Review: Handicap This by Thomas Whitney
My rating: 4 of 5 stars
So, I started this book having no idea what to expect. If I’m being honest, I dove into this just solely based on the title and nothing else. I’ll explain why in a moment. Because this book is in an entirely different genre than what I am used to reviewing, I am also going to structure this review a bit differently than what I usually do. I still want to use sections, but I don’t expect there to be as many as usual. I am also forgoing the summary because, since it’s not fiction, there isn’t a plot to recap here before going into thoughts.
Anyway, let’s get into it!
Thoughts
So, like I said earlier, I looked into this based on the title. This is because (and I have never confessed this here, but I will now for the sake of this review) I am physically disabled, so immediately I was intrigued. I went into this hoping for some sort of story about a disabled individual and – while that is not what I got – I don’t think what is here is bad at all!
Whitney has a solid guide to life here with some seriously good advice. I want to break down what we’ve got here in these sections in order to explain where the work’s strengths and weaknesses are. Let’s break this down a little further.
Humor
I don’t really know how to explain the humor in this book. I can only really describe it as dark and witty. One of the things that sticks out about this book is how Whitney will title certain chapters, such as one title in which he compares life to rocky road ice cream, or another referencing Agatha Christie in a question. These titles intrigued me and made me want to read on in the chapter. Whitney’s wit and sense of humor is the most fun part of this book, and he uses it freely throughout the narrative to provide the reader with something to smile about, even if the information he’s relaying is not the most uplifting.
I think what makes that fun is he knows he’s not always relaying uplifting information, so one of the messages he tries so hard to convey is that humor will carry us through life, through the good and the bad. He doesn’t shy away from how life is not always going to be sunshine and roses, but he gives the reader tools for dealing with that through humor.
His tone throughout the book is kind of matter of fact, but he still retains the ability to make the reader laugh with that exact tone. Like he would quote a piece of research and then follow it up with some witty and humorous remark that acknowledges that the reader could, without his humor to bring us back to the present narrative he’s presenting, get lost in the research alone.
Tone
Like I said in that last paragraph, Whitney has a matter-of-fact tone when presenting research and talking about certain things that happened in his life. The thing with that is, he will often follow it up with a little dark humor to keep the reader engaged.
This works because – without that humor – there is a risk that the work would turn out very dry without it, and he is presenting this work to the general public, so he would need to keep it on terms that can be easy to engage with and understand. If he were presenting an article or research paper to publish in a scientific journal, then he can use all the scientific jargon he wants because that audience would better understand what he’s conveying there. Here, he needs to keep it on terms that the general public can get behind.
Research
I really like that Whitney isn’t just saying these things – he is backing them up with research, experiments, well-known documented facts. Like I said, it’s great that he has humor here because that makes it fun – but that fun means nothing if he doesn’t back up what he says.
All that said, there were moments where he was using so much research, backing up what he was saying with so many documented works by scientists and other researchers, that I would sometimes get lost in what he was saying.
To solve that, I think he could have really balanced it out with more personal experiences and/or events. Forget the humor for a second. Connect it more to himself and/or the people reading so that they get what he’s saying. When you sit down to read an academic journal, you expect certain jargon that will probably go over a layperson’s head because they have less experience reading material like that, and that is why I am saying connect it to something the reader can relate to. It helps get the point across and you don’t lose the reader’s attention.
Writing
Whitney’s writing is particularly interesting for a nonfictional life guide. I’d honestly read any nonfiction he writes because he has such flair and zest with what he’s working with that it’s fun to go into. He starts out with a basic idea and builds upon that throughout the book, and he does so by approaching each subject with care, humor, and a unique voice that is easy to get behind.
I think that’s the biggest thing. His voice is intriguing to follow, and it makes you want to know more, even if he’s talking about someone else’s research. His writing starts in the personal areas and then branches out, but he does so with a style that is fun to read. He has a voice that is funny, and he has that sense of dark humor that makes the entire book enjoyable. I would say my favorite chapter is the one where he talks about how it’s crucial to get a hobby, because throughout said chapter you can hear the passion in his writing – this is big for him, you have to listen to what he has to say – and it’s intriguing to follow because of that!
Conclusion
So, this was something very different from what I usually cover. That said, I really enjoyed it! Whitney’s advice is spot-on and the research he uses to back up what he’s saying is also perfect for the situation.
I honestly think everyone needs to read this book at least once in their life. Far too many people (including myself – I won’t lie) go throughout life too seriously, and his advice and humor provided a serious wakeup call for me. One day, I’ll learn not to take life too seriously. Until then, I’ll leave you with this: the message is powerful, and will leave you looking for ways to change your own life for the better!