As Dan Abnett states on the back cover of this book’s sequel, Matthew Farrer is Black Library’s secret weapon. In my experience he's something of a cult concern compared to the very popular Aaron Dembski-Bowden or Dan Abnett, or very prolific authors like Guy Haley. BL has some gifted authors for sure, some who are great at pulp and some who are just great, but I think Farrer might be the most underrated, he's the best writer on their roster with the least recognition. Some find his style impenetrable, his books too wordy or long-winded – but those of us who are fans eagerly await any new book or short story from one of the masters of the Dark Millennium.
Farrer's ‘Urdesh’ story has a messy genesis and started being teased a long, long time ago, post-‘Salvation’s Reach’ I think. If I recall right it was initially sold as a ‘Space Marine Battles’ type book, more combat focused than Farrer’s books tended to be. It, very clearly, was meant to be a ‘prequel’ story or perhaps a ‘parallel’ to the Gaunt’s Ghosts novel ‘The Warmaster’, a story which was also about the battle for Urdesh. ‘The Warmaster’ was a famously delayed book, but ‘Urdesh’ was even more so. Somewhat unsurprisingly, completion didn’t mesh up neatly between the two authors and so the ‘Urdesh’ novels came out in 2021, four years after ‘The Warmaster’ was published and two years after ‘The Warmaster’ got a sequel and moved the Ghosts’ storyline along yet further. In that sequel, ‘Anarch’, a whole group of characters show up near the end who are very clearly fresh from the events that happened in Farrer’s book.
If you don’t mind re-reading those Gaunt books – and what GG fan could object to revisiting those two great novels? – ‘Urdesh’ is a fantastic companion piece, giving us a wider view of the nasty, grinding Urdesh fight than even Dan was able to give in his stories and lengthy background writing. More even than that, though, Farrer’s book is most clearly is a sequel to ‘Brothers of the Snake’, Abnett’s short story cycle about the Iron Snakes Space Marine Chapter and in particular one battle-brother Priad (now a Captain). The primary focus of ‘The Serpent and the Saint’ is an account of the four squads of Iron Snakes fighting across this area of Urdesh, paying particular attention to the famed Damocles Squad who now act as Saint Sabbat’s honour guard. Taking over from Dan as the custodian of the Snakes’ story, Farrer writes with respect and reverence for the established Iron Snakes lore without making it feel like simply a re-tread or fanfic; it’s a deepening and a progression of these characters we’ve already grown to love and the culture of their Chapter. I strongly recommend re-reading ‘Brothers of the Snake’ as well before you jump into this new one. (It’s also a sequel of sorts to ‘Titanicus’, but with less emphasis on that – still, you might want to read ‘Titanicus’ before ‘Urdesh’ as well!)
The structure of this one is a little ragged, and it does take a while to get moving I think. Once Farrer has thrown his characters into combat, though, it becomes utterly gripping, and then when you see how well he does the more quiet post-battle bits you wonder how you could’ve ever found the beginning parts boring. (I do just think it takes some time to acclimatise to the prose and the characters.) Farrer’s writing here can be uneven – at it’s best it’s exceptional. Sometimes he gets too caught up in describing particular architecture or trying to communicate the lay of the land setting the scene for a particular battle, and that doesn’t always work; it’s well done but the pace isn’t always right, I guess I’d say. You perhaps don’t get the sense of place that some of the other BL authors can assuredly give quickly by just hitting those key elements of 40K vocabulary, but I actually really admire Farrer for staying away from those and trying to be more original.
What you do get are characters that feel real, living and breathing in ways that sometimes are totally foreign to Black Library books. And while it’s arguable that giving a character / world-building genius like Farrer a book that often feels like it’s primarily battles is a waste, he is very good at the conflict stuff here, enough that this book is nowhere near the uncomplicated 'bolter porn' you might worry would be a waste of his talent.
‘The Serpent and the Saint’ cuts out rather abruptly, its story half-finished, and when I realised it was just book 1 of 2 I surely had some panic about waiting another several years for the concluding volume. Luckily the next one came out a few months later and I can reassure you it’s up to as just a high standard as the first, if not better.
7.5/10