3.75 stars
There are some gems here. Though it is two pages long, I personally think Pancakes is the best Hellboy story. It's the cutest, funniest and most endearing tale featuring a two year old Hellboy.
The Midnight Circus is also one of the best stories from this collection. Kid Hellboy overhears a colleague of Professor Bruttenholm telling him to reconsider his adoption and care of Hellboy, so he runs away and stumbles onto the circus. It is a tale inspired by Pinocchio.
Personally, I love seeing stories from Hellboy's childhood. There's something so pure and innocent about a demon boy being raised with compassion and love by a human. It makes it even bittersweet when remembering Hellboy's later and lonely years as an adult.
This volume also collects all of Hellboy in Mexico. That's a mixed bag for me. Some good, some very bad, some I found really creepy. I liked the main storyline, where Hellboy's devastated by losing his friend.
In the later half, there's The Crooked Man. Man, maybe the creepiest Hellboy story? It's just that the art alone is terrifying. It's a tale about witches. Richard Corben did an amazing job with the story.
The Corpse is another highlight. The story of the baby (Alice) who was stolen by a changeling (Gruagach) and how Hellboy is forced to carry a corpse and to bury him before sunrise so he can save Alice from the Irish fairies. It's funny, dark and full of mythology. So that's already great, but it's also a great story to have considering how important the characters of Alice and Gruagach become later on.
Hellboy: Double feature of Evil is also collected here. I loved these two short stories. They are so fun. In such short time, and with the dead watching Hellboy's missions as if they were a movie, Mignola and Corben just deliver classic Hellboy escapades.
In total, of the sixteen short stories collected here, most of them are good, a few of them don't quite reach that mark. However, all of them are just quintessential Hellboy. Creepy stories, full of wonder and tragedy, full of folklore and nightmares, of evil characters and supernatural creatures. And in the midst of it all, Hellboy is there to help anyone who needs a hand.