Holly by Sharon Srock was a really interesting read. Holly and Sage are sisters, and they're the pair of characters that got my attention from Ember's story when they were introduced, so I was actually looking forward to their story. I'm not sure if I ever thought what their background would entail (it's heartbreaking), but my heart definitely went out to Holly. Her story definitely portrays the lengths to which God will go to reach anyone. Now, going in, I knew the elements of the Nativity set would come to life, so I was kinda wary about that aspect, but still decided to give it a go. I was pleasantly surprised that I enjoyed most of their appearances, and that it was pretty accurate biblically speaking, though not completely perfect (the names of the Magi, Gabriel visiting Mary but not being the one sent "six months prior to someone else", etc). Still, God's love shines through all of it, and it was intriguing getting to experience the Christmas message in this way. As for Riley, the only "but" (that is on me) was that I'm used to hearing this name for a woman, so it was hard for me to reconcile it to a male throughout the story. Still, I really liked his relationship with the Lord and how he was willing to serve others and care for the people God placed in his path. Yes, there are also valuable lessons he gets to learn, and I also enjoyed how his relationship with Holly developed. Of course, with his being a minister and her being an unbeliever, it made for some really deep, no-easy-answers conversations.
As for the narrator, I think she was good at bringing most of the characters to life (from little kids to older people, from Riley's smooth tone to Holly's kinda snarky one, and everything in between). There may be some room for improvement since there were some parts of Riley and Holly's conversations where their voices sounded similar, but as for nuances of emotions, I think she nailed all of them (especially the tremors when scared, or the tearful voices both from sorrow or joy).
Overall, a unique Christmas story and a great addition to the series (though it can be read on its own). Perfect for fans of the author, the series, and/or the Christian Contemporary Romance genre. Looking forward to the next! ~ 4.5 stars