A decent collection of Holmes short stories, again with more of an emphasis on Watson in most of the tales although a couple were good Holmes showcases. It is odd in these stories where every single female character is amazing, strong, intelligent, and winning. There are no damsels in distress or simple local girls, they're all wonderful. One girl is so great she's able to single handedly beat up a larger, more athletic boy because she "grew up with boys." Let's just say that's not the finest characterization on earth.
The mysteries are okay, a couple aren't really mysteries, but they are decent enough. Riccard does a good enough job with the time period and language, and for the most part good with the characterizations, but what's missing is Doyle's main reason for writing the Holmes stories: to showcase and demonstrate deductive (and inductive, although he never mentions it by name) reasoning.