9/30/24 I loved how utterly amazing FL was - a true actual badass. So skilled! So stalwart! She really endured a lot more than so many others could - not just FLs but men - and MLs too. Was a smidgen frustrated by how long it took her to get together with ML, though I get with the super awkward relationship it wouldn't and couldn't be easy. [And then they were kinda together unofficially though not acknowledged or even realized by her... and then they finally WERE together, but only secretly...] and wow did I ... like I don't even want to say "I hated ML's mom" cuz she doesn't even deserve my hate. But I do scorn her. DEEPLY. Was glad to see the TAE actually did basically redeem himself. Interesting ending - felt it kinda petered a bit ... though it was nice to see mostly people who deserved punishments got them. [Still think it was WTF for ML to be beaten so badly at the end and then just glossed over like bloop he's okay now!]
Just... :\ I dunno - I get the ending, but didn't love it. Solid B read though.
And again - sadly can't rec it cuz the "translating"/the site is just insultingly "edited" MTL. *sigh*
~*~*~*~ Fight For Love
1 FL is Chu Yu … and Gu Chu Sheng is her trash ass ex 💪💯 “Gu Chu Sheng,” she gasped, speaking softly, “If I were to be reborn, I wish to have no more entanglements with you!” (Sigh. I hate she - well her bitch ass sister says everything was her choice… pushed by the bitch!)
Ugh c2 and it’s already word salad 😡 (talking about the shit “translation.”) Ohhh shit 🙊🙊🙊 - I literally put my fist to my mouth. GCS CAME BACK TOO?!?! … HOW?!?! Guy. She already gave you 12 years. Leave her TF alone. Fuuuck “The longer she was dead, the more obsessed and deep his feelings for her became. Until he died under Wei Yun’s sword, only then did he feel released. When he woke up, he had returned to his seventeen-year-old self. He was overjoyed. How wonderful. He opened his eyes, his eyebrows curving into a smile. He could see the living, breathing Chu Yu again. This time… He would accompany her well.” I literally recoiled from my screen 😖
C4 I LOVE IT! She chased after him! 💪💯 (tho mad he left without saying anything to her…)
C7 😩😩😩 omfg I can’t with these flashbacks too many too tragic!!!
C9 😬 yikes - so GCS is going to be A Problem. An actual yandere not a cute romance one
C11 God. Damn. “What about you?” Liu Xueyang came to her senses, “What will you do if you stay here?” “I’ll stay here, waiting for the Wei family’s sons to return,” Chu Yu said firmly. “If they return safely, I’ll welcome them home. If they return in coffins, I’ll arrange their funerals. If they’re wrongfully imprisoned, I’ll work tirelessly to save them. If their heads are displayed at the city gate, I’ll collect their remains for burial.” Chu Yu’s voice was calm as she listed all possible outcomes, good and bad. She looked at Liu Xueyang and, amid the other’s shocked expression, calmly said, “As a woman of the Wei family, I live and die with the Wei family.”” That idiot GCS really dropped the ball with the best - THE BEST woman
Fuck c12 so they did all die (again). Even as she expected. … so who is ML?! Don’t tell me it’s her younger BIL the sole survivor? OR IS IT?!
13 Jiang Chun the 2nd master’s wife is a good one too. Her recounting her wedding day & crying made me tear up
C17 seriously just… damn she’s impressive getting the crowd (and holy hell that evil fuckhead smashing coffins)
😿 21 her bleeding back
24 holy shit she’s been kneeling for four days - what about her injuries? (Also glad she yelled at 7 for writing that divorce letter for her to her mom. JFC her ES2 is evil)
26(?) oof Wei Yun’s mourning in the carriage made me tear up. Def 26 - oh - so FL liked GCS her last life (both lives?) cuz he saved her in a battle when she was 12 & he 14
27 oof he’s dreaming… but it’s how/of the last
28 cried again at the eulogy & FL looking at her husband. Her doing the spear dance for 7 … is he … attracted to her? (Him thinking he’d be ruling to die in her service…) Liked the woman drank their sorrows & had a party. Can’t blame them for wanting “divorces” & like the MIL for telling 7 he has to pick good future husbands for FL & his 2nd SIL. lol to him putting on the fake sickly look to go to the palace. Fuck that emperor and destroy that shitbag crown prince (CP) and all his ilk
32 that fucking cunt sister. But yay her new SIL & BIL have her back & immediately see how she’s suffered.
36 O.o didn’t realize Chu LinYang was so… decisive. Yikes. But I don’t think this will stop ES2 in any way. Heh I kinda love FL has this unhinged brother. “If you slander her I’ll cut out your tongue.”
40 lol her finding GCS & being taken aback by his change in attitude
Huh 41 both surprised and not GCS tells FL he wants her to be with him
42 wow that idiot was in part awful to her in the first life cuz he thought she didn’t really love him? Well it’s mostly cuz you ruined it. Glad she was able to say she liked him cuz the first meeting. I’d forgotten she did kinda cultivate a relationship with her husband through letters. (Also her oldest brother was never gentle to her?!)
43 Wei Yun is so badass! Yay assassination attempt failed!
44 ok WY has definitely caught feelings… is he ML though?! Cuz how do they get over FL technically being his SIL?!
Oof ““Intelligence and background are not the most important things. How to be a person is the fundamental thing that determines one’s fate throughout life.” Wei Yun didn’t speak. His gaze fell on Chu Yu’s fingertip, “Then, in sister-in-law’s opinion, how should one be a person?” “Without shame before others, without shame before oneself,” Chu Yu leaned back against the pillar and sighed, “Not hurting others is the bottom line of being a person. But not hurting yourself is the bottom line of being yourself.””
49 oof so slightly drunk her basically just told GCS she was reborn - but she doesn’t know he was too.
50 aww FL feels safe with WY. Glad she was finally able to cry. lol to WY going to beat up GCS
51 Omg 😹☠️❤️ ML is literally herding cats for FL. Kittens.
54 Who the hell is Xue HanMei/was he in the past? And too bad he doesn’t believe the princess royal loves him
57 ah ok WY has finally kinda realized he has feelings but is suppressing them
58 omfg the shit emperor kidnapped WY’s mom
59 what?! FL wants to go to battle?! Isn’t that to die?! And WTF is up with Fenglin City?! And that cunt emperor still protecting Yao You or whatever
61 wtf kind of city ON A MOUNTAIN doesn’t store food. Also omfg they need to get rid of that emperor ASAP. Fucking evil idiot.
63 oh no he finally realized he loves her but will bury all that deep. Bleh. At least they got the gunpowder and hopefully WY’s plan works
64 oh. Idiot emperor still thought YY was good. Which almost is worse. I wonder if he really will kill the crown prince & YY though 🤷🏻♀️
65 Ah. The princess royal’s favorite companion is Zhao Yue the son of the prince who rebelled - that GCS gave up
67 omg WY saying maybe he can even wait for SIL to save him - their hearts are so aligned ❤️
69 Ahhh WHAT KIND OF LOVE?! “She saved him out of love, admiration, responsibility, and a certain recklessness towards life and death that came from her rebirth.” Nooo WY you misunderstand! (I hope) FL won’t fall for GCS again!
70 oof their moment by the campfire
🙄 71 this is just stupid though - WHERE ARE ALL THEIR PEOPLE?! Like I get the author wants them to have alone time but 🙄
77 Hm ML might be the smartest character ever - liking someone is fine & that’s your business. But expecting something in return or even demanding it - that is wrong, and [almost disgusting]. Smart boy ❤️ Ahhh she said this is the happiest she’s been in a long long time watching the lanterns & he kissed her - giving her a lot of time to reject him and she didn’t! 💪💯
78 gawddammit she thinks it was a drunken dream Heh. WY confident FL won’t fall in someone else before he makes his move because he’s by her side 😄💯❤️😹💯 Omg Wei Xia & Wei Qiu are so badass too 💯
Damn 81 FL’s brother would pick her if the Wei family rebels 💪💯
83 hm so how long will WY & GCS’s pause of pursuit be?
86 oh wow so the princess royal never had sex eyes ZY … told him she liked him 3 years ago & never touched anyone since… but he never believed her. And she even chose her consort back in the day cuz he looked like ZY. But now that ZY has imprisoned her daughter & killed her brother… welp. She still loves him but I think hates him more. Especially since he’s basically imprisoned her in the harem and is (raping) her…
88 rnnggghh he did need that wake up call but argh did FL take it as a rejection? 😖 (yes). I almost want her to be like “well ok that’s done then” to him too. 4 year time jump …
89 ugh 2ndSIL JC is trying to match make FL with GCS. Also… will he still be so gentle if/when he truly realizes she’s rejecting him?
90 hm so WY has marked “One thousand one hundred and thirty-two days.” he still misses her. Glad he’s steadfast but… guy don’t assume the girl will just wait. Ugh I wish she had a third suitor.
93 man I felt it was reckless for FL to let the Wangs know she was a) involved b) saved them - and uh, the assassins does that mean the emperor knows it was her?! Heh to her chance meeting with ML
94 This is just silly though - his voice is the same so even masked she should still know him. Though him pretending to be his advisor - serves him right if she falls for that identity
98 “… in this world, no one but yourself can be your light. Not a husband, not a child. Only dreams and passion can stay with you throughout life.” And 😬😖 GCS is starting to act violent against her - or at least cornering her & grabbing her, kissing her against her will
Ahhhh 99 “A thousand hardships, ten thousand hardships, none compare to the hardship of longing for you.” Our romantic boy ❤️💯 (Heh and FL finally ~figured out ML was impersonating the advisor)
Fuuuck 100 Wang declared himself King so GCS wants WY to deal with it. Asshole. I hope FL goes to the frontline so GCS eats his liver in regret
Ooo 101 FL finally maybe realized she likes WY? Sexy dream! But 😖 she feels she has to bury it. And stupidly thinks he’ll marry the princess. This over reliance on past life - not knowing the actual details - is so annoying.
102 😩😩😩 oh WY. I’m mad at FL for agreeing to GCS so easily. Idiot REALLY thinks he’s going to respect her? Idiot.
103 “When Gu Chusheng threatened her, it wasn’t that she had no way out. It was just that when faced with these feelings, she suddenly felt afraid. She wanted to marry someone who made her feel safe, someone she would never fall for, always maintaining rationality and distance, to avoid reaching a point of mutual disgust.” 😒😡 I get it but I’m so annoyed. GCS just caught her in a weak moment Ahhhh WY is SO smart & capable & knows her so well!! Hopefully this gets her to reject GCS
104 how does she not realize GCS was reborn too. Although that still wouldn’t explain the obsession I guess considering how shitty he was to her in the last life & the obsession happened after he killed her from abuse then neglect. And I’m mad she hasn’t thrown him marrying her sister in his face. Ugh but again - doesn’t know he was rebirthed too
Omg 😹 106 “Song Shilan put down the letter in his hand and said gently, “Tell the Second Madam, if she’s willing to marry me, I’ll go through fire and water for the Wei family. If she’s not willing…” “What if she’s not willing?” Song Shilan thought for a moment, then laughed. “What a pity it would be to miss out on such a good man as myself.””
107 that despicable emperor drugging FL
😱 108 they had sex! Although the next morning him bringing her the sword his brother gave him & telling her she can kill him or marry him was pretty boss
114 all grievances aired!
115 … will GCS actually let go now?
116 ah the assassins were arranged by ML as was his shoulder injury. lol I know it won’t be but wish FL would somehow do a sexy dance for him for his birthday 😜💯
123 wait he named himself for her? Wei HuaiYu?!
124 😻😻😻 “Yu’er,” he held her hand, his expression solemn, “There’s nothing in this world I can’t resolve. If being by my side means you must endure such great humiliation, then I am incompetent. Such an incompetent man,” he paused, then continued with great difficulty, “wouldn’t be worth keeping.” Omg 😹😹😹☠️☠️☠️💯💯💯 the princess wanting to take FL away. Unexpected GL! But oof 😿 “In this back chamber, she had slowly become someone she didn’t even like anymore.”
Awww “Next time you’re angry, don’t bear it alone. Tell me. Otherwise, I might survive the battlefield only to be angered to death by you at home.”
126 oh my heart “He embraced her, felt her, and in that moment, he suddenly realized that even if she said she wanted to leave right now, he wouldn’t be afraid. Because he knew that at that moment, Chu Yu truly loved him.” - glad she realizes she’s been unfair to him & he’s been suffering And yay start over sex!
127 WY is so smart “If you can’t become the person she likes, at least don’t become someone she dislikes.” I really hope this means GCS has let go & will work to make a better world
132 “Rules that make life better are called etiquette. Rules that make life worse are called dogma. One word’s difference, but worlds apart.” Also 😹☠️ ML’s mom might be his biggest pig teammate
134 Uhoh the mom finally has an inkling. And lololol to FL’s new suitor Yan YunLang is a mess.
😡 136 I do not like his mom. Also holy hell disrupting his battle plans AYFKM
137 Oof I both love and hate this “”No one dictates who should love whom for a lifetime,” Chu Yu said calmly. “If two people were beautiful together while they were together, that’s enough.”” Fuuuuuck why did that all feel like a breakup
139 dammit I was right. She left as he’s coming back. ML’s bitch ass mom never should’ve searched her room. I’m glad FL left though. The Wei family never has been good outside of ML
140 I’m not surprised yet utterly disgusted his mom had him beaten. I hate her. Only she doesn’t even deserve my hate. Just my scorn and disgust.
141 holy fucking shit he lashed himself 99 times. His mom makes me want to throw up . I’m literally about to throw up. Swallowing saliva. (I mean in part some of that is the caramel apple bundtlet I just pounded. But more it’s her that trash ass bitch.)
Aww fuck. 142 FL got caught in a mudslide. Bitch you set your plan too late! Ugh. Though I’m convinced she’s alive cuz she’s FL!
143 not sure how I feel about GCS “rescuing” her but effectively getting rescued by her instead
144 … maybe … GCS can become emperor? And a good one? Anyway love ML rushed to find FL and of course did ❤️
152 and GCS is now a daddy via tragic means. I think had he not been so exhausted he would’ve known the lady would kill herself it was so obvious
😭😭😭 155 smart FL - and loyal rushing back to save the Wei family & giving herself up as a hostage
159 the emperor is insane and a monster. As are people who obey his orders. Spreading plague and selling the country just for a temper tantrum
161 (final chapter P1) omfg FINALLY JC goes to see Song ShiLan
Hated 162 P2 - as if I’m supposed to feel sympathy for that shit emperor. Oh you were bullied as a kid so you can burn the world down? So many other people had pasts just as tragic but didn’t act like you
163 (p3) ““Anyone can bow, but not you. Anyone can betray the country, but not you.” “Wei Yun,” Gu Chusheng’s voice held a smile, “I’ll bear this infamy for all time.” Wei Yun said nothing, just smiled gently: “Didn’t you always want to leave with her? You’re giving up your two-lifetime dream just like that?” “In one’s life,” Gu Chusheng said with some resignation, “It’s not just about love. I have loved her,” the wind scattered his voice in the air, “This life, I have no regrets.” To have loved such a good person, this life has no regrets. Many people go through life without ever experiencing true love even once.”
164 (p4) was so pissed the crowd was so extreme to ML. Glad he seems healed
165 extra 1 birth!
Extra 2 166 I’m pissed the baby will be surnamed Zhao but… at least Zhao Shun will O.o call ML dad But how do they explain him looking like ML 🫠
Didn’t read extra 3 167 cuz fuck that trash ass guy Zhao Yue I don’t care about his past
168 extra 4 Song ShiLan you devoted guy ❤️ “In the beginning and the end, it was always you.”
169 extra 5 omfg I didn’t realize Chu Yu & Chu Jin were twins. Meh. Whatever GCS. At least he wasn’t entirely awful the second life
Extra 6 (split into 2 parts so 170-171?) cute Wei QQ & Qin ShiLang ❤️
Extra 7 172 meh chapter on Chu LinYang imo - don’t care about his wife really, wish it had been nice stuff about him & FL
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
This has all the tropes I like but it's a bit too draggy. The pairing is the female lead Chu Yu, with a heroic and strong personality, and the male lead Wei Yun, a black bellied introverted and devoted character. Chu Yu starts the story being reborn and marries into the Wei family to the eldest Wei son, older brother of Wei Yun. Tragedy strikes and all the Wei men except for Wei Yun die, even Chu Yu's husband.
The first half revolves around wars and politicking as Chu Yu and Wei Yun grow to mutually depend on and support each other as they struggle through this difficult time and try to figure out the cruel strategist behind the tragedy. They're both very young, around 14-15. Chu Yu mainly sees Wei Yun as a younger brother, while Wei Yun's feelings gradually morph into romance and yearning. The two then separated for 4 years as Wei Yun was sent to fight an enemy state. He also needed to mature and be more independent of Chu Yu.
The second half revolves around the two building a relationship as adults and equals. The two reunite after 4 years and Wei Yun is now certain in his romantic feelings and wants to pursue Chu Yu, but she is too afraid of being hurt to love. The author's excellent skill at capturing emotions and psyches comes in here as the two characters emotional progression and changes are very consistent with their personalities and histories, and all their actions make sense. She touches on the difference between dependency and trust, familial love and romantic love, love and lust. These are all the feelings and ideas our two leads learn to distinguish as they mature emotionally to understand their true feelings towards each other.
But the pace of the novel is really slow. The romance is slow as a glacier and some scenes and side plots could have seriously been cut without affecting the story. I also felt that the author wrote herself into a corner with Chu Yu's absolute refusal to face her true feelings for Wei Yue, so much so that the author had to write a 'lust drug' plot point to force Chu Yu to be with Wei Yun (or at least that's how I interpret it).
In her other book, 长风渡, most of the couples exemplified the theme of 'finding happiness and true love in marriage' (even if some of them died). In this novel, almost every couple exemplified 求之不得/seeking and yearning but unable to find happiness. (I LOVE the Grand Princess in this one. Her storyline with Zhao Yue is just so tragic 😭 happy AU please...)
Anyway, this novel is quite 狗血/melodramatic but not the type of melodrama I usually like... sadly.
220725 p82 1. Nhân thiết tốt Nhân thiết được viết rất tốt, cực kỳ tốt: lớp lang, chu đáo, có trước có sau.
Đọc đến đoạn Văn Cố võ Vệ của Mặc Thư Bạch, tim mình run lên vì hào hứng. Là một người học viết, mình liền so sánh với một thiết lập tương tự ở một tác phẩm trước đây mình đọc: Gian thần chi muội.
Tuy GTCM mình hay đọc lại để giải trí “ăn liền” cũng nhiều, nhưng rõ ràng GTCM không sâu sắc bằng SHC.
Lý Duy Nguyên và Thuần Vu Kỳ (nam chính và thứ của GTCM) cũng được mô tả là Hữu và Tả tướng ngang tài ngang sức của triều đình. Nhưng dường như chỉ nói xuông, chỉ trên bề mặt.
Còn Mặc Thư Bạch làm cách nào không rõ, nhưng đặc điểm, phẩm chất trực tiếp, và ngay cả những thứ vô hình như xu hướng hành động, cái “vibe” của từng nhân vật được đắp nặn rõ ràng trong tiềm thức của người đọc.
2. story engine siêu mạnh
Đối với mình, story engine, 1 là tò mò, từ lúc đọc văn án, không biết sau này mối tình chị dâu em chồng sẽ được tháo gỡ như thế nào trong bối cảnh đạo đức của xã hội thời bấy giờ.
Sau này khi đọc được vài chương rồi, động cơ thứ 2 của mình là mong chờ khúc gặp lại của Cố Sở Sinh và Sở Du.
Truyện được viết theo góc nhìn của Sở Du, nên đôi khi mình cảm thấy sự việc vẫn chủ quan và cảm tính mơ hồ lắm. Ví dụ, đối với Sở Cẩm và CSS là hai người lầm lỗi với nàng đời trước, nhiều lúc SD dùng những tính từ tiêu cực như “tâm cơ” hay “hung ác”… nhưng cho mình cảm giác mơ hồ. Mình không có đủ chứng cứ để kết luận, “ác” đến mức nào, “tồi” đến mức nào. Tuy truyện có kể về các việc làm “không đúng” của CSS và Sở Cẩm, nhưng mình luôn cảm thấy không toàn vẹn, không khách quan.
Vì vậy mình luôn mong chờ pov của CSS, ngoài việc xem CSS bị “ngược” ntn thì mình cũng quan tâm đến lý giải tâm lý của nhân vật.
240725 Chương 43, 44 1. thích nhân vật Cố Sở Sinh vô cùng.
Từ các chương ba mươi mấy là đã cảm giác thích nhân vật của CSS còn hơn là nhân vật của Vệ Uẩn, mà đến chương này là được confirmed, được xác định rõ ràng hơn trong mình. Bởi vì nhân vật này có nội tâm, diễn biến và động cơ tâm lý phức tạp, đa chiều. Bởi vì đen không thuần đen, trắng không thuần trắng. Bởi vì Mặc Thư Bạch làm người đọc đúng là phải thừa nhận tài cán của người này, tuy có thể đối với nhân vật trung tâm, là một người không tốt.
Đọc truyện lần đầu hứng thú với một thằng ex tồi hơn là nam chính.
2. Miêu tả tâm lý của hai bên, của cả nữ chính Sở Du và Cố SS siêu tốt, siêu hợp lý
Đọc khúc hai anh chị nói chuyện với nhau lần đầu tiên sau trọng sinh Cảm giác như tôi đang nghe my divorced parents tâm sự giãi bày vậy há há há
Currently reading mà có thể cho 5 sao rồi, thật may mắn sau bao nhiêu cuốn không hay quyết định đọc cuốn này.
------- tạm drop ngày 280725 (ch 65) do khúc chiến sự nặng nề và nhàm chán. Tuyến tình cảm của Vệ Uẩn thấy cũng hơi khiên cưỡng và bi luỵ nha (???)