The time-travel and all alliances were fantastic. The planning and the subterfuge and all the pulling the wool over Voldemort's eyes - A+ plotting. I liked the Ripple Effect and that there were a lot of differences both before they started trying to change things and after things started to change.
The fact that Harry and Ginny were battle-tested adults and married yet at the same time were kids with grown-up memories made it really awkward to read through their scenes at times. I definitely support Arthur and Molly's reactions. While all the miscommunication at the end seemed to take forever to resolve, I'm glad we got enough moments of levity to push forward and move things along.
The price was still too high, in my opinion, and my throat got a bit tight reading those parts but the emotions came through. I'm glad I didn't trust a certain misdirect and I had three guesses for who Merlin was (well, four, but Regulus was a pipedream) and one was right. So, I'm counting that as a win.
I didn't like the plot. They go back in time to first year and then try for things to happen exactly the same way as they did before, and they do, even when they are acting totally different. So I guess there is no butterfly effect in this universe. Everything is predestined to happen the same way. They may as well do nothing then.
Until the scene with Nagini biting Arthur Weasley in the ministry it's pretty much all canon. Then it changes and I liked it better.
Wow. This throughly shocked me. The quality was astounding considering it was entirely free. I was literally engulfed in this story from beginning to end. The heartstrings it pulls are numerous. Much more interesting than the last three Harry Potter books.