What do you think?
Rate this book
The Wraith #1
The Wraith and the Rose
The Fair Folk are stealing children.
One man is stealing them back.
When Miss Lilybeth Rose Hathaway and her family arrive in Ardmond for the season, Lily can’t help but be charmed by wealthy, popular Theo Overton’s lovely manners and genuine affection. The Hathaways are soon elevated far beyond what they might have imagined, and like everyone else, they are captivated by rumors of the national hero known as the Wraith, who is saving human children from the terrors of the Fair Court.
The arrival of the Special Envoy of the Fair Court tasked with capturing the Wraith frightens everyone. But the Wraith is far too clever to be captured… until the stakes become personal.
The Wraith and the Rose is a delightful reimagining of The Scarlet Pimpernel in a Regency-inspired setting with dangerous Fair Folk and a love worth dying for.
One man is stealing them back.
When Miss Lilybeth Rose Hathaway and her family arrive in Ardmond for the season, Lily can’t help but be charmed by wealthy, popular Theo Overton’s lovely manners and genuine affection. The Hathaways are soon elevated far beyond what they might have imagined, and like everyone else, they are captivated by rumors of the national hero known as the Wraith, who is saving human children from the terrors of the Fair Court.
The arrival of the Special Envoy of the Fair Court tasked with capturing the Wraith frightens everyone. But the Wraith is far too clever to be captured… until the stakes become personal.
The Wraith and the Rose is a delightful reimagining of The Scarlet Pimpernel in a Regency-inspired setting with dangerous Fair Folk and a love worth dying for.
362 pages, Kindle Edition
First published August 24, 2021
16 people are currently reading
783 people want to read
About the author
C.J. Brightley
28 books254 followersC. J. Brightley lives outside Washington, D.C., with her husband and their two young children. When she's not busy writing, she teaches karate, bakes too many desserts, and makes jewelry. She loves to connect with readers!
Follow C. J. Brightley at https://www.facebook.com/CJBrightley and https://www.instagram.com/cjbrightley/
Follow C. J. Brightley at https://www.facebook.com/CJBrightley and https://www.instagram.com/cjbrightley/
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 47 reviews
Read
September 9, 2021What do you get when Sir Percy is a nobleman rescuing children from Faery and Marguerite is sweet and trusting (and determined to help, but not quite sure who to help)?
You get C.J. Brightley’s The Wraith and the Rose: a very loose, very faery rendition of The Scarlet Pimpernel! Heartfelt, wholesome, and easy to while away the weekend with, The Wraith and the Rose is sweet, fluffy, noblebright fun.
Theo isn’t rescuing the nobility from France, and Lily is certainly not the sharp, clever Marguerite of The Scarlet Pimpernel, but the parallels are there--and fun to spot. There is so much heart to this book, and a real focus on sweet relationships. It was enjoyable getting to know carefully-foppish-but-actually-dashing Theo and sweet, heartfelt, determined Lily; I fully expect sequels featuring others from the story!
You get C.J. Brightley’s The Wraith and the Rose: a very loose, very faery rendition of The Scarlet Pimpernel! Heartfelt, wholesome, and easy to while away the weekend with, The Wraith and the Rose is sweet, fluffy, noblebright fun.
Theo isn’t rescuing the nobility from France, and Lily is certainly not the sharp, clever Marguerite of The Scarlet Pimpernel, but the parallels are there--and fun to spot. There is so much heart to this book, and a real focus on sweet relationships. It was enjoyable getting to know carefully-foppish-but-actually-dashing Theo and sweet, heartfelt, determined Lily; I fully expect sequels featuring others from the story!
September 9, 2022
I would have never imagined retelling The Scarlet Pimpernel with Fae courts with a habit of kidnapping humans—and yet this utterly unique concept works perfectly with the premise of the original story.
While this retelling leans more towards the romance side of things than the danger, but there is still plenty of mystery and atmosphere that keeps one turning the pages. Just as we expect, our hero is lovable and charming and surrounded by a cast of likable allies - and surprisingly sympathetic antagonists.
Perfect for fans of Fae courts, Jane Austen, clean romances, or even just luscious descriptions of food and parties—this Regency-esque retelling of the Scarlet Pimpernel is an enjoyable read wrapped up in an absolutely gorgeous cover.
May 2, 2022
I have been a HUGE Scarlet Pimpernel fan for years. But really good retellings are few and far between.
This one stands up there as one of the best. Twisting Scarlet Pimpernel with the fae is a great twist, and it has all the fun rescues and clever tricks of the original. The author also manages to capture much of the fun and daring of Sir Percy in her hero, along with some of his inane, surface personality that he uses to hide his cleverness.
This one stands up there as one of the best. Twisting Scarlet Pimpernel with the fae is a great twist, and it has all the fun rescues and clever tricks of the original. The author also manages to capture much of the fun and daring of Sir Percy in her hero, along with some of his inane, surface personality that he uses to hide his cleverness.
July 31, 2021
All you folks weighed down by doom, gloom, murder and sorrow can lift your spirits with this fantastic, light Victorian Fae Romp. Seriously. If you're looking for Jane Austin does magic, this is for you. Particularly, if you've ever wondered what Jane and Bingley's marriage was like (if they lived near the border to Fairy obviously). The lead MC is Victorian perfection, so sweet it hurts your teeth. And the lead male has the charm and money of Bingley with more spunk, fire and warmth. Theo is my absolute favorite. Between debutant balls ruined by a grumpy Fairy, stolen children, a Scarlet Pimpernel-esce masked magical hero and the pending destruction of the magical world, the sweet charm and handsome manners will delight and uplift.
Also. THAT COVER. -growl-
I received this ARC and this is my honest, pleased review.
Read
August 23, 2021This week, my lovely friend C. J. Brightley is releasing her first novel in some years, and it's a delightfully sweet fantasy retelling of The Scarlet Pimpernel! I spent most of yesterday afternoon devouring my advance review copy of this story. In this version of the classic, the mysterious and dashing Wraith is stealing back kidnapped human children from the fairies, as the sinister Lord Willowvale attempts to unmask the intruder.
With its sincere characters and an ending that left me catching my breath at its eucatastrophic beauty, The Wraith and the Rose is the definition of noblebright fantasy.
With its sincere characters and an ending that left me catching my breath at its eucatastrophic beauty, The Wraith and the Rose is the definition of noblebright fantasy.
Want to read
October 14, 2024WHY IS THIS COVER SO PRETTY?! 😩🤩🤩🤩🤩
January 3, 2022
4.5 stars
Yeah, so uh..what the heck is happening with Fenton!?!?!?
That is all. *bows out*
Yeah, so uh..what the heck is happening with Fenton!?!?!?
That is all. *bows out*
July 31, 2021
A retelling of Scarlet Pimpernel with fairies and magic. I love Scarlet Pimpernel, and I love this book. It is utterly delightful. Brightley, as always, does a magnificent job with her creation of the fae and their land.
My abso-freaking-lute most favorite part of this book is Theo, one of the main characters. He is vibrant, funny, kind, and just... the very best person. I want a Theo friend. Everyone should have a Theo friend. He carries this story, he brings it to life. The other characters(Lily, I love Lily! And Juniper and Cedar and Anselm and--) are charming too, but Theo takes the cake.
I loved the ending, but I can't say more because I don't do spoiler reviews. I'll just say it was clever and satisfying and leave it at that.
The attention to detail made this world feel perfectly regency/Victorian-esque. It is a charming story, and the perfect comfort read.
I received and ARC and this is my very pleased, willing review.
My abso-freaking-lute most favorite part of this book is Theo, one of the main characters. He is vibrant, funny, kind, and just... the very best person. I want a Theo friend. Everyone should have a Theo friend. He carries this story, he brings it to life. The other characters(Lily, I love Lily! And Juniper and Cedar and Anselm and--) are charming too, but Theo takes the cake.
I loved the ending, but I can't say more because I don't do spoiler reviews. I'll just say it was clever and satisfying and leave it at that.
The attention to detail made this world feel perfectly regency/Victorian-esque. It is a charming story, and the perfect comfort read.
I received and ARC and this is my very pleased, willing review.
September 6, 2021
COMMUNICATION IS KEY
September 27, 2023
Dnf. I am bored. Also, I could not, for the life of me, understand Lily. Her devotion to the Wraith never made any sense, and I completely gave up when she wanted to go to the fae lands because she "just wants to see it." Like???? It's one thing to be making stupid, dangerous decisions on your own, but to bring your genuinely *good* brother along? Nah.
Read
October 25, 2021This book pulls off a feat that’s actually quite difficult. It’s a fantasy, set in a world inspired by British upper-class life of the late eighteenth or early nineteenth centuries. The plot concept is borrowed from The Scarlet Pimpernel, but instead of a French Revolution we have fairies stealing human children and forcing them to dance. Fortunately for the children, a mysterious human known as “the Rose” is extremely good at rescuing them.
Meanwhile, our heroine, a lovely but relatively penniless young woman, has entered the social scene and fallen in love with a man who doesn’t appear to be the mysterious Rose. Not at all.
For me, the biggest feat of the book was the way the author made the setting work. There are so many other fantasies set in a vaguely Regency-esque era, and all of them throw around words like “propriety,” “gown,” and “ballroom” without convincing me that the writers understand the idea that people in the past had their own cultures, full of nuance and depth. It all makes me quite grumpy, because I like intense worldbuilding and--when applicable--exhaustive historical detail.
Now, this book doesn’t actually attempt to create a believable and richly developed historical-feeling world; but you know what? It succeeds at something different. C. J. Brightley has chosen to use a veneer of historicity to create a certain tone. She seems attracted to the idea of refinement, courtliness, and honor, and therefore dresses her characters in silk. They move through life like actors in front of stage scenery, and because the characters are so consistent, it ends up being quite sweet and enjoyable.
For me, the story would have been stronger if Theo had initially come across as a silly fop instead of just being called that by various other characters. Instead, he’s obviously an active and dominant character from the beginning. The author seems to have been caught between the desire to convey the idea that he leads a double life vs. the desire to make his romance with Lily make sense, and I’m not sure she figured out how to reconcile those two things, which weakens the tension during their estrangement.
Overall, though, what made me like this story is the gentle, earnest, kindly tone that shines through so strongly it made even grumpy me enjoy the ride.
Meanwhile, our heroine, a lovely but relatively penniless young woman, has entered the social scene and fallen in love with a man who doesn’t appear to be the mysterious Rose. Not at all.
For me, the biggest feat of the book was the way the author made the setting work. There are so many other fantasies set in a vaguely Regency-esque era, and all of them throw around words like “propriety,” “gown,” and “ballroom” without convincing me that the writers understand the idea that people in the past had their own cultures, full of nuance and depth. It all makes me quite grumpy, because I like intense worldbuilding and--when applicable--exhaustive historical detail.
Now, this book doesn’t actually attempt to create a believable and richly developed historical-feeling world; but you know what? It succeeds at something different. C. J. Brightley has chosen to use a veneer of historicity to create a certain tone. She seems attracted to the idea of refinement, courtliness, and honor, and therefore dresses her characters in silk. They move through life like actors in front of stage scenery, and because the characters are so consistent, it ends up being quite sweet and enjoyable.
For me, the story would have been stronger if Theo had initially come across as a silly fop instead of just being called that by various other characters. Instead, he’s obviously an active and dominant character from the beginning. The author seems to have been caught between the desire to convey the idea that he leads a double life vs. the desire to make his romance with Lily make sense, and I’m not sure she figured out how to reconcile those two things, which weakens the tension during their estrangement.
Overall, though, what made me like this story is the gentle, earnest, kindly tone that shines through so strongly it made even grumpy me enjoy the ride.
August 24, 2021
As a longtime fan of the classic masked-hero story The Scarlet Pimpernel (both the book and the movie), I was excited to learn that C.J. Brightley was writing a fantasy retelling. It has a Victorian setting, and the fight is against the fae, who are stealing children.
If you enjoy sweet romance with near-perfect heroes, rich descriptions of fashions and foods, manners and the language of flowers, then you'll enjoy this book. If you're looking more for the swashbuckling daring-do and cleverness of the rescues of the movie version of The Scarlet Pimpernel, you'll likely be disappointed. This is a book for the romantics. I admit I was hoping for a greater sense of danger and cunning, but the author seemed to be avoiding that as much as possible, going for light descriptions and only telling us of the danger. The Veil (the passage between the human and fairy worlds) is said to be dangerous, but I never felt the danger. We're told it has dangerous creatures and may glimpse them, but it felt more like something tossed in because there should be danger than a grounded part of the story. In at least one rescue of the stolen children, the hero, in disguise, merely bullies the guards into letting him have the children. I could see that happening early in the Wraith's/Rose's rescues, but not when the fae are desperately trying to catch him. They would be looking for something like that, I would think. The reason for the rift between the hero and heroine also wasn't convincingly serious either. The greatest grievance, though, in my opinion is the lack of the clever ditty about the Scarlet Pimpernel; it's fun to repeat and was a great part of the movie version as the hero uses it to mock his rival.
I did still like the characters in The Wraith and the Rose, though they were a bit too sappy sweet and shallow for my taste, and reading the book brought back fond memories of the original story. For me, it just focused on the aspects I wasn't so fond of in the original--the hero's worship of the heroine and fashion concerns. This is a retelling for the romantics, and I won't knock the rating simply because I'm not quite that much of a romantic.
If you enjoy sweet romance with near-perfect heroes, rich descriptions of fashions and foods, manners and the language of flowers, then you'll enjoy this book. If you're looking more for the swashbuckling daring-do and cleverness of the rescues of the movie version of The Scarlet Pimpernel, you'll likely be disappointed. This is a book for the romantics. I admit I was hoping for a greater sense of danger and cunning, but the author seemed to be avoiding that as much as possible, going for light descriptions and only telling us of the danger. The Veil (the passage between the human and fairy worlds) is said to be dangerous, but I never felt the danger. We're told it has dangerous creatures and may glimpse them, but it felt more like something tossed in because there should be danger than a grounded part of the story. In at least one rescue of the stolen children, the hero, in disguise, merely bullies the guards into letting him have the children. I could see that happening early in the Wraith's/Rose's rescues, but not when the fae are desperately trying to catch him. They would be looking for something like that, I would think. The reason for the rift between the hero and heroine also wasn't convincingly serious either. The greatest grievance, though, in my opinion is the lack of the clever ditty about the Scarlet Pimpernel; it's fun to repeat and was a great part of the movie version as the hero uses it to mock his rival.
I did still like the characters in The Wraith and the Rose, though they were a bit too sappy sweet and shallow for my taste, and reading the book brought back fond memories of the original story. For me, it just focused on the aspects I wasn't so fond of in the original--the hero's worship of the heroine and fashion concerns. This is a retelling for the romantics, and I won't knock the rating simply because I'm not quite that much of a romantic.
January 1, 2025
My all time favorite Scarlet Pimpernel retelling! Fae and Regency vibes! Just so good!
June 19, 2024
Ok…ok…ok…Hear me out here lovely readers! YOU HAVE TO READ THE WRAITH AND THE ROSE!!!!! YOU JUST SIMPLY MUST READ IT!!! I am 100% not being overly dramatic! It is that amazing and you NEED to have it in your life. This book will live forever rent free in my heart.
The Fair Realm is beginning to wither. And the Fae King and much of his Court have decided that the only way to save it is to steal human children and force them to dance. However, to their utter dismay, The Wraith has other plans. And he will do anything within his power to steal back those children and bring them back to the human realm.
But who is the Wraith?
The Fae hold him with destain and the humans honor him with roses in their hair, clothes, and jewelry. But all they really know is that he never has the same appearance twice…sometimes he’s an ogre…or a Fae…or…he whisks the children away into the vale…leaving behind a rose embellished card in their place.
Now I don’t want to give too much away about the actual players in the story! Part of the magic of it all is discovering all the lovely and wonderful nuances, characters, world building, and secrets for yourself. But this is such and enchanting and delightful read and I really couldn’t have enjoyed it any more!!!
I loved the romance which was sweet and swoony and absolutely clean. I loved the characters that were absolutely delightful (or absolutely dreadful!)! And I loved the ending which was everything I expected, everything I hoped for, and then more!!!
So yep…GO FORTH AND READ THE WRAITH AND THE ROSE! It is the quintessential combination of mystery, sweet/swoony/clean romance, devious Fae, chivalrous heroes, and intriguing magic!
The Fair Realm is beginning to wither. And the Fae King and much of his Court have decided that the only way to save it is to steal human children and force them to dance. However, to their utter dismay, The Wraith has other plans. And he will do anything within his power to steal back those children and bring them back to the human realm.
But who is the Wraith?
The Fae hold him with destain and the humans honor him with roses in their hair, clothes, and jewelry. But all they really know is that he never has the same appearance twice…sometimes he’s an ogre…or a Fae…or…he whisks the children away into the vale…leaving behind a rose embellished card in their place.
Now I don’t want to give too much away about the actual players in the story! Part of the magic of it all is discovering all the lovely and wonderful nuances, characters, world building, and secrets for yourself. But this is such and enchanting and delightful read and I really couldn’t have enjoyed it any more!!!
I loved the romance which was sweet and swoony and absolutely clean. I loved the characters that were absolutely delightful (or absolutely dreadful!)! And I loved the ending which was everything I expected, everything I hoped for, and then more!!!
So yep…GO FORTH AND READ THE WRAITH AND THE ROSE! It is the quintessential combination of mystery, sweet/swoony/clean romance, devious Fae, chivalrous heroes, and intriguing magic!
May 29, 2024
A wonderful Scarlet Pimpernel retelling! I KNEW the conflict that was coming having read the Scarlet Pimpernel so I had to drop all responsibilities to finish this book as quickly as possible so as not to deal with heartbreak longer than necessary. I’m not usually an insta-love fan but Theo was so charming how could you not love him? The resolution of the villains plot was a little too easy and rushed but upon further reflection i found it nice to take a break from the intense stories with dramatic conclusions that are so popular these days. A cozy read that I look forward to reading again. ☺️❤️
August 22, 2021
Theo, Theo. Theo. I mean... Theo. As a writer myself, Theo is the kind of well-rounded, fleshed-out, and joyous character I'd always want to create. In my head, I have. On paper, well, that's a discussion for another time, but I can assure you that author C.J. Brightley absolutely has.
Theo is brilliant. Theo needs more stories. Theo needs a TV show on Amazon Prime. All of the characters in The Wraith and the Rose - a Fae/Victorian retelling of the Scarlett Pimpernel - are superbly written, but Theo jumps off the page and sits by you as you read, bringing you your favourite drinks and snacks, and throwing in a quip or witty remark here and there.
I want a Team Theo t-shirt. Oh, and read this book. You won't regret it.
Theo is brilliant. Theo needs more stories. Theo needs a TV show on Amazon Prime. All of the characters in The Wraith and the Rose - a Fae/Victorian retelling of the Scarlett Pimpernel - are superbly written, but Theo jumps off the page and sits by you as you read, bringing you your favourite drinks and snacks, and throwing in a quip or witty remark here and there.
I want a Team Theo t-shirt. Oh, and read this book. You won't regret it.
September 25, 2022
A lovely retelling!
While I would’ve liked for Lilybeth to be able to match wits and intelligence to Theo, she was charming in her own way. She did, however, seem somewhat one-note. I think the intensity of Theo’s infatuation might’ve been better explained if she had more to her than kind eyes and simplicity.
Theo was altogether wonderful and his companions were likewise lovely.
I really like the way the author threaded themes of sacrifice and love throughout the story, but not in the sense one might think.
I loved the vivid descriptions of the fair folk and their land and the thought of so many vibrant hues in one landscape sound wonderful.
The Victorian/regency sort of vibe everything had going was a lovely backdrop and made everything a little more interesting.
All in all, I quite enjoyed this one and I look forward to reading more from CJ Brightley.
While I would’ve liked for Lilybeth to be able to match wits and intelligence to Theo, she was charming in her own way. She did, however, seem somewhat one-note. I think the intensity of Theo’s infatuation might’ve been better explained if she had more to her than kind eyes and simplicity.
Theo was altogether wonderful and his companions were likewise lovely.
I really like the way the author threaded themes of sacrifice and love throughout the story, but not in the sense one might think.
I loved the vivid descriptions of the fair folk and their land and the thought of so many vibrant hues in one landscape sound wonderful.
The Victorian/regency sort of vibe everything had going was a lovely backdrop and made everything a little more interesting.
All in all, I quite enjoyed this one and I look forward to reading more from CJ Brightley.
March 21, 2022
Heartbreakingly beautiful and full of delightful magic. My favorite character was the hero, who's love and beautiful soul bleed into his every action, making the world come alive in a breathtaking way.
Daring, dashing, and bold, the wraith stole my heart from the very first page and refused to let go even after the wild, explosive climax.
This book is perfect for lovers of fae magic, sweet romance, and a fierce, defiant hero who is willing to sacrifice himself for the lands and people he loves. Its also delightfully clean!
Truly, there are no words to do it justice.
Daring, dashing, and bold, the wraith stole my heart from the very first page and refused to let go even after the wild, explosive climax.
This book is perfect for lovers of fae magic, sweet romance, and a fierce, defiant hero who is willing to sacrifice himself for the lands and people he loves. Its also delightfully clean!
Truly, there are no words to do it justice.
July 22, 2022
This turned a bit more rant-y than I was expecting, and I want to say off the top that I really did enjoy this book. Despite all my grumbling, I would still recommend it to someone looking for a good historical fae read. It was really just one thing that bugged me in hindsight.
I very much enjoyed the world and the writing in The Wraith and the Rose but I found Lily to be an extremely passive and frustrating character.
She didn't do much besides and I felt she had the potential to be really interesting.
Like maybe
Instead, we're repeatedly told how perfect and pretty and kind and wonderful she is and how lucky she is that she was chosen by
Not every heroine can or should be a cool calculating badass swashbuckling hero in her own right - particularly in a Victorian/Regency-coded setting, there should always be a space for shrinking violets or demure young women - but every time she just lets things happen around her without doing anything, it frustrated me. For example,
To be honest, her behaviour didn't bother me so much in reading, particularly in the first half where hers was my favourite perspective. It's only now at my keyboard that I'm thinking over her actions and unearthing more perceived faults.
Despite the above rant, I did enjoy this book and am looking at picking up the sequel when I get a chance. I loved a lot about the book and the world Brightly wrote, and I'm looking forward to seeing what happens next.
I very much enjoyed the world and the writing in The Wraith and the Rose but I found Lily to be an extremely passive and frustrating character.
She didn't do much besides and I felt she had the potential to be really interesting.
Like maybe
Instead, we're repeatedly told how perfect and pretty and kind and wonderful she is and how lucky she is that she was chosen by
Not every heroine can or should be a cool calculating badass swashbuckling hero in her own right - particularly in a Victorian/Regency-coded setting, there should always be a space for shrinking violets or demure young women - but every time she just lets things happen around her without doing anything, it frustrated me. For example,
To be honest, her behaviour didn't bother me so much in reading, particularly in the first half where hers was my favourite perspective. It's only now at my keyboard that I'm thinking over her actions and unearthing more perceived faults.
Despite the above rant, I did enjoy this book and am looking at picking up the sequel when I get a chance. I loved a lot about the book and the world Brightly wrote, and I'm looking forward to seeing what happens next.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
March 18, 2024
Summary
What if the Scarlet Pimpernel was set in a world of men and fae?
When Miss Lilybeth Hathaway arrives in Ardmond for her to be introduced to society, she never expects a whirlwind romance with one of the wealthiest bachelor's Ardmond has to offer. But not all is well. The fae have been stealing human children, and an ellusive and enigmatic character has been stealing them back. Since she does not know the mysterious heroes true identity, Lilybeth vows to help however she can. The most obvious option being volunteering at the home that cares for the liberated children.
Then, on the day of her wedding, a clumsy encounter with the emisary of the fae court brings her romantic fairy tale to a crashing halt. Her previously attentive husband abandons her on their wedding night and returns with a mask of cold indiference.
Thoughts
Brightley managed to capture much of the atmosphere and charm of the original Scarlet Pimpernel story. This retelling focus much of its "screen time" on events that occured before the original story began. Here we see the hero and heroine fall in love ... and fall out of love. Except they haven't fallen out of love at all and the lack of trust breaks both their hearts. I was intrigued to see how Brightley would manage to make Theo and Lily mistrust each other, and it was handled simply, but with enough authenticity to be believable.
Theo does not have quite the same degree of hilarious, foppish charm as the original Sir Percy, but he is quite delightful in his own way. Where Sir Percy is equal parts altruist and thrill seeker, Theo leans much more heavily into the altruist.
This was also one of the more enjoyable "instalove" stories I've read. I wish we got to see more of a reason for Theo's initial and immediate interest in Lily, but there is a good enough blend of commitment and shy gentleness to their relationship that I was willing to accept it. The fact that the original story indicates a whirlwind romance also helped me to accept it here. I also appreciated that, rather than depend on passionate physical displays of affection to depict Lily and Theo's attraction, the author took a path more grounded in wooing and earning trust.
On the (slight) negative side, I found the climax a bit overly grandiose. But I have a feeling that might just be me (and possibly an unfair comparison to the original).
All in all, this is a delightful, fluffy retelling that holds up well enough to The Scarlet Pimpernel to make me happy.
Content
Romance: Mostly consists of romantic guestures (like extravagant gifts) and chaste expressions of love (like hand kissing). Several enthusiastic but undescribed kisses are enjoyed on the wedding day and the female main character bashfully thinks of how she looks forward to going beyond kissing.
Language: None.
Violence: Minimal until the climax, which could be rated PG or PG-13 level gruesomeness depending on how vivid your imagination is. I'd lean more towards PG-13.
Religion: Basically non-existent. Theo and Lily are married in a church by a priest.
What if the Scarlet Pimpernel was set in a world of men and fae?
When Miss Lilybeth Hathaway arrives in Ardmond for her to be introduced to society, she never expects a whirlwind romance with one of the wealthiest bachelor's Ardmond has to offer. But not all is well. The fae have been stealing human children, and an ellusive and enigmatic character has been stealing them back. Since she does not know the mysterious heroes true identity, Lilybeth vows to help however she can. The most obvious option being volunteering at the home that cares for the liberated children.
Then, on the day of her wedding, a clumsy encounter with the emisary of the fae court brings her romantic fairy tale to a crashing halt. Her previously attentive husband abandons her on their wedding night and returns with a mask of cold indiference.
Thoughts
Brightley managed to capture much of the atmosphere and charm of the original Scarlet Pimpernel story. This retelling focus much of its "screen time" on events that occured before the original story began. Here we see the hero and heroine fall in love ... and fall out of love. Except they haven't fallen out of love at all and the lack of trust breaks both their hearts. I was intrigued to see how Brightley would manage to make Theo and Lily mistrust each other, and it was handled simply, but with enough authenticity to be believable.
Theo does not have quite the same degree of hilarious, foppish charm as the original Sir Percy, but he is quite delightful in his own way. Where Sir Percy is equal parts altruist and thrill seeker, Theo leans much more heavily into the altruist.
This was also one of the more enjoyable "instalove" stories I've read. I wish we got to see more of a reason for Theo's initial and immediate interest in Lily, but there is a good enough blend of commitment and shy gentleness to their relationship that I was willing to accept it. The fact that the original story indicates a whirlwind romance also helped me to accept it here. I also appreciated that, rather than depend on passionate physical displays of affection to depict Lily and Theo's attraction, the author took a path more grounded in wooing and earning trust.
On the (slight) negative side, I found the climax a bit overly grandiose. But I have a feeling that might just be me (and possibly an unfair comparison to the original).
All in all, this is a delightful, fluffy retelling that holds up well enough to The Scarlet Pimpernel to make me happy.
Content
Romance: Mostly consists of romantic guestures (like extravagant gifts) and chaste expressions of love (like hand kissing). Several enthusiastic but undescribed kisses are enjoyed on the wedding day and the female main character bashfully thinks of how she looks forward to going beyond kissing.
Language: None.
Violence: Minimal until the climax, which could be rated PG or PG-13 level gruesomeness depending on how vivid your imagination is. I'd lean more towards PG-13.
Religion: Basically non-existent. Theo and Lily are married in a church by a priest.
May 28, 2024
Scarlet Pimpernel + fae - what's not to love? The audiobook narration was fantastic. Finished in a day, loved it!
June 6, 2022
I’ve never read the Scarlet Pimpernel, and the only familiarity with the story I have comes from the Scarlet Pumpernickel Looney Tunes short, so I can’t evaluate how well this book does as an adaptation.
I enjoyed the first half of the book. The setting was nice, and the set up for the overall plot was good. After Lily and Theo got married, though, the story became drawn out and repetitive. The entire second half of the plot was dependent on miscommunication between the newly weds, which was very frustrating because they could have solved everything much faster if they had just been willing to talk with each other. Actually, Lily and Theo didn’t seem to grow as characters after their wedding: Theo stayed brave and reckless and in love, and Lily was naive, boring, and in love. The book also felt very YA even though the characters were in their mid to late 20s. Finally, ending felt abrupt and could have been explained better.
I enjoyed the first half of the book. The setting was nice, and the set up for the overall plot was good. After Lily and Theo got married, though, the story became drawn out and repetitive. The entire second half of the plot was dependent on miscommunication between the newly weds, which was very frustrating because they could have solved everything much faster if they had just been willing to talk with each other. Actually, Lily and Theo didn’t seem to grow as characters after their wedding: Theo stayed brave and reckless and in love, and Lily was naive, boring, and in love. The book also felt very YA even though the characters were in their mid to late 20s. Finally, ending felt abrupt and could have been explained better.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
January 12, 2024
The Scarlet Pimpernel is one of my all time favorite books and I also love the movie. I was really intrigued by this book. It is such a interesting concept yet still worked well with the story. The characters aren’t as intense as the original and Theo isn’t as mysterious as Percy(though certainly as mad). Lilly is also less dark and dramatic and a lot more innocent.
My main complaint was at times it felt rushed. I was planning on giving it 3 stars until I got to the end. Minor spoilers I guess? Theo being drunk on fairy magic was the best thing ever. It was absolutely hilarious. He is such a dear🥰 Definitely the highlight of the book and pushed me up to 4 stars.
Overall it doesn’t compare to the original but is a fun book for scarlet pimpernel or fantasy fans in general.
Also Anslem needs a raise for dealing with Theo’s life risking escapades.
My main complaint was at times it felt rushed. I was planning on giving it 3 stars until I got to the end. Minor spoilers I guess? Theo being drunk on fairy magic was the best thing ever. It was absolutely hilarious. He is such a dear🥰 Definitely the highlight of the book and pushed me up to 4 stars.
Overall it doesn’t compare to the original but is a fun book for scarlet pimpernel or fantasy fans in general.
Also Anslem needs a raise for dealing with Theo’s life risking escapades.
March 14, 2024
So I’m supposed to believe the fmc was in the wrong for being upset with her husband who yelled at and ignored her just bc he had valiant motives that she had no way of knowing?
July 7, 2023
The Scarlet Pimpernel meets Jane Austen’s Persuasion in this Victorian-inspired story filled with enchanting romance, daring heroics, and a dying Fae realm.
The Fair Court has been stealing children from the human realm, and one man is stealing them back.
As the Wraith slips in and out of enemy territory, he leaves behind a rose as a symbol, one that is soon taken up by the people in silent support. Miss Lilybeth Hathaway feels a special affinity for it as Rose is her middle name.
She also feels a special affinity toward handsome, wealthy Theo Overton — who seems equally enchanted with her.
With a special envoy from the Fair Court on the hunt for the Wraith, and more people are taken, will the Wraith be able to rescue them all? And will Lily’s dreams of being Theo’s wife twist like the path to the fae realm?
“Wouldn't it be better to love extravagantly … than to hold back for fear of the unknown?”
Love is the core theme throughout this book, from the way Theo and Lily adore each other, to the selfless giving of the Wraith’s friends and supporters, to the saving of the fae realm itself.
I absolutely adored this book. Brightley writes from an omniscient point of view that allows the reader to follow the characters while still empathizing with them fully.
The heartbreak in this one! I don’t love the miscommunication trope, but I fully get why Theo couldn’t ask Lily about it. To ask would have meant revealing more and he didn’t know if he could trust her. Yet despite everything, he loved her. I would have liked a little more agency from Lily, but I don’t think it took much from the story.
Persuasion is my favorite Jane Austen novel, and this book had the same feel to it — I think Anne and Lilybeth are very similar characters, with a little bit of Catherine’s innocence from Northanger Abbey. The culture and tone are similar, with the added fun of the fae realm.
And everything about the Wraith made me so happy. The Scarlet Pimpernel is one of my favorite series, and this did justice to the hero created by Baroness Orczy. The steel he hides behind his foppish façade is just perfect. Even the way the fairy calls him “puppy” was fitting.
An absolutely gorgeous homage to the original, but also stunningly unique, The Wraith and the Rose is a daring hero novel blended with enchanting romance that had me turning pages late into the night.
5 Stars. I’d give it ten if I could
Lots of kissing, but innocently. Nothing overtly passionate or inappropriate.
No swearing
Some injuries from a sword fight, but not dwelt on.
The Fair Court has been stealing children from the human realm, and one man is stealing them back.
As the Wraith slips in and out of enemy territory, he leaves behind a rose as a symbol, one that is soon taken up by the people in silent support. Miss Lilybeth Hathaway feels a special affinity for it as Rose is her middle name.
She also feels a special affinity toward handsome, wealthy Theo Overton — who seems equally enchanted with her.
With a special envoy from the Fair Court on the hunt for the Wraith, and more people are taken, will the Wraith be able to rescue them all? And will Lily’s dreams of being Theo’s wife twist like the path to the fae realm?
“Wouldn't it be better to love extravagantly … than to hold back for fear of the unknown?”
Love is the core theme throughout this book, from the way Theo and Lily adore each other, to the selfless giving of the Wraith’s friends and supporters, to the saving of the fae realm itself.
I absolutely adored this book. Brightley writes from an omniscient point of view that allows the reader to follow the characters while still empathizing with them fully.
The heartbreak in this one! I don’t love the miscommunication trope, but I fully get why Theo couldn’t ask Lily about it. To ask would have meant revealing more and he didn’t know if he could trust her. Yet despite everything, he loved her. I would have liked a little more agency from Lily, but I don’t think it took much from the story.
Persuasion is my favorite Jane Austen novel, and this book had the same feel to it — I think Anne and Lilybeth are very similar characters, with a little bit of Catherine’s innocence from Northanger Abbey. The culture and tone are similar, with the added fun of the fae realm.
And everything about the Wraith made me so happy. The Scarlet Pimpernel is one of my favorite series, and this did justice to the hero created by Baroness Orczy. The steel he hides behind his foppish façade is just perfect. Even the way the fairy calls him “puppy” was fitting.
An absolutely gorgeous homage to the original, but also stunningly unique, The Wraith and the Rose is a daring hero novel blended with enchanting romance that had me turning pages late into the night.
5 Stars. I’d give it ten if I could
Lots of kissing, but innocently. Nothing overtly passionate or inappropriate.
No swearing
Some injuries from a sword fight, but not dwelt on.
March 27, 2023
⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ | 3 stars for The Wraith and the Rose by C. J. Brightley •
Brightley sets a beautiful scene in this often fun reimagining of the classic Scarlet Pimpernel story. I grew up on the 1982 TV film, and later read Baroness Orczy’s delightful books of the original masked hero—so I couldn’t help but read this clean, imaginative retelling.
What I liked:
Theo is a charming, endearing male lead—fun to follow and cheer for. While he lacks the cunning of his inspiration (the original Scarlet Pimpernel), his fierce loyalty and devotion to his cause, even at the cost of his life if necessary, is wonderful to read. I also loved the setting, the description of rooms, gardens, flowers. Brightley’s world is a pageant of color and sensation. Her use of classical words is especially enjoyable.
What I didn’t like:
The stakes felt too low. Even though children were being taken, and the Fair Lands were disintegrating, somehow the peril seemed distant compared to the whirlwind romance—and subsequent miscommunication. I expected the latter, as it’s in keeping with the original story, but in this it felt forced and unbelievable. Sadly, I found the leading lady, Lily, frustrating in her thoughtlessness. She’s trusted with a secret and then spills said secret to the one person she shouldn’t. Then she’s mopey when she can’t understand why certain people don’t trust her. She felt useless in her own story, except for causing nearly every problem.
Conclusion:
Readers of fantasy romance and fae-centered stories may thoroughly enjoy this. For me, it’s proof of what I already suspected. With very few exceptions, fantasy romance is not my cup of tea.
Brightley sets a beautiful scene in this often fun reimagining of the classic Scarlet Pimpernel story. I grew up on the 1982 TV film, and later read Baroness Orczy’s delightful books of the original masked hero—so I couldn’t help but read this clean, imaginative retelling.
What I liked:
Theo is a charming, endearing male lead—fun to follow and cheer for. While he lacks the cunning of his inspiration (the original Scarlet Pimpernel), his fierce loyalty and devotion to his cause, even at the cost of his life if necessary, is wonderful to read. I also loved the setting, the description of rooms, gardens, flowers. Brightley’s world is a pageant of color and sensation. Her use of classical words is especially enjoyable.
What I didn’t like:
The stakes felt too low. Even though children were being taken, and the Fair Lands were disintegrating, somehow the peril seemed distant compared to the whirlwind romance—and subsequent miscommunication. I expected the latter, as it’s in keeping with the original story, but in this it felt forced and unbelievable. Sadly, I found the leading lady, Lily, frustrating in her thoughtlessness. She’s trusted with a secret and then spills said secret to the one person she shouldn’t. Then she’s mopey when she can’t understand why certain people don’t trust her. She felt useless in her own story, except for causing nearly every problem.
Conclusion:
Readers of fantasy romance and fae-centered stories may thoroughly enjoy this. For me, it’s proof of what I already suspected. With very few exceptions, fantasy romance is not my cup of tea.
June 15, 2024
Set during the Regency period, this book is based on "The Scarlet Pimpernel." However, the main character is saving human children who were kidnapped by fairies, as opposed to victims of the French Revolution. The author includes the theme of an estrangement between the hero and his wife, which of course is rectified by the end. The first half of the book reads like a traditional Regency romance, and is focused on the hero's courtship and marriage. I thought this part was too long, and not all that interesting. The second half of the book focused on the main character's conflict with the fairies. This was more interesting, and could have been developed in more depth. I thought the author included some interesting examples of Christian symbolism, but this came rather late in the story, and was somewhat anti-climactic. Overall, it was a nice idea, but the author should have spent more time developing the fairy aspect of the story, as well as the main characters, but the author had a good idea. Overall, I liked her writing style, except for the fact that many parts of the story were overly long.
February 3, 2026
4 stars — rounded up from 3.5
The Wraith and the Rose was my first novel by C.J. Brightley, and it definitely won me over.
The worldbuilding is rich and immersive, taking its time to set the stage in a way that really pays off later. While the opening is slow, it’s clearly intentional, and once the pieces start falling into place, the buildup makes complete sense. I appreciated that the story didn’t rush its foundations.
The MMC was a standout for me—compelling, layered, and easily my favorite part of the book. He added depth and intrigue to the story and kept me invested even during the slower moments.
By the end, I was fully on board with this world and its characters, and I’m genuinely excited to jump into book two to see where the story goes next.
And can we talk about the cover for a second? Absolutely stunning—one of those books that looks just as good on your shelf as it feels to read.
If you enjoy strong worldbuilding, a rewarding slow burn, and memorable characters, this one is worth picking up.
The Wraith and the Rose was my first novel by C.J. Brightley, and it definitely won me over.
The worldbuilding is rich and immersive, taking its time to set the stage in a way that really pays off later. While the opening is slow, it’s clearly intentional, and once the pieces start falling into place, the buildup makes complete sense. I appreciated that the story didn’t rush its foundations.
The MMC was a standout for me—compelling, layered, and easily my favorite part of the book. He added depth and intrigue to the story and kept me invested even during the slower moments.
By the end, I was fully on board with this world and its characters, and I’m genuinely excited to jump into book two to see where the story goes next.
And can we talk about the cover for a second? Absolutely stunning—one of those books that looks just as good on your shelf as it feels to read.
If you enjoy strong worldbuilding, a rewarding slow burn, and memorable characters, this one is worth picking up.
January 11, 2023
Ugh!!! I don’t know what to say because it wasn’t entirely bad but I didn’t like it.
I wish I could understand how the two main characters developed feelings for one another… You can’t fall in love with a person just because they flatter you and send you flowers. What are the foundations of their “love”? They spent very little time together and didn’t know much of each other except for their favourite colours, hobbies and the people they loved the most. Plus, why wouldn’t he tell her the truth? How can you possibly marry somebody you don’t trust? It doesn’t make sense to me.
The whole conflict with the fairies was pointless, he could have stopped it earlier.
By the way, I found the reasons behind his love for the land of the fairies and its king quite insubstantial and absurd. That king dragged poor, innocent children away from their homes and tortured them, nevertheless he loved him.
On the whole, it was very boring, two stars is all I can give and I’m being generous.
I wish I could understand how the two main characters developed feelings for one another… You can’t fall in love with a person just because they flatter you and send you flowers. What are the foundations of their “love”? They spent very little time together and didn’t know much of each other except for their favourite colours, hobbies and the people they loved the most. Plus, why wouldn’t he tell her the truth? How can you possibly marry somebody you don’t trust? It doesn’t make sense to me.
The whole conflict with the fairies was pointless, he could have stopped it earlier.
By the way, I found the reasons behind his love for the land of the fairies and its king quite insubstantial and absurd. That king dragged poor, innocent children away from their homes and tortured them, nevertheless he loved him.
On the whole, it was very boring, two stars is all I can give and I’m being generous.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
August 11, 2024
Love is the answer
Very enjoyable retelling of the Scarlet Pimpernel. I really enjoyed the fantasy setting and I think it's a great way to retell the Pimpernel. I think Theo and Lily were great reworking of Percy and Marguerite, the romance was very sweet and cute. I also really also like the language of the flowers being included and the meaning of all the flowers Theo sent Lily.
However I think that things that frustrate me where all story beats of the original tale, geeze, he meet you once he's smitten? By the second meeting he purposes? Girl you don't know him. Geeze if only Theo and Lily had only had a conversion; they wouldn't have the two Weeks?!?? of coldness.
I do wish the original little poem had been reworked and include; It's one of my favorite parts of the original
“They seek him here, they seek him there
Those Frenchies seek him everywhere
Is he in heaven or is he in hell?
That demned elusive Pimpernel”
My biggest compliant is everyone blinks way too much. Like every other paragraph someone is blinking. The other ways to show surprise
Excuse me I'm off the suck on the lime to counter the sickly sweetness I just finished.
Very enjoyable retelling of the Scarlet Pimpernel. I really enjoyed the fantasy setting and I think it's a great way to retell the Pimpernel. I think Theo and Lily were great reworking of Percy and Marguerite, the romance was very sweet and cute. I also really also like the language of the flowers being included and the meaning of all the flowers Theo sent Lily.
However I think that things that frustrate me where all story beats of the original tale, geeze, he meet you once he's smitten? By the second meeting he purposes? Girl you don't know him. Geeze if only Theo and Lily had only had a conversion; they wouldn't have the two Weeks?!?? of coldness.
I do wish the original little poem had been reworked and include; It's one of my favorite parts of the original
“They seek him here, they seek him there
Those Frenchies seek him everywhere
Is he in heaven or is he in hell?
That demned elusive Pimpernel”
My biggest compliant is everyone blinks way too much. Like every other paragraph someone is blinking. The other ways to show surprise
Excuse me I'm off the suck on the lime to counter the sickly sweetness I just finished.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 47 reviews