Please see the publishers warning about triggers.
3.5 rounded up
Gale Reynolds reports a terrifying sexual assault to the police with DS Shona White interviewing her. Although Shona believes her she is told to drop the case as Gail has previously made a “false report“. However, two years later Gail is trying to move on with her life, although it is understandably incredibly difficult. Then Gail meets another victim with an identical story to hers and one chilling “coincidence“. What will Gail do? Will she take what action she can before he strikes again? The story is told via three points of view.
This is a brave book and I commend the author for the job she does here. It’s obviously hard-hitting as it should be, it portrays the suffering and trauma also as it should but it’s not overdone though still makes for grim reading. There’s much to reflect on here as not only has Gail and others been forced to endure the trauma of an assault there is the trauma of reporting it and the trauma of what comes after making that report. It’s chilling how some victims can be treated, especially on social media and this is done horribly well in the book with keyboard warriors and incels doing their despicable worst. There is accuracy too in the amount of assaults that never make it to trial often due to insufficient evidence and your heart breaks for those people.
Gail’s perspective is very compelling and powerful, I like how she addresses her attacker making it so personal which hits all the harder. It makes you feel sad, shocked and moved in equal proportions. Shona’s point of view is also good and you feel the frustration of believing a victim with the inability to secure a conviction. The rapists narrative is horrifying as you’d expect sending shivers down the spine ,
As the story progresses, it encompasses a number of things such as female bonds and friendship, which gives the courage to take back control of your life, in this case dramatically.
Although there is much to praise it does get a bit repetitive and the writing is a bit flat on occasions and the pacing is somewhat uneven. I guess the perpetrator about halfway through so there’s no huge surprise there.
Overall though, it’s well worth reading if you can because it does make some very thought-provoking points.
With thanks to NetGalley and especially to Avon Books for the much appreciated arc in return for an honest review.