✨3 stars✨
It doesn’t usually take me that long to read books, but this one took me forever to get through. I think I’ve been in a bit of a reading slump, and life has been quite busy recently too, but even so, at times it felt like I would never finish this book. It isn’t boring, it just isn’t what I wanted it to be; I didn’t hate it, I just didn’t love it. Which is a bit disappointing because it’s my 50th book of the year (meaning I’ve completed my 2018 reading challenge of 50 books!!) and it was a pretty ‘meh’ book to hit that with, ya know what I mean?!
I really enjoyed Kate and Corwin’s contrasting perspectives throughout the book as it really helped to keep it that bit more interesting- if it had just been Kate’s perspective for the whole thing then it’s entirely possible I may never have finished it. I liked Kate, and her journey to finding out more about her father (and discovering Kiran) was so unique and intriguing, but I didn’t find her personality to be all that special- she kind of just felt the same as a lot of other female YA characters who ‘don’t quite fit into society’ and ‘rebel against the system’. Corwin definitely had more of a defined and specific personality, and I absolutely loved finding out more about his past, why he's referred to as the Errant Prince, and why he left in the first place. HOWEVER (and this is a big however), the whole book really would have benefitted from more character development. Tell me more about how Dal and Corwin met, tell me more about Kate and Corwin’s childhood, tell me more about Kate’s relationship with her father, tell me more about Corwin’s mother, T E L L. M E. M O R E !!!
Highlight of this book is definitely Signe and Dal, I neeeeed more about them, I could happily have had this whole book be about them instead of Kate and Corwin, they’re the only reason I might pick up the sequel (I’m assuming there’s going to be a sequel, right? Since it ends right as the action finally starts happening?? Right???). I adore Signe’s fabrications about herself, the ambiguity tied to basically everything she reveals about herself, and she really stood out as a wickedly strong character that wasn’t delved into nearly enough. Dal, too. We hear so many things about him in passing, and I would have loved for his character and personality to have been explored in more depth.
I really did like the concept of this book, it just ended up following a bit too much of a typical and slightly overdone YA formula for me at times- ‘Girl is different, she is part of something that society shuns, she joins uprising and rebels, and she also falls in love too because hey why not’- I could name atleast a million other YA books that follow this exact structure. Also, it was so slow to start with, and then when the pace finally started to pick up, the book ended, which just felt a bit frustrating, honestly. I still enjoyed it, it just wasn’t what I was expecting or hoping it to be. I thought that the Relay would play a bigger part in the story (or any real part in the story, to be honest), although I did really adore the uror trials aspect of it. Trials are a plot point that I always find extremely fun for some reason, and that element really didn’t let me down. Like I said, I didn’t hate it, I just didn’t love it. It could have been because of the reading slump, and maybe I’ll reread it one day and love it, who knows. For now though, it was pretty average and I’m hoping I like my next read more!😂