I rarely give out bad reviews. However, as this is listed as a “children’s graphic novel” and, after reading this, it raises a lot of red flags for me as a student librarian.
I want to begin by saying I actually like the art style, its vibrant and fun therefore perfect for kids. For the Australian’s out there, it’s very reminiscent of old ABC3 cartoons. Sadly, my positives end there.
I’ll leave the general consensus of the plot to the other reviewers, as I’ll be focusing on why this is harmful to kids and issues with the triggering content shown in this book.
Instead of creating fun complex characters, it’s all stereotypes. I thought we got past as a society the use of: asian nerd, fat kid who’s whole identity is food, and angry POC characters?! Kids don’t need to read versions of themselves being put into boxes; it does nothing but cause identity issues and continues harmful stigma within future generations.
And the bully? Switches up between calling the others “chickens” and “nerds” to using really outdated and harmful language, including slurs. I understand bullies are supposed to be mean, but it just ends up feeling like the author is trying to incorporate his ableist and fatphobic views. But, it’s okay, right? Because the bully (quite graphically for a “children’s” book) gets beat by his dad and, therefore, it’s okay and he’s just misunderstood and perpetuating the cycle of abuse on unknowingly of the consequences.
This is not a book I would recommend for my library. In fact, I would argue for it to be weeded due to its capacity for harm towards young children and their already fragile self esteem. I’m really disappointed in the use of negative language for seemingly no genuine reason and the inclusion of tired, harmful stereotypes. We can tell effective stories about bullies and their motivations without becoming bullies ourselves.
I received this as an E-ARC from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.