Brown tells three stories. The first is about Jeffrey Epstein’s abuse of underage girls and sex trafficking; the second is about Epstein’s undermining the criminal justice system using money, connections, and intimidation to secure the complicity of prosecutors and silence victims; and the third is about Brown’s trials and tribulations as an investigative reporter working on those stories. The book is written like a memoir as her personal story fills many of the pages. Many of the details describe the immense amount of work and dedication it took for her to penetrate the maze of the criminal justice system to find out how Epstein was able to manipulate it. She also discusses the toll the work took on her personal life making her own story a significant part of the book.
As for Epstein, the book confirms what is common knowledge, that he was a sexual predator, but the scope and scale of his crimes still amazes. Brown makes her case relying heavily on her interviews with victims, girls who were as young as fourteen when they were raped by Epstein and his friends. She clearly implicates Alan Dershowitz, Prince Andrew and Trump among others as participants in Epstein’s sexual abuse. Then there were his assistants and procurers, most significantly Ghislaine Maxwell, who apparently was actually in love with Epstein.
The most revealing part of the book, as the title states, is how Epstein was able to get away with his crimes by manipulating law enforcement with favors and threats. His “charitable” contributions to pet projects and organizations of local officials and the police kept them looking the other way. He also used money and favors to keep victims quiet. When that didn’t work Epstein hired lawyers and private investigators to make life hell for them or anyone who threatened his depraved lifestyle. Brown focuses on the 2008 plea deal under which Epstein served a year in jail for procuring a child for prostitution. He was jailed in the county jail in Palm Beach under supervision of the sheriff who had a good relationship with Epstein. Epstein was able to get work release which meant he could spend the day at his office. Police sat outside, for whom Epstein hired a caterer to make sure they were well fed, while Epstein still brought in young girls for sex while serving his sentence.
Federal prosecutors led by Florida U.S. Attorney Alex Acosta negotiated the plea deal with Dershowitz and other Epstein lawyers. It gave Epstein immunity from federal charges in return for Epstein pleading guilty to two state charges for which he received the year in a jail run by his buddy the county sheriff whose deputies monitored Epstein’s liberal work release. The deal stopped an ongoing FBI investigation which had already identified over thirty victims of Epstein’s while Epstein’s conviction was based on only one. Brown questions whether the highly favorable deal for Epstein was to protect prominent figures and how much intimidation and inducements to prosecutors secured the deal. The deal was kept secret from the victims, many of whom filed civil suit later pointing out that their rights under the Crime Victims’ Rights Act had been violated. Brown followed up with many of the victims and released her reporting and documentary in 2018. It created a firestorm of controversy that led to the resignation of Acosta who had been appointed by Trump as Secretary of Labor and to the reopening of the case in 2019 by New York U.S. Attorney Geoffrey Berman.
The remaining mystery is Epstein’s “suicide”. After Berman charged Epstein with sex trafficking, he was held in the Manhattan Correctional Center run by the Feds. He was found dead in his cell. Epstein’s death was ruled a suicide but many disagreed and there were very suspicious circumstances. Guards had fallen asleep, surveillance cameras didn’t work, the guards falsified records, his cell mate was removed and not replaced, his body was moved before pictures were taken, and outside forensic doctors said broken bones in his neck indicated strangulation, just to name a few. Epstein’s lawyers had just met with him and said he was upbeat as they felt they could beat the charges. Brown clearly doubts this was a suicide. Epstein took a lot of secrets with him and many prominent people benefited from that.
There were two takeaways for me from this book. First is the credit we owe investigative journalists. Without Brown’s reporting, Epstein would likely still be trafficking in young girls. It takes a tough, determined person willing to work long hours for little pay to do what Brown did. She was named one of Time magazines 100 most influential people in 2020. She deserves all the kudos she has earned. Second, the criminal justice system is inherently corruptible. It is too easy for a person with money and connections to not only hire the most powerful and well-connected lawyers, but to hire private detectives to harass and dig up dirt on accusers, prosecutors, reporters, anyone in their way, and to pull strings to offer inducements to prosecutors who play ball. How can a poor abused teenager get justice against a billionaire like Epstein who stopped at nothing? It can only happen when people like Brown completely dedicate themselves to the fight and are fortunate enough to be successful. I can’t think of a better illustration of the importance of a free press.