WOW, oh wow. Full-fledged, unadulterated hyper-Calvinism is presented as the clear and plain biblical truth that every Christian should believe as if no interpretation is involved. In several of these chapters, we have all the classic and overused apologetic bandaids that try (and fail) to cover the gapping and gory nasty bits, everything is spun as if Calvinism is actually a wonderful doctrine.
Reading Grudem's chapter on Election, was analogous to reading a true, drunk-the-kool-aid believer in communism, who honestly and sincerely believes Joseph Stalin was the best leader EVER, and writes a gushing apologetic for all he did. In response to those "strawmen" attacks and enemies to the Truth, who spew their propaganda against Stalin, condemning him for murdering like 60,000,000 of his own people, the Stalin-apologist points out it was all done in love, and in the name of justice and there was a reason for all he did, and yes some things are mysterious and hard for mere mortals to understand, but Stalin is good and we should NEVER question his choices, which were all done for the higher good.
The excuses and positive spin could only satisfy other communists and true believers, for everyone else who is not a Stalin fan, the morally repugnant mental gymnastics will NOT work.
Now, if the evil of Stalin is like a candle, the evil of the god that Grudem proclaims in this chapter is like the sun. Stalin, Hitler, Mao, Antiochus Epiphanes, and every other tyrant combined would still pale in comparison, honestly, they would come out looking like a Mother Tresa compared to the deity Grudem presents in this chapter. As John Wesley points out, Calvinism makes God out to be infinitely worse than the devil.
Grudem thinks his god created mankind so they could ONLY do what they want and thus they are "free" because they can do what they want (though they couldn't have done otherwise). But Grudem's god has predetermined and ordained everything they want, to be in complete control. So, all for his good pleasure, this god ordained every evil desire and designed humans so they could only do the evil he made them want to do. But then, for Grudem, because the people do the evil they wanted to do, they alone are guilty of the sin, and his god is off the hook! yes! you heard this right! This god is now wholly just and right to have them sadistically tortured for all of eternality for "choosing" to do what he determined they would do! like heck NO! The depth of ludicrous absurdity Grudem must engage in is unfathomable. He had me yelling at the book! Only for the true believer in Calvinism does it get Gruden's god off the hook, for everyone else who has not drunk the Kool-aid, it blasphemously entails logically that God is the source and the cause of every evil that has ever occurred in history and he unjustly tortures people forever.
Grudem then goes into the two wills of god: his god is Dr. Jackle and Mr. Hyde. The revealed will, you know things like "God wants all to be saved" This simply doesn't occur, Why? because the dark side of god, his "secretive will" which cannot be thwarted, predetermined 99.9% of all humanity to burn alive for all of eternity, all for his good pleasure. So what the bible says God wants, Nope! but ALL the evil that happens in the world: the holocaust, every rape, every abduction, every sexually abused child, every genocide, every act of cruelty, and almost everyone being eternally tortured for doing what god determined them to do, YEP! This is ALL part of his absolute unthwartable sovereign will predetermine before time, all determined for Grudem's god's selfish and twisted pleasure since evil must bring god so much more glory than good. As John Piper would insist, his god is the most selfish being in the entire universe and does all for his glory. The Calvinist god is simply absolute power and will, arbitrary and monstrous, Augustine and Calvin and their followers imagined the most evil earthly sovereign and blew him up to divine proportions.
Grudem tries to spin this all positive and drape his paper-thin rationalizations over this hideousness, but in the book of Isaiah, the prophet said "Woe to him who calls evil good, darkness light, bittersweet" and this is what Grudem is doing. It is tragic to the depths of his delusion and tragic he convinces so many others to affirm heresies.
Fortunately, the proof texts Grudem used are taken out of context, and often the Greek grammar is ignored. There are excellent interpretations from imminent scholars that show literally not a single proof-text that he used clearly presents the heinous doctrines Augustine and Calvin read into the text and Grudem perpetuates.
Okay, now with that rant out of the way. Election and predestination are typically IN Christ. A simple analogy can help us get a sense of what may be expressed. A plane might be predetermined to go from Dallas to New York, now everyone who gets IN that plane takes part in that predestination, and whoever does not get on the plane is not. So everyone who responds to God's loving pursuit of them and is reconciled is then IN Christ and partakes of this election, they are like a branch grafted into the Olive Tree.
Next, Paul says all those whom God foreknew, he predetermined to be conformed to the image of his Son. If a word study is done on the Greek word foreknow, it is learned it simply means "previous knowledge of" For example in Acts Paul said the Pharisees foreknew him from the beginning. All Paul is saying in Romans 8 is that those God already knows (those with whom he is already in a relationship) he has a plan to conform to the image of his son. Great news! Now despite this plan, some of us are not quite living in our destiny.
An example of Grudem's poor hermeneutics is in Acts, if the Greek is consulted, and Grudem's theology is not read into the text, Luke could have simply stated "And all those who committed themselves to eternal life, believed." This would fit the context perfectly. It is an interpretative decision to make it "All those God appointed to eternal life believed."
Having gotten the Calvinism train, Grudem continues on about irresistible grace.
Now very little scripture even hints at the Calvinist doctrine of irresistible grace, as a result very little scripture is presented in favor of this key tenant of Calvinism in this chapter. It is interesting how Calvinists like to use Paul’s blinding light conversion experience, then overgeneralize from it as if this is THE case study of how God’s irresistible grace always overwhelms and forces conversions of those who were the lucky winners of the salvation lotto. However, later in Acts 26:19, Paul makes it clear he had a choice, for to Agrippa he stated he didn’t resist the vision of God—implying he could have.
Interestingly, it logically follows from Grudem’s doctrine of irresistible grace, that God is exceedingly less potent than a human who could pursue, woo, and win another’s love. For Grudem, God cannot do what humans can, but rather he has to use something like a love potion, to make others (who otherwise would never have anything to do with him otherwise) want him—and to have no choice but to accept his love. This deity is also said to send a (very disingenuous) message to ALL, telling ALL to come, telling ALL to be reconciled to God, and declaring (an absolute lie) that God wants ALL to be reconciled to him, but then, in reality, he only sends the love potion to a tiny few to force them to want him. As with the doctrine of Election, this twisted view is, in reality, slanderous of God, and we have a moral and biblical obligation to expose it for what it is.
He then goes on into the Preservation of the Saints and sanctification:
In this chapter, Grudem presents the doctrine of the Preservation of the Saints. Of Course, if it is God who ordained all people to be wholly depraved--making them so they could only do what they want and then determining they only want evil, and it is God who arbitrarily elects a tiny few to be saved, and whose Son's death was limited to the tiny few he elected beforehand, and God who then gives the love potion (I mean irresistible grace), to cause the monster's of iniquity to love him, then clearly, since humanity has no part in anything, then obviously the tiny handful he decided to save cannot be lost.
As Christians though, people can still ONLY do what they want, and the tiny bit of good that Christians do is only because God made them want good. Now of course, as Pelagius recognized with Augustine's teaching, this implies God is ultimately responsible for all the evil of Christians too. Sanctification can only occur to the degree God decides to step in and make one want to change and love. The revealed will of God would suggest this is something God really wants to do, of course, the unthwartable secret, dark, and mysterious will prefers sin and unrighteousness (clearly bringing him so much more glory and good pleasure) and determines most Christians on this side of eternity to NOT be conformed to the image of his Son. Yet, still, because of contradiction (I mean, mystery), Grudem still talks as if Christians should go ahead a try to be better, though they can't do this unless God makes them want to, something God is most of the time quite unwilling to do--thus the Romans 7 life.
What is fascinating, is that John Piper's son Abraham left the faith, which means he was never one of God's elect to begin with (According to Grudem), now if John Piper also left the faith, it would mean he was NEVER a Christian! Just think, it is possible now that John Piper is NOT among the elect; just think about it, every sermon, every book might have been written by a reprobate! Same with Wayne Grudem! This entire book might be written by someone predetermined to be burned alive for all of eternity, we cannot know until Grudem dies. We cannot know until they die. Falling away from the faith could happen to both of them. Even evangelical gate-keeper's faith can crumble; tons of evangelists, missionaries, and pastors eventually lose their faith later in life. So what this means, is despite Grudem saying it is about assurance, logically, there is ABSOLUTELY NO ASSURANCE. Since the most passionate Christian for 60 years who falls away later in life, was NEVER actually a Christian to begin with, this means NO one can be sure they are saved, there is no evidence, absolutely none.