Somewhere between 3 & 4 stars, rounded up. One month later ! This is a LONG one (730 pages!)
Two things to note:
1) I got this book for free for participating in an ongoing research study at the University of Arizona on breastfeeding and infant sleep! I probably would have never bought it otherwise, but I was looking for a book on sleep and development!
2) After reading this book, my 1yo is definitely sleeping better. (I didn’t follow any specific plan in this book, but I’m sure my behavior changed based on what I was taking away from it.)
I don’t think I agree with Dr. Weissbluth in all things, but I appreciate his dedication to review the whole of sleep research in children and adults and give actionable recommendations to parents in this sleep manual, based on both the empirical results and his anecdotal experience as a pediatrician / sleep consultant. After reading this, I feel much more informed about things that can threaten healthy sleep and considerations to make in trying to support your child’s healthy sleep. The second and third chapters got on my nerves… but by the end of the book I started to appreciate it more.
This book truly needed a better editor - maybe it’s the result of being the 5th edition with a bunch of added sections and chapters for research updates, but it’s hard to track the flow of each chapter. It takes a while to decipher what he thinks are hard lines and what he thinks are nuances that depend on each kid and family. The fact that the book is so long is proof that he understands that sleep, temperament, and family routines are nuanced and varied circumstances which get in the way of a super simple answer. However, he also seems to think early bedtimes are the super simple answer 😂