stealing a lawn gnome on his way out
There is also a secondary storyline of Bunny helping one of the boys, Alan, that is a teammate on the hurling team that Bunny coaches for the local Catholic church. Seems the boy and his mother, Janice, are being physically abused by Janice’s abusive alcoholic boyfriend. One of Bunny’s friends from the Gardia, Det Pamela Cassidy (aka Butch), who is experienced in domestic abuse cases, agrees to help Bunny get Alan and Janice away from their abuser.
Most of the story revolves around the investigation of Coop’s murder. My armchair detective immediately zeroes in on two possible suspects and Bunny wasn’t one of them. The Gardia also brings in one Bunny’s nemesis, from his police academy days, to lead the investigation. This brings on a whole new level of amusement between Bunny and DS Marshall. In anticipation of being questioned and/or arrested for Coop’s murder, Bunny hires local attorney, Kaffe, to represent him or not. Love Kaffe and I hope there is more of him in future installments. Between the interviews of potential suspects, vigilante neighborhood watches and quasi-SAS nuns, McDonnell provides another rollicking and hilarious installment in the life and times of Bunny McGarry and his motley crew of friends and misfits.
The continuing character development of Bunny was well done and I’m finding him even more endearing than ever. The pacing was steady to fast and the storyline was very entertaining. Like all of the previous installments of this series, McDonnell had kept me cracking up throughout the story. The narrator, Morgan C Jones, is absolutely superb and is a master of voices. I’m looking at an overall rating of 4.75 only because I figured out the killer almost from the get-go. Doesn’t matter though because I am going to round up to a 5star review. McDonnell continues to be one of my fave authors with this series being one of my fave series. Oh, how I so wish that Guy Ritchie would please do a movie for any of the installments of this series. He would be the perfect person to adapt this series to film.
Anyway, Bunny is back and had me laughing within minutes. LOVE BUNNY! The book summary lays out the two different storylines. Bunny is on a sabbatical from the Gardia and finds himself dealing with the repercussions of the last installment where Bunny’s partner, Jimmy, was killed and now his secrets are coming to light (as well as his debts). This has Bunny butting heads with a nefarious loan shark, Coop Hannity, in an effort to help keep Jimmy’s mom in her home that Jimmy had leveraged before Jimmy was killed. Shortly after meeting with Bunny, where Coop threatened to expose Jimmy’s real part in the caper that got him killed, Coop is murdered. This has Bunny becoming a suspect due to Bunny being recorded at Coops home the day before, and stealing a lawn gnome on his way out
There is also a secondary storyline of Bunny helping one of the boys, Alan, that is a teammate on the hurling team that Bunny coaches for the local Catholic church. Seems the boy and his mother, Janice, are being physically abused by Janice’s abusive alcoholic boyfriend. One of Bunny’s friends from the Gardia, Det Pamela Cassidy (aka Butch), who is experienced in domestic abuse cases, agrees to help Bunny get Alan and Janice away from their abuser.
Most of the story revolves around the investigation of Coop’s murder. My armchair detective immediately zeroes in on two possible suspects and Bunny wasn’t one of them. The Gardia also brings in one Bunny’s nemesis, from his police academy days, to lead the investigation. This brings on a whole new level of amusement between Bunny and DS Marshall. In anticipation of being questioned and/or arrested for Coop’s murder, Bunny hires local attorney, Kaffe, to represent him or not. Love Kaffe and I hope there is more of him in future installments. Between the interviews of potential suspects, vigilante neighborhood watches and quasi-SAS nuns, McDonnell provides another rollicking and hilarious installment in the life and times of Bunny McGarry and his motley crew of friends and misfits.
The continuing character development of Bunny was well done and I’m finding him even more endearing than ever. The pacing was steady to fast and the storyline was very entertaining. Like all of the previous installments of this series, McDonnell had kept me cracking up throughout the story. The narrator, Morgan C Jones, is absolutely superb and is a master of voices. I’m looking at an overall rating of 4.75 only because I figured out the killer almost from the get-go. Doesn’t matter though because I am going to round up to a 5star review. McDonnell continues to be one of my fave authors with this series being one of my fave series. Oh, how I so wish that Guy Ritchie would please do a movie for any of the installments of this series. He would be the perfect person to adapt this series to film.
March 22, 2022
Really best if one just sits back and enjoys the ride. Relax into the exaggerated writing that is McDonnell, because some of the rat-a-tat-tat is sure to land. Not gonna lie, though: there’s an extended bit at the beginning with my new favorite character Deccie, a twelve year-old with a gift of gab and debatable ethics:
“’We are not having a vote,’” said Bunny, before turning to Deccie. ‘And didn’t you say to me last week that you’d no faith in democracy? That voters were a bunch of sheep too easily fooled’
‘I did,’ said Deccie with a firm nod, ‘but I’ve never been the shepherd before.’”
The beginning conflict elicited a smile and ended with out-loud laughter at Deccie’s description of a brawl to an investigating Guarda. But now that I pause a moment, I’m also quite fond of Butch (the name supposedly joins her last, Cassidy, very well, but she also happens to be a lesbian). She’s the department martial arts expert and has a knack for the quip, particularly when she’s maintaining her composure:
“She had tried not to form an opinion when she’d picked him up from the train station and, after a grunt of acknowledgement, he’d handed her his suitcase to carry back to the car.”
or trying to get Bunny to focus:
“’Why didn’t you say something when you walked in?’
Bunny shrugged. ‘I thought you were going for a sort of Bond-villain vibe.’
‘Why would I … Never mind. Forget about the cat,’ she said, while stroking the cat. ‘What are we going to do?'”
Anyway, it’s a decent enough mystery. It apparently has its roots in another story about Bunny’s former partner but is explained well enough here. I didn’t read it, but wasn’t bothered by any missing details. In fact, it ended up annoying me just a touch because of the amount of times it is stressed that Bunny is protecting his former partner’s reputation or dear ol’ ma. Or maybe that’s because Bunny’s a simple man, and that really is all he comes back to at the end of the day.
“Bunny awoke to a pounding noise. No, that wasn’t right – two pounding noises. One appeared to be in his head, but the other was coming from an external source. They were infuriatingly out of sync with each other, as if the outside world and his hangover were conspiring against him.”
It is always challenging for an author to find that delicate balance between humor and violence, particularly when you want to include issues like domestic abuse, economic crimes and murder. McDonnell mostly succeeds here. What begins as rather jokey and extreme gradually strips much of the silliness away into some core issues of family and community.
“It was always the way with places like this – you spend ages raising funds to get them built, and then, as soon as they’re finished, the thing starts slowly falling down.”
McDonnell also does a decent job of maintaining tension, but because Bunny is one of those character that no one wants to take on directly, it means we hop into the viewpoints of the aforementioned Butch, as well the wife of the deceased, Angela. There’s also a side road into a domestic abuse issue that may result in some catharsis (and again provided an opportunity for outlier humor) but probably could have been trimmed, particularly a random viewpoint from a hanger-on.
Now that I’m writing this all up, I’m feeling like this is definitely a book I want to re-read. Or at least through Deccie’s bit.
“’Will do. So, what’s this information worth?’
‘Excuse me?’
‘I’m a busy man.’
‘You are, in fact, neither of those things.’
Deccie ploughed on. ‘Fifty quid?’”
“’We are not having a vote,’” said Bunny, before turning to Deccie. ‘And didn’t you say to me last week that you’d no faith in democracy? That voters were a bunch of sheep too easily fooled’
‘I did,’ said Deccie with a firm nod, ‘but I’ve never been the shepherd before.’”
The beginning conflict elicited a smile and ended with out-loud laughter at Deccie’s description of a brawl to an investigating Guarda. But now that I pause a moment, I’m also quite fond of Butch (the name supposedly joins her last, Cassidy, very well, but she also happens to be a lesbian). She’s the department martial arts expert and has a knack for the quip, particularly when she’s maintaining her composure:
“She had tried not to form an opinion when she’d picked him up from the train station and, after a grunt of acknowledgement, he’d handed her his suitcase to carry back to the car.”
or trying to get Bunny to focus:
“’Why didn’t you say something when you walked in?’
Bunny shrugged. ‘I thought you were going for a sort of Bond-villain vibe.’
‘Why would I … Never mind. Forget about the cat,’ she said, while stroking the cat. ‘What are we going to do?'”
Anyway, it’s a decent enough mystery. It apparently has its roots in another story about Bunny’s former partner but is explained well enough here. I didn’t read it, but wasn’t bothered by any missing details. In fact, it ended up annoying me just a touch because of the amount of times it is stressed that Bunny is protecting his former partner’s reputation or dear ol’ ma. Or maybe that’s because Bunny’s a simple man, and that really is all he comes back to at the end of the day.
“Bunny awoke to a pounding noise. No, that wasn’t right – two pounding noises. One appeared to be in his head, but the other was coming from an external source. They were infuriatingly out of sync with each other, as if the outside world and his hangover were conspiring against him.”
It is always challenging for an author to find that delicate balance between humor and violence, particularly when you want to include issues like domestic abuse, economic crimes and murder. McDonnell mostly succeeds here. What begins as rather jokey and extreme gradually strips much of the silliness away into some core issues of family and community.
“It was always the way with places like this – you spend ages raising funds to get them built, and then, as soon as they’re finished, the thing starts slowly falling down.”
McDonnell also does a decent job of maintaining tension, but because Bunny is one of those character that no one wants to take on directly, it means we hop into the viewpoints of the aforementioned Butch, as well the wife of the deceased, Angela. There’s also a side road into a domestic abuse issue that may result in some catharsis (and again provided an opportunity for outlier humor) but probably could have been trimmed, particularly a random viewpoint from a hanger-on.
Now that I’m writing this all up, I’m feeling like this is definitely a book I want to re-read. Or at least through Deccie’s bit.
“’Will do. So, what’s this information worth?’
‘Excuse me?’
‘I’m a busy man.’
‘You are, in fact, neither of those things.’
Deccie ploughed on. ‘Fifty quid?’”
March 19, 2024
Part 2 (or 5 depending on your point of view) and we have a proper whodunnit facing Bunny. Although it might even be him what did it, unless our erstwhile hero can prove otherwise. Certainly all the evidence is pointing his way.
Of course when the victim is one of the city's vilest loan sharks you're never going to be short of candidates. Thankfully the murder is all on tape. Unfortunately the tape is missing.
Its a puzzle and no mistake. Matters aren't helped by Bunny's nemesis coming from Limerick to take over the running of the case. And he's not a people person at all.
With lots of cameos from the usual suspects (and a special appearance by the Deccie Fadden Collective) Dead Man's Sins keeps you laughing and guessing to the end. Thankyou Caimh McDonnell for another entertaining episode.
Onto Firewater Blues.
Of course when the victim is one of the city's vilest loan sharks you're never going to be short of candidates. Thankfully the murder is all on tape. Unfortunately the tape is missing.
Its a puzzle and no mistake. Matters aren't helped by Bunny's nemesis coming from Limerick to take over the running of the case. And he's not a people person at all.
With lots of cameos from the usual suspects (and a special appearance by the Deccie Fadden Collective) Dead Man's Sins keeps you laughing and guessing to the end. Thankyou Caimh McDonnell for another entertaining episode.
Onto Firewater Blues.
August 24, 2025
This was another one I listened to and I think I would have preferred to read it but I can't always be reading, can I?
June 26, 2021
Another great book in the Dublin Trilogy! (Book 5?).
A story going back in time with Bunny McGarry and his helpful assistant manager to the St Judes under 12 hurling team, Deccie.
Bunny gets himself typically without knowing into a bit of a situation, Arthur’s finest certainly has some input, while on sabbatical (is that Jewish?) after Gringos death.
Bunny is helped to clear his name with the help of Deccie, bad ass Guard Butch and some surprisingly up for violence elderly neighbours.
You will not be disappointed in this book as Bunny’s legend in the Guard grows and more characters are developed.
A story going back in time with Bunny McGarry and his helpful assistant manager to the St Judes under 12 hurling team, Deccie.
Bunny gets himself typically without knowing into a bit of a situation, Arthur’s finest certainly has some input, while on sabbatical (is that Jewish?) after Gringos death.
Bunny is helped to clear his name with the help of Deccie, bad ass Guard Butch and some surprisingly up for violence elderly neighbours.
You will not be disappointed in this book as Bunny’s legend in the Guard grows and more characters are developed.
March 23, 2022
I read this book after Angels in the Moonlight and once again I wasn't disappointed.
Caimh McDonnell manages to blend in jokes and hilarious dialogues with fast-paced crime plot and meaningful topics like loyalty towards friends, caring for one's community and social issues like domestic abuse.
I figured out who was responsible for the murder early on but that didn't spoil any of the fun.
Caimh McDonnell manages to blend in jokes and hilarious dialogues with fast-paced crime plot and meaningful topics like loyalty towards friends, caring for one's community and social issues like domestic abuse.
I figured out who was responsible for the murder early on but that didn't spoil any of the fun.
June 24, 2021
the only problem with Caimh's books is that they are over too soon!
July 15, 2021
With Mr McDonnell having branched out into new spheres with The Stranger Times, you might be forgiven for wondering if we had seen the last of Bunny McGarry.
But you can't keep a good man down, no matter how many blue alcopops he drinks, and sure enough earlier this year Dublin's finest policeman was brought back to us by Caimh.
And what a return.
With an approach to prequels that George Lucas would do well to learn from, McDonnell (The Caimh One) takes us back to Bunny's past once more, and the months that follow the previous prequel Angels In The Moonlight.
Yes, this is a sequel to a stand-alone prequel. But then this is still The Dublin Trilogy five books in - so hey.
This time around Bunny finds himself in the wrong place at the wrong time and has to race against the clock to prove he hasn't done anything wrong while trying to find who has before his Garda colleagues do.
It's as slick a crime caper as any that have come before, and the humour again pours off the page to such an extent you can only read it alone. Otherwise others won't get any sleep either.
The plot trots along at a cracking pace, with the characters new and old leaping off the page fully-formed, becoming instant firm friends.
But what really leaps out is Bunny's character. We've come to know and love him over several books now, and he has grown and changed with every adventure and punch-up.
So it's a rare delight to go back to someone you love and remember just how much of an objectionable arse our old friend was.
Not in a bad way, either.
He just works to his own higher moral code. A code which causes more problems than it solves, and his lifestyle – already legendary – was somehow worse, adding to the mystery of how the old sod ever survived Dublin, never mind America.
It's a sign of just how good McDonnell's writings and characters are, that you can be reminded of a loved characters major flaws and only find yourself warming to them even more.
The fact this would really annoy Bunny is a major added bonus.
But you can't keep a good man down, no matter how many blue alcopops he drinks, and sure enough earlier this year Dublin's finest policeman was brought back to us by Caimh.
And what a return.
With an approach to prequels that George Lucas would do well to learn from, McDonnell (The Caimh One) takes us back to Bunny's past once more, and the months that follow the previous prequel Angels In The Moonlight.
Yes, this is a sequel to a stand-alone prequel. But then this is still The Dublin Trilogy five books in - so hey.
This time around Bunny finds himself in the wrong place at the wrong time and has to race against the clock to prove he hasn't done anything wrong while trying to find who has before his Garda colleagues do.
It's as slick a crime caper as any that have come before, and the humour again pours off the page to such an extent you can only read it alone. Otherwise others won't get any sleep either.
The plot trots along at a cracking pace, with the characters new and old leaping off the page fully-formed, becoming instant firm friends.
But what really leaps out is Bunny's character. We've come to know and love him over several books now, and he has grown and changed with every adventure and punch-up.
So it's a rare delight to go back to someone you love and remember just how much of an objectionable arse our old friend was.
Not in a bad way, either.
He just works to his own higher moral code. A code which causes more problems than it solves, and his lifestyle – already legendary – was somehow worse, adding to the mystery of how the old sod ever survived Dublin, never mind America.
It's a sign of just how good McDonnell's writings and characters are, that you can be reminded of a loved characters major flaws and only find yourself warming to them even more.
The fact this would really annoy Bunny is a major added bonus.
June 16, 2021
I started laughing at the cover, after all, this is book 5 of a trilogy. This is the sequel to the prequel, of the prequel to the sequel, to be honest I'm not sure and it doesn't make any difference because everything about Dead Man's Sins is pure, undiluted happiness. I started and finished the book in 2 sessions because it is such a wonderous piece of writing. If you haven't met Bunny yet, then sort yourself out. I think he's the best creation in modern writing. Spending time in Bunny's world is like being licked by kittens, it's weird and wonderful in equal measure. The continuous laughing-out-loud, to which I subjected the unfortunates in my vicinity wasn't annoying in the least, (said no-one, ever). But I didn't care because my mood was lifted, my cheer was up and I was so happy my smile was registered as an eclipse. Of course, if you don't appreciate witty writing, impeccable characterisation, well thought out plots or comedy then this isn't the book for you. But if you're searching for a story that will stimulate all your senses and tickle your fancy, invest in Dead Man's Sins, then the rest of the Bunny McGarry series. You can always thank me later.
July 8, 2021
Laugh out loud funny
If you read this book in public, prepare to get some funny looks from everyone around you when it repeatedly makes you burst into loud laughter.
It's also a cracking thriller with a great whodunnit plot AND a great story from Bunny's past as a gard, featuring a lot of the characters you've met over the course of the series. Highly recommended!
If you read this book in public, prepare to get some funny looks from everyone around you when it repeatedly makes you burst into loud laughter.
It's also a cracking thriller with a great whodunnit plot AND a great story from Bunny's past as a gard, featuring a lot of the characters you've met over the course of the series. Highly recommended!
June 11, 2024
Another lively addition to the Dublin Trilogy. And more to go 🙂. There are 3 different series - Dublin Trilogy, MCM investigation and McGarry Stateside all featuring Bunny.
I hope McDonnell does a crossover of Stranger Times and Bunny's world.
I hope McDonnell does a crossover of Stranger Times and Bunny's world.
July 14, 2021
I have always enjoyed McDonnell's best character, one Bernard "Bunny" McGarry, particularly when he's in his natural environment of Ireland. In this issue, McGarry returns to what I consider to be his strengths, namely, trying to coach a bunch of twelve-year-old boys on his hurling team while working to solve some murder or other.
In this case, he's on "sabbatical" from the Gardai, where he serves as a Detective, and yet still manages to operate much like he would were he on duty. Plagued by an old nemesis who is a DI that's been brought up to the city to oversee the murder investigation of a notorious loan shark in which Bunny is a "person of interest," Bunny must juggle various thorny issues surrounding the case while remaining "unofficial."
McDonnell has crafted a pretty decent plot, but the real pleasure of these novels is his wit and the sarcastic humor that permeates the characters. Bunny's exchanges with the kids is always entertaining, as are his interactions in his favorite pub. He's a big fella, and larger than life within the confines of these stories. Bunny's a guy with whom you just want to hang out, share a pint, and a laugh or two. In the end, there's nothing earth shattering going on in these books-- if you're seeking dark, twisted, gory, or overly complicated, you'd best be served by another author (e.g., Nesbo), but if it's a laugh and fun character or two you're after, then pull up a pint and enjoy. 3.5 stars rounded up for just being Bunny.
In this case, he's on "sabbatical" from the Gardai, where he serves as a Detective, and yet still manages to operate much like he would were he on duty. Plagued by an old nemesis who is a DI that's been brought up to the city to oversee the murder investigation of a notorious loan shark in which Bunny is a "person of interest," Bunny must juggle various thorny issues surrounding the case while remaining "unofficial."
McDonnell has crafted a pretty decent plot, but the real pleasure of these novels is his wit and the sarcastic humor that permeates the characters. Bunny's exchanges with the kids is always entertaining, as are his interactions in his favorite pub. He's a big fella, and larger than life within the confines of these stories. Bunny's a guy with whom you just want to hang out, share a pint, and a laugh or two. In the end, there's nothing earth shattering going on in these books-- if you're seeking dark, twisted, gory, or overly complicated, you'd best be served by another author (e.g., Nesbo), but if it's a laugh and fun character or two you're after, then pull up a pint and enjoy. 3.5 stars rounded up for just being Bunny.
July 8, 2021
I’m never sure as I approach these books, whether the comic appeal of Bunny et al will endure for another outing. I’m not sure why I think that as every time I find it does and I thoroughly enjoy it.
This last outing is a welcome return to the sequel of the prequel to the 4 book trilogy. Bunny is in the frame for an audacious murder that only an old protagonist believes he would have done. The old protagonist, is of course, an idiot.
Absorbing, amusing and an easy and fun read, Caimh McDonnell does it again. I zoomed through it because I enjoyed it hugely.
This last outing is a welcome return to the sequel of the prequel to the 4 book trilogy. Bunny is in the frame for an audacious murder that only an old protagonist believes he would have done. The old protagonist, is of course, an idiot.
Absorbing, amusing and an easy and fun read, Caimh McDonnell does it again. I zoomed through it because I enjoyed it hugely.
July 3, 2021
Another great entry in the Bunny McGarry series
I am a big fan of this series of books and this entry did not disappoint. By turns laugh out loud funny and saddening this book adds more pieces to the picture of Bunny’s life and back story. A must for all fans of the series and a good, fun read for newcomers.
I am a big fan of this series of books and this entry did not disappoint. By turns laugh out loud funny and saddening this book adds more pieces to the picture of Bunny’s life and back story. A must for all fans of the series and a good, fun read for newcomers.
June 15, 2021
Delighted Bunny is back at base! Fits in well with rest of Dublin 'Trilogy! Another thoroughly enjoyable romp.
June 21, 2021
Loved this book. Bunny in Dublin is the best. The books are hysterical. I'm an older female but wish I could have played in the under-12s with Deccie and Bunny.
November 30, 2025
Impressive installment in this series. Funny, well plotted. Kept me uncertain about the actual solution to the mystery part despite not really having much in the way of alternative suspects. And McDonnell always keeps me happy despite using the sort of TV style pov cuts I normally hate in mystery/crime novels.
Some random spoiler plot bits I want to remember about this one:
Some random spoiler plot bits I want to remember about this one:
January 5, 2022
I love the whole series of six. My favorite is The Day That Never Comes for the added depth of political commentary, but this one is solid and thoroughly enjoyable. The Dublin books are as much about contemporary Ireland as they are about the plot of the books. All are full of hyperbole, humor, implicit tragedy, and warm-hearted insouciance. The series is built around the character of Bunny MacBride, an ugly, drunken guard (Irish cop) as he careens through whatever problems are besetting him and his friends. The love story in the earlier books is truly touching. The supporting cast of characters are wonderfully human, flaws and all. I highly recommend the whole series of six. BTW the books were not written in chronical order and can be read any way you want--but I recommend starting with The Man With One of Those Faces and following with The Day That Never Comes. After that the order doesn't matter much.
June 24, 2021
Dead Man's Sins is the latest installment in the Dublin Trilogy and it is a continuation of Angels in the moonlight. Both books are prequels to A man with one of those faces.
You know a book series is good when you don't hesitate to purchase the latest installment.
I strongly recommend your read all the books in the series, you won't regret it.
The series Is perfect for readers looking for books in the crime/mystery/ comedy sub genre.
In Dead Man's Sins, the author covers the aftermath of the events of Angels in the moonlight. Bunny is on sabbatical from the Garda Síochána and is looking to stay out of trouble but trouble finds Bunny. He is called by the mother of his former garda partner who requires his assistance. Bunny of course assists but this sets of a chain of events which leads to Bunny being framed for murder.
We see the best of Bunny in this book, we see how loyal he is to the memory of his best friend and former partner and we see his investigating prowess.
The book also features the sisters of the Saint and that was a delight to read.
In summary, another wonderful book from Caimh and i can't wait to read further installments which continue on the timeline from this book to just before the events in A man with one of those faces.
If you have not already done so, read the books in the Dublin Trilogy and the McGarry Stateside series, you won't regret it. Also sign up to the authors newsletter and subscribe to the Bunny Cast which is a podcast in which the author talks about certain chapters and we also hear a reading of the chapter.
You know a book series is good when you don't hesitate to purchase the latest installment.
I strongly recommend your read all the books in the series, you won't regret it.
The series Is perfect for readers looking for books in the crime/mystery/ comedy sub genre.
In Dead Man's Sins, the author covers the aftermath of the events of Angels in the moonlight. Bunny is on sabbatical from the Garda Síochána and is looking to stay out of trouble but trouble finds Bunny. He is called by the mother of his former garda partner who requires his assistance. Bunny of course assists but this sets of a chain of events which leads to Bunny being framed for murder.
We see the best of Bunny in this book, we see how loyal he is to the memory of his best friend and former partner and we see his investigating prowess.
The book also features the sisters of the Saint and that was a delight to read.
In summary, another wonderful book from Caimh and i can't wait to read further installments which continue on the timeline from this book to just before the events in A man with one of those faces.
If you have not already done so, read the books in the Dublin Trilogy and the McGarry Stateside series, you won't regret it. Also sign up to the authors newsletter and subscribe to the Bunny Cast which is a podcast in which the author talks about certain chapters and we also hear a reading of the chapter.
June 26, 2021
You know the feeling when you have been running around the whole day in uncomfortable shoes, and then you come home, enjoy a relaxing footbath and after that you stick your tired feet into your favourite slippers? It’s a heavenly feeling, and for me it’s exactly the feeling I get when I read one of Caimh McDonnell’s books. His characters and stories have become my comfort world, and boy, would I love to have a Bunny McGarry in my life, too.
Dead Man’s Sins was just what I needed in these dreary times and during the dreadful heatwave we’re going through where I live, and which drains me of every ounce of energy. That’s why a book really needs to be perfect for me, otherwise I can’t concentrate. A Bunny book is a 100% guarantee.
As always, Caimh McDonnell’s characters are strong and well drawn, there are loads of laugh-out-loud moments and quite a few “I want to kick that prick in the bollocks” moments, too. The plot is engaging and credible. What else would I ever want from a book?
I have no idea whether authors know how much their work can mean for someone, I really hope they do know, and I wish Caimh McDonnell knew how very good and important his books are for me, and have been for the last few years. Thank you, Caimh
Dead Man’s Sins was just what I needed in these dreary times and during the dreadful heatwave we’re going through where I live, and which drains me of every ounce of energy. That’s why a book really needs to be perfect for me, otherwise I can’t concentrate. A Bunny book is a 100% guarantee.
As always, Caimh McDonnell’s characters are strong and well drawn, there are loads of laugh-out-loud moments and quite a few “I want to kick that prick in the bollocks” moments, too. The plot is engaging and credible. What else would I ever want from a book?
I have no idea whether authors know how much their work can mean for someone, I really hope they do know, and I wish Caimh McDonnell knew how very good and important his books are for me, and have been for the last few years. Thank you, Caimh
February 22, 2022
4.5 stars, rounded up
I've missed Bunny so much and in reading McDonnell's reading note on why he's decided to write a sequel to the prequel (Angels in the Moonlight), it really did seem like a simpler time especially knowing how Bunny is doing in the States at the moment.
It's basically a filler story, but it's one I really don't mind reading particularly because there's a number of characters I've come to know making a feature, which was pretty fun. Also, it's a cracking story told with loads of humour and in the irrevalent way McDonnell does so well.
I've missed Bunny so much and in reading McDonnell's reading note on why he's decided to write a sequel to the prequel (Angels in the Moonlight), it really did seem like a simpler time especially knowing how Bunny is doing in the States at the moment.
It's basically a filler story, but it's one I really don't mind reading particularly because there's a number of characters I've come to know making a feature, which was pretty fun. Also, it's a cracking story told with loads of humour and in the irrevalent way McDonnell does so well.
August 23, 2022
Another hugely enjoyable Bunny McGarry book, this one going back to the early days. I have read all the books, and while they could be read as stand alone you will appreciate them more if you have the full background.
With any writer that I really like, I'm always worried that they won't be able to maintain the standard, but no worries on that score here. McDonnell has a fluent writing style, plenty of humour throughout but not to the extent of detracting from a thoroughly plotted detective story. Plenty of unforgettable characters, some familiar from the past and some new.
Highly recommended.
With any writer that I really like, I'm always worried that they won't be able to maintain the standard, but no worries on that score here. McDonnell has a fluent writing style, plenty of humour throughout but not to the extent of detracting from a thoroughly plotted detective story. Plenty of unforgettable characters, some familiar from the past and some new.
Highly recommended.
June 17, 2021
Caimh is a gifted & funny storyteller!
Through Mr. McDonnell's gifted talents, Bunny McGarry—a most flawed protagonist—delights readers as he rights wrongs by doing everything as wrong as possible until he magically turns a hopeless situation around and makes everything right.
Every Bunny McGarry story is a delight, and with Dead Man's Sins being a welcome addition to the Bunny-verse!
Commendations, Caimh McDonnell for crafting such great stories that are so much fun to read! Now that all the praising is over: please get crackin' on the next Bunny book!
Through Mr. McDonnell's gifted talents, Bunny McGarry—a most flawed protagonist—delights readers as he rights wrongs by doing everything as wrong as possible until he magically turns a hopeless situation around and makes everything right.
Every Bunny McGarry story is a delight, and with Dead Man's Sins being a welcome addition to the Bunny-verse!
Commendations, Caimh McDonnell for crafting such great stories that are so much fun to read! Now that all the praising is over: please get crackin' on the next Bunny book!
June 22, 2021
The problem with prequels…
Or sequels to prequels, is that you know where the characters are going to be at the end. (Think Anakin in the phantom menace for example) The trick is to make the journey to that point as entertaining as possible, Caimh manages this brilliantly and I was laughing often. Also, his ability to write characters that are relatable and that you find yourself caring about is impressive.
Buy this, then buy everything else he’s done! Your funny bone will thank you.
Or sequels to prequels, is that you know where the characters are going to be at the end. (Think Anakin in the phantom menace for example) The trick is to make the journey to that point as entertaining as possible, Caimh manages this brilliantly and I was laughing often. Also, his ability to write characters that are relatable and that you find yourself caring about is impressive.
Buy this, then buy everything else he’s done! Your funny bone will thank you.
June 19, 2021
He does it again
Predictive text won't allow me to write me McDonnell s name. Suffice to say he's given us another treat with Bunny in the deepest of poo while simply trying to enjoy his sabbatical and get on with training his hurling team. Like previous books we are entertained,made to laugh as well as being drawn along a crooked path of a gripping whodunit. No, it won't win the Nobel prize but it's great tonic in these difficult times thanks Caimh. Hey,predictive text allowed me to print his name!!
Predictive text won't allow me to write me McDonnell s name. Suffice to say he's given us another treat with Bunny in the deepest of poo while simply trying to enjoy his sabbatical and get on with training his hurling team. Like previous books we are entertained,made to laugh as well as being drawn along a crooked path of a gripping whodunit. No, it won't win the Nobel prize but it's great tonic in these difficult times thanks Caimh. Hey,predictive text allowed me to print his name!!
June 21, 2021
Highly Entertaining
I'm a huge fan of Caimh McDonnell's and Bunny's too so I await each new book with glee and much anticipation. In the Bunnyverse leaping back and forth in time isn't a problem because whenever Bunny is, madness, hilarity, and the weird ensues. Do you enjoy dry, sarcastic humor rooted in the certainty that life will always be f*ucked and strange to boot? Do you too appreciate social commentary that points out the hypocrisy of most and the oddness of many cultural norms? Then do read on and enjoy Bunny time.
I'm a huge fan of Caimh McDonnell's and Bunny's too so I await each new book with glee and much anticipation. In the Bunnyverse leaping back and forth in time isn't a problem because whenever Bunny is, madness, hilarity, and the weird ensues. Do you enjoy dry, sarcastic humor rooted in the certainty that life will always be f*ucked and strange to boot? Do you too appreciate social commentary that points out the hypocrisy of most and the oddness of many cultural norms? Then do read on and enjoy Bunny time.
June 23, 2021
McDonnell Gets Even More Serious & Funnier
Mr. McDonnell is growing as a writer - each book has him reaching new heights as a serious Celtic noir member. The plotting & character development are excellent at this point. Even if you haven't read earlier works of his in 6 or 7 book trilogy (Douglas Adams started the practice).
The best thing is that as he gets better at his writing skill, the humor doesn't slow down at all. He is a master of twists and turns that leave one laughing without breaking the spell of Celtic noir.
Well done to Mr. McDonnell.
Mr. McDonnell is growing as a writer - each book has him reaching new heights as a serious Celtic noir member. The plotting & character development are excellent at this point. Even if you haven't read earlier works of his in 6 or 7 book trilogy (Douglas Adams started the practice).
The best thing is that as he gets better at his writing skill, the humor doesn't slow down at all. He is a master of twists and turns that leave one laughing without breaking the spell of Celtic noir.
Well done to Mr. McDonnell.
June 30, 2021
Fifth in the Dublin Trilogy, (don't you love it when a series you enjoy ignores that convention?) continues in the Bunny McGarry saga. While fifth in order of writing, this story jumps back to events early in Bunny's career. Bunny's growing list of people, both cops and robbers, that he's irritated over the years, pop up again to complicate and threaten his life.
Turns out there is another series of books, wherein characters from the Dublin series pop up in the US for both good and bad reasons. I'm on them.
Turns out there is another series of books, wherein characters from the Dublin series pop up in the US for both good and bad reasons. I'm on them.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 256 reviews