What do you think?
Rate this book
The Disenchanted #1
Slanted and Disenchanted
It’s 2001. MTV stopped playing music videos. Boy bands and thongs are pop culture. And two college dropouts start a garage band.
When former classmates Carla and Pete run into each other, they learn that they're both looking for something beyond a suburban existence. Despite discovering their comically conflicting tastes, they bond over vinyl—the meaning of those songs, the covers of those albums—and making music together.
Before their greasy dive-bar cross-country tour, tragedy turns their world upside down, forcing them to decide if the band is just a teenage dream or a gateway to freedom… and maybe each other?
Slanted and Disenchanted is an early-2000’s coming-of-age gem packed with pop culture jabs and rock-nerd heart. High Fidelity for the MTV generation, unraveling sexual tension in friendships, the chaos of adulting, family dysfunction, and the records that get us through it all.
When former classmates Carla and Pete run into each other, they learn that they're both looking for something beyond a suburban existence. Despite discovering their comically conflicting tastes, they bond over vinyl—the meaning of those songs, the covers of those albums—and making music together.
Before their greasy dive-bar cross-country tour, tragedy turns their world upside down, forcing them to decide if the band is just a teenage dream or a gateway to freedom… and maybe each other?
Slanted and Disenchanted is an early-2000’s coming-of-age gem packed with pop culture jabs and rock-nerd heart. High Fidelity for the MTV generation, unraveling sexual tension in friendships, the chaos of adulting, family dysfunction, and the records that get us through it all.
284 pages, Paperback
Published September 21, 2021
6 people are currently reading
422 people want to read
About the author
Lisa Czarina Michaud
2 books26 followersLisa Czarina Michaud is an American author based in Paris. She also writes the Vinyl Diaries Newsletter on Substack (https://thevinyldiaries.substack.com/) where she shares her stories behind the songs.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 59 reviews
September 16, 2021
When the author of Slanted and Disenchanted reached out inviting me to read her new debut, I couldn’t resist accepting. A book about Gen X music-loving young adults who form a band and go on a cross-country road trip tour?! Yes, please! As a Gen Xer myself, I’m always eager to read books set in the early 2000s, and especially ones about music AND road trips, two of my favorite sub-genres.
But this book about music is so much more than that. First off, it’s about cultivated music fans—those folks who know the deep cuts, who wouldn’t be caught dead listening to a boy band, who are aware of music magazines and which ones are worth reading. And they actually read them.
I am not that kind of music fan, my friends. I’m your bargain-basement music fan. I like any and everything. But this book made me wish I was more discerning. I wanted to look up each new-to-me artist and song mentioned, but I stopped myself knowing it would take me out of the story. (Don’t worry, I went back to do that once I finished the book and there’s a playlist to prove it!) And even though much of the music lingo went over my head, I loved every word. And I was never confused.
Michaud has used her knowledge of music to flesh-out her characters in such an attractive way. These are beautifully flawed characters—and sometimes I wanted to shake them (ever so gently)—but their flaws made them real and compelling. Initially, I was frustrated with Pete’s unwavering commitment to his girlfriend despite the obvious toxicity of their relationship, but it’s a crucial character flaw of Pete’s that I’m counting on the author to expound on even more in the next book. And Carla’s passiveness when dealing with her family is hard to read at times, but it’s a symptom of a much deeper issue.
I also appreciated the main characters’ diversity. Carla is from an overbearing Italian family with expressive brothers who take most of their parents’ attention. Pete’s mother is of Eastern European descent while his father is French, and both of these facts heavily influence Pete’s personality. And as someone who took French in college (but can’t speak a lick of it), I enjoyed the smattering of French included throughout the book.
Michaud has taken this book set in the early 2000s and somehow made it so very relevant today. It’s striking to view the important events of that time through our current pandemic-lens. And to see the juxtaposition of how unified the country became in those days after 9/11 and how divided we are now. While reading, I could remember exactly how I felt living through those horrific events, but I could also view them knowing what I know now. If that makes any sense.
Beautifully written, I found myself immersed and impressed with how well Michaud illustrates the story, showing instead of telling, painting these characters into their settings and placing me there with them. It was easy to be entertained.
Slanted and Disenchanted is a hard book to categorize. It’s being promoted as Young Adult for 17+ and I think that’s a good place to start. It contains stronger language and sexual content than most Young Adult books. But our characters are college-aged, so it makes perfect sense that the book contains more adult situations.
This witty little debut full of heart has earned a permanent spot on my bookshelf, and I’m already looking forward to rereading it someday. I’m going to make a bold statement and say it will be among my favorite books of the year!
Thank you to Lisa Czarina Michaud for an advanced reader’s copy!
Check out my full review and playlist at A Book Wanderer.
#popsugarreadingchallenge2021 (prompt #40i - Upside-down image on the cover)
“…I settled us into a variation on disco with my double kick laying down a steady bass rhythm. Exploring a mood that was a little dance and maybe even a little punk, she timed in some melodic chord progressions, which got our packed house moving like it was the last party on Earth. We stayed in this space, keeping it punchy as we gradually evolved it into a full dance break that toppled the room like thunder. The walls trembled as dancing feet pounded the sagging wooden floor, bodies sweat up against one another, and arms hung around necks. Feeling the emotions bleed out of every person, it felt clear what so many of us needed right now was music."
But this book about music is so much more than that. First off, it’s about cultivated music fans—those folks who know the deep cuts, who wouldn’t be caught dead listening to a boy band, who are aware of music magazines and which ones are worth reading. And they actually read them.
I am not that kind of music fan, my friends. I’m your bargain-basement music fan. I like any and everything. But this book made me wish I was more discerning. I wanted to look up each new-to-me artist and song mentioned, but I stopped myself knowing it would take me out of the story. (Don’t worry, I went back to do that once I finished the book and there’s a playlist to prove it!) And even though much of the music lingo went over my head, I loved every word. And I was never confused.
Michaud has used her knowledge of music to flesh-out her characters in such an attractive way. These are beautifully flawed characters—and sometimes I wanted to shake them (ever so gently)—but their flaws made them real and compelling. Initially, I was frustrated with Pete’s unwavering commitment to his girlfriend despite the obvious toxicity of their relationship, but it’s a crucial character flaw of Pete’s that I’m counting on the author to expound on even more in the next book. And Carla’s passiveness when dealing with her family is hard to read at times, but it’s a symptom of a much deeper issue.
I also appreciated the main characters’ diversity. Carla is from an overbearing Italian family with expressive brothers who take most of their parents’ attention. Pete’s mother is of Eastern European descent while his father is French, and both of these facts heavily influence Pete’s personality. And as someone who took French in college (but can’t speak a lick of it), I enjoyed the smattering of French included throughout the book.
Michaud has taken this book set in the early 2000s and somehow made it so very relevant today. It’s striking to view the important events of that time through our current pandemic-lens. And to see the juxtaposition of how unified the country became in those days after 9/11 and how divided we are now. While reading, I could remember exactly how I felt living through those horrific events, but I could also view them knowing what I know now. If that makes any sense.
Beautifully written, I found myself immersed and impressed with how well Michaud illustrates the story, showing instead of telling, painting these characters into their settings and placing me there with them. It was easy to be entertained.
“…we lingered over a late breakfast at a greasy spoon. From across the booth, I observed her as she read a local newspaper. Every so often, she’d look up to capture her surroundings; the air perfumed with butter the size of ice cream scoops that slid across the grill; the hiss of bacon cooking; and the sun kissing her shoulder. She glowed in the Southwest light that cut through the window. I wanted to tell her how beautiful she looked in this old café, an image I knew one day would make me feel old from how long ago it would feel. Looking at her, she already felt like a distant memory.”
Slanted and Disenchanted is a hard book to categorize. It’s being promoted as Young Adult for 17+ and I think that’s a good place to start. It contains stronger language and sexual content than most Young Adult books. But our characters are college-aged, so it makes perfect sense that the book contains more adult situations.
This witty little debut full of heart has earned a permanent spot on my bookshelf, and I’m already looking forward to rereading it someday. I’m going to make a bold statement and say it will be among my favorite books of the year!
Thank you to Lisa Czarina Michaud for an advanced reader’s copy!
Check out my full review and playlist at A Book Wanderer.
#popsugarreadingchallenge2021 (prompt #40i - Upside-down image on the cover)
September 23, 2021
It's no secret that I'm obsessed with any book that deals with musicians, especially books with even a little bit of romance. Let me tell you, Slanted and Disenchanted delivered! I finished this book in about 12 hours over the course of two days because I had other things to do, but if I had the possibility of just binging it in one go, I absolutely would've been able to. It was such an addicting, beautifully written book! I truly loved everything about this one, and I really hope it gets the recognition it deserves!
I absolutely loved the author's writing style. It was so smooth and beautiful! This is one of the best debut novels I've read in a long time, and I'm so glad I got the chance to read it for this tour. There were references and phrases throughout the book relating to French culture which I found to be fascinating.
Carla and Pete were realistic and relatable. While I'm younger than they were, I could still relate to these characters, especially Carla when it comes to college. I hardly ever read books with young adults not going to college, so it was refreshing to see myself sort of represented in that way. The book is told through both of their perspectives, which I absolutely love (as I'm sure is obvious by reading my other reviews). I do wish we got to see more of Tony because he was hilarious, though.
There is a few chapters about 9/11, and while I wasn't born when it happened, it broke my heart reading it. I wasn't really expecting anything about 9/11 - I'm not sure why - so when I reached that point in the book, my heart just dropped. The author did a great job of highlighting how traumatic 9/11 was for the United States and how things started to abruptly change after it happened.
I really hope more people pick this book up, whether it's because they read my review, someone else's review, or they just like the cover. It's a truly beautiful book, and I just loved everything about it. Even though I was very young in the early 2000s, reading this book made me feel so nostalgic. It's emotional, addicting, focuses on music, AND there's bisexual representation; I truly couldn't ask of more from a YA/NA book!
Disclaimer: I received a free copy of this book from Rachel's Random Resources in exchange for an honest review.
I absolutely loved the author's writing style. It was so smooth and beautiful! This is one of the best debut novels I've read in a long time, and I'm so glad I got the chance to read it for this tour. There were references and phrases throughout the book relating to French culture which I found to be fascinating.
Carla and Pete were realistic and relatable. While I'm younger than they were, I could still relate to these characters, especially Carla when it comes to college. I hardly ever read books with young adults not going to college, so it was refreshing to see myself sort of represented in that way. The book is told through both of their perspectives, which I absolutely love (as I'm sure is obvious by reading my other reviews). I do wish we got to see more of Tony because he was hilarious, though.
There is a few chapters about 9/11, and while I wasn't born when it happened, it broke my heart reading it. I wasn't really expecting anything about 9/11 - I'm not sure why - so when I reached that point in the book, my heart just dropped. The author did a great job of highlighting how traumatic 9/11 was for the United States and how things started to abruptly change after it happened.
I really hope more people pick this book up, whether it's because they read my review, someone else's review, or they just like the cover. It's a truly beautiful book, and I just loved everything about it. Even though I was very young in the early 2000s, reading this book made me feel so nostalgic. It's emotional, addicting, focuses on music, AND there's bisexual representation; I truly couldn't ask of more from a YA/NA book!
Disclaimer: I received a free copy of this book from Rachel's Random Resources in exchange for an honest review.
March 17, 2025
Trigger warning: This is like revenge of the freaking rock nerds. If jabs at early-2000s pop culture triggers you, then maybe sit this one out.
A tour de force of rock history, the author leaves no stone left unturned as the characters identify by their music preferences. Carla’s all-girl punk (think riot grrrl and Babes in Toyland) while Pete is more jazz and jam. The contrast of their musical tastes against the backdrop of early-aughts pop culture makes for some hilarious observations because what teenage stoner dude who explains how his life was changed upon hearing the first notes of « Bitches Brew » by Miles Davis is going to relate to the sudden shift in culture with boy bands. Same with Carla. This makes for a delicious read for those of us who were there when MTV stopped playing rock videos. This is the fun and superficial side to set the tone of the story…
The story dives into a lot of deep topics from well-researched French culture that my half-French side was impressed with, family dysfunction and the cost it has on us as we enter adulthood and the music we get lost in to escape the hard questions we might not be mature enough to ask ourselves. It was some Times uncomfortable but very real where I found myself relating to both Carla and Pete. How they tried to find themselves through music, each other and their garage band with the arpeggios and chords creating a score in my head. I imagined the band sounding like a female-led Black Keys mixed with the toe-tapping energy of The Vines. Also - crazy rock dork points for the mention of CAN’s Jaki Liebzeit and his drumming technique which was a chef’s kiss in selling a convincing fiction drummer (the author is either a drummer or did some crazy research for this character.)
The cross-country road trip during such a turbulant time in world history felt so natural as many of us wanted to get out of dodge after 9/11. I loved how the author handled this heavy topic as I related wholeheartedly to feeling lost at this time but having a newfound appreciation for family and friends at such a tumultuous time.
Packed with detail, written with soul, this is a book that will stay with me for a long time. I look forward to the follow-up.
A tour de force of rock history, the author leaves no stone left unturned as the characters identify by their music preferences. Carla’s all-girl punk (think riot grrrl and Babes in Toyland) while Pete is more jazz and jam. The contrast of their musical tastes against the backdrop of early-aughts pop culture makes for some hilarious observations because what teenage stoner dude who explains how his life was changed upon hearing the first notes of « Bitches Brew » by Miles Davis is going to relate to the sudden shift in culture with boy bands. Same with Carla. This makes for a delicious read for those of us who were there when MTV stopped playing rock videos. This is the fun and superficial side to set the tone of the story…
The story dives into a lot of deep topics from well-researched French culture that my half-French side was impressed with, family dysfunction and the cost it has on us as we enter adulthood and the music we get lost in to escape the hard questions we might not be mature enough to ask ourselves. It was some Times uncomfortable but very real where I found myself relating to both Carla and Pete. How they tried to find themselves through music, each other and their garage band with the arpeggios and chords creating a score in my head. I imagined the band sounding like a female-led Black Keys mixed with the toe-tapping energy of The Vines. Also - crazy rock dork points for the mention of CAN’s Jaki Liebzeit and his drumming technique which was a chef’s kiss in selling a convincing fiction drummer (the author is either a drummer or did some crazy research for this character.)
The cross-country road trip during such a turbulant time in world history felt so natural as many of us wanted to get out of dodge after 9/11. I loved how the author handled this heavy topic as I related wholeheartedly to feeling lost at this time but having a newfound appreciation for family and friends at such a tumultuous time.
Packed with detail, written with soul, this is a book that will stay with me for a long time. I look forward to the follow-up.
February 27, 2025
By far, this was one of the most original books I've ever read. I loved how it wasn't trying to be anything other than what seemed to be in the author's head. A love story about friendship, music and newfound freedom, written in a way that is not meant to appeal to the masses. It makes us who loves it feel special because we "get it" as we remember our own responses to smaller cultural changes like when MTV stopped playing music videos to large-scale events like 9/11. I can see why a younger reader wouldn't get this and even be mad at it as every generation feels like they invented snark and pop culture references, and to feel on the outside of a "private joke" is uncomfortable. The good news is that this feeling becomes less important with age until you're in your 40s reading a book like this remembering when you were the little shit thinking you invented everything. To be young again....Five stars all the way for a book that felt like hanging out with a younger version of myself who incidentally has the same first name as me.
February 15, 2025
"High Fidelity" meets "Normal People" would perfectly describe Slanted and Disenchanted, the stunning debut novel from Lisa Czarina Michaud. Set in 2001, she takes us on a journey of vinyl, pop culture and what it meant to be coming-of-age in this 9/11 era.
A friendship that obviously is built on more, Carla and Pete are curious about one another but they both have past experiences and secrets that hold them back from doing the obvious, which is being together. But what they have, I believe is deeper than romantic love, which the author explores in such a lyrical way with textures and sounds that make you feel like you are taking every breath with them. There's also humor where they but heads on music genres with fun banter for the rock-loving crowd (which explains why the vinyl guys on Instagram seem to love this secret gem of a novel) and Carla's introspection and ability to poke fun at herself.
They travel across the US where the decriptions of landscapes are so rich I wonder how many times Michaud has made this trip. On the road, Carla and Pete discover each other as well as parts of themselves that they aren't ready to reveal. Michaud takes the utmost care in each detail with words that fall off the page as if watching a movie. A beautiful debut that shows promise for this new author.
A friendship that obviously is built on more, Carla and Pete are curious about one another but they both have past experiences and secrets that hold them back from doing the obvious, which is being together. But what they have, I believe is deeper than romantic love, which the author explores in such a lyrical way with textures and sounds that make you feel like you are taking every breath with them. There's also humor where they but heads on music genres with fun banter for the rock-loving crowd (which explains why the vinyl guys on Instagram seem to love this secret gem of a novel) and Carla's introspection and ability to poke fun at herself.
They travel across the US where the decriptions of landscapes are so rich I wonder how many times Michaud has made this trip. On the road, Carla and Pete discover each other as well as parts of themselves that they aren't ready to reveal. Michaud takes the utmost care in each detail with words that fall off the page as if watching a movie. A beautiful debut that shows promise for this new author.
September 27, 2021
90’s Nostalgia , enthralling, coming of age, music galore, road trip.
I was blown away by this book. It’s set in 2000-2001 and being about 5 years younger than the main characters I was all over the nostalgic vibes of pre-smartphone, having both tapes and CDs and using a landline to get a hold of people, era. Our two MC’s Carla and Pete, both have a POV in each chapter. They both turn 21 and try to come to terms with what it means to grow up and “be an adult” while finding and accepting who they are. Fate throws them together and they start up a band, decide to hit the road and tour to the Pacific all while trying to sort out their own shit.
There are so, so many music references and name drops, some I knew just because you’d have to live under a rock not to know names like “Nirvana” and “Britney Spears.” However, a lot was either super-obscure (thanks Pete) or very indie punk-grunge/Riot Grrrl (alright Carla!). I found myself flagging bands and names to look up later as I didn’t want to lose the flow of the story and though I didn’t know exactly what they were saying when they got deep into the melomanism it didn’t detract from the story, it made it stronger.
Pete and Carla were magnetic and I could hardly put this book down. When I did I was constantly thinking about the story. There are some big, complex issues and events that come up including 9/11. I was coincidentally reading this part on Sept 11th and as I read how the characters and country reacted to the events I re-visited where I was and how I felt when I watched the tragedy 20 years ago (AP BIO on a TV my teacher wheeled in, even being Canadian the events were heavy and heartbreaking). I know I’m not alone in this and anyone able to remember the event will be doing the same, only adding to the evocative draw to the story and characters.
I loved both Carla and Pete for very different reasons. My heart went out to Carla as we see her struggle with really rough emotional abuse from her alcoholic mother (and I’m hella upset with her family for just letting it happen). Seeing Carla evolve and come to terms with this and the damage it has caused her made my heartache yet I was proud of her as she started to find herself and her way. Pete, was AH-dorable, however, at times I just wanted to shake some sense into him. I did find his big secret or obstacle to make peace with came a bit out of the blue, and I wish we had learned a few of his end of book revelations a bit earlier (like a hint to the importance of his relationship with Allison). Despite this, I was still invested in his journey and was happy when all was revealed.
The ending was fantastic but I selfishly wanted so much more. I need to know where they go from there. I thought maybe another chapter or an epilogue but no I need more. I need another freaking book! Please, please give us another book, I need more Carla and Pete (and Tony because he was fan-freaking-tastic). This book was a captivating, nostalgic read that I’ll defiantly be re-visiting and gifting.
Special thank you to NetGalley and Barre Chord Press for sharing this digital copy in exchange for my honest thoughts.
#NetGalley #SlantedAndDisenchanted
I was blown away by this book. It’s set in 2000-2001 and being about 5 years younger than the main characters I was all over the nostalgic vibes of pre-smartphone, having both tapes and CDs and using a landline to get a hold of people, era. Our two MC’s Carla and Pete, both have a POV in each chapter. They both turn 21 and try to come to terms with what it means to grow up and “be an adult” while finding and accepting who they are. Fate throws them together and they start up a band, decide to hit the road and tour to the Pacific all while trying to sort out their own shit.
There are so, so many music references and name drops, some I knew just because you’d have to live under a rock not to know names like “Nirvana” and “Britney Spears.” However, a lot was either super-obscure (thanks Pete) or very indie punk-grunge/Riot Grrrl (alright Carla!). I found myself flagging bands and names to look up later as I didn’t want to lose the flow of the story and though I didn’t know exactly what they were saying when they got deep into the melomanism it didn’t detract from the story, it made it stronger.
Pete and Carla were magnetic and I could hardly put this book down. When I did I was constantly thinking about the story. There are some big, complex issues and events that come up including 9/11. I was coincidentally reading this part on Sept 11th and as I read how the characters and country reacted to the events I re-visited where I was and how I felt when I watched the tragedy 20 years ago (AP BIO on a TV my teacher wheeled in, even being Canadian the events were heavy and heartbreaking). I know I’m not alone in this and anyone able to remember the event will be doing the same, only adding to the evocative draw to the story and characters.
I loved both Carla and Pete for very different reasons. My heart went out to Carla as we see her struggle with really rough emotional abuse from her alcoholic mother (and I’m hella upset with her family for just letting it happen). Seeing Carla evolve and come to terms with this and the damage it has caused her made my heartache yet I was proud of her as she started to find herself and her way. Pete, was AH-dorable, however, at times I just wanted to shake some sense into him. I did find his big secret or obstacle to make peace with came a bit out of the blue, and I wish we had learned a few of his end of book revelations a bit earlier (like a hint to the importance of his relationship with Allison). Despite this, I was still invested in his journey and was happy when all was revealed.
The ending was fantastic but I selfishly wanted so much more. I need to know where they go from there. I thought maybe another chapter or an epilogue but no I need more. I need another freaking book! Please, please give us another book, I need more Carla and Pete (and Tony because he was fan-freaking-tastic). This book was a captivating, nostalgic read that I’ll defiantly be re-visiting and gifting.
Special thank you to NetGalley and Barre Chord Press for sharing this digital copy in exchange for my honest thoughts.
#NetGalley #SlantedAndDisenchanted
September 25, 2021
Carla and Pete were at the same high school, but didn't really know each other. Now, at 20, they find they have an insane amount in common, and start their own band.
I received a free copy in exchange for an honest review.
Carla is the invisible daughter from an Italian family. Her mother is an emotionally-abusive drunk, getting worse as Carla gets older.
Her best friend has gone to college, but there's nothing Carla cares to study for four years. She issues a vague interest in photography, so she can work in peace at the local photo shop; but her real passion is music.
Pete has a french family, who don't care if he goes to college or not, as long as he's happy. So whilst his friends and girlfriend continue their education, Pete works a dead-end job in Starbucks, with no real idea of what he wants to do with his life.
He loves music, and has been training on the drums from a young age. He's a skilled and devoted drummer, but is a little disenchanted by the mediocre bands from school. He finally meets his match in guitarist, Carla.
This book is set in New York 2000/2001, and is filled with lots pop culture of the time.
It's also a complete love note to music. Throughout the narrative, you really get the sense of deep knowledge and passion for different bands and music styles. Carla and Pete spend a lot of time thinking and talking about music (as this is their passion) ; dissecting why certain songs are important to them, and how they make them feel; or looking at the current trend for boy bands, and how some music is losing its soul.
The first book follows Pete and Carla reconnecting as friends; having an insane amount of chemistry, and putting their two-man-band together. They also go on their first tours, and get to discover who they are and what they want from life.
In the background, they each have their own issues.
Pete's girlfriend Allison gets increasingly demanding, as she suspects that Pete and Carla are more than just friends.
I thought Allison was a very interesting character, and she did have a right to be concerned. She's the perfect young woman, she's educated, and ambitious, and sees their lives going on an upward trajectory.
It's so realistic and relatable to how people change, and how their paths alter from what they dreamed of as teenagers.
I know that I did the same - as a kid, I thought 21 was an adult, and I'd have a degree, a house, a husband, a career... All the traditional stuff that we're programmed to want. How very wrong and stupid I was!
It was so easy to connect with these characters. As well as the big, important stuff; there was also a lot of banter, and all the little stuff that builds a friendship/relationship. Both were so easy to read, and (except for some of the deep-dive music debates) I never got bored.
I'm interested to see where the series goes next.
I received a free copy in exchange for an honest review.
Carla is the invisible daughter from an Italian family. Her mother is an emotionally-abusive drunk, getting worse as Carla gets older.
Her best friend has gone to college, but there's nothing Carla cares to study for four years. She issues a vague interest in photography, so she can work in peace at the local photo shop; but her real passion is music.
Pete has a french family, who don't care if he goes to college or not, as long as he's happy. So whilst his friends and girlfriend continue their education, Pete works a dead-end job in Starbucks, with no real idea of what he wants to do with his life.
He loves music, and has been training on the drums from a young age. He's a skilled and devoted drummer, but is a little disenchanted by the mediocre bands from school. He finally meets his match in guitarist, Carla.
This book is set in New York 2000/2001, and is filled with lots pop culture of the time.
It's also a complete love note to music. Throughout the narrative, you really get the sense of deep knowledge and passion for different bands and music styles. Carla and Pete spend a lot of time thinking and talking about music (as this is their passion) ; dissecting why certain songs are important to them, and how they make them feel; or looking at the current trend for boy bands, and how some music is losing its soul.
The first book follows Pete and Carla reconnecting as friends; having an insane amount of chemistry, and putting their two-man-band together. They also go on their first tours, and get to discover who they are and what they want from life.
In the background, they each have their own issues.
Pete's girlfriend Allison gets increasingly demanding, as she suspects that Pete and Carla are more than just friends.
I thought Allison was a very interesting character, and she did have a right to be concerned. She's the perfect young woman, she's educated, and ambitious, and sees their lives going on an upward trajectory.
It's so realistic and relatable to how people change, and how their paths alter from what they dreamed of as teenagers.
I know that I did the same - as a kid, I thought 21 was an adult, and I'd have a degree, a house, a husband, a career... All the traditional stuff that we're programmed to want. How very wrong and stupid I was!
It was so easy to connect with these characters. As well as the big, important stuff; there was also a lot of banter, and all the little stuff that builds a friendship/relationship. Both were so easy to read, and (except for some of the deep-dive music debates) I never got bored.
I'm interested to see where the series goes next.
May 23, 2024
90s nostalgia runs DEEP in this charming, lovable, road-trippin' debut from Lisa Michaud. Told in alternating perspectives between Carla, a wayward guitarist at odds with her heavy-drinking mother, and Pete, a talented drummer who doesn't know what to do next, Slanted and Disenchanted perfectly captures the spirit of what it's like to start a band, find your sound, and figure out what you're made of when the road gets bumpy.
Michaud is obviously a musician, not to mention an encyclopedia of 90s/early 00s music. The references run deep, and seeing Carla and Pete's love of different kinds of music rub up against each other was one of this book's greatest joys. As were the musical scenes that bring practice and rehearsal to life in a visceral way, which is not easy to do. In a lot of ways, this is a book about fandom. What it means. Why it matters. Music lovers take their tastes seriously, and some of the tension around Carla wondering if she can hang with a guy who likes Phish, and Pete frustrated at the simplicity of punk rock and embracing new sounds, rang so true to me remembering my teenaged self. At that age, your tastes define your personality like at no other time in your life. The bands you like matter. And you will defend them to the death!
There's also a sweet and tender love story at this book's center, which in the end, is actually about two people falling in love and learning how to be honest about it.
If you like road trips, love stories, music, and books that capture the spirit of the 90s/early 00s, you will LOVE Slanted and Disenchanted.
Michaud is obviously a musician, not to mention an encyclopedia of 90s/early 00s music. The references run deep, and seeing Carla and Pete's love of different kinds of music rub up against each other was one of this book's greatest joys. As were the musical scenes that bring practice and rehearsal to life in a visceral way, which is not easy to do. In a lot of ways, this is a book about fandom. What it means. Why it matters. Music lovers take their tastes seriously, and some of the tension around Carla wondering if she can hang with a guy who likes Phish, and Pete frustrated at the simplicity of punk rock and embracing new sounds, rang so true to me remembering my teenaged self. At that age, your tastes define your personality like at no other time in your life. The bands you like matter. And you will defend them to the death!
There's also a sweet and tender love story at this book's center, which in the end, is actually about two people falling in love and learning how to be honest about it.
If you like road trips, love stories, music, and books that capture the spirit of the 90s/early 00s, you will LOVE Slanted and Disenchanted.
September 26, 2021
Lisa has a keen eye and a sharp memory for the smallest details of raw human interaction. She captures the true spirit of that awkward not-a-teen-anymore-but-learning-to-be-grown era of our lives that we all experience in one way or another - navigating those ride-or-die teen friendships, first romantic flirtations, and what feels like the hardest part of growing up - navigating and accepting one’s relationship with family. This book hit hard in lots of ways and not just because I am also late-GenX-early-millennial (what a couple internet articles call Xennial). All the late 90s-girl-fronted-rock mentions PLUS the love-letter-to-90s-NYC bits really echoed my own adolescence (not to mention my New Yorker’s experience of 9/11), making it easy to fall in love with this story! As a musician and traveler who did the cross-country trip a few times in my 20s, I totally appreciated the tour-diary aspect of the book as well, and the deep magic of musical collaboration is perfectly honored in its description.
Other pluses: the alternating POV between chapters / battle of the musical tastes (who can't relate to that?), and the lessons on French/Alsatian & NY Italian culture. I absolutely can’t wait for the next installment!!!
Other pluses: the alternating POV between chapters / battle of the musical tastes (who can't relate to that?), and the lessons on French/Alsatian & NY Italian culture. I absolutely can’t wait for the next installment!!!
September 6, 2021
(Full disclosure: I received an ARC from the publisher.)
I intended to savor this book slowly at the beach, but whoops, I finished “Slanted & Disenchanted” in one night. Lisa had me at her page 1 description of “scabby-looking” egg salad.
The book contains pop-culture details and nostalgic Easter eggs that made it a lot of fun. Alsatian culture! French! Italian-American Sunday traditions! Guitars and drumming! Road tripping! Punk rock! Lots to relate to! Even the things that I couldn’t identify with--like growing up on Long Island—were engaging glimpses into a different culture, place, or lifestyle.
Another plus: realistic, multi-faceted characters. This book had plenty of moments that made my heart squeeze, but I appreciated that Carla and Pete felt like real humans dealing with often difficult situations. (Also, they have bodily functions and don’t always smell great while living a dirtbag-esque life.) I enjoyed the alternating points of view, especially the awkward misinterpretations of small behaviors.
This was definitely an engaging read and one that makes me want to expand my musical horizons and plan a trip to Alsace.
I intended to savor this book slowly at the beach, but whoops, I finished “Slanted & Disenchanted” in one night. Lisa had me at her page 1 description of “scabby-looking” egg salad.
The book contains pop-culture details and nostalgic Easter eggs that made it a lot of fun. Alsatian culture! French! Italian-American Sunday traditions! Guitars and drumming! Road tripping! Punk rock! Lots to relate to! Even the things that I couldn’t identify with--like growing up on Long Island—were engaging glimpses into a different culture, place, or lifestyle.
Another plus: realistic, multi-faceted characters. This book had plenty of moments that made my heart squeeze, but I appreciated that Carla and Pete felt like real humans dealing with often difficult situations. (Also, they have bodily functions and don’t always smell great while living a dirtbag-esque life.) I enjoyed the alternating points of view, especially the awkward misinterpretations of small behaviors.
This was definitely an engaging read and one that makes me want to expand my musical horizons and plan a trip to Alsace.
September 22, 2021
Not having a lot of time to read at the moment, I was excited to see how the book was divided up between the point of views of the two main characters offering perfect breaking points. Of course, I was immediately drawn into the story and couldn't put it down. The story took me back to the early 2000s (even though the characters were slightly older than I was at the time) and remembering what it felt to be that young and vulnerable, trying to discover who you are.
I really liked both Carla and Pete. I'm not sure I could pick a favorite as it was so easy to sympathize with both. I wanted both of them to be happy. And just when you think you have them figured out, there are new twists.
Slanted and Disenchanted was so well written that I found it hard to believe it was a first novel. The story felt so rich, and I could really picture the characters in my mind and hear the music that was flowing through their veins. I'm pretty sure I've been humming a tune since I finished the book.
I cannot wait for the next chapter!
I really liked both Carla and Pete. I'm not sure I could pick a favorite as it was so easy to sympathize with both. I wanted both of them to be happy. And just when you think you have them figured out, there are new twists.
Slanted and Disenchanted was so well written that I found it hard to believe it was a first novel. The story felt so rich, and I could really picture the characters in my mind and hear the music that was flowing through their veins. I'm pretty sure I've been humming a tune since I finished the book.
I cannot wait for the next chapter!
October 15, 2021
Slanted and Disenchanted was a fun and deeply profound book to discover this autumn season. It went well with my Pumpkin Spice Candle and cool Fall evenings. I wasn't expecting it to go as deep as it did. Even though I'm decades older than the characters I had fun with these two. Pete and Carla were smart, a little self-effacing, witty, very funny at times, and dare I say, kind of sexy but not just with each other. I picked up on all the little pop culture references of the 90's but there were even ones for older folks like me where I was like, where in the hell did this author learn this ? I heard the author on a book talk podcast and learned her father was a roadie for an old 70's band,so I said to myself there you go. Pete the French-American bad boy reminded me of Timothee Chalamet and the girl reminded me a little of my upbringing (also being an Italian girl from a big family). It was a great read with fluid writing and impressive character development. I can't wait for the sequel.
February 10, 2022
Pete and Carla have graduated high school and now feel a bit stuck in mundane jobs and with loved ones that are not always the most supportive. Luckily, they have music, the one activity where they can fully express their creativity. A couple of chance encounters lead to the start of their band and friendship, and maybe a lot more.
This was a fun breezy read, with some hard-hitting topics sprinkled through the book.
I listened to the audiobook and I really enjoyed the experience, with the two narrators doing a really good job.
Overall, 3.5 stars for me
I received a complimentary copy of the audiobook and these are my own opinions.
This was a fun breezy read, with some hard-hitting topics sprinkled through the book.
I listened to the audiobook and I really enjoyed the experience, with the two narrators doing a really good job.
Overall, 3.5 stars for me
I received a complimentary copy of the audiobook and these are my own opinions.
April 4, 2022
I enjoyed meeting Carla and Pete. I had a different view of what I was expecting with this one. I got more. Friends, family, expectations (meet, exceeded, missed), and life as a young adult in the world of today.
I had the opportunity to meet two new authors to me. I enjoyed both of them. There was a smooth quality to the audio and the smoothness of the narrators complementing the story from Lisa Czarina.
I had the opportunity to meet two new authors to me. I enjoyed both of them. There was a smooth quality to the audio and the smoothness of the narrators complementing the story from Lisa Czarina.
January 21, 2023
Wonderfully and hilariously written with incredible knowledge of music - instruments, bands and technical aspects alike. Lisa captures the early 'oughts ennui of post-high school graduates on Long Island with whimsical dialogue and delicious character developments. Written from two perspectives, the man and the woman, it's a transparent look at the dynamics and perceptions of people in a burgeoning relationship. I loved it!
March 3, 2025
I'm not YA. I'm actually a spry old fart, and I've performed and recorded and toured for much of my life. I couldn't put this book down! It's ageless. It's an enchanting story about the true heartbeat of music and love, a joyous page-turner! Oh, and if you've ever watched Loudermilk on Amazon, you'll fall in love with these characters!
August 15, 2021
This was such a fun book. Tons of awesome laugh out loud 90s references and a really cute yet heartbreaking story to boot. I liked the French touch and music references too. I definitely learned stuff I didn’t know. I really enjoyed it!
September 22, 2021
*Thank you Netgalley and the publisher for providing me with an early copy of this book for review, all opinions are my own*
I took longer than I thought to read this book, I still don't know if this is good or bad, it flows very well so much that whenever I picked it up I read a lot but at the same time this didn't make the percentage of the book go faster, what helps is that the book is not dragged so you don't feel so much difficulty reading the story, the chapters are very fast as well which it helps.
Another thing that helped in the reading was the fact that we are always changing points of view, which makes the story interesting.
This book is about music, about entering adulthood not knowing what to do, about discoveries, about finding yourself in the world. The book touches on several important subjects, sexuality, eating disorders, 9/11, relationshipsnof love and family.
In fact the family has a very important part in this book which I really liked.
As I said this book is about music, if you were a young adult/teen in the 90s/00 and liked/likes music you will love this book because it has a lot of references to music that being honest, most of it went through my head.
What I liked the least about this book was the open ending and how it could have been resolved with 10 more pages of heartfelt dialogue between the characters.
But I do recommend the book if you like books about bands and music and young people discovering themselves!
I took longer than I thought to read this book, I still don't know if this is good or bad, it flows very well so much that whenever I picked it up I read a lot but at the same time this didn't make the percentage of the book go faster, what helps is that the book is not dragged so you don't feel so much difficulty reading the story, the chapters are very fast as well which it helps.
Another thing that helped in the reading was the fact that we are always changing points of view, which makes the story interesting.
This book is about music, about entering adulthood not knowing what to do, about discoveries, about finding yourself in the world. The book touches on several important subjects, sexuality, eating disorders, 9/11, relationshipsnof love and family.
In fact the family has a very important part in this book which I really liked.
As I said this book is about music, if you were a young adult/teen in the 90s/00 and liked/likes music you will love this book because it has a lot of references to music that being honest, most of it went through my head.
What I liked the least about this book was the open ending and how it could have been resolved with 10 more pages of heartfelt dialogue between the characters.
But I do recommend the book if you like books about bands and music and young people discovering themselves!
September 18, 2021
(English review, coming soon!)
Pues bueno, quisiera empezar hablando de lo que más me gustó de este libro que son los personajes: Carla y Pete se robaron mi corazón, y sobre todo disfrutaba ver sus interacciones porque me parecía que tenían una gran química.
La música es un elemento muy importante en la historia y también fue algo que me encantó, a pesar de que yo no toco ningún instrumento ni diría que soy una super aficionada a la música, me parece que la autora si logró transmitir muy bien la magia de la música.
Ahora, la trama de la historia es seguir a los personajes en sus vidas y problemas, y como me gustaron los personajes entonces si disfruté bastante la trama, pero también tengo un par de quejas sobre ella :l
Por lo mismo de que la trama es una cosa bastante cotidiana, había un par de momentos que me parecieron un tanto tediosos; pero lo que me pareció más grave fue el final, porque me pareció un tanto apresurado, y aunque se podría decir que si se cerraron varias cosas, en general el final no me dejó totalmente satisfecha.
En fin, estoy escribiendo esto cuando recién terminé el libro así que podría decir que son mis primeras impresiones, pero igual haré una reseña más completa después de haber asimilado mejor el libro, en la comunidad de Libros Amino.
Gracias por leer :D
Pues bueno, quisiera empezar hablando de lo que más me gustó de este libro que son los personajes: Carla y Pete se robaron mi corazón, y sobre todo disfrutaba ver sus interacciones porque me parecía que tenían una gran química.
La música es un elemento muy importante en la historia y también fue algo que me encantó, a pesar de que yo no toco ningún instrumento ni diría que soy una super aficionada a la música, me parece que la autora si logró transmitir muy bien la magia de la música.
Ahora, la trama de la historia es seguir a los personajes en sus vidas y problemas, y como me gustaron los personajes entonces si disfruté bastante la trama, pero también tengo un par de quejas sobre ella :l
Por lo mismo de que la trama es una cosa bastante cotidiana, había un par de momentos que me parecieron un tanto tediosos; pero lo que me pareció más grave fue el final, porque me pareció un tanto apresurado, y aunque se podría decir que si se cerraron varias cosas, en general el final no me dejó totalmente satisfecha.
En fin, estoy escribiendo esto cuando recién terminé el libro así que podría decir que son mis primeras impresiones, pero igual haré una reseña más completa después de haber asimilado mejor el libro, en la comunidad de Libros Amino.
Gracias por leer :D
August 26, 2021
I thought this was a fantastic read. Pete and Carla were well-crafted main characters, and while there is a bit of a romance, I am relieved that it didn’t take over the book. Being a music person, I loved their conversations comparing bands and how they connected through their love of their instruments. I was impressed with the honesty of this novel – the characters have to deal with some difficult situations not just as young adults, but also as people who are struggling to figure out who they really are and what they want. Their issues with family and relationships were relevant and real, as are their reactions and while much of this book is light, it is also surprisingly deep. Slanted and Disenchanted was a wonderful coming-of-age story that will pull at the heartstrings while also make you frantically search for everything they’re listening to. Great book and highly recommended!
Thank you Voracious Readers and Lisa Michaud for my copy!
Thank you Voracious Readers and Lisa Michaud for my copy!
July 8, 2021
I really enjoyed this book. It looked at issues that are current topics of discussion and allowed us to view it from the lens of the early 2000s. I loved the way the two MCs connect over music and deepen their connection as they learn about the music scene together. Most likely this story is going to need some content warnings for the deeply difficult situations going on, but it was an honest look at hardships and relationships people endure as they meet new people and grow up. I recommend it as a good read but believe content warnings should be added to warn those who struggle with abuse or intense situations.
Thanks to NetGalley and the Publisher for the ARC.
Thanks to NetGalley and the Publisher for the ARC.
November 1, 2021
I thoroughly enjoyed Slanted and Disenchanted: A Total Rock Nerd Young Adult Adventure! I couldn't put the book down and read in one day. I would highly recommend!
I've been following the author for years, starting with her blog about her experience as an American living in Paris. I loved reading the story of Carla and Pete and seeing the incorporation of the author's lived experience as a teen of the 90s and living in France. The alternative POVs offered a window into the character's mind - how they felt, what they were thinking, and how they interpreted each experience. I can't wait for the next installment of the series!
I've been following the author for years, starting with her blog about her experience as an American living in Paris. I loved reading the story of Carla and Pete and seeing the incorporation of the author's lived experience as a teen of the 90s and living in France. The alternative POVs offered a window into the character's mind - how they felt, what they were thinking, and how they interpreted each experience. I can't wait for the next installment of the series!
September 29, 2021
Being a lover of music, I thought this book would be right up my alley! I was right! I loved it! I could relate to Carla on several levels. This book was so realistic. I was able to imagine everything as it was happening. I loved the writing style. I enjoy multiple points of view. I think the author nailed what it is like growing from a teen to an adult!
September 16, 2021
3.5 stars
I don't know if I would market this as a young adult, it feels too mature for teens. This hits the new adult, trying to figure out life and who you are post structured school perfectly. The setting took a while for me to understand that we were in 2000 and 2001 which is an interesting choice for a coming of ago story.
As for the characters I preferred reading from Pete's POV, but both were lyrical and unique.
The ending didn't wrap up everything in a bow, which in this case did not leave me feeling satisfied. It was very one-sided and I don't feel like one character shared their secret.
Overall, has vibes of early-2000s hipsters Normal People by Sally Rooney, with loads of musical references that I did not get.
Thank you Netgally and the publishers for a review copy.
I don't know if I would market this as a young adult, it feels too mature for teens. This hits the new adult, trying to figure out life and who you are post structured school perfectly. The setting took a while for me to understand that we were in 2000 and 2001 which is an interesting choice for a coming of ago story.
As for the characters I preferred reading from Pete's POV, but both were lyrical and unique.
The ending didn't wrap up everything in a bow, which in this case did not leave me feeling satisfied. It was very one-sided and I don't feel like one character shared their secret.
Overall, has vibes of early-2000s hipsters Normal People by Sally Rooney, with loads of musical references that I did not get.
Thank you Netgally and the publishers for a review copy.
September 16, 2021
Slanted and Disenchanted was one of my favorite books of 2021. The story is sweet and engaging and the author created characters who are emotional and vulnerable. I loved the toggle between both Carla and Pete. You like both of them - root for both them - want them both to succeed and be happy but also sympathize with them at the moments they are down.
The other amazing part of this book are all of the fun late 90s/early 00s pop culture references. There were many many times where I chuckled about something the author included in her delightful prose that was a reminder of something I didn't even remember I had forgotten! It was so great to relive so many small details throughout such a wonderful story.
I can't wait to read the sequel!
The other amazing part of this book are all of the fun late 90s/early 00s pop culture references. There were many many times where I chuckled about something the author included in her delightful prose that was a reminder of something I didn't even remember I had forgotten! It was so great to relive so many small details throughout such a wonderful story.
I can't wait to read the sequel!
March 16, 2022
Some great characters in this and what an adventure this book takes you on. Loved the mix of cultures too.
Some hard hitting topics dealt with well in this read.
Music lovers unite as this has a great music theme throughout.
Some hard hitting topics dealt with well in this read.
Music lovers unite as this has a great music theme throughout.
March 3, 2025
This is a coming-of-age novel with a heavy emphasis on music. The blurb aptly compares it to High Fidelity and Normal People. Our flawed main characters have a lot of emotional baggage to fit into their music van along with their amps. If you’ve ever lugged one around, you know there’s barely room left over for feelings.
I liked the way Carla and Pete connected over music! They could talk forever about all the different bands they listen to, argue album rankings, and just jam together to create their own sound. The way they got each other felt real. I’m fortunate to have this kind of relationship in my own life, so it made me feel all warm and fuzzy.
Of course, I have a few nitpicks about their music takes:
- I could have done without the boyband slander. I get that music snobbery was part of the scene, but still. The Backstreet Boys did nothing wrong.
- Kurt Cobain’s go-to guitar was a Mustang, not a Strat.
- There’s also some Avril Lavigne hate that is A) uncalled for, and B) anachronistic, since this book takes place in 2001 and Avril’s debut album released in 2002. It’s a pity, because Carla would have loved Girlfriend.
Still, watching their garage band come together was great. Much like myself, Carla’s a Fender girlie. I don’t fully get how her adorable orange Telecaster and Pete’s drums can compensate for the band’s lack of bassist, but I do appreciate the you-and-me-against-the-world energy of the duo. They figured things out along the way, and I felt like I was in their garage and tour van with them.
Did anyone bring Febreze?
That said, I sometimes struggled to actually hear what their band sounded like. They said that they blended their styles, but it didn’t fully come together for me. Like Pete, I’m blaming the (imaginary) bassist. The choppy POV shifts also threw me off; some chapters were barely half a page, making the constant switches feel more jarring than intentional. I think this could’ve worked better as a movie or show to bring the music to life and avoid the whiplash.
The romantic angst in this story must have burned a mixtape from Stevie Nicks and Lindsey Buckingham, because ooh boy. Pete and Carla were a mess. Unfortunately, a big part of this conflict revolved around Pete’s girlfriend, and I just didn’t care for that. It dragged on for too long, and being in Pete’s head made it hard to root for him. I didn’t like how he was stringing along both girls, and his thoughts felt really selfish. And horny.
I really felt for Carla. She struggled with self-worth and it didn’t help that her family was so unsupportive. She kept repeating that everything was fine and just internalized everything and shrunk in on herself. (“Who can relate? WOO” - esteemed Maryland poet, Logic) Definitely me, but I wanted to see more character growth. I also think her eating disorder was realistically woven into the story, but mental health awareness wasn’t great in the early aughts, so her struggles weren’t always given the weight they deserved.
The story captures the messy in-between phase of growing up, with vivid imagery of the music scene and a deep love for music at its core. The emotional angst didn’t quite resolve in a satisfying way for me, but I think other readers will connect with it. If I’d read this book in my angsty college years, it probably would’ve hit harder. At this point in my life, it didn’t land the way I hoped—but my punk rock spirit still sees something familiar in it.
2.5 stars, rounded up since I think this caught me at the wrong time.
Thank you to Netgalley and BooksGoSocial for providing me with this ebook for an honest review!
I liked the way Carla and Pete connected over music! They could talk forever about all the different bands they listen to, argue album rankings, and just jam together to create their own sound. The way they got each other felt real. I’m fortunate to have this kind of relationship in my own life, so it made me feel all warm and fuzzy.
Of course, I have a few nitpicks about their music takes:
- I could have done without the boyband slander. I get that music snobbery was part of the scene, but still. The Backstreet Boys did nothing wrong.
- Kurt Cobain’s go-to guitar was a Mustang, not a Strat.
- There’s also some Avril Lavigne hate that is A) uncalled for, and B) anachronistic, since this book takes place in 2001 and Avril’s debut album released in 2002. It’s a pity, because Carla would have loved Girlfriend.
Still, watching their garage band come together was great. Much like myself, Carla’s a Fender girlie. I don’t fully get how her adorable orange Telecaster and Pete’s drums can compensate for the band’s lack of bassist, but I do appreciate the you-and-me-against-the-world energy of the duo. They figured things out along the way, and I felt like I was in their garage and tour van with them.
Did anyone bring Febreze?
That said, I sometimes struggled to actually hear what their band sounded like. They said that they blended their styles, but it didn’t fully come together for me. Like Pete, I’m blaming the (imaginary) bassist. The choppy POV shifts also threw me off; some chapters were barely half a page, making the constant switches feel more jarring than intentional. I think this could’ve worked better as a movie or show to bring the music to life and avoid the whiplash.
The romantic angst in this story must have burned a mixtape from Stevie Nicks and Lindsey Buckingham, because ooh boy. Pete and Carla were a mess. Unfortunately, a big part of this conflict revolved around Pete’s girlfriend, and I just didn’t care for that. It dragged on for too long, and being in Pete’s head made it hard to root for him. I didn’t like how he was stringing along both girls, and his thoughts felt really selfish. And horny.
I really felt for Carla. She struggled with self-worth and it didn’t help that her family was so unsupportive. She kept repeating that everything was fine and just internalized everything and shrunk in on herself. (“Who can relate? WOO” - esteemed Maryland poet, Logic) Definitely me, but I wanted to see more character growth. I also think her eating disorder was realistically woven into the story, but mental health awareness wasn’t great in the early aughts, so her struggles weren’t always given the weight they deserved.
The story captures the messy in-between phase of growing up, with vivid imagery of the music scene and a deep love for music at its core. The emotional angst didn’t quite resolve in a satisfying way for me, but I think other readers will connect with it. If I’d read this book in my angsty college years, it probably would’ve hit harder. At this point in my life, it didn’t land the way I hoped—but my punk rock spirit still sees something familiar in it.
2.5 stars, rounded up since I think this caught me at the wrong time.
Thank you to Netgalley and BooksGoSocial for providing me with this ebook for an honest review!
September 12, 2021
Rating: 3.5 stars
This was a witty, coming-of-age novel that had a heavy focus on music. So many aspects of this story were handled well. Despite that, I found it hard to become invested in the story and it didn't quite resonate with me. However, I think anyone who's passionate about music and looking for a realistic coming-of-age, upper YA book will really enjoy this.
You can check out my full review here: https://hasnitasinghauthor.com/2021/0...
This was a witty, coming-of-age novel that had a heavy focus on music. So many aspects of this story were handled well. Despite that, I found it hard to become invested in the story and it didn't quite resonate with me. However, I think anyone who's passionate about music and looking for a realistic coming-of-age, upper YA book will really enjoy this.
You can check out my full review here: https://hasnitasinghauthor.com/2021/0...
March 6, 2025
Slanted and Disenchanted is a book like none other, qualifying it as "punk fiction", the genre the author has branded it with. And you know what? It works. This book is punk rock. To be clear: it's not punk in what we know with the repeated imagery. Think the mohawk, leather jacket, studs, Sex Pistols. I say it's punk in the way that it's not trying to be anything other than itself, it's genuine to its core (and to the irritation of those who don't seem to get it), which right there is the foundation of the grassroots punk rock movement. If this book were a band, I'd be one of the early fans seeing them at CBGB. (I can see there are a few of us here.)
The author's knowledge of music and its history shine through, and it's cool to see a woman take a passion for vinyl; something that's increasingly crossing genders and losing its "boy's club" stigma. But S&D is more than rock references, it's a love story of self, finding yourself post-high school when you truly wonder who you are. A time when you realize that your family might not know everything and when you see how their dysfunction has played a significant role in who you are. It's also a story of friendship, which I found to be the most endearing. Not just between the two MCs Carla and Pete but there's the sweet best-friend-girl friendship between Carla and Alex that felt so real with how they spoke to each other and how they can read each other's mind (the Janet Jackson conversation had me in stitches. I remember that song "If" and also thinking about boys I liked so this felt very real). Reading their scenes made me feel like I was hanging out with my own ride-or-die bestie. There was the friendship between Pete and big Italian Tony, showing that you don't always have to have things in common to have a friendship based on mutual respect but also a lot of teasing the crap out of each other (their dialogue, by the way, was some of the best, like when Pete knits him a beanie - it's so random but so funny) But this is what made the story resonate for me even deeper than getting the pop culture and music references. The idea that friendship is stronger than any kiss at the end made for powerful writing and I think deepened the connection between Carla and Pete.
To conclude, I think the author did a great job with a story that feels written from her heart. I am delighted to have discovered her and love that there's a sequel, which I also read and will review next.
Thank you Net Galley for the free copies of this fantastic series.
The author's knowledge of music and its history shine through, and it's cool to see a woman take a passion for vinyl; something that's increasingly crossing genders and losing its "boy's club" stigma. But S&D is more than rock references, it's a love story of self, finding yourself post-high school when you truly wonder who you are. A time when you realize that your family might not know everything and when you see how their dysfunction has played a significant role in who you are. It's also a story of friendship, which I found to be the most endearing. Not just between the two MCs Carla and Pete but there's the sweet best-friend-girl friendship between Carla and Alex that felt so real with how they spoke to each other and how they can read each other's mind (the Janet Jackson conversation had me in stitches. I remember that song "If" and also thinking about boys I liked so this felt very real). Reading their scenes made me feel like I was hanging out with my own ride-or-die bestie. There was the friendship between Pete and big Italian Tony, showing that you don't always have to have things in common to have a friendship based on mutual respect but also a lot of teasing the crap out of each other (their dialogue, by the way, was some of the best, like when Pete knits him a beanie - it's so random but so funny) But this is what made the story resonate for me even deeper than getting the pop culture and music references. The idea that friendship is stronger than any kiss at the end made for powerful writing and I think deepened the connection between Carla and Pete.
To conclude, I think the author did a great job with a story that feels written from her heart. I am delighted to have discovered her and love that there's a sequel, which I also read and will review next.
Thank you Net Galley for the free copies of this fantastic series.
March 18, 2025
A book about a fictional band that feels realistic. Finally. There's no skyrocket to fame where we're supposed to suspend belief that this band is suddenly the biggest thing in the world. Nope. It's dive bars, it's getting pulled over, and it's more about self-discovery than trying to convince us that they're a popular band. It's done so realistically, I wondered if the author had been in a band with some guy because it reads so truthfully.
Then there's the emotional aspect of it. Carla’s journey of figuring out who she is while wrestling with her inner chaos felt lived with the experience dominating the pages. The mixed-tape vibes of the novel also pulled me with each song choice, a coping mechanism for drowning out our thoughts with our favorite bands. It’s a beautifully messy portrait, revealing emotional scars, and I couldn’t put it down.
Then there’s the “more than friendship” arc with Pete, which had me nodding along with every blurry line and unspoken feeling. Anyone who’s ever had that one friend where you’re not sure if it’s just late-night talks or something deeper will definitely feel seen here. Their connection is tender and confusing in the best way. Pete’s arc is also sweet, watching him stumble through his own lostness as he acknowledges who he is, which I LOVED this angle and hope the author fleshes out in the sequel. But here, he proves he's a true friend to Carla and their push-pull dynamic kept me rooting for them both. This author made truly lovable characters who made me laugh, smile and even tear up at times.
This is a coming of age story in the truest sense that captures two lost souls finding themselves in music and each other. It’s not a tidy fairy tale with a HEA. There’s pain, there’s doubt, there’s beauty in the cracks, which is what makes it so real with hard-won lessons in self-worth and discovery. This book is a love letter to anyone who’s ever had to claw their way out of family baggage and into their own light, with a killer soundtrack to match.
Then there's the emotional aspect of it. Carla’s journey of figuring out who she is while wrestling with her inner chaos felt lived with the experience dominating the pages. The mixed-tape vibes of the novel also pulled me with each song choice, a coping mechanism for drowning out our thoughts with our favorite bands. It’s a beautifully messy portrait, revealing emotional scars, and I couldn’t put it down.
Then there’s the “more than friendship” arc with Pete, which had me nodding along with every blurry line and unspoken feeling. Anyone who’s ever had that one friend where you’re not sure if it’s just late-night talks or something deeper will definitely feel seen here. Their connection is tender and confusing in the best way. Pete’s arc is also sweet, watching him stumble through his own lostness as he acknowledges who he is, which I LOVED this angle and hope the author fleshes out in the sequel. But here, he proves he's a true friend to Carla and their push-pull dynamic kept me rooting for them both. This author made truly lovable characters who made me laugh, smile and even tear up at times.
This is a coming of age story in the truest sense that captures two lost souls finding themselves in music and each other. It’s not a tidy fairy tale with a HEA. There’s pain, there’s doubt, there’s beauty in the cracks, which is what makes it so real with hard-won lessons in self-worth and discovery. This book is a love letter to anyone who’s ever had to claw their way out of family baggage and into their own light, with a killer soundtrack to match.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 59 reviews