3.9 stars rounded up to 4.
Great desert adventure, impressive characters, lively dialogues and charming exotic setting with a hint of history.
Although I don't recommend "City of Jasmine" by Deanna Raybourn to those looking for a sweeping romance, I do wholeheartedly recommend it to those who want a light read, with fast-paced, thrilling adventures and a happy ending.
__THE PLOT:
1920s. Famed aviatrix Evangeline Starke never expected to see her husband, adventurer Gabriel Starke, ever again. They had been a golden couple, enjoying a whirlwind courtship amid the backdrop of a glittering social set in pre-war London until his sudden death with the sinking of the Lusitania. Five years later, beginning to embrace life again, Evie embarks upon a flight around the world, collecting fame and admirers along the way. In the midst of her triumphant tour, she is shocked to receive a mysterious — and recent — photograph of Gabriel, which brings her ambitious stunt to a screeching halt.
With her eccentric aunt Dove in tow, Evie tracks the source of the photo to the ancient City of Jasmine, Damascus. There she discovers that nothing is as it seems. Danger lurks at every turn, and at stake is a priceless relic, an artefact once lost to time and so valuable that criminals will stop at nothing to acquire it — even murder. Leaving the jewelled city behind, Evie sets off across the punishing sands of the desert to unearth the truth of Gabriel’s disappearance and retrieve a relic straight from the pages of history.
Along the way, Evie must come to terms with the deception that separated her from Gabriel and the passion that will change her destiny forever...
*******______*******
*** WHAT I LIKED:
1 _ First and foremost, I really liked the brief but effective INTRODUCTION to Evangeline Starke, our main female character. We quickly learn how she transformed into a celebrated aviatrix, making a living by traveling the world and providing newspapers with exciting articles and photographs of herself, her old but adventurous aunt, and her aristocratic friend Wally. This immediately sets the stage for an unconventional heroine and promises globe-trotting escapades.
2 _ EVE, THE MAIN FEMALE CHARCTER _ a beautifully crafted character who resonates deeply because of her complexity and realism. She’s not a perfect heroine but a real person—full of contradictions, strength, and vulnerability. Her love for her husband, despite years of absence and a difficult marriage, shows a kind of passionate stubbornness that feels genuine rather than clichéd. The way she hides her true feelings from everyone, including herself, adds layers to her emotional struggle.
What really stands out is Eve’s refusal to be a victim. Even when faced with her husband’s rough treatment, she meets it with wit and iron will, showing both courage and a fierce loyalty. She’s patient beyond reason and willing to confront painful truths instead of running away, which gives her a remarkable depth. Her self-awareness, taking blame but also showing generosity and warmth to those around her, makes her incredibly relatable.
It’s a shame the author didn’t give Gabriel the same depth or charm because that imbalance can take away from the emotional impact. But Eve’s character shines enough to carry the story with authenticity and heart. She’s the kind of character you want to root for, the kind who sticks with you long after the last page is turned.
3 _ I absolutely loved the great DESERT ADVENTURE that unfolds, full of twists and turns. It magically rekindled that specific atmosphere of the Middle East, reminiscent of the fairy tales of Aladdin, Scheherazade, and The Arabian Nights, which I adored as a child. Unfortunately, I had lost that enchantment for the region as I grew up, especially after the rise of ISIS and the Taliban, their attacks on the West, the executions of journalists, and all the wars between various religious factions. For a long time, when I thought of the Arab world, all that came to mind was dust, dirt, blood, and fear.
This book, however, delivered an adventure that made me want to discover more about the historical and cultural stories behind these lands.
4_ I also thoroughly enjoyed the HISTORICAL SETTING of the 1920s. The narrative subtly highlights how, even after the ravages of the First World War, Western colonial empires continued their attempts to seize control of something that didn't belong to them.
The references to Lawrence of Arabia were particularly engaging (whom I only knew from movies, since he's part of British history, while I'm Italian).
While reading the book, I found myself exploring online the life of this Englishman who tried to help the Arabs establish an independent state, and how the subsequent events and the revolts against the Turks unfolded in a disappointing manner.
I enjoyed researching, through Wikipedia, blog articles, and old black-and-white photos, the real-world places mentioned in the book, such as Damascus, Palmyra, and the Zenobia Hotel – an elegant hotel that was still in operation until 2013, now sadly a victim of the conflict in Syria, full of holes and decay.
This historical immersion added a rich layer to the story.
5_ The INTRIGUE surrounding the archaeological finds, perfectly intertwined with the political situation of the time, was another strong point. It kept me guessing and invested in the unfolding mystery.
6_ Finally, I loved almost all the SUPPORTING CHARACTERS, both good and villains.
Evie's loyal friend Wally, the enigmatic Sheikh Hamid, the various personalities at the archaeological dig, Hallyday the British diplomat, and even the funny and chatty parrot – they all added depth and flavor to the narrative.
There was only one character I didn't quite like, though I know many readers did.
***WHAT I DIDN'T LIKE :
1_LACK OF ROMANCE : My primary disappointment stemmed from the book’s cover and blurb (in addition to a prequel written a year after the book), which strongly suggest an intense love story between two protagonists deeply in love with each other.
Actually, for up to 90% of the book, it seems like the only one truly in love is the young woman, Evie. Her ex-husband, meanwhile, uses a consistently gruff tone throughout, and the only two kisses we see toward the middle of the book are completely sterile and devoid of passion and genuine feeling. The romance trope should be "enemies to lovers," but here, even the slightest hint of love and interest on his part is missing, making the book profoundly disappointing from a romantic perspective.
Only in the last 10% do we get a making-love scene. Nothing vulgar; the author merely hints at it, but doesn't specifically describe it, so it's suitable for younger readers. Unfortunately, even after that scene, there are no strong emotions or romantic thrills.
The ending is happy, but here too the author missed an opportunity to make the hero more tender towards his ex-wife and now-returned partner. In fact, she's the only one who says "I love you," and there are no kisses that give you goosebumps (as any romance should, even if it's "clean" and free of explicit scenes).
2_ The character I didn't like was the ELDERLY AUNT and her behaviour.
While she's meant to be a whimsical, adventurous character, which could have been endearing, her portrayal as a 60-year-old Victorian woman who, despite her storied past, still flirts and makes insistent advances, even towards young men, was off-putting. I found it quite disgusting and it jarred with the rest of the narrative. It's also utterly absurd that at a certain point in the story, she, at 60 years old and without prior experience, manages to fly an airplane on her own after less than an hour of lessons. This is particularly unbelievable when Evie herself has taken countless lessons from aviators recovering from the war, preparing herself both practically, mentally, and physically.
3_The last thing that annoyed me a little was the constant and somewhat RIDICULOUS REFERENCES to Peter Pan and Wendy, and the famous fairy tale.
I've loved that fairy tale since I was a child, but in this context, it seemed a bit forced, and for a man of the world like Gabriel to constantly reference Peter Pan seemed a bit ridiculous and out of character.
******______ ******
In any case, the negative things I mentioned were only a minor annoyance for me; overall, I thoroughly enjoyed the whole story, and the main characters and their friends stayed with me for several days after I finished reading.
Despite its few flaws, "City of Jasmine" is a fantastic read for those seeking adventure, historical intrigue, and an escape to a vibrant, bygone era.