Wake of the Phoenix tells the story of an ensemble of characters—members of nobility and commoners, as they maneuver through court politics and intrigue, while trying to pursue their own selfish goals.
I have to say I was largely disappointed by this book and ended up giving it a 2.5 stars rating rounded down to 2. I want to preface this review by clarifying that my ratings usually depend on the level of my enjoyment. In case of Wake of the Phoenix, there were so many elements that seemed very appealing to me: a politics-heavy epic fantasy story that also features gay leads(something we don't see often enough in this genre), so I was very excited to read this; however, I found myself very bored for the vast majority of the book. Thus, as much as I can appreciate certain elements of the book, I still was unable to enjoy it or be entertained by it.
Some aspects of the book are truly great—the politics and the worldbuilding of this book are very fleshed out and intricate. It's obvious that the author put great effort and care into developing the elements of lore and culture of this world. I liked the convoluted nature of the court, the constant game of chess between the members of the nobility, in fact, the aristocracy and its games were the most interesting aspect of the book.
However, in terms of its other components—characters, plot, pacing—this book falls quite short. I couldn't get attached to any of the characters, and even the romantic relationship between Kaen and Lasha or the sibling bond between Niamsha and her brother didn't feel compelling enough to get invested. All the characters seemed too preoccupied with the court intrigue and politicking and that led to almost every character, with the exception of Saylina, feeling too dry. I wanted to care about the forbidden romance, I wanted to care for Niamsha's devotion to her brother, but the information overload on the page and lack of characterization made it quite challenging.
Some characters were downright frustrating; Arkaen in particular seemed quite useless for the most part of the book—he was there to just mingle around, uninterested in court politics or alliances, simply existing there. Lasha, albeit being the most interesting of the bunch, was often frustrating because we simply didn't have enough information about him to understand what was going on. The way he used magic also was left underexplored; however, knowing this is the first book in a series I assume the author will expand on both his character and his abilities in future books. Saylina was the only character I actually liked—she was politically savvy and seemed genuine enough to be somewhat likeable. Overall, the characters were not interesting or compelling enough—they all felt dull.
The dullness of the characters and the moderate pace of the book made this read very slow. It took me ages to get through the first half of the book, and though the second half was a bit smoother, I simply wasn’t interested enough to care. I think this book needed a few rounds of edits, because the writing at times was quite tedious and concentrated too much on the environment rather than the characters and their internal and external conflicts.
I wasn't the biggest fan of homophobia being such a prominent element of the worldbuilding, but that is simply a personal preference—I always choose the fantasy worlds where being queer is considered normal over anything else. Another aspect that bugged me somewhat was how the Torsdell commoners were portrayed—the casual mention of rape, the accent and dialect the author chose to use here weren't exactly my cup of tea.
Overall, I really hope that we will see more epic fantasy with queer leads, but this book, due to its slow pace, wordy writing and uncompelling characters, simply was not for me.
Thanks to NetGalley for providing me with an advanced reader's copy of Wake of the Phoenix.