What do you think?
Rate this book
The Winter Souls #2
A Heart as Red as Paint
"Deck the halls with bells and folly..."
Helen Bell has changed since facing off with Mara Rouge in the Quarrel of Sword and Bone. But so has Winter.
When a Timepiece crosses the intersect to give Helen a set of three warnings in the form of a puzzle, she's forced to re-enter the world she thought she might never see again to solve it before she meets a deadly end.
But things are different in Winter. Things that were once proudly colourful have been painted red, and the Patrolman who swore to always be there for her has his own demons to face. Helen is forced to hide in plain sight by impersonating a Red Kingdom celebrity, all to follow the leads and solve the Timepiece's puzzle before she's taken and Winter's last Carrier of Truth is silenced forever.
A Heart as Red as Paint is the second installment of The Winter Souls Series; a faith-based Christmas collection for teens, with characters from old holiday legends and folklore.
Helen Bell has changed since facing off with Mara Rouge in the Quarrel of Sword and Bone. But so has Winter.
When a Timepiece crosses the intersect to give Helen a set of three warnings in the form of a puzzle, she's forced to re-enter the world she thought she might never see again to solve it before she meets a deadly end.
But things are different in Winter. Things that were once proudly colourful have been painted red, and the Patrolman who swore to always be there for her has his own demons to face. Helen is forced to hide in plain sight by impersonating a Red Kingdom celebrity, all to follow the leads and solve the Timepiece's puzzle before she's taken and Winter's last Carrier of Truth is silenced forever.
A Heart as Red as Paint is the second installment of The Winter Souls Series; a faith-based Christmas collection for teens, with characters from old holiday legends and folklore.
418 pages, Kindle Edition
Published November 10, 2021
133 people are currently reading
5782 people want to read
About the author
Jennifer Kropf
16 books890 followersJennifer Kropf spent her college years bored to death (nearly) in marketing and advertising classes, and graduated only to discover once and for all that her true passion is telling stories. She lives amidst lush Ontario farmland with her husband and three kids, reads obsessively, and writes even more obsessively. She thinks tea is gross and coffee is great and secretly wishes Peter Pan will show up on some cool summer evening and ask if she wants to visit Neverland.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 148 reviews
January 5, 2025
"My face broke and I smiled. 'You want me to stay this time?' I realized, and he huffed.
'I wanted you to stay last time. I'll want your to stay every time.' He pulled his Patrol staff out again and proceeded with his walk. 'You're going to have to get used to that,' he added with a mutter."
**the image above is NOT mine. I found it online.**
*sighs and smiles dreamily*
Someone please tell me when the intersect opens next because I really gotta go to Winter. ASAP.
Kropf did it again. A Heart as Red as Paint was a spectacular addition to the Winter Souls series. I loved the different setting of the Crimson Court in this one. Seeing Helen act as Scarlet Stranage was so cool! I loved the worldbuilding, from the Library to the Crimson Court, to Cane's little cave... this book was imagery rich, and the food portrayals just made my mouth water. Someone have Apple whip me up a batch of those delectable goodies!
Jennifer Kropf has an incredible brain. Each book is so unique and yet so interesting in their own way. The way this book was written with riddles and the Timepiece's visits... ingenious! I just can't stop fawning over the intersect, orbs, the land of Winter, the patrol staffs, and the TRAIN, OHMYGOSH THE TRAIN! IT'S SO COOL, I'VE LITERALLY HAD DREAMS ABOUT IT LOLL.
I loved Helen's character development. She changed a lot and forged her own path of independence. Whereas in the first book, she was a little weaker and needed more help, in this book she found her own way and improved dramatically. I also love how she wasn't portrayed as overtly powerful, but rather a brave and strong carrier or the Truth. She wasn't a favorite of mine, though. I don't know, I just never clicked with her, but I do respect her, and how far she's come.
The characters in all were so uniquely written, and I loved their depictions. I loved the Crimson Court's royal family; it was kinda like the Hawthorne Brothers mixed with the Ballenger family. If you know me, you know I love political/court intrigue, and this book had such an interesting amount of that! I loved the ambiguity around Cane and Zane's mom, and how we got little cameos of Helen's grandma and siblings; the end had me worried, but it was all right! But all in all, the characters were so homely and endearing, so courageous in times of peril.
There were soo many Christian parallels and quotes hidden in here, little nuggets for us believers to find, and it was so seamlessly added that even if you're not a Christian, they're still enjoyable! I love Elowin's symbolism of God, and the war between light and darkness; good and evil.
A few critiques: I feel Kropf's depiction of high school was very stereotypical, and it was written like what happens to students is what happens everywhere. I don't know, I had the same thought regarding the first book, and I just think she needs to find a middleground. Though the problems Winston faced and the conflicts high schoolers face were represented well, I think.
I loved Helen and Zane's romance! It was developed even more in here, and the subtle or not-so-subtle glances and touches just made my heart warm. The *tEnSiOn* was soo good, especially with Quinten and Eliot... ahhh, the green monster appeared! *smirks*
But, once again, Kropf's worldbuilding was phenomenal and the imagery was just *chef's kiss* I loved Apple's dresses; they were soo pretty and I could envision them perfectly!
To conclude, whether you're a Christian or not, I believe everyone can enjoy this series! It's definitely one of my favorite series, and I look forward to reading A Crown as Sharp as Pine! I also Hihgly recommend reading Kropf's rom-com fae fantasy series, starting with Welcome to Fae Cafe; it's absolutely adorable, and you'll fall in love with the characters from the very first page! 🍫 This series is best enjoyed with beautifully crafted chocolates and steaming hot cocoa ☕
❤️⚔️🍫👑❤️⚔️🍫👑❤️⚔️🍫👑❤️⚔️🍫👑❤️⚔️🍫👑❤️⚔️🍫👑
'I wanted you to stay last time. I'll want your to stay every time.' He pulled his Patrol staff out again and proceeded with his walk. 'You're going to have to get used to that,' he added with a mutter."
**the image above is NOT mine. I found it online.**
*sighs and smiles dreamily*
Someone please tell me when the intersect opens next because I really gotta go to Winter. ASAP.
Kropf did it again. A Heart as Red as Paint was a spectacular addition to the Winter Souls series. I loved the different setting of the Crimson Court in this one. Seeing Helen act as Scarlet Stranage was so cool! I loved the worldbuilding, from the Library to the Crimson Court, to Cane's little cave... this book was imagery rich, and the food portrayals just made my mouth water. Someone have Apple whip me up a batch of those delectable goodies!
Jennifer Kropf has an incredible brain. Each book is so unique and yet so interesting in their own way. The way this book was written with riddles and the Timepiece's visits... ingenious! I just can't stop fawning over the intersect, orbs, the land of Winter, the patrol staffs, and the TRAIN, OHMYGOSH THE TRAIN! IT'S SO COOL, I'VE LITERALLY HAD DREAMS ABOUT IT LOLL.
I loved Helen's character development. She changed a lot and forged her own path of independence. Whereas in the first book, she was a little weaker and needed more help, in this book she found her own way and improved dramatically. I also love how she wasn't portrayed as overtly powerful, but rather a brave and strong carrier or the Truth. She wasn't a favorite of mine, though. I don't know, I just never clicked with her, but I do respect her, and how far she's come.
The characters in all were so uniquely written, and I loved their depictions. I loved the Crimson Court's royal family; it was kinda like the Hawthorne Brothers mixed with the Ballenger family. If you know me, you know I love political/court intrigue, and this book had such an interesting amount of that! I loved the ambiguity around Cane and Zane's mom, and how we got little cameos of Helen's grandma and siblings; the end had me worried, but it was all right! But all in all, the characters were so homely and endearing, so courageous in times of peril.
There were soo many Christian parallels and quotes hidden in here, little nuggets for us believers to find, and it was so seamlessly added that even if you're not a Christian, they're still enjoyable! I love Elowin's symbolism of God, and the war between light and darkness; good and evil.
A few critiques: I feel Kropf's depiction of high school was very stereotypical, and it was written like what happens to students is what happens everywhere. I don't know, I had the same thought regarding the first book, and I just think she needs to find a middleground. Though the problems Winston faced and the conflicts high schoolers face were represented well, I think.
I loved Helen and Zane's romance! It was developed even more in here, and the subtle or not-so-subtle glances and touches just made my heart warm. The *tEnSiOn* was soo good, especially with Quinten and Eliot... ahhh, the green monster appeared! *smirks*
But, once again, Kropf's worldbuilding was phenomenal and the imagery was just *chef's kiss* I loved Apple's dresses; they were soo pretty and I could envision them perfectly!
To conclude, whether you're a Christian or not, I believe everyone can enjoy this series! It's definitely one of my favorite series, and I look forward to reading A Crown as Sharp as Pine! I also Hihgly recommend reading Kropf's rom-com fae fantasy series, starting with Welcome to Fae Cafe; it's absolutely adorable, and you'll fall in love with the characters from the very first page! 🍫 This series is best enjoyed with beautifully crafted chocolates and steaming hot cocoa ☕
❤️⚔️🍫👑❤️⚔️🍫👑❤️⚔️🍫👑❤️⚔️🍫👑❤️⚔️🍫👑❤️⚔️🍫👑
November 6, 2021
Wow. This book was amazing. It picks up a year after A Soul As Cold As Frost and I was so excited to reunite with these characters guys!😍
I loved the first one but I might have liked this one even more. This one is action-packed, y’all. I was so into it. It was hard to put down. There’s a dangerous mission, deceitful princes, secret identities, and an amazing allegory. I really loved the royalty aspect! I’ve always really liked the secret identity trope because it keeps things interesting. I was on the edge of my seat basically the whole time. Not to mention some plot twists thrown in there…
I really liked how the books was separated into parts. It broke things up and made it interesting.
Reuniting with these characters made me really happy. I literally felt like I was going with Helen back into the world of Winter. I felt the anticipation and excitement of seeing old friends. It was so much fun!
Of course I couldn’t wait to see Zane again. Honestly, he’s just one of my favorites. He’s a complex character and I loved that I got to know more about him in this book.
Lucas too.💙 Both of them are great.
Alsooo as a romantic I’ve got to say, I loved seeing Zane and Helen’s friendship grow into a bit more. I ship them so hard! 😭 Ahh, I love those two!
The allegory is so beautifully woven in. It’s my favorite part of this series. It’s filled with so much hope and it inspires me. There’s hope and light in the darkness, even when we can’t seem to see it. That message shines throughout these books.
I love the feel/ aesthetic of the books. Christmasy, wintery, cozy— seriously perfect for winter evenings. It’s got such Narnia vibes and I love it! 😍 If you’re looking for a good November/ December/ January read, this book is it!
I’d definitely recommending the first in the series so you know the characters and know what’s happening. Plus the first book is just really good!♥️
So that ending was bittersweet. I already can’t wait for more books in this series!! Im attached to these characters. ♥️🥺
In conclusion, this second book in the Winter Souls blew me away. It had it all. It had an exciting plot, amazing characters, plot twists, and great writing. I’m soo excited for more books in this series. I definitely recommend, especially if you love Narnia and fantasy!
*Thanks to the author for an ARC in exchange for a review. All opinions are my own.
I loved the first one but I might have liked this one even more. This one is action-packed, y’all. I was so into it. It was hard to put down. There’s a dangerous mission, deceitful princes, secret identities, and an amazing allegory. I really loved the royalty aspect! I’ve always really liked the secret identity trope because it keeps things interesting. I was on the edge of my seat basically the whole time. Not to mention some plot twists thrown in there…
I really liked how the books was separated into parts. It broke things up and made it interesting.
Reuniting with these characters made me really happy. I literally felt like I was going with Helen back into the world of Winter. I felt the anticipation and excitement of seeing old friends. It was so much fun!
Of course I couldn’t wait to see Zane again. Honestly, he’s just one of my favorites. He’s a complex character and I loved that I got to know more about him in this book.
Lucas too.💙 Both of them are great.
Alsooo as a romantic I’ve got to say, I loved seeing Zane and Helen’s friendship grow into a bit more. I ship them so hard! 😭 Ahh, I love those two!
The allegory is so beautifully woven in. It’s my favorite part of this series. It’s filled with so much hope and it inspires me. There’s hope and light in the darkness, even when we can’t seem to see it. That message shines throughout these books.
I love the feel/ aesthetic of the books. Christmasy, wintery, cozy— seriously perfect for winter evenings. It’s got such Narnia vibes and I love it! 😍 If you’re looking for a good November/ December/ January read, this book is it!
I’d definitely recommending the first in the series so you know the characters and know what’s happening. Plus the first book is just really good!♥️
So that ending was bittersweet. I already can’t wait for more books in this series!! Im attached to these characters. ♥️🥺
In conclusion, this second book in the Winter Souls blew me away. It had it all. It had an exciting plot, amazing characters, plot twists, and great writing. I’m soo excited for more books in this series. I definitely recommend, especially if you love Narnia and fantasy!
*Thanks to the author for an ARC in exchange for a review. All opinions are my own.
January 1, 2022
Helen was a liiiittle annoying, but Zane made up for it!💜 Still haven't figured out why she has to be a carrier, but in a way she's as interesting a character as the others and I like her.
I love winter (the world and the season) and I. Just. Can't. Wait. For the next books!
I love winter (the world and the season) and I. Just. Can't. Wait. For the next books!
February 19, 2024
the way I was like “one more chapter” and then finished the book
January 2, 2022
"Truly I couldn't imagine anything more wonderful than a booklover wandering through a secret library at night."
Me too, Helen, Me too.
This is the second installment in the Winter Souls Series and I think I loved this one even more than the first?!
There were twists and turns, edge-of-your-seat-inducing moments, and I had a lot of fun trying to guess who was who and what side they were on. Even when I correctly suspected one particular person, I was still shocked!
I loved meeting back up with familiar characters but also loved meeting new ones.
I want to know more about Cane! He's an interesting character and it would be cool if we get to see more of him and a certain golden-eyed young lady in the next book!
Helen and Zane's friendship starts becoming something more in this book and I loved their cute and serious moments. I really hope they end up together! I ship them.
The world-building was so intriguing, I could read an encyclopedia dedicated to the world of Winter (which is why I am so happy that the author will be coming up with something like this in the future.
The allegory continues to be a blessing and I appreciated every mention of prayer.
"Should someone be kind enough to gift you a prayer, you ought to then pass a prayer on to someone else. The prayer you send might be precisely what that person needs at that exact time."
"For worship is a cry of war, you see."
I wish I had these books growing up but am glad I've got them now because this series is becoming a favorite.
THAT ENDING. That was like my favorite scene, I think? I wish it was on the big screen so I could see it play out. But with Kropf's descriptive writing style, it was easy to visualize in my head. :)
I look forward to when all the books are out so I can buy them and have them on my bookshelf. <3
Me too, Helen, Me too.
This is the second installment in the Winter Souls Series and I think I loved this one even more than the first?!
There were twists and turns, edge-of-your-seat-inducing moments, and I had a lot of fun trying to guess who was who and what side they were on. Even when I correctly suspected one particular person, I was still shocked!
I loved meeting back up with familiar characters but also loved meeting new ones.
I want to know more about Cane! He's an interesting character and it would be cool if we get to see more of him and a certain golden-eyed young lady in the next book!
Helen and Zane's friendship starts becoming something more in this book and I loved their cute and serious moments. I really hope they end up together! I ship them.
The world-building was so intriguing, I could read an encyclopedia dedicated to the world of Winter (which is why I am so happy that the author will be coming up with something like this in the future.
The allegory continues to be a blessing and I appreciated every mention of prayer.
"Should someone be kind enough to gift you a prayer, you ought to then pass a prayer on to someone else. The prayer you send might be precisely what that person needs at that exact time."
"For worship is a cry of war, you see."
I wish I had these books growing up but am glad I've got them now because this series is becoming a favorite.
THAT ENDING. That was like my favorite scene, I think? I wish it was on the big screen so I could see it play out. But with Kropf's descriptive writing style, it was easy to visualize in my head. :)
I look forward to when all the books are out so I can buy them and have them on my bookshelf. <3
November 10, 2021
I was eager to get back to Winter with Helen and her patrolman. (I adore Zane.) This book picks up a short while after the ending of A Soul As Cold As Frost. Helen is drawn back to Winter by a mysterious entity and finds that something is brewing in the Red Kingdom...and it's not hot chocolate.
This book felt a bit more grown up than the first. Darker characters and themes. Romance (super sweet and clean). I would recommend to middle school readers+ who enjoy fantasy and adventure reads.
I love how Kropf sprinkles in elements of faith throughout the series. It has a very C.S. Lewis feel. And her world building is very reminiscent of Narnia. I also enjoy her nods to various Christmas characters. It's clever and creative.
This book felt a bit more grown up than the first. Darker characters and themes. Romance (super sweet and clean). I would recommend to middle school readers+ who enjoy fantasy and adventure reads.
I love how Kropf sprinkles in elements of faith throughout the series. It has a very C.S. Lewis feel. And her world building is very reminiscent of Narnia. I also enjoy her nods to various Christmas characters. It's clever and creative.
January 5, 2023
I am really enjoying this series. Better than the first book!
June 5, 2024
I have never been this GAGGED by a book, gaslit gatekeeped and girl bosses so hard since Animal Farm and that’s saying something
October 24, 2025
This book was so good! The characters were amazing and I loved seeing how much they grew from the first book but also seeing how much more they still have to learn. I honestly wanted to cry many times, it has so much depth and good faith content in it! Highly recommend!
January 13, 2023
I’m not really sure how to describe this story. It’s fascinating and extremely well-narrated (I listened to it on Audible). A bit predictable at times, but the story still kept me going. I hope the rest of the series comes out on Audible soon!
I really appreciate clean fantasy! So thank you very much, Jennifer Kropf! Please keep writing. :)
I really appreciate clean fantasy! So thank you very much, Jennifer Kropf! Please keep writing. :)
October 22, 2025
ok... I just HAD to rewrite my review... I have not stopped thinking about this book since I closed it, I have re-read chapter 28 over ten times.... I've officially deemed this book "my favorite book of all time" 6 🌟 yall
March 28, 2025
Nooo whyyyyyyyyyyyy
I can't get the image of Zane drowning in red paint out of my heaaaaaddd
Okay so this book was rough
And THEORY TIME (usually I'm too oblivious to make theories, much less theories that actually are relevant but still)
So the fruit symbolizes affection right (so adorable ngl. Instead of candy it's fruit. But what happens if it's fruit shaped candy...)
And the magician gave her a white apple
WASNT THE MAGICIAN JOLLY CHEAT??
and if so
MAYBE HE IS A PERV-
*dainty cough
Orrrr possible Helen reminds him of a certain someone that he used the love, hence why he's trying to rizz up a teenager.
...
For lack of a better word, yes I used rizz *bows
And also, if we didn't have multiple POVs in this I'd hate Zane for only liking Helen when she was all dolled up by Apple.
...
But evidently that wasn't the only reason why he liked her so I guess I won't hunt him down and shove a pike through his ear
And Quinten
Quintin Quintin Quintin
I thought you were adorable and prolly wouldn't last in Helen's life then you proved yourself to be a UGLY FILTHY ASSUALTING POSIONING BETRAYING AWFUL SNAKE
LITERALLY.
YOU LEGIT ARE A SNAKE
Anyway
And Winston needs to man up 👍
I can't get the image of Zane drowning in red paint out of my heaaaaaddd
Okay so this book was rough
And THEORY TIME (usually I'm too oblivious to make theories, much less theories that actually are relevant but still)
So the fruit symbolizes affection right (so adorable ngl. Instead of candy it's fruit. But what happens if it's fruit shaped candy...)
And the magician gave her a white apple
WASNT THE MAGICIAN JOLLY CHEAT??
and if so
MAYBE HE IS A PERV-
*dainty cough
Orrrr possible Helen reminds him of a certain someone that he used the love, hence why he's trying to rizz up a teenager.
...
For lack of a better word, yes I used rizz *bows
And also, if we didn't have multiple POVs in this I'd hate Zane for only liking Helen when she was all dolled up by Apple.
...
But evidently that wasn't the only reason why he liked her so I guess I won't hunt him down and shove a pike through his ear
And Quinten
Quintin Quintin Quintin
I thought you were adorable and prolly wouldn't last in Helen's life then you proved yourself to be a UGLY FILTHY ASSUALTING POSIONING BETRAYING AWFUL SNAKE
LITERALLY.
YOU LEGIT ARE A SNAKE
Anyway
And Winston needs to man up 👍
January 24, 2024
This series is like drinking hot chocolate. It’s cozy and sweet and you never want to be done because it just tastes so good yet you can’t stop drinking it and finish it too soon. The religious elements are done without being corny which is much appreciated. The actual book itself is beautiful yet whimsical with fun little details throughout to admire. You can tell so much love was put into crafting the story and the book.
September 4, 2024
"For worship is a cry of war, you see."
September 29, 2024
*4.75*
Ummm, wow! This book was such a wild ride. I was so excited to get back into Winter and see Zane and Helen. I actually enjoyed Helen’s character because she was so real about everything she had to go through. She could have made better decisions, but I could understand why she made those decisions, and it made sense in the story. The role she had to step into was a bit… well, the things is… Let’s just say I had reason to be wary of how it would be described, but I am happy to report that it did not go too far (that’s a yay from me cuz I could see other authors taking this downhill)! I was slightly confused, but it eventually made sense. So far I would say it’s best to binge the series so you don’t get so easily confused (but don’t worry, things will still be explained). Also, Zane’s *redacted* made me nervous because of what profession *redacted* was in. I’m glad the profession was portrayed the way it was. It’s similar to another book I read, but in this world it makes so much sense.
ELOWIN. No words. Loved all the different references.
Zane. Eeeeee! At times I wanted to punch him, but he was honest. He was so amazing. Definitely want more of him. Also, his and Helen’s banter/dynamic was hilarious…stressful, but hilarious.
Content: unwanted kiss (not detailed), allegory and magic that fits into it, minor (not detailed) bullying, mentions of Helen’s clothes and how they could make someone feel something (they recognize it as a not great thing, also [praise the Lord 🙌🏻🙌🏻] her clothes were not described in detail, there was one description of a strap style back but it wasn’t in detail) let’s just say I’m thrilled that what could’ve been immodest and uncomfy was not detailed and I could still read it
Ummm, wow! This book was such a wild ride. I was so excited to get back into Winter and see Zane and Helen. I actually enjoyed Helen’s character because she was so real about everything she had to go through. She could have made better decisions, but I could understand why she made those decisions, and it made sense in the story. The role she had to step into was a bit… well, the things is… Let’s just say I had reason to be wary of how it would be described, but I am happy to report that it did not go too far (that’s a yay from me cuz I could see other authors taking this downhill)! I was slightly confused, but it eventually made sense. So far I would say it’s best to binge the series so you don’t get so easily confused (but don’t worry, things will still be explained). Also, Zane’s *redacted* made me nervous because of what profession *redacted* was in. I’m glad the profession was portrayed the way it was. It’s similar to another book I read, but in this world it makes so much sense.
ELOWIN. No words. Loved all the different references.
Zane. Eeeeee! At times I wanted to punch him, but he was honest. He was so amazing. Definitely want more of him. Also, his and Helen’s banter/dynamic was hilarious…stressful, but hilarious.
Content: unwanted kiss (not detailed), allegory and magic that fits into it, minor (not detailed) bullying, mentions of Helen’s clothes and how they could make someone feel something (they recognize it as a not great thing, also [praise the Lord 🙌🏻🙌🏻] her clothes were not described in detail, there was one description of a strap style back but it wasn’t in detail) let’s just say I’m thrilled that what could’ve been immodest and uncomfy was not detailed and I could still read it
December 10, 2024
⭐⭐⭐ I don't normally post reviews because they take more time than I usually have, but I wrote this review for my friends and decided to post on here too.
So... I have mixed feelings.
World building... I love the world and think it has a lot of potential. I do however wish we got to see how it interacts with the real world more. The world of "Winter" has what they call "The Truth." The book even mentioned church, and I'd like to know how that interacts with the bible. Because it seems like everyone but Helen is unaware of this "Truth" and thinks she's a lil crazy. What is christmas about in the "trite" world then? A few questions I'd like to see answered. 🤷🏼♀️
As far as Characters go... I liked the MC's well enough. They make some dumb decisions throughout (which is relatable) so I don't necessarily hold it against them. Although the lack of communication is 😩 quite frustrating. And annoying. Helen is a bit flat as a character (she doesn't have enough questions for her situation) and she's pretty gullible.
Elliot felt out of place... And like he was only there to cause drama. Didn't give a real reason for his actions
But overall my main beef with the book was the writing. Well not the writing particularly (it was rather poetic) it's more how the characters do stuff that doesn't quite make sense for them as a character. Sort of random choices and a lot of "huh🤨" moments. like one chapter the characters are getting along swimmingly, and the next they're fighting over something random.
I like when the characters move the plot forward, and this book seems more like the plot drives the characters. (Dunno if that makes sense)
That being said I'm curious enough to keep reading them. I like the overall storyline. It just feels like something is missing.
So... I have mixed feelings.
World building... I love the world and think it has a lot of potential. I do however wish we got to see how it interacts with the real world more. The world of "Winter" has what they call "The Truth." The book even mentioned church, and I'd like to know how that interacts with the bible. Because it seems like everyone but Helen is unaware of this "Truth" and thinks she's a lil crazy. What is christmas about in the "trite" world then? A few questions I'd like to see answered. 🤷🏼♀️
As far as Characters go... I liked the MC's well enough. They make some dumb decisions throughout (which is relatable) so I don't necessarily hold it against them. Although the lack of communication is 😩 quite frustrating. And annoying. Helen is a bit flat as a character (she doesn't have enough questions for her situation) and she's pretty gullible.
Elliot felt out of place... And like he was only there to cause drama. Didn't give a real reason for his actions
But overall my main beef with the book was the writing. Well not the writing particularly (it was rather poetic) it's more how the characters do stuff that doesn't quite make sense for them as a character. Sort of random choices and a lot of "huh🤨" moments. like one chapter the characters are getting along swimmingly, and the next they're fighting over something random.
I like when the characters move the plot forward, and this book seems more like the plot drives the characters. (Dunno if that makes sense)
That being said I'm curious enough to keep reading them. I like the overall storyline. It just feels like something is missing.
October 18, 2025
4.75⭐️ I haven’t had a book that made me stay up late in a while but this book changed that
March 26, 2023
ja nez zas je ovaj series tako nepoznat jer su knjige tako dobre i entertaining i likovi su tako dobro napisani
winston me tako nervirao u ovoj knjizi u prosloj je bio bolji I BILO JE MALO ROMANCE IZMEDJU HELEN I ZANEA <33333 valja cekat da mi dodje treci dio tho :( i nadam se da helen ostane u winter na kraju
winston me tako nervirao u ovoj knjizi u prosloj je bio bolji I BILO JE MALO ROMANCE IZMEDJU HELEN I ZANEA <33333 valja cekat da mi dodje treci dio tho :( i nadam se da helen ostane u winter na kraju
January 12, 2025
I read the first book of this series during Christmas of 2023 and loved it so much that I decided I would read book 2 come Christmas of 2024, and so on. (This plan especially works since there’s a whole year between each story in the books, too.) So when Christmas of 2024 rolled around, I excitedly grabbed this second book and started reading!
It was well worth the wait! I enjoy these characters and this world so much. The whimsy of the writing style is also delightful.
If I thought that things couldn’t get more exciting and intriguing than book 1, I was wrong. This story had so many twists and turns, I truly didn’t know what to expect! We see our characters going to the dangerous Red Kingdom in disguise, but even as Helen thinks she’s fooling everyone, she’s getting the wool pulled over her eyes at the same time. And I can’t even criticize her for it because I got thoroughly fooled, too. And that wasn’t even the end of all the surprise reveals that I totally didn’t see coming, even though I really should have, but Jennifer Kropf is just that good!
I loved seeing characters old and new. Apple and her sweet and faithful personality was my favorite new character, but I was also delighted to meet this world’s version of the Sugar Plum Fairy who is actually more like the Sugar Plum Warrior Angel. Zane and Helen also had some growing and changing to do and I love seeing their relationship be challenged and developed.
I felt so sorry for Lucas and all the things he went through in this story, but it was great to see that his spirit couldn’t be crushed and he was going to come back fighting. It was also interesting to learn more about a certain other Patrolman and his *cough* issues. Maybe there will be a redemption arc for him further down the line, but if not… well, he certainly made his choices in this story.
AND THAT ENDING! For one thing the climax was so intense and exciting and I just couldn’t stop reading! But also Jennifer Kropf is the master of making me NEED the next book because in those last couple of chatpers whaaaaaaat! What just happened? How can this be? What’s going to happen next? How is this going to impact things? I NEED TO KNOW!
Y’all, I am not exaggerating when I tell you that I’m experiencing something of a conundrum because I’ve loved reading book 1 and book 2 at Christmas these past two years, and I want to read book 3 at Christmas of 2025 BUT I also want to read book 3 NOW because of that ending and just really really really wanting to know what’s going to happen! 😅 So, um… I’ve got some decisions to make, LOL.
Until then, I HIGHLY recommend this series as a fun, unique, and exciting Christmas themed fantasy series!
Content Advisory
This book is YA, and while it is also plenty appropriate for preteens who are reading up, there are some more intense moments and scarier elements that parents may want to be aware of to make sure this book is right for your unique child.
Language:
A couple of uses of the British profanity, “Bloody”. Otherwise there were only made up ones like “Ragnashuk” and “frostbite.”
Sexual/Romance:
Nothing sexual occurs. The romantic tension between Zane and Helen has increased so that it’s more overt than in book one, and there is some romantic tension between another boy and girl as well.
Helen notices Zane’s muscles under his jacket a time or two.
There is semi-frequent hand or arm holding, frequent physical closeness (Zane standing close to Helen in a protective and occasionally romantic manner), and occasionally, looking at someone’s lips.
One romantic kiss is very brief and barely described.
An evil person forces a kiss on Helen.
One character is flirtatious with Helen, commenting on her beauty and the like.
A couple of young men comment on the attractiveness (and distracting nature) of the dresses Helen wears when in disguise as a noble.
Mentions of some rich women wearing sheer dresses but no detailed description of exactly how sheer.
Violence:
The world of Winter is just as dangerous as in the previous book. Helen has a couple of dreams where she witnesses various individuals in dangerous situations, and sometimes they appear to be injured, including someone getting burned with flame. These incidents are described with intense emotion, but no graphic details or blood.
A large animal nearly crushes someone (mildly described), but the person survives.
A building burns. People fight attackers, but the violence is not graphically described.
In one of the creepier moments of the story an evil person bites their own lip intentionally to make it bleed with black, venomous blood before forcibly kissing a girl to poison her. This person’s pupils also sometimes turn to slits like a snake’s and they do a lot of manhandling of the poisoned girl, pulling and pushing her around by the arm to make her go places, at least once grabbing her by the hair, and another time chaining her to themselves.
A patrolman who has been captured by villains is implied to have been beaten up to get him to give up important information. The act of him being beaten is never described, but his bruises are described.
Mentions of the Red Kingdom’s arena where they pit prisoners against each other in bloody hand-to-hand combat, but there are no scenes in which any actual deadly combat occurs.
Someone defends himself (while avoiding killing anyone) by knocking multiple combatants unconscious.
Someone evil gets an appendage cut off by a blade. I was a little unclear if it was just the fingers or the whole hand. There’s mention of black blood, but little description beyond that, other than a passing mention of doctors trying to reattach the appendage, and not being able to reattach a mangled thumb.
There is some description of the physical sensation of being poisoned. Mentions of pain and a burning stomach.
Someone evil morphs into a giant snake (the transformation is described and is a little creepy, though not gross). The snake fights and bites multiple people, leaving the bitten ones unconscious. Mentions of people fighting and falling, but never any graphic description.
Spiritual/Magic:
Just as in book 1, faith threads are woven throughout. Prayer and hymns are mentioned multiple times as being powerful tools of battle against evil. Once, it’s mentioned that a hymn causes evil spirits to flee.
The Christ figure, Elowin, is referenced multiple times and there is one interlude that features his perspective while he listens to the prayers of people everywhere.
As in the previous book, various people have magical powers, like the Patrolmen with their ice powers, and other individuals who live in the world of Winter. Patrolmen are protectors and use their magic for good. Others use their powers for evil. One person has snake-like poison and the ability to turn into a giant snake.
One individual called the Timepiece has the ability to temporarily pause time.
There are some scenes with a blind fortune teller who uses a crystal ball. Helen listens to the woman a few times and it’s made very clear that this was not the right thing to do. (The woman’s prediction of the future also turns out to be untrue.
Just like in book one, the biggest villain of the book is possessed. The entity controlling the person is never actually called a demon, though it’s very clear from the way it behaves that that’s what it is. Late in the book we come to learn that this being may be an allegorical version of the devil himself. It is, however, continually made clear that Elowin is stronger than he is and that Elowin will permanently defeat that this evil being when the proper time comes.
It was well worth the wait! I enjoy these characters and this world so much. The whimsy of the writing style is also delightful.
If I thought that things couldn’t get more exciting and intriguing than book 1, I was wrong. This story had so many twists and turns, I truly didn’t know what to expect! We see our characters going to the dangerous Red Kingdom in disguise, but even as Helen thinks she’s fooling everyone, she’s getting the wool pulled over her eyes at the same time. And I can’t even criticize her for it because I got thoroughly fooled, too. And that wasn’t even the end of all the surprise reveals that I totally didn’t see coming, even though I really should have, but Jennifer Kropf is just that good!
I loved seeing characters old and new. Apple and her sweet and faithful personality was my favorite new character, but I was also delighted to meet this world’s version of the Sugar Plum Fairy who is actually more like the Sugar Plum Warrior Angel. Zane and Helen also had some growing and changing to do and I love seeing their relationship be challenged and developed.
I felt so sorry for Lucas and all the things he went through in this story, but it was great to see that his spirit couldn’t be crushed and he was going to come back fighting. It was also interesting to learn more about a certain other Patrolman and his *cough* issues. Maybe there will be a redemption arc for him further down the line, but if not… well, he certainly made his choices in this story.
AND THAT ENDING! For one thing the climax was so intense and exciting and I just couldn’t stop reading! But also Jennifer Kropf is the master of making me NEED the next book because in those last couple of chatpers whaaaaaaat! What just happened? How can this be? What’s going to happen next? How is this going to impact things? I NEED TO KNOW!
Y’all, I am not exaggerating when I tell you that I’m experiencing something of a conundrum because I’ve loved reading book 1 and book 2 at Christmas these past two years, and I want to read book 3 at Christmas of 2025 BUT I also want to read book 3 NOW because of that ending and just really really really wanting to know what’s going to happen! 😅 So, um… I’ve got some decisions to make, LOL.
Until then, I HIGHLY recommend this series as a fun, unique, and exciting Christmas themed fantasy series!
Content Advisory
This book is YA, and while it is also plenty appropriate for preteens who are reading up, there are some more intense moments and scarier elements that parents may want to be aware of to make sure this book is right for your unique child.
Language:
A couple of uses of the British profanity, “Bloody”. Otherwise there were only made up ones like “Ragnashuk” and “frostbite.”
Sexual/Romance:
Nothing sexual occurs. The romantic tension between Zane and Helen has increased so that it’s more overt than in book one, and there is some romantic tension between another boy and girl as well.
Helen notices Zane’s muscles under his jacket a time or two.
There is semi-frequent hand or arm holding, frequent physical closeness (Zane standing close to Helen in a protective and occasionally romantic manner), and occasionally, looking at someone’s lips.
One romantic kiss is very brief and barely described.
An evil person forces a kiss on Helen.
One character is flirtatious with Helen, commenting on her beauty and the like.
A couple of young men comment on the attractiveness (and distracting nature) of the dresses Helen wears when in disguise as a noble.
Mentions of some rich women wearing sheer dresses but no detailed description of exactly how sheer.
Violence:
The world of Winter is just as dangerous as in the previous book. Helen has a couple of dreams where she witnesses various individuals in dangerous situations, and sometimes they appear to be injured, including someone getting burned with flame. These incidents are described with intense emotion, but no graphic details or blood.
A large animal nearly crushes someone (mildly described), but the person survives.
A building burns. People fight attackers, but the violence is not graphically described.
In one of the creepier moments of the story an evil person bites their own lip intentionally to make it bleed with black, venomous blood before forcibly kissing a girl to poison her. This person’s pupils also sometimes turn to slits like a snake’s and they do a lot of manhandling of the poisoned girl, pulling and pushing her around by the arm to make her go places, at least once grabbing her by the hair, and another time chaining her to themselves.
A patrolman who has been captured by villains is implied to have been beaten up to get him to give up important information. The act of him being beaten is never described, but his bruises are described.
Mentions of the Red Kingdom’s arena where they pit prisoners against each other in bloody hand-to-hand combat, but there are no scenes in which any actual deadly combat occurs.
Someone defends himself (while avoiding killing anyone) by knocking multiple combatants unconscious.
Someone evil gets an appendage cut off by a blade. I was a little unclear if it was just the fingers or the whole hand. There’s mention of black blood, but little description beyond that, other than a passing mention of doctors trying to reattach the appendage, and not being able to reattach a mangled thumb.
There is some description of the physical sensation of being poisoned. Mentions of pain and a burning stomach.
Someone evil morphs into a giant snake (the transformation is described and is a little creepy, though not gross). The snake fights and bites multiple people, leaving the bitten ones unconscious. Mentions of people fighting and falling, but never any graphic description.
Spiritual/Magic:
Just as in book 1, faith threads are woven throughout. Prayer and hymns are mentioned multiple times as being powerful tools of battle against evil. Once, it’s mentioned that a hymn causes evil spirits to flee.
The Christ figure, Elowin, is referenced multiple times and there is one interlude that features his perspective while he listens to the prayers of people everywhere.
As in the previous book, various people have magical powers, like the Patrolmen with their ice powers, and other individuals who live in the world of Winter. Patrolmen are protectors and use their magic for good. Others use their powers for evil. One person has snake-like poison and the ability to turn into a giant snake.
One individual called the Timepiece has the ability to temporarily pause time.
There are some scenes with a blind fortune teller who uses a crystal ball. Helen listens to the woman a few times and it’s made very clear that this was not the right thing to do. (The woman’s prediction of the future also turns out to be untrue.
Just like in book one, the biggest villain of the book is possessed. The entity controlling the person is never actually called a demon, though it’s very clear from the way it behaves that that’s what it is. Late in the book we come to learn that this being may be an allegorical version of the devil himself. It is, however, continually made clear that Elowin is stronger than he is and that Elowin will permanently defeat that this evil being when the proper time comes.
April 4, 2023
I have complicated thoughts about this book. So many side storylines seem to start, then fade to nothing. The main female character isn’t completely unlikable, but she can definitely be annoying. She really just seems to make the same errors in judgment over and over again not learning much from the fallout. I found myself struggling to connect to the world of Winter while I have come to care about some of its people. The actual world building to me doesn’t give the same pull as worlds in books like Narina, Lord Of The Rings , or Harry Potter. Some of the big plot shockers are painfully obvious . I will say there were points I wasn’t sure I wanted to keep going. The whole book had been predictable yet somehow still confusing. That being said the last like 25% of the book picks up and the storyline seems to tighten up a good bit some actual growth happens. There did turn out to be an actually shocking betray I did not see coming . The very first time it that a plot Point was not Is blatantly obvious. The biblical undertones for most of this series felt weird to me unnatural almost but towards the end it shifts and it starts to flow into the story and comes across more natural. I will definitely read the last book and I can’t say I ended up regretting reading this one but that answer would have been different for large chunks of the story. I have to say the blooming love story between the two main characters while a bit predictable is sweet minus the repeated miss communication trope. The main male character Zane is a well-written character and I am interested in learning more of his story. I will finish up by saying I think that a lot of people will really enjoy the series even more than I did. I do tend to be a little critical especially about the fantasy books I like . If you are someone you know are just big fantasy readers, then I still recommend giving this series a chance. I feel like this would be the perfect series for the long winter season . Just don’t go in expecting Narina level magic.
P.s The acknowledgement letter from the author was sweet and she sounds like a lovely woman.
P.s The acknowledgement letter from the author was sweet and she sounds like a lovely woman.
April 25, 2022
Wow!!! This is the second book in the series and I loved it!
The further development of the characters as they reconvene a year later in Winter is amazing and this story maybe has a darker, more serious feel to it. The Biblical imagery used is powerful and can be traced throughout the book. One scene further into the story shows how the character was pulled out of ‘the miry clay’ after making decisions that put them there.
Enjoyed learning more about the backgrounds of the characters which have shaped their behaviours in the present story and in the previous book. And how prayers and hymns are spiritual weapons to be employed to battle against the dark - a good reminder for Christian readers.
Looking forward to seeing how Helen’s siblings may be involved in future books and will we find out where Eliot has disappeared to?? I loved the playfulness of the Patrolmen and their joyful enthusiasm near the start of the book made me grin…I dare you not to smile when they prank Helen!!!
Highly recommend this series - please read!
Received this via the Winter World Book Club as a free copy and this is my honest opinion.
The further development of the characters as they reconvene a year later in Winter is amazing and this story maybe has a darker, more serious feel to it. The Biblical imagery used is powerful and can be traced throughout the book. One scene further into the story shows how the character was pulled out of ‘the miry clay’ after making decisions that put them there.
Enjoyed learning more about the backgrounds of the characters which have shaped their behaviours in the present story and in the previous book. And how prayers and hymns are spiritual weapons to be employed to battle against the dark - a good reminder for Christian readers.
Looking forward to seeing how Helen’s siblings may be involved in future books and will we find out where Eliot has disappeared to?? I loved the playfulness of the Patrolmen and their joyful enthusiasm near the start of the book made me grin…I dare you not to smile when they prank Helen!!!
Highly recommend this series - please read!
Received this via the Winter World Book Club as a free copy and this is my honest opinion.
November 12, 2024
I was not disappointed by this second instalment in the Winter Souls series. Again, I was reminded of Narnia. We see Helen, the Carrier, grow into her role. Just like us, she can be easily deceived, and lose hope. But we are reminded that God has a plan, and hasn’t left us alone. I eagerly await book 3. I received a free copy of this book, with no obligation.
dnf
December 19, 2022Ok I'm so confused, I think I have to re-read the first book at some point because there's just so much to this world and the story, I'm so so lost.
December 29, 2023
I’m so bummed because I absolutely loved the first book in the series but this one just didn’t do it for me. The prose was not as beautiful and unique, the characters were not as likable, and the story felt very repetitive and not engaging.
All the things I loved about the first book were lacking in this one. Zane and Helen’s relationship was not enjoyable to read about in this book. I loved their banter in the previous book but it bordered on toxic in this one and was very cringe and obnoxious.The Christmas themes were barely there and when they were they felt forced and unexplained. Much of the world and plot still feels unexplained. By this point in a series I think the reader should feel more acquainted with the fantasy world and why it is the way it is. However, the world building feels very thrown together and still not fully fleshed out or explained to our human main character.Why doesn’t she have more questioned about it? The things that are explained do not make sense and don’t feel thought out. The only way a vague world building/explaining like this works in a fantasy book is when the fantasy world is the only one that exists and everyone in the book already knows how it works so the explanations are not as warranted. If there is a human character then they should have the same questions the readers do and the author should be answering them. I want to know how Winter relates to the human world and how Christmas works for both worlds. The new plots and characters in this book were not ones I cared much about and would’ve liked to see less of that and more of furthering the world and characters that were established in the first book.
All that being said, there were still things about this I really enjoyed. Lines that made me laugh out loud, romance that made me squeal, plot twists that were very clever, and cozy winter magic that was perfect for this time of year. I plan to continue this series and ham very hopeful for it.
All the things I loved about the first book were lacking in this one. Zane and Helen’s relationship was not enjoyable to read about in this book. I loved their banter in the previous book but it bordered on toxic in this one and was very cringe and obnoxious.The Christmas themes were barely there and when they were they felt forced and unexplained. Much of the world and plot still feels unexplained. By this point in a series I think the reader should feel more acquainted with the fantasy world and why it is the way it is. However, the world building feels very thrown together and still not fully fleshed out or explained to our human main character.Why doesn’t she have more questioned about it? The things that are explained do not make sense and don’t feel thought out. The only way a vague world building/explaining like this works in a fantasy book is when the fantasy world is the only one that exists and everyone in the book already knows how it works so the explanations are not as warranted. If there is a human character then they should have the same questions the readers do and the author should be answering them. I want to know how Winter relates to the human world and how Christmas works for both worlds. The new plots and characters in this book were not ones I cared much about and would’ve liked to see less of that and more of furthering the world and characters that were established in the first book.
All that being said, there were still things about this I really enjoyed. Lines that made me laugh out loud, romance that made me squeal, plot twists that were very clever, and cozy winter magic that was perfect for this time of year. I plan to continue this series and ham very hopeful for it.
April 13, 2022
I leapt into the deep end of this thoroughly delectable book and sank up to my eyeballs in its mysteries and believable characters. It tastes wonderfully sweet being back in the lives of Helen Bell and Zane, her patrolman, rather like eating a whole bar of peppermint chocolate or a sugar-coated cake all by yourself and not worrying about putting on weight. But there’s no shallow veneer in Jennifer Kropf’s novel, A Heart as Red as Paint; it’s the best treat in the literature store. Once again, I followed her characters around like a lost child, eager to know where their prosaic feet would lead me and I wasn’t disappointed. Kropf never leads astray.
It begins with a lullaby that soothes a dying boy, who—doesn’t exactly die. Then Helen discovers pearl-like gems which she collects but doesn’t know what they represent, until she meets a Timepiece from Winter. The vaporous being warns her of three hearts that will contribute to her destruction: one black, one red and one green and that she will return to Winter. Helen tries to make sense of the manic knowledge of this alternate world along with her crazy school life and her dysfunctional family. She’s figured out that the Timepiece’s warnings are an obvious bait to lure her back to Winter and she eventually does return. After all, that’s where her heart belongs—with the boy Zane.
I’m getting to know Helen better and how she thinks. I realise how she deals with things is how a teenager would handle problems. She’s growing up. She’s already faced the wicked witch of Winter in battle and won. I sense a certain amount of cockiness in her personality, and daring, which she’ll need when she faces betrayal, loss and deceit later on in this book.
Once again, Kropf weaves her wonderful magic through a tale as complex as a tangled ball of wool. As emotionally charged as a bolt of sizzling lightning. As sweet as jam-filled pancakes. Yesterday’s story still holds my heartbeat today and I’m so very hungry for more.
November 4, 2023
Oh my freaking goodness. How can I explain the amazing-ness that is this book that I stayed up until two in the morning to finish? I shall make an attempt.
I was just as eager as Helen to enter back into the world of Winter. Kropf returns with her magical writing style and thrilling worldbuilding, but this time, our characters must tread into a world of royalty and secret identities. The Narnian vibes drew me in, and the intrigue of the puzzle kept me reading on.
Much of this book’s plot is relationship centered. The relationship between Helen and Zane with its many downs and ups (be still, my heart!)—such a deep connection that is only getting deeper, saturated with hard truth and the choice of persisting. Between Helen and Eliot, Apple, Quinten, Kaley and Winston, and the rest of Winter—the realization of the true nature of friends. Between Helen and Elowin—the most precious relationship of them all.
Like in the previous book, the Christian allegory is my favorite part. We get to see Helen’s faith tested and her vulnerabilities shown on full display. Can I say that it built to a beautiful crescendo of revealing Elowin’s relationship to Helen? I fear gushing all about it would be a plot twist, but suffice it to say that it is my favorite thing in this book. It truly is a representation of Christ and His church, á la Isaiah 54:5.
My thoughts as of finishing: BAHHHHHH I must read the NEXT ONE!!! Zane and Helen are so stinking cute!!!!! (I don’t care if the many exclamation points are childish, okay? They accurately portray the way my heart is skipping ❤️)
…
“For worship is a cry of war, you see.”
For the King of Kings and Lord of Lords!
I was just as eager as Helen to enter back into the world of Winter. Kropf returns with her magical writing style and thrilling worldbuilding, but this time, our characters must tread into a world of royalty and secret identities. The Narnian vibes drew me in, and the intrigue of the puzzle kept me reading on.
Much of this book’s plot is relationship centered. The relationship between Helen and Zane with its many downs and ups (be still, my heart!)—such a deep connection that is only getting deeper, saturated with hard truth and the choice of persisting. Between Helen and Eliot, Apple, Quinten, Kaley and Winston, and the rest of Winter—the realization of the true nature of friends. Between Helen and Elowin—the most precious relationship of them all.
Like in the previous book, the Christian allegory is my favorite part. We get to see Helen’s faith tested and her vulnerabilities shown on full display. Can I say that it built to a beautiful crescendo of revealing Elowin’s relationship to Helen? I fear gushing all about it would be a plot twist, but suffice it to say that it is my favorite thing in this book. It truly is a representation of Christ and His church, á la Isaiah 54:5.
My thoughts as of finishing: BAHHHHHH I must read the NEXT ONE!!! Zane and Helen are so stinking cute!!!!! (I don’t care if the many exclamation points are childish, okay? They accurately portray the way my heart is skipping ❤️)
…
“For worship is a cry of war, you see.”
For the King of Kings and Lord of Lords!
November 10, 2021
I like reading the first one, but this book has a lot of development that makes me like it even more! There are riddles, actions, hidden identities and also more development on Zane and Helen's relationship!!!
First of all, the plot is good and I really like the riddles aspect. It makes me keep flipping the pages to find out what it means and who those three heart belongs to. I guess one of them pretty early because it was quite easy and turn out to be right but I'm not really sure about the other two riddles so it came as a surprise near the ending.
I really like the characters in this series, all of them are well developed. I have to admit, Helen's character is far more interesting in this book. She used to be rather timid in the first book since she didn't know much about how the world works. But, when she came back she's a lot more confident and stronger, although it made her over confident when she's trying to do all of the things by herself.
Zane still being rather mysterious in the first part of the books and keeping secrets. He's quite a complex character but I think he's starting to open up more in the second part of the book which is a good sign!!
There are also great messages in this book especially when Helen feels like she was alone in a hard situations, someone remind her that she's never really alone even when she can't see them. That scene really touched me.
Overall, this is great and at the moment this one is my favorite. I enjoy my time reading this book and coming back to the Winter world. Great characters and world building as well as unexpected twists really makes me wish I could have the next one right now!
I'm looking forward for the next book in this series!
Special thanks to Jennifer Kropf and Winter Wood Publishing House for giving me this beautiful ARC in exchange for my honest review!
First of all, the plot is good and I really like the riddles aspect. It makes me keep flipping the pages to find out what it means and who those three heart belongs to. I guess one of them pretty early because it was quite easy and turn out to be right but I'm not really sure about the other two riddles so it came as a surprise near the ending.
I really like the characters in this series, all of them are well developed. I have to admit, Helen's character is far more interesting in this book. She used to be rather timid in the first book since she didn't know much about how the world works. But, when she came back she's a lot more confident and stronger, although it made her over confident when she's trying to do all of the things by herself.
Zane still being rather mysterious in the first part of the books and keeping secrets. He's quite a complex character but I think he's starting to open up more in the second part of the book which is a good sign!!
There are also great messages in this book especially when Helen feels like she was alone in a hard situations, someone remind her that she's never really alone even when she can't see them. That scene really touched me.
Overall, this is great and at the moment this one is my favorite. I enjoy my time reading this book and coming back to the Winter world. Great characters and world building as well as unexpected twists really makes me wish I could have the next one right now!
I'm looking forward for the next book in this series!
Special thanks to Jennifer Kropf and Winter Wood Publishing House for giving me this beautiful ARC in exchange for my honest review!
January 20, 2025
Okay this book was just as PHENOMENAL as the first one!! Where do I even start??
I was a little scared it would be a “the first book was great but the second definitely wasn’t as good” situation but I couldn’t have been more wrong!!
The use of imagery in Jennifer Kropf’s writing style is pure ART and don’t even get me STARTED on the world building!!!
The character development was ✨gorgeous✨
*chef’s kiss*
And there were moments I wanted to scream, cry, and laugh like a lunatic because I physically couldn’t handle the words in front of me.
It had me a little worried for a second there with a little character (just because I hate love triangles) but everything worked out WAY better than I expected 😆!!
Jennifer Kropf, I just wanted to thank you again for sharing your gifts with the world. Thank you for being such a phenomenal writer and for making your faith a firm foundation of your writing. You’re AWESOME!!
Thank you for Winter (which I can’t wait to go back to again), the Truth, and still…Zane.🤣
(Look me in the eyes and say you don’t agree with me I dare you 🤣)
Overall I would recommend this entire series to anyone I came across because I feel like people deserve to feel the thrill of reading these.
Hands down, without a doubt, this is one of the proudest 5 stars I can bestow to you.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️(I would add more stars if I could 😆)
I was a little scared it would be a “the first book was great but the second definitely wasn’t as good” situation but I couldn’t have been more wrong!!
The use of imagery in Jennifer Kropf’s writing style is pure ART and don’t even get me STARTED on the world building!!!
The character development was ✨gorgeous✨
*chef’s kiss*
And there were moments I wanted to scream, cry, and laugh like a lunatic because I physically couldn’t handle the words in front of me.
It had me a little worried for a second there with a little character (just because I hate love triangles) but everything worked out WAY better than I expected 😆!!
Jennifer Kropf, I just wanted to thank you again for sharing your gifts with the world. Thank you for being such a phenomenal writer and for making your faith a firm foundation of your writing. You’re AWESOME!!
Thank you for Winter (which I can’t wait to go back to again), the Truth, and still…Zane.🤣
(Look me in the eyes and say you don’t agree with me I dare you 🤣)
Overall I would recommend this entire series to anyone I came across because I feel like people deserve to feel the thrill of reading these.
Hands down, without a doubt, this is one of the proudest 5 stars I can bestow to you.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️(I would add more stars if I could 😆)
July 13, 2025
I’m gonna keep this short. I LOVE what the author is *trying* to do with this series. Unfortunately, this book wasn’t it for me. This book was 404 pages, but it was 290 pages before it got interesting in the slightest.
The author has an excellent writing style, particularly for the whimsical Christmasy vibe. That continued well from the first book. Unfortunately, everything else that was good in the first book was less good or even bad in this book.
What really frustrated me is that the author spent more time describing the MC’s various outfits than actually furthering the plot. That drove me nuts. There was almost zero plot development for the middle 200 pages.
The only reason I bumped this from 2 stars to 3 (really 2.5) is that the final 100 pages were legitimately very good and I would even say inspiring.
I very much hope the final 2 books in the series are significantly better than this one.
The author has an excellent writing style, particularly for the whimsical Christmasy vibe. That continued well from the first book. Unfortunately, everything else that was good in the first book was less good or even bad in this book.
What really frustrated me is that the author spent more time describing the MC’s various outfits than actually furthering the plot. That drove me nuts. There was almost zero plot development for the middle 200 pages.
The only reason I bumped this from 2 stars to 3 (really 2.5) is that the final 100 pages were legitimately very good and I would even say inspiring.
I very much hope the final 2 books in the series are significantly better than this one.
November 10, 2021
A Heart as Red as Paint is the second book in the Winter series, and it picks up about a year after A Soul as Cold as Frost.
The world of Winter has only continued to grow and show its many layers. This book was fast-paced, and just as I was starting to grasp where the adventure was taking us, an interruption from the Story Teller occurs only, adding to the layers and urging me to read on, needing to know what would happen next.
I thoroughly enjoyed seeing Helen and Zane’s relationship grow and seeing more backstory, and being introduced to even more characters.
There were sweet moments; there was adventure; there was sorrow, mishap, intrigue and ruses. This book had it all and so much more.
I cannot wait for the next book in the series; I have many questions and hopes, and I need more Helen and Zane!
This series is perfect for curling up snuggled under layers of blankets, some hot cocoa on the side table while the snow falls gently outside the window.
I highly recommend this series; you will not be disappointed.
The world of Winter has only continued to grow and show its many layers. This book was fast-paced, and just as I was starting to grasp where the adventure was taking us, an interruption from the Story Teller occurs only, adding to the layers and urging me to read on, needing to know what would happen next.
I thoroughly enjoyed seeing Helen and Zane’s relationship grow and seeing more backstory, and being introduced to even more characters.
There were sweet moments; there was adventure; there was sorrow, mishap, intrigue and ruses. This book had it all and so much more.
I cannot wait for the next book in the series; I have many questions and hopes, and I need more Helen and Zane!
This series is perfect for curling up snuggled under layers of blankets, some hot cocoa on the side table while the snow falls gently outside the window.
I highly recommend this series; you will not be disappointed.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 148 reviews