Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Hades & Persephone #3

The Good Counselor

Rate this book
One who is twice woven, cannot remain your own. Two the ether bound, who shines the torch in darkness. Three the blessed harbinger who reaps the reaper’s heart.

Nearly a century has passed since Hades and Persephone’s children were foretold, but their efforts to conceive have been in vain. A secret rite on Samothrace conducted by the gifted hymnist, Orpheus, might finally bend the will of the Fates and give the King and Queen of the Underworld everything they have ever dreamed of, or pave a path of unimaginable suffering.

Hades and Persephone’s sway over the mortals has only grown, drawing the covetous attention of the Olympian gods. When a hastily made oath, a silver lyre, and the returning restless dead put the gods below at odds with Olympus, it could shatter the peace that has existed between the realms since the Titanomachy.

The Good Counselor continues the erotic Underworld romance that began with Rachel Alexander’s highly-acclaimed novel, Receiver of Many.

558 pages, Kindle Edition

Published March 22, 2022

70 people are currently reading
1218 people want to read

About the author

Rachel Alexander

10 books500 followers
Rachel Alexander has been a resident of California all her life and finished her first novel at age 16. She co-wrote a play that won awards from Bill Moyers of PBS and the University of Southern California. She received her Bachelor of Arts degree in English Literature and Literary Criticism with an emphasis on creative writing.

When not writing, Rachel can often be found sewing corsets, overstocking her spice cabinet, and petting chickens. She is married and lives in Half Moon Bay, CA with her wonderful husband/editor and their son, William.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
331 (57%)
4 stars
151 (26%)
3 stars
79 (13%)
2 stars
9 (1%)
1 star
3 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 72 reviews
Profile Image for Tatiana.
4 reviews
April 22, 2025
I normally don't write reviews, but for this book and this series I had to.
This book was EVERYTHING I had been waiting for. The amount of different emotions this book put me through, I don't even know what I'm going to do now! Aidon and Persephone are amazing as always in their relationship, but I liked how this book opened up the world in mythology more and introduced us to more characters. I can't wait to read the next book, it feels like it'll just keep getting better and better.
Profile Image for ✦ Rox ☽.
325 reviews61 followers
March 28, 2022
A powerful, heart wrenching story of love, loss and inescapable fate.

I have known from before I even opened this book that it would be a wild, unpredicted ride and still it managed to find me unprepared.

The good counselor is a book whose main theme is loss and what that aching, gaping feeling does to everyone who experiences it. It wears different disguises with different people and its aftermath is a dangerous minefield ready to blow in your face in the worst possible moments. Gods, like humans, feel this emotion deeply and powerfully enough to risk the very balance of the universe.

In this 3rd book, Aidon (Hades) and Persephone’s marriage is the strongest it's ever been, the very soil from which life on earth thrives from, but despite the many reaches the King and Queen of the Underworld have they want something they were told (more or less) they could never get: a child. They tempt the wrath of powerful Olympian gods when a fertility rite led by Orpheus gets them so close to what they want.

There was a LOT of anger burning hot in my gut while reading everything unfold, a clenched-jaw quietness before everything broke loose. When Persephone said something along the lines of ‘nothing bad is going to happen’ I literally yelled at my kindle for her to shut the fuck up and not tempt the fates.

The tension was palpable from the very first page to the climax, keeping me in a nail-biting mindset that made me honestly afraid that Hades and Persephone could not recover from this horrific situation. For more than half of the book I was repeating my please let them be okay mantra.

While the first half of the book was a deadly avalanche building momentum, the second half of the book dealt with its aftershock. It was painful to read about these two main characters I love so much to deal with such complex suffering, but I really appreciated that they were deeply changed by the events (not only personally, but their entire philosophy and marriage).

My few qualms with this story:

a) the large new cast - they took A LOT of page time and although I understand WHY they needed to be there, my brain was close to frying itself. It’s Hades and Persephone’s story but it’s also Orpheus and Eurydice’s and a little bit of Zeus with Hera and let’s not forget fuckface Apollo and Hermes and of course Demeter with her loverboi and Zeus with his mistress…like I get it, it’s interesting but ultimately too much.

b) the conflict resolve - this one hurt in both Destroyer of Light and here. I dunno man, I was out for blood. When Athena had her girlboss speech I was so hyped up and ready to get that sweet, sweet revenge and then…nothing. I mean nothing *I* wanted. Like, I get it - the world would have literally ended if my wish was put in action, but I felt like the story didn’t offer me the possibility to bleed out all that accumulated throughout the story. I think it’s a missed opportunity to offer the reader - me, me, meee - some well-earned relief.

That said, I still love this story to bits. I’ve been waiting for this book for a year and it did not disappoint. I don't know what Rachel Alexander puts in her books but I am unable to stop once I start - not to mention that my hands are shaking at the end of each and every book. Talk about emotional rollercoaster!

Cannot wait for the next books to come out!!!!
Profile Image for Mari.
36 reviews2 followers
March 29, 2022
Aaaahhhhh

Orphic cosmogony but better! Hermes' ending gesture! An account of labor that doesn't quite leave me, a mother, rolling my eyes! I'm So Happy
Profile Image for Leah.
261 reviews49 followers
January 6, 2025
It took me an embarrassingly long time to figure out the first bit of the blurb is about the children and when I tell you I got all squeaky when I figured out the future Makaria & Thanatos ship, I’m not kidding. After everything he went through in Destroyer of Light and the changes since then… I’m so ready to see it unfold, my boy deserves to be happy with a girl who sees him and not as toxic as Eris.

But to the book. It was so so so good. I loved this series before, but you can tell there is serious improvement in this book, both in quality (more focused on POV, more balanced in plot, etc) and how it all expanded to a big Greek drama.

All the complaints that some people seemed to have with the first books that it was like fanfiction (which is, surprise, it was originally. and to be fair every retelling in any topic is fanfiction to some extent, so go home) didn't exist here. It was really well written, well researched and put together in such a unique, interesting and entertaining way that it was hard to put this book down.

These days there's an influx of baby plots and dealing with miscarriage in books, but most of them don't even come close to touch my strings. Not this book though. What they went through in the second half of the book had me so heartbroken and sad for H&P. They fought so long to have a family and it was heartbreaking to see it ripped away from them. But their love proved stronger and gave them another chance and I just can't wait to see the girls' journey as they grow up and embrace their roles in the cosmos. I'm so excited for Makaria and Thanatos and Melinoe becoming the chaotic beauty.
Profile Image for Hikami D..
251 reviews12 followers
June 1, 2022
The best book in this series yet! Absolutely adored all the eastereggs pointing towards different myths! You can also learn mythology from this book which is amazing although the line between real myth and retelling is blurry at times. Loved all about this book and devoured it in 3 days straight.

Proper review to follow!
Profile Image for madeline.
232 reviews2 followers
August 4, 2022
Easy 5/5, more like 10/5! a million stars!! I give up my life to this book and this whole series!! I want to live in the joy these books give me for the rest of my life.
23 reviews
June 17, 2022
I’m not a woman of religion but if I was, these books would be my bibles. Forever and always my favorites! This one made me big cry. At work, no less!
Profile Image for Kit.
215 reviews1 follower
March 21, 2022
I was lucky enough to get my copy a month early and have been biting my tongue this whole time, but now I can gush!

The third installment in an incredible series, The Good Counselor picks up several decades after Destroyer of Light, and proceeds to delve even deeper into the lore and myths we all know and love. Rachel Alexander proves time and again to be a master weaver when it comes to picking the threads of Greek mythology and intertwining it into a tapestry of a fulfilling story with the gods and goddesses. The time and dedication they put into research and details is only a part of what makes this series worth the read.

The promise of Hades and Persephone spice is most likely what draws a lot of people in at first, but we all stay for the well-developed relationships, the drama, and to see Persephone and Hades grow into their destinies as rulers of the Underworld. One of the best parts of it all is the petty politics of the gods, all the more illuminated with the POV of the Olympians.

As a big Greek mythology nerd that has been obsessed since middle school, knowing about the myths brought to light in this book had me stressed over and over again! No spoilers, but this book sometimes speared my heart over and over, but then kissed it better. The way old tales were retold here, how things came to be (sorry, I have to be vague!), just had me gripping The Good Counselor tighter and tighter with every turn of the page.

I absolutely cannot wait for The Ineffable Seeds!
Profile Image for Lily K.
31 reviews
February 28, 2022
I was lucky enough to get this book a month before it’s release date, so I will be VERY vague and brief in this review so there’s zero chance of spoilers.

I love this series the most of any books I have ever read, and this book did NOT disappoint. It ripped my heart out, broke my soul, then put me back together again. Rachel is an incredible author, and her characters and interpretations of the myths and gods/goddesses is spectacular. If you have read the first two, BUY THIS ONE NOW. If you haven’t, go buy the first two then come back for this one. There isn’t a star rating high enough for this series ♥️
Profile Image for Brittany Taft.
280 reviews365 followers
May 14, 2022
Sometimes… the book content is just not for the reader. I liked the previous ones in this series (when I read them many years ago) but as a uterus owner who has absolutely no interest in children and is admittedly pretty repulsed by the mere thought of it and can’t relate to the emotional struggles… this book being pretty much exclusively about fertility struggles, pregnancy, miscarriages, grief, marriage problems, etc etc… not my cup of tea. I understand why it was written but I am DEFINITELY not the intended audience.

Also, I have a particular ick about a certain masturbation scene in this because it’s so often an abuse/guilt tactic and I don’t think it was adequately handled/talked about afterwards. Never thought I’d be so put off by Hades but yeah. It was gross.

So I don’t know. I can’t say I enjoyed this book. Trying not to be very harsh about it either, but I don’t really know what else to say. Simply not for me on many, many levels. Not sure if I will continue this series after this one (assuming the author does write more)
Profile Image for Courtney Pantone .
145 reviews11 followers
May 5, 2022
GODDAMN I am unwell. This is such a good series, the world building is phenomenal compared to other Greek myth retellings. Like astronomically different. This entire book had me picking up my kindle every chance I had. I was literally loosing sleep over it. Sometimes I think I may read too many hades/Persephone Greek retellings because the stories start to mesh together but this series stands out. Again, it ACTUALLY has plot, and a fantastic one. I love how the author brings in other myths and I liked how much we got to hear from other characters!! The book may seem long but the pacing is absolutely chef's kiss because you don't even notice it. PLEASE tell me there is another one coming for us ??
Profile Image for Adélie.
339 reviews
March 28, 2022
Omg this book was just amazing! I loved it even more than the first two. I was absolutely blown away by this book. It was so brilliantly written. I can’t even find the words to express how much I enjoyed this book. I also loved the interactions between the various gods and goddesses. There were so many amazing scenes! Absolutely blown away!
Profile Image for ஸ∂dℓą.
37 reviews
April 19, 2022
Leer un retelling siempre es un reto ya que más o menos sabes el final pero no sabes como le hará el autor para explicar como los protas llegan a ese punto, y en el caso de la mitología griega es algo engañoso ya que hay más de una versión y eso le añade en toque más emocionante...
Pero Rachel Alexander es una diosa escribiendo en toooda la extensión de la palabra.
Despues de 6 años de Destroyer of the ligth, al fin tenemos el después de los hieros gamos que produjo Elysion...y la profecía que las fates le dijeron a Perséfone.
OMG! que hermoso libro!!! que puedo decir? Rache Alexander nunca decepciona..JAMAS!
Ella es excelente describiendo el spice y todas las explosiones emocionales de los protagonistas y es imposible no sentirse envuelto por todo.
Amé y disfrute todo el rito en Samotracea para encarnar a Zagreus: el temor de ambos de no solo ser reconocidos si no dañar a los mortales o ser engañados, recoger hierbas con formas fálicas.. y omg... cuando ella encuentra la madrágora.. se me hizo el corazón pasita....y la consumación! la manera tan devota y tierna de Aidon de cuidar y proteger la desnudez de su esposa.. y la manera tan salvaje de consumar el rito.....el es tan fucking perfecto! <3
Y cuando por fin llegaron las noticias de Zagreus encarnado..lo tierno de ambos, los miedos también pero la ternura de Aidon de tomarse el tiempo de hacer con sus propias manos la cuna de su hijo.
El libro tiene más background sobre como se relaciona Perséfone con otra diosas tales como Afrodita, Hestia, Anfitrite y la perra culera hipócrita, doble moral celosa de Hera; ésto con el fin de entender las motivaciones de ella y de Apolo para detener el nacimiento de Zagreus.
Zeus y Hera...QUE PUTO ASCO !! TAL PARA CUAL! al principio sentía mucha pena por ella, pero luego de ver lo bajo que cae ..y luego saber que Zeus siempre supo todo y simplemente uso a Hera y Apolo como pistola y bala para que hicieron lo que el no se atrevía por poco hombre... y ahí entiendes que son tal para cual...PAR DE BASURAS!
Pensé que afrodita realmente quería entablar una amistad sincera pero como todo, solo busca beneficiarse...
Ahora el pex llamada Orfeo y Eurídice ..... me encantó la pareja.. pero me cagaban las pinches canciones culeras que componía... del resto estuvo super bien como al final final... ellos terminan juntos.
Perséfone y Aidon...omfg.... que agobiante fue leer todo el show de perder al bebé... :(
Como cada uno lidiaba con el dolor, la pérdida..la desesperanza la cual cortó su vinculo y además casi les cuesta el matrimonio... La manera en la que se resolvió preservar el corazón de Zagreus y la única solución fue dárselo al pelele de Zeus y literal tener que renunciar a él.
Fue tan horrible leer el dolor, la rabia y desesperación de Perséfone al enterarse que la envenenaron culeramente y que además su esposo fue a sus espaldas para hacer negociaciones...
Al final el trato neta se quedo mega corto para lo que les quitaron...
Sin duda este libro fue la prueba de fuego para ambos: saber si realmente su amor es capas de resistir una vida eterna de ser solo 2 y perdonarse mutuamente ...y cuando al fin entendieron que su amor está mas allá de todo y se aceptaron uno al otro como en sus hieros gamos, las gemelas fueron concebidas sin ser buscadas..
Pensé que no veríamos el parto de ellas pero estoy super contenta que la autora avanzara el libro hasta ese punto y ahora tenemos nuevas incógnitas:¿Como harán para que Macaria y Melione crezcan y vivan sin ser notadas por los olímpicos? y ¿Hermes realmente se atará al underworld?
Ahora solo queda esperar al 4 libro The Ineffable Seeds..
Estoy contenta por que el libro fue tan hermoso..bello..tan bien escrito...
Fue el bálsamo perfecto para mi corazón roto después de leer el chasco de The War of the 2 queens...
Lo amé de principio a fin! <3

This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Mary West.
27 reviews
June 3, 2022
This was an amazing continuation of my favorite story. The growth you see in both Hades and Persephone as individuals as well as a couple is so refreshing and real. Also, Hera, Apollo, and others in the book still maintain their mythologically accurate traits. Overall, I’m so happy I preordered this.
Profile Image for Sasha Johnson.
Author 3 books14 followers
May 18, 2022
5 ⭐️'s and probably the best Hades and Persephone book/books I've read.
Profile Image for Miss Garceau.
117 reviews18 followers
April 30, 2022
My Favorite Hades/Persephone

This trilogy is beautifully written & extremely well researched. This story brought tears to my eyes & made my heart swell. This third installment introduces Orpheus & the devastation of miscarriage & trials of pregnancy. We get to see the Gods struggle at a level humans are all too familiar with & it is both heartbreaking & satisfying. I highly recommend this series to any lover of Greek Mythology. It will be a series I read over & over again! Check TW’s 18+ MA for adult themes
Profile Image for Becca.
483 reviews15 followers
January 2, 2023
A masterpiece in how to pick up and weave Greek mythology and create an interesting and fulfilling story of the Gods, Goddesses and Titans

I came for the Hades x Persephone spice and stayed for the absolute dedication to the research that has been put into this series, well developed relationships, drama and to see H&P grow in their relationship and their destiny

I am eager for book 4!
Profile Image for Taylor Ramsey.
375 reviews16 followers
May 11, 2022
K but this ending was legit the best. I loved this ending. The only reason why I gave it four instead of five is some of the language in the beginning of the book was cringey and I found myself with second hand embarrassment because of what characters said to each other 😂
Profile Image for Renee.
10 reviews2 followers
August 23, 2022
Best book out of the trilogy. Usually Hades and Persephone books are about how they meet and end up together and that’s it, not what happens after. These books describe their relationship with more depth and what they go through together.
Profile Image for Laura Vi.
1 review
April 20, 2022
can’t have enough of this Hades & Persephone

Just amazing, can not wait for what’s next. This is the most wonderful Hades and Persephone series I have ever read.
Profile Image for Erica Ragland.
248 reviews4 followers
May 4, 2022
Can’t enough about how this author weaves these stories together WITH major historical accuracy.

Can’t wait to see how the story continues!
Profile Image for Rebecca Augustine.
372 reviews2 followers
March 30, 2022
No. 3 in the latest Hades and Persephone Fanfic

If you don't mind excessive eroticism, you should enjoy the latest chapter in the saga of Persephone and Hades, their marital life, and how it contrasts with the Olympians. However, one thing is lacking to make their marital bliss complete. You guessed it--a child of their own! Will they be successful in attaining their dream? Or will their hopes be dashed--perhaps by an evil influence?
2 reviews
Read
March 22, 2022
Six pomegranate seeds worthy!

This book had me in tears of happiness and distraught. Rachel Alexander has done it again with a fabulous retelling of another mythology from ancient Greece. Filled with everything you could ask for - romance, angst, drama, fantasy, erotica, great characters, and more. This book, along with its previous two sisters, deserve to be recognized everywhere for being one of the best fiction, fantasy, and erotic series. Please check out Receiver of Many and Destroyer of Light so you can enjoy the latest in Hades and Persephone's story.
TW: This series is an erotic story and filled with many mature themes, so 18+ only. Read at your own caution.
Profile Image for Lilou82.
89 reviews1 follower
March 25, 2022
This 3rd book was so good! Full of pain but it was worth it. H&P relationship is tested in this one and it was good to see them find their way to each other.
The Olympians schemes reach to height of evilness and some of them got a little taste of what they rightfully deserved. Team chtonia is awesome as ever and now we have new players entering the game with the next generation. Can't wait to see how it will play out but i trust RA to continue to weave her story as beautifully as ever!
39 reviews
March 22, 2022
I don't have enough words to gush about this book!!! I ADORE this series!!! I LOVE how Rachel writes everything so perfectly. The feels are just ❤❤❤❤. I hate that I've read it so fast. I just can't seem to pace myself with these books😁😁. I just want this semester to be over so I can do a thorough reread. I've read many retellings of the Hades/Persephone myth but Rachel Alexander's is just THE ABSOLUTE BEST!!! Thank you so much for writing so awesomely and sharing your work, Rachel!!! You are one of my favorite authors!!!❤❤❤
Profile Image for Preet K.
308 reviews5 followers
March 24, 2022
Rachel Alexander has done it again. A fantastic story filled with mythos and a well-cast of characters that leave you wanting more. I laughed and cried and felt the emotions the characters themselves went through. It takes true talent for an author to balance so many characters and myths and include foreshadowing of all the things to come. I loved that the tonal quality of the work stayed the same and the ending scene had me gasping. Absolutely fantastic. Well done, Rachel. X
Profile Image for Gabrielle.
26 reviews
March 23, 2022
This series is so underrated! I love how well researched this whole retelling is. Rachel takes the classic mythology and weaves a coherent and compelling story. Its spicey, romantic, there's drama and betrayal. I devoured this book and went through an emotional rollercoaster along the way. Checks every single box!
Profile Image for Giselle.
25 reviews3 followers
March 24, 2022
AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA!!!

I've been following this series since the first book, and the author has never failed to deliver a deeply engrossing narrative.

Three down, two to go.

All hail Persephone Praxidike Chthonia!
Profile Image for Aryn.
58 reviews4 followers
March 29, 2022
This Persephone and Hades retelling is my absolute favorite because Rachel crushes it when combining the existing myths with original storytelling.

I wasn’t sure how I felt about so many new pov’s at first, but now I just find myself wanting more! How am I supposed to wait for the next book?!?!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 72 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.