What do you think?
Rate this book
Memorable Proposals #2
A Faithful Proposal
She was born to lead London Society. He could not leave it fast enough.
With a few well-placed words in the right ear, Anna Tunstall can direct anyone to do her bidding, exactly the skill needed for one destined to be the wife of a man in politics. A summer visit to a friend’s country estate is the perfect distraction before the London Season begins and Anna can achieve her ambition of a perfect match.
Harry Aston has spurned the noble aspirations of his family to enter holy orders where he might make a difference in people’s lives. His mother’s untiring attempts to find him a wife worthy—and wealthy—enough to suit him only serve to set up his back. He has never been in love, and she should not think that suitable wives dropped down from heaven, especially not in the village of Avebury.
When Harry finds Anna unconscious on the road, and she awakens in his arms, his world shifts at her gaze. But before he can think that heaven has come through at last, he must convince Anna that her prolonged stay in Avebury is not fate’s way of toying with her, but rather opening her eyes to a new direction for her ambitions—and her heart.
With a few well-placed words in the right ear, Anna Tunstall can direct anyone to do her bidding, exactly the skill needed for one destined to be the wife of a man in politics. A summer visit to a friend’s country estate is the perfect distraction before the London Season begins and Anna can achieve her ambition of a perfect match.
Harry Aston has spurned the noble aspirations of his family to enter holy orders where he might make a difference in people’s lives. His mother’s untiring attempts to find him a wife worthy—and wealthy—enough to suit him only serve to set up his back. He has never been in love, and she should not think that suitable wives dropped down from heaven, especially not in the village of Avebury.
When Harry finds Anna unconscious on the road, and she awakens in his arms, his world shifts at her gaze. But before he can think that heaven has come through at last, he must convince Anna that her prolonged stay in Avebury is not fate’s way of toying with her, but rather opening her eyes to a new direction for her ambitions—and her heart.
305 pages, Kindle Edition
First published February 11, 2020
536 people are currently reading
502 people want to read
About the author
Jennie Goutet
38 books634 followersJennie Goutet is the best-selling author of eighteen historical romances, including the Clavering Chronicles, Memorable Proposals, and The Bridwells’ Grand Tour series. Her books have received first place in historical romance for the New England Reader’s Choice Awards and have hit the number one spot in Regency Romance on Amazon. They have been featured on BookBub and Hoopla, and are translated into six languages. Jennie is an American-born Anglophile who lives with her French husband and their three children in a small town outside of Paris, but her imagination resides in Georgian England, where her proper historical romances are set. You can learn more about Jennie’s books and sign up for her newsletter on her author website, jenniegoutet.com.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 182 reviews
February 21, 2022
2.5 - eh
As much as this pains me, 2.5 stars. I LOVED the first in this series. I stayed up too late reading it, I was so eager for this book. But it was so very ho hum. I didn’t really like Anna much, sorry!!! She just seemed immature to me. And I didn’t really see why the two fell in love. More time could’ve been spent on building their relationship together than the eons of internal debate about it. I also felt like it served a 100% social gospel. Nothing about Jesus being the true reason for reformation, nothing about forgiven sin, etc. The rector never once asked Anna about her faith, just assumed she had one and was “good” deep down. I don’t understand Harry’s insta-love that was based on certainty about attributes we didn’t ever see. (I know, toward the end Anna felt moved by a charity work—didn’t convince me though.) It just didn’t feel believable and because of that, the characters had almost no tension, which meant the plot overall lacked tension. I didn’t read this book for religious purposes but I hate poorly presented religious books worse than those that omit it entirely. Hence, the 2.5. I hate to do it because I know the author can be talented. The plot and characters just let her down.
As much as this pains me, 2.5 stars. I LOVED the first in this series. I stayed up too late reading it, I was so eager for this book. But it was so very ho hum. I didn’t really like Anna much, sorry!!! She just seemed immature to me. And I didn’t really see why the two fell in love. More time could’ve been spent on building their relationship together than the eons of internal debate about it. I also felt like it served a 100% social gospel. Nothing about Jesus being the true reason for reformation, nothing about forgiven sin, etc. The rector never once asked Anna about her faith, just assumed she had one and was “good” deep down. I don’t understand Harry’s insta-love that was based on certainty about attributes we didn’t ever see. (I know, toward the end Anna felt moved by a charity work—didn’t convince me though.) It just didn’t feel believable and because of that, the characters had almost no tension, which meant the plot overall lacked tension. I didn’t read this book for religious purposes but I hate poorly presented religious books worse than those that omit it entirely. Hence, the 2.5. I hate to do it because I know the author can be talented. The plot and characters just let her down.
April 12, 2021
Weak romantic interest
The writing is excellent. The sentiment is awful. Here is a woman with extraordinary cosmopolitan gifts, and no effort is made to explain how they may be spent particularly in a rural town. Instead, it's a whole and significant aspect of the heroine's character that's expected to be straight up sacrificed on behalf of her groom's romantic certainty. Depressing, and not equal to the author's talents.
The writing is excellent. The sentiment is awful. Here is a woman with extraordinary cosmopolitan gifts, and no effort is made to explain how they may be spent particularly in a rural town. Instead, it's a whole and significant aspect of the heroine's character that's expected to be straight up sacrificed on behalf of her groom's romantic certainty. Depressing, and not equal to the author's talents.
February 20, 2020
Anna seemed superficial, at first, caring only for the attractions of London society. However, as she spent time in the village community her attitudes changed. Harry was a very charismatic person and he had a very real caring attitude to his parishioners. He was a bit of an enigma, in that he had the clothes and manners of a gentleman but was a vicar of a parish church. There is an immediate attractions between Anna and Harry but before anything can come of it, Harry has a visit from his older brother, who is out to cause trouble. There is also the mystery of who is the highwaymen in the area. This was an engaging tale and I would love to read more of Anna’s twin sister, Phoebe.
January 24, 2022
4.5 stars. This was another lovely romance. Harry and Anna couldn’t be more different at first glance. He is the rector of a country parish, she loves London society and can’t imagine living anywhere else. Harry gives off some serious Mr Knightley vibes, which I loved. It’s a really engaging and well written story with some misunderstandings and secrets but that guaranteed happy ending. Now it’s on to book three, Phoebe’s story, which releases February 1st.
October 25, 2023
A Faithful Proposal is a regency romance that strikes a unique chord, deserving a lovely four-star rating. This audiobook masterfully weaves a tale of contrasting worlds and entwines it with the warmth and charm of beloved literary characters who initially appear worlds apart.
The audiobook, which I highly recommend, is expertly narrated, with distinct character voices and accents that add depth to the storytelling. The quaint village setting provides a charming backdrop for the unfolding romance.
Anna, at first glance, may come across as shallow, but her transformation throughout the story is heartwarming. Harry, the charismatic rector, radiates a genuine care for his parishioners, making him a character you'll grow fond of. Their immediate attraction is palpable, yet their budding romance is thwarted by the arrival of Harry's troublesome brother and the mystery of the highwaymen.
What truly captivates in this audiobook is the chemistry between Anna and Harry. Anna's vivacity complements Harry's piety and dedication, making their love story all the more endearing. The conflicts, misunderstandings, and the mischievous big brother keep the plot engaging and the listener utterly engrossed.
The characters resonate with readers, making them entirely relatable. A Faithful Proposal is a charming regency romance, and I eagerly anticipate future installments from the talented author, Jennie Goutet.
I greatly appreciate the audiobook, A Faithful Proposal, that I received from the talented author Jennie Goutet, via Booksprout and Spotify. I was not required to write a positive review or paid to do so. The words above are my honest review of A Faithful Proposal!
The audiobook, which I highly recommend, is expertly narrated, with distinct character voices and accents that add depth to the storytelling. The quaint village setting provides a charming backdrop for the unfolding romance.
Anna, at first glance, may come across as shallow, but her transformation throughout the story is heartwarming. Harry, the charismatic rector, radiates a genuine care for his parishioners, making him a character you'll grow fond of. Their immediate attraction is palpable, yet their budding romance is thwarted by the arrival of Harry's troublesome brother and the mystery of the highwaymen.
What truly captivates in this audiobook is the chemistry between Anna and Harry. Anna's vivacity complements Harry's piety and dedication, making their love story all the more endearing. The conflicts, misunderstandings, and the mischievous big brother keep the plot engaging and the listener utterly engrossed.
The characters resonate with readers, making them entirely relatable. A Faithful Proposal is a charming regency romance, and I eagerly anticipate future installments from the talented author, Jennie Goutet.
I greatly appreciate the audiobook, A Faithful Proposal, that I received from the talented author Jennie Goutet, via Booksprout and Spotify. I was not required to write a positive review or paid to do so. The words above are my honest review of A Faithful Proposal!
August 11, 2022
I almost gave this 3 stars but I just didn’t like the main characters. Anna was a snob and very shallow. She gets a little better at the end but still a snobbish aristocrat. Harry disdained the nobility but was snobbish in the reverse. He was very disappointing and way too judgmental. I really liked him at the start of the book but less so at the end. You kind of need to read this book to keep the series flowing but go in with low expectations.
February 15, 2020
A Faithful Proposal (Memorable Proposals 2) was a fun romance to read. I enjoyed Harry and Anna's characters. I didn't always agree with the side characters' views of Anna, but as a reader I could learn about her feelings, thoughts and fears whereas the other characters didn't have the view. The story is a fast, fun read. I felt like the author did a good job with the pacing of the action and dramatic turning points. I would suggest reading the first book first, A Regrettable Proposal. Some of the actions, characters and story line mention events from the first book and I think it would be confusing to the reader to read the books out of order.
Please note that I received a free e-copy to review, however, this is my honest opinion.
Please note that I received a free e-copy to review, however, this is my honest opinion.
February 18, 2020
Clergyman
I grew weary of the rector chasing after Anna after 25% of the book. After that I decided to go on to other books.
I grew weary of the rector chasing after Anna after 25% of the book. After that I decided to go on to other books.
March 14, 2020
Very good second in the series
I liked hearing more details of the family that we met in the first book. A book about Phoebe will hopefully be written soon!
I liked hearing more details of the family that we met in the first book. A book about Phoebe will hopefully be written soon!
February 1, 2021
Disappointing
I thought given the storyline there would be some fireworks given the description of the heroine, but it was tepid reading to the end.
I thought given the storyline there would be some fireworks given the description of the heroine, but it was tepid reading to the end.
December 23, 2020
This is one of those books where it would be very easy to dislike either the hero or the heroine - or both! The hero is a bit of a goody two-shoes, a pious clergyman with egalitarian ideals and a burning desire to improve the lot of his parishioners, who hates the frivolity of the beau monde. The heroine is a society butterfly, only happy in the swirl of entertainments and gossipy chatter that is London, and very disparaging of country life (and country parsons). But fortunately, the parson has an Achilles heel in the shape of his meddlesome brother, and the socialite is discovered to have a more compassionate side. They are both more human and more redeemable than they appear at first.
Here’s the premise: Anna Tunstall is to join her friend, Emily Leatham, at the village of Avebury, in Wiltshire. On the way, she is attacked by highwaymen and knocked out. Harry Aston, the pious clergyman, happens upon her prostrate form and naturally sets out to rescue her. And when her eyes flutter open, he’s smitten (with this lovely line): ‘When she raised her clear eyes to his and he saw the answering gleam of fun, Harry knew the end to his bachelor days had come. He was done for.’ But of course she’s an earl’s sister and destined, she’s sure, for a life as a political wife, and he’s a lowly rector of a country parish. Or is he?
At first, things chug along rather nicely, with Harry pursuing his suit steadily, and Anna succumbing to his charm and finding out that he’s not as bad as she’s thought, for a parson. There’s still a huge difference in personalities, she wavers back and forth and they seem to be drawn to each other by physical attraction more than anything else, but it seems to be working out. And then comes the huge spanner in the works - Harry’s big brother arrives, complete with fancy title, and the secret of Harry’s identity is out (this is not a spoiler; his family is mentioned in the blurb). And naturally Anna’s far from pleased that he didn’t tell her.
The rest of the book is a succession of misunderstandings, more wavering from Anna and mischief-making from big brother, together with a number of dramatic upheavals to do with friend Emily and Harry’s cook, with everything resolved in an improbable sequence at the end, including the highwaymen. I feel there was rather too much drama thrown in, but never mind.
I was a bit surprised by the church scene, where the parishioners were locked out of the church, there appeared to be stables for the gentry’s carriages, and the rector arrives by curricle. Even when I was a child, church doors were never, ever locked, and the rectory would normally have been right next door to the church, a very short walk away. I’ve never heard of a church with its own stables. There were a few other oddities like this that had me puzzled, but nothing that spoiled the story for me.
It was a little disappointing that, after choosing such an unusual setting for this book, so little was made of it. Avebury is a unique place, sitting pretty much in the middle of a huge and spectacular stone circle, but the stones were barely mentioned and Avebury felt like just another generic English village. At least the author resisted the temptation to have the main characters go haring off to London for part of the time, which I half expected as a way of pointing up the different natures of hero and heroine. It would have been interesting to see Anna back in her more usual environment, and see her growing disenchantment with the shallowness of society life.
The romance ends in fine style, although I confess I’m not too sure that this is a match made in heaven. How will Anna cope as a country parson’s wife? I don’t really see it, somehow, and she’s sharp-tongued enough to make his life miserable if she’s discontented with her lot. But I’m an optimist, so let’s go with the happy ever after.
There’s nothing terribly unexpected here, but it’s very readable, and kept me turning the pages voraciously. Both hero and heroine grew on me over the course of the book, despite their flaws, and I enjoyed the unusual setting, a parson hero who’s genuinely devout, and a heroine who was forced to face up to her true nature. Four stars.
Here’s the premise: Anna Tunstall is to join her friend, Emily Leatham, at the village of Avebury, in Wiltshire. On the way, she is attacked by highwaymen and knocked out. Harry Aston, the pious clergyman, happens upon her prostrate form and naturally sets out to rescue her. And when her eyes flutter open, he’s smitten (with this lovely line): ‘When she raised her clear eyes to his and he saw the answering gleam of fun, Harry knew the end to his bachelor days had come. He was done for.’ But of course she’s an earl’s sister and destined, she’s sure, for a life as a political wife, and he’s a lowly rector of a country parish. Or is he?
At first, things chug along rather nicely, with Harry pursuing his suit steadily, and Anna succumbing to his charm and finding out that he’s not as bad as she’s thought, for a parson. There’s still a huge difference in personalities, she wavers back and forth and they seem to be drawn to each other by physical attraction more than anything else, but it seems to be working out. And then comes the huge spanner in the works - Harry’s big brother arrives, complete with fancy title, and the secret of Harry’s identity is out (this is not a spoiler; his family is mentioned in the blurb). And naturally Anna’s far from pleased that he didn’t tell her.
The rest of the book is a succession of misunderstandings, more wavering from Anna and mischief-making from big brother, together with a number of dramatic upheavals to do with friend Emily and Harry’s cook, with everything resolved in an improbable sequence at the end, including the highwaymen. I feel there was rather too much drama thrown in, but never mind.
I was a bit surprised by the church scene, where the parishioners were locked out of the church, there appeared to be stables for the gentry’s carriages, and the rector arrives by curricle. Even when I was a child, church doors were never, ever locked, and the rectory would normally have been right next door to the church, a very short walk away. I’ve never heard of a church with its own stables. There were a few other oddities like this that had me puzzled, but nothing that spoiled the story for me.
It was a little disappointing that, after choosing such an unusual setting for this book, so little was made of it. Avebury is a unique place, sitting pretty much in the middle of a huge and spectacular stone circle, but the stones were barely mentioned and Avebury felt like just another generic English village. At least the author resisted the temptation to have the main characters go haring off to London for part of the time, which I half expected as a way of pointing up the different natures of hero and heroine. It would have been interesting to see Anna back in her more usual environment, and see her growing disenchantment with the shallowness of society life.
The romance ends in fine style, although I confess I’m not too sure that this is a match made in heaven. How will Anna cope as a country parson’s wife? I don’t really see it, somehow, and she’s sharp-tongued enough to make his life miserable if she’s discontented with her lot. But I’m an optimist, so let’s go with the happy ever after.
There’s nothing terribly unexpected here, but it’s very readable, and kept me turning the pages voraciously. Both hero and heroine grew on me over the course of the book, despite their flaws, and I enjoyed the unusual setting, a parson hero who’s genuinely devout, and a heroine who was forced to face up to her true nature. Four stars.
March 16, 2021
Highwayman of Her Heart💘
SWEET Regency Romance 💕 and AdventureWith a Mystery.
This is a well written Regency Romance 💕 about two people who finally figure out what they really want.
The book is somewhat angsty and it takes a long time for the main characters to come around to each other.
SWEET Regency Romance 💕 and AdventureWith a Mystery.
This is a well written Regency Romance 💕 about two people who finally figure out what they really want.
The book is somewhat angsty and it takes a long time for the main characters to come around to each other.
January 19, 2023
I loved the first book in the series and have to say in honest I had a tough time getting into this story. I seemed very boring at first, but once you overcame this first third of the book things get a little more interesting and you will be rooting for the couple in the end.
Anna is the twin, from the first book that felt a little left out back then, because she never seemed very pleased with the match her brother made.
In this book you get to see how she feels and acts, but it feels a little disconnected with the first book. She is set into a story where she is put in an entirely new position. One where she has to take responsibility and care for someone else. And she supposedly learns how to overcome her superficial self to show more compassion with those around her.
I felt her actions were always self-serving and she did not turn out to be a more sympathetic being she just found the love that made her want to give up on other things she liked before. I liked the story in the second half of the book, but I did not warm to the characters quite as much as I did in the first book.
Anna is the twin, from the first book that felt a little left out back then, because she never seemed very pleased with the match her brother made.
In this book you get to see how she feels and acts, but it feels a little disconnected with the first book. She is set into a story where she is put in an entirely new position. One where she has to take responsibility and care for someone else. And she supposedly learns how to overcome her superficial self to show more compassion with those around her.
I felt her actions were always self-serving and she did not turn out to be a more sympathetic being she just found the love that made her want to give up on other things she liked before. I liked the story in the second half of the book, but I did not warm to the characters quite as much as I did in the first book.
January 7, 2023
It is hard to fully enjoy a story when you don't like the main character. Harry Aston is enamored with Anna Tunstall after meeting her. He thinks all these wonderful things about her, and I will admit that she does do some really good things. However, her snobbish attitude and selfishness stood out the most to me. Harry was really too good for her. I was happy with a couple of resolutions, but a little underwhelmed by one. I did enjoy seeing Stratford and Eleanor Daventry for a bit, who were in the previous Proposal book, A Regrettable Proposal. I definitely enjoyed that one more than this one.
March 22, 2020
Well-written with a sweet love story, A Faithful Proposal is an enjoyable clean romance that will engage the reader and leave them with a sweet happily ever after. What I enjoyed most in this novel was how well the author developed her characters and that the reader can see how while Harry and Anna might not have been the most logical match to start with, they really did bring out the best in one another and had a connection between them that was undeniable.
The plot moved at a good pace with enough romance to move the relationships along and enough action as it were to keep the reader interested in what was occurring in the background to move the characters forward.
I read the first novel in this series (A Regrettable Proposal) and enjoyed it, but I also can see improvement in the author's style and ability in this novel which makes me look forward even more to her next story. I do hope we get to see Phoebe get a happily ever after as well.
Definitely a fun addition to the Regency romance genre and worth a read.
The plot moved at a good pace with enough romance to move the relationships along and enough action as it were to keep the reader interested in what was occurring in the background to move the characters forward.
I read the first novel in this series (A Regrettable Proposal) and enjoyed it, but I also can see improvement in the author's style and ability in this novel which makes me look forward even more to her next story. I do hope we get to see Phoebe get a happily ever after as well.
Definitely a fun addition to the Regency romance genre and worth a read.
January 23, 2021
Despite his high ranking position by birth, Harry Aston wishes to serve his fellow man in the best possible way, much against his family's wishes. Anna Tunstall, on the other hand, is only too happy to play her part in society and is looking for the perfect husband where her influence can be of most benefit. Visiting her friend in the country was supposed to be a short-term affair, but circumstances conspire against her. The story is sweet and clean, but also suspenseful as an attack against Anna is investigated. The romance that brews between Anna and Harry is short-circuited by his rogue brother, and Harry makes too many assumptions. Nevertheless, the book comes to a happy conclusion as all the loose ends come together. I received a copy of this book as a gift and this is my honest and voluntary review.
April 21, 2020
Sit back and enjoy this wonderful clean Regency from Jennie Goutet which not only highlights a budding romance between two seemingly unlike characters, but also provides significant secondary storylines among several supporting characters. While I initially found Anna’s personality to be a bit off-putting, it was quite heartening to see how her character developed from the beginning to the end of the story. And Harry—although by no means perfect as he wrestled with some long standing family issues, was such a thoughtful and gallant hero! Throw into the mix some interesting twists and turns and you will feel a range of emotions as the story unfolds. Definitely recommend this book and this author!
April 29, 2020
What a wonderful book! With highwaymen, disguised identities, and sweet reunions what's not to love! I loved the characters in this book. Anna had such spunk and Harry was such a fun rector! I loved how Anna had to change her view of the world to finally allow her to love the perfect man for her and I loved how Harry had to get over his past to take a chance on the woman he loves. I loved the first book in this series and this book was great! I'm looking forward to reading more books by Jennie!
April 17, 2020
Faithless Absurdity
If I could give this book negative stars, I would. The heroine is shallow and vapid. The hero is weak and diminutive. The ending was certainly achieved through divine intervention. I never wanted two people further apart and a book to end so much.
Please, read only if you wish to suffer.
If I could give this book negative stars, I would. The heroine is shallow and vapid. The hero is weak and diminutive. The ending was certainly achieved through divine intervention. I never wanted two people further apart and a book to end so much.
Please, read only if you wish to suffer.
July 23, 2022
This one was a little weaker than the first one in development, but still nicely written. There wasn't enough of a transformation of Anne, and wasn't enough of why he would fall in love with someone so shallow, even though she had depth in her eyes.
January 21, 2023
I don't like the characters so far. A woman was dragged away screaming by robbers. No one, not even her sister, her employer, or her priest, has expressed any concern for her or made any plans to look for her. It's immersion-breaking and turning me off the characters.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
July 22, 2021
Sweet proper read
Good writing and attention to detail made this a pleasant read although it lacked a little sparkle in the romance, hence the 3 stars.
Good writing and attention to detail made this a pleasant read although it lacked a little sparkle in the romance, hence the 3 stars.
February 16, 2024
Anna is very different from me. Sometimes this makes reading a character more fun, and other times it makes them hard to relate to. Anna comes off as shallow. She likes gossip and fashion. And she bonded with...oh shoot...what was her name?...her friend over these things before her friend married and moved from London. Anna is now on her way to visit her friend before her confinement while her husband is away at war. Anna is headstrong and often disregards logic and sense for her own whims. She's one of those people that thinks "Oh, that could never happen to me." But it seems "that" often does happen to her.
After dismissing the idea of traveling with any sort of male escort and only hiring a temporary maid, her coach is robbed by highwaymen. Anna is found by Harry, the local vicar, and deposited with her friend to recover. Harry is almost immediately taken with Anna's beauty. But he needs to know there is more to Anna than her looks.
Harry is of noble birth, but all things London and high society rub him completely wrong. Most especially, his family. He does battle with wondering whether Anna is as surface level as she gives off because as a vicar, he needs his bride to be deeper than that and concerned with more than simply herself. Anna does rise to the occasion, but I was a little disappointed that he didn't probe deeper into her faith. As a vicar, I would imagine it isn't good enough to have a kind wife. Wouldn't you need a believing wife as well? And given the main role that Harry has, I would have expected to see some deeper religious themes used throughout the book. I wasn't put off by it, but it was something I noted.
A Faithful Propopsal has a few mysteries wrapped up in the overall storyline. Who are the highwaymen who robbed Anna at the beginning of the book? Why were her possessions returned to her? Anna's friend's husband is missing. Will he return or will she finally receive news that he is dead? Or will he remain missing? This was perhaps one of my favorite parts of the overall story, and I can't spoil anything surrounding it.
A Faitfhul Proposal wasn't a perfect book for me. I had a few issues with Anna as a character, to begin with. I wanted to see a little more depth to Anna where Harry was concerned. Sure I didn't expect her to change just for his sake, but are they truly the best fit for each other? I did enjoy the side stories because they didn't take over the main plot, but I felt like they truly did add to the story instead of take away which can sometimes happen in romantic mysteries. I give A Faithful Proposal 3 Stars. Have you read (or listened to) A Faithful Proposal? What did you think? Let me know!
After dismissing the idea of traveling with any sort of male escort and only hiring a temporary maid, her coach is robbed by highwaymen. Anna is found by Harry, the local vicar, and deposited with her friend to recover. Harry is almost immediately taken with Anna's beauty. But he needs to know there is more to Anna than her looks.
Harry is of noble birth, but all things London and high society rub him completely wrong. Most especially, his family. He does battle with wondering whether Anna is as surface level as she gives off because as a vicar, he needs his bride to be deeper than that and concerned with more than simply herself. Anna does rise to the occasion, but I was a little disappointed that he didn't probe deeper into her faith. As a vicar, I would imagine it isn't good enough to have a kind wife. Wouldn't you need a believing wife as well? And given the main role that Harry has, I would have expected to see some deeper religious themes used throughout the book. I wasn't put off by it, but it was something I noted.
A Faithful Propopsal has a few mysteries wrapped up in the overall storyline. Who are the highwaymen who robbed Anna at the beginning of the book? Why were her possessions returned to her? Anna's friend's husband is missing. Will he return or will she finally receive news that he is dead? Or will he remain missing? This was perhaps one of my favorite parts of the overall story, and I can't spoil anything surrounding it.
A Faitfhul Proposal wasn't a perfect book for me. I had a few issues with Anna as a character, to begin with. I wanted to see a little more depth to Anna where Harry was concerned. Sure I didn't expect her to change just for his sake, but are they truly the best fit for each other? I did enjoy the side stories because they didn't take over the main plot, but I felt like they truly did add to the story instead of take away which can sometimes happen in romantic mysteries. I give A Faithful Proposal 3 Stars. Have you read (or listened to) A Faithful Proposal? What did you think? Let me know!
November 15, 2023
A Faithful Proposal was such an intriguing read for me -- Jennie Goutet writes ordinary, realistically flawed people so that I'm totally invested in their stories and relationships. This book was no exception. Both Anna and Harry are flawed, very realistic people. Harry's a little self righteous, and Anna is a little bit vain and vapid (which makes sense in the context of the society she lives in and her age), but Goutet manages to make them lovingly so, both through their strengths and through the character growth each undergoes from start to finish (full disclosure though, I struggle with Anna until about halfway through the book. She didn't become lovable to me until much, much later in the story, after she's had a chance to sacrifice to help her friend and also realizes she's made some stupid choices). I loved reading about their developing relationship because each ultimately improves the other by association.
I loved the action woven throughout the novel alongside the romance. In my opinion, every good romance includes some additional elements to the plot, and I appreciated the highwayman plot and the suspense surrounding Emily's husband's disappearance. I also appreciated that everything was wrapped up happily! (I don't appreciate when what is supposed to be an escapist read gut punches me emotionally, and I was SO relieved this one was all pleasant by the end!)
Not quite a five star read for me; while I did ultimately really enjoy the novel, it took me awhile to get fully sucked into (not loving the main character at the start made for a bit of a rough beginning). It's good but not the best of Goutet's books. There were also a few mistakes in the audiobook narration (one character's name in place of another type of mistakes).
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
I loved the action woven throughout the novel alongside the romance. In my opinion, every good romance includes some additional elements to the plot, and I appreciated the highwayman plot and the suspense surrounding Emily's husband's disappearance. I also appreciated that everything was wrapped up happily! (I don't appreciate when what is supposed to be an escapist read gut punches me emotionally, and I was SO relieved this one was all pleasant by the end!)
Not quite a five star read for me; while I did ultimately really enjoy the novel, it took me awhile to get fully sucked into (not loving the main character at the start made for a bit of a rough beginning). It's good but not the best of Goutet's books. There were also a few mistakes in the audiobook narration (one character's name in place of another type of mistakes).
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
November 13, 2023
The book starts out in a hilarious exciting and cute way. Yes all three. haha And so it was so full of promise for me.
Anna seemed like a very unlikely heroine from the ones I'm used to from the author because in book one she came off as a little spoiled and somewhat self involved. So it was quite interesting to dig in and see who she really was when the spotlight shone on her story and how she would get on with a rector (akin to preacher in today terms) for a love interest.
Harry is just a lovely sweet green-flag bean! I enjoyed learning about him.
What drew me to engage with this read was that Anna's story with Harry is quite an unlikely one given they had such different world views. So it was exciting to look forward to finding out how it would all come together for them.
I have read 2 other books by this author that I enjoyed and I really wanted to love this one but it was simply okay. It was a nice read with an unlikely love line, a cute little town setting, and a good amount of ups and downs to keep the journey going and the reader wanting to know more. But it just did not dig deep enough into its own immense potential.
Don't get me wrong it was not bad or boring but just okay. An okay 3.5 out of 5 for me. Something cozy and lovely to listen to. Also aside form being a clean read-which is always a deal breaker for me personally, it also reminded me of some important life lessons and made me smile with how warm the last chapter was.
It is therefore something you can comfortably listen to while pittering and pottering about your business.
That said, I will definitely read the next book because I enjoyed part 1, fairly liked part 2 and absolutely want to see how the other characters fair on in the last installment.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Anna seemed like a very unlikely heroine from the ones I'm used to from the author because in book one she came off as a little spoiled and somewhat self involved. So it was quite interesting to dig in and see who she really was when the spotlight shone on her story and how she would get on with a rector (akin to preacher in today terms) for a love interest.
Harry is just a lovely sweet green-flag bean! I enjoyed learning about him.
What drew me to engage with this read was that Anna's story with Harry is quite an unlikely one given they had such different world views. So it was exciting to look forward to finding out how it would all come together for them.
I have read 2 other books by this author that I enjoyed and I really wanted to love this one but it was simply okay. It was a nice read with an unlikely love line, a cute little town setting, and a good amount of ups and downs to keep the journey going and the reader wanting to know more. But it just did not dig deep enough into its own immense potential.
Don't get me wrong it was not bad or boring but just okay. An okay 3.5 out of 5 for me. Something cozy and lovely to listen to. Also aside form being a clean read-which is always a deal breaker for me personally, it also reminded me of some important life lessons and made me smile with how warm the last chapter was.
It is therefore something you can comfortably listen to while pittering and pottering about your business.
That said, I will definitely read the next book because I enjoyed part 1, fairly liked part 2 and absolutely want to see how the other characters fair on in the last installment.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
November 20, 2023
I wanted to like this book. It had the makings of a good story, it was well-written, and I've read the book after it (A Daring Proposal) and LOVED it. This fell flat for me though.
Anna and Harry fell into insta-love, despite being very different from one another and having very few things in common. Harry fell in love immediately, and while He Falls First is one of my favorite tropes, I usually like if there's a reason he falls? Anna kept telling herself she didn't love him but she had about as much insta-love as him, again, without any real reason for it.
There were some cute moments at the end with side characters that made it satisfying, but my least favorite part about this romance book was the romance, so it's safe to say it wasn't a favorite for me. I'll stick with the incredible third book and try never to think about this one again.
About halfway through the book picked up and got more interesting. Various plot points picked up, the relationship was actually tested, and I enjoyed the book for a while. But then... Anna and Harry really didn't mesh. I was convinced that Harry was obsessed with Anna (not in love, obsessed in a cringy way) and Anna spent a long time convincing herself she was in love with Harry (more thoughts below - Spoiler)
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
but the fact of the matter was he hated society and wanted to be a rector forever and she loved London and all the excitement that came with it. And the solution was simply that she changed for him. She gave up her dreams and these important parts of who she was simply because she saw her friend happy and convinced herself she loved Harry. I HATED her changing for a man she spent most of the book feeling lukewarm about. I absolutely got the ick.
Anna and Harry fell into insta-love, despite being very different from one another and having very few things in common. Harry fell in love immediately, and while He Falls First is one of my favorite tropes, I usually like if there's a reason he falls? Anna kept telling herself she didn't love him but she had about as much insta-love as him, again, without any real reason for it.
There were some cute moments at the end with side characters that made it satisfying, but my least favorite part about this romance book was the romance, so it's safe to say it wasn't a favorite for me. I'll stick with the incredible third book and try never to think about this one again.
About halfway through the book picked up and got more interesting. Various plot points picked up, the relationship was actually tested, and I enjoyed the book for a while. But then... Anna and Harry really didn't mesh. I was convinced that Harry was obsessed with Anna (not in love, obsessed in a cringy way) and Anna spent a long time convincing herself she was in love with Harry (more thoughts below - Spoiler)
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
but the fact of the matter was he hated society and wanted to be a rector forever and she loved London and all the excitement that came with it. And the solution was simply that she changed for him. She gave up her dreams and these important parts of who she was simply because she saw her friend happy and convinced herself she loved Harry. I HATED her changing for a man she spent most of the book feeling lukewarm about. I absolutely got the ick.
March 24, 2020
This clean and sweet regency romance was amazing.
This is the first book I’ve read by Jennie Goutet, and it will definitely not be my last. Everything is on point here: The village setting; the details about the homes that make it a true regency story; the descriptions of the parties and dancing; and the snappy dialogue between the characters.
Anna and Harry are the couple that give this story its heart. Anna Tunstall is strong, determined, loyal, and compassionate. She has always thought that she’d marry a wealthy man with political ambitions, and combined with her skills in society matters, they would accomplish a great deal of good. But as she visits a friend in a country village, she finds that the rector, Harry Aston, has a strong hold on her heart. Anna’s torn between the society life she’s always thought she wanted, and the quieter life she would have in this village of Avebury. The storyline follows Anna as she determines the truth of her heart. Harry is an unusual regency hero. He loves his calling to minister to the citizens of Avebury and has found a life he loves in the village. It was fun following both Harry and Anna as they tried to decide if they belonged together. There’s also two small mysteries that run throughout the storyline, and I loved how it all tied together at the end.
If you are a fan of clean regency fiction, don’t hesitate to read this one. I’m going to be looking for other books by this author.
This is the first book I’ve read by Jennie Goutet, and it will definitely not be my last. Everything is on point here: The village setting; the details about the homes that make it a true regency story; the descriptions of the parties and dancing; and the snappy dialogue between the characters.
Anna and Harry are the couple that give this story its heart. Anna Tunstall is strong, determined, loyal, and compassionate. She has always thought that she’d marry a wealthy man with political ambitions, and combined with her skills in society matters, they would accomplish a great deal of good. But as she visits a friend in a country village, she finds that the rector, Harry Aston, has a strong hold on her heart. Anna’s torn between the society life she’s always thought she wanted, and the quieter life she would have in this village of Avebury. The storyline follows Anna as she determines the truth of her heart. Harry is an unusual regency hero. He loves his calling to minister to the citizens of Avebury and has found a life he loves in the village. It was fun following both Harry and Anna as they tried to decide if they belonged together. There’s also two small mysteries that run throughout the storyline, and I loved how it all tied together at the end.
If you are a fan of clean regency fiction, don’t hesitate to read this one. I’m going to be looking for other books by this author.
November 8, 2023
I was gifted free access to the audiobook version of A Faithful Proposal by Jennie Goutet with the expectation of offering my honest review – which I’m happily about to do.
Goutet has masterfully developed a host of characters who, right before our eyes (or ears), live out delightful stories of reevaluations, reconciliation, reunions, and requited love with the perfect amount of tension and release to keep a reader intrigued. While anyone who regularly enjoys the clean romance and historical romance genre might suspect how the story will end, the journey there is expertly crafted with all the formalities of period-accurate vernacular and multiple brilliantly woven stories with not one dull moment.
As an avid audiobook connoisseur, the audiobook is so well done and was a joy to listen to! I could easily imagine each character as the narrator, Annadee Morgan, fantastically maneuvered through each voice – which, with the plethora of characters involved, was surely no easy task.
As I was listening, my husband asked, “Jane Austen?” I’ve included this in my review not intending to compare but to offer high praise to Goutet and Morgan.
As a professional writer and editor, I am naturally drawn to critique, but I found no fault in this lovely book. It was a five-star read and listen, leaving me with joy and gratitude for nine+ hours of my time well spent.
Goutet has masterfully developed a host of characters who, right before our eyes (or ears), live out delightful stories of reevaluations, reconciliation, reunions, and requited love with the perfect amount of tension and release to keep a reader intrigued. While anyone who regularly enjoys the clean romance and historical romance genre might suspect how the story will end, the journey there is expertly crafted with all the formalities of period-accurate vernacular and multiple brilliantly woven stories with not one dull moment.
As an avid audiobook connoisseur, the audiobook is so well done and was a joy to listen to! I could easily imagine each character as the narrator, Annadee Morgan, fantastically maneuvered through each voice – which, with the plethora of characters involved, was surely no easy task.
As I was listening, my husband asked, “Jane Austen?” I’ve included this in my review not intending to compare but to offer high praise to Goutet and Morgan.
As a professional writer and editor, I am naturally drawn to critique, but I found no fault in this lovely book. It was a five-star read and listen, leaving me with joy and gratitude for nine+ hours of my time well spent.
November 15, 2023
Anna knows and loves London society - she belongs and can make a difference. A visit to a friend in the country is all very well, but however delightful the place or the people, it's not where she's meant to be long-term - even if the parson is Harry Aston, a conversationalist like none she's ever met before. As she sees more of him, she starts to wonder whether a different future might be possible - but when members of the ton come to visit, she's faced once again with the difference between what she always expected and what Harry offers. Will she work out what she really wants in life before it's too late?
This is an enjoyable romance in itself, but it also has in the background a mystery that provides added interest. The family relationships are somewhat depressing, but watching Anna gradually come to recognise what's important in life was worth it - and the unexpected visitors who appear near the end added the perfect touch. Harry was a great character, his cook a delightful secondary character, and Anna a person worth getting to know - particularly later in the book. The reading was done well, making it a pleasure to listen to as well as being a good story. All in all, a great read and I look forward to more by the author.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
This is an enjoyable romance in itself, but it also has in the background a mystery that provides added interest. The family relationships are somewhat depressing, but watching Anna gradually come to recognise what's important in life was worth it - and the unexpected visitors who appear near the end added the perfect touch. Harry was a great character, his cook a delightful secondary character, and Anna a person worth getting to know - particularly later in the book. The reading was done well, making it a pleasure to listen to as well as being a good story. All in all, a great read and I look forward to more by the author.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
September 29, 2022
A Faithful Proposal: A Regency Romance (Memorable Proposals Book 2)
Pages 305
⭐️⭐️💫
PROS:
◇Available in 🎧📚
◇Closed Door Romance/Clean Romance
CONS:
◇Really Long 🥱
◇Two Brothers Fight for one women TROPE 😔
◇Misunderstandings trope
◇Unlikable Charters 😪
◇MISCOMMUNICATION trope😡
I am really sad about this one I almost dropped it. I enjoyed book 1 but not this one .
Content Warning ⚠️
~Violence
~Sexual assult
(Forced grabing & kissing)
Book Synopsis:
"With a few well-placed words in the right ear, Anna Tunstall can direct anyone to do her bidding, exactly the skill needed for one destined to be the wife of a man in politics. A summer visit to a friend’s country estate is the perfect distraction before the London Season begins and Anna can achieve her ambition of a perfect match.
Harry Aston has spurned the noble aspirations of his family to enter holy orders where he might make a difference in people’s lives. His mother’s untiring attempts to find him a wife worthy—and wealthy—enough to suit him only serve to set up his back. He has never been in love, and she should not think that suitable wives dropped down from heaven, especially not in the village of Avebury."
Pages 305
⭐️⭐️💫
PROS:
◇Available in 🎧📚
◇Closed Door Romance/Clean Romance
CONS:
◇Really Long 🥱
◇Two Brothers Fight for one women TROPE 😔
◇Misunderstandings trope
◇Unlikable Charters 😪
◇MISCOMMUNICATION trope😡
I am really sad about this one I almost dropped it. I enjoyed book 1 but not this one .
Content Warning ⚠️
~Violence
~Sexual assult
(Forced grabing & kissing)
Book Synopsis:
"With a few well-placed words in the right ear, Anna Tunstall can direct anyone to do her bidding, exactly the skill needed for one destined to be the wife of a man in politics. A summer visit to a friend’s country estate is the perfect distraction before the London Season begins and Anna can achieve her ambition of a perfect match.
Harry Aston has spurned the noble aspirations of his family to enter holy orders where he might make a difference in people’s lives. His mother’s untiring attempts to find him a wife worthy—and wealthy—enough to suit him only serve to set up his back. He has never been in love, and she should not think that suitable wives dropped down from heaven, especially not in the village of Avebury."
Displaying 1 - 30 of 182 reviews