Incredible first novel from a unique talent and artistic vision.
Quick summary: Olive and Penelope are from Cloud Town, but have had to go to school in the rich kids neighborhoods ever since their high school was destroyed by a 'Hurricane' (Kaiju from another dimension). The change had been rough on everyone-- Olive is getting bullied and Penelope's dad is having trouble making ends meet, meaning she has to find a job. But all that changes when the two have a chance encounter with a 'Storm Catcher' (Giant mechs that police the Kaiju). Could one of them have what it takes to be a Storm Catcher pilot?
I didn't know what to expect when I opened Cloud Town but I got a very sophisticated story set in a rich fantasy world with resonances to our own. The 'hurricanes' that buffet the poor people of the Floating Island represent any unstoppable destructive force that always manages to impact the less fortunate more severely. And, as in our world, there exists an elaborate industrial complex dedicated to studying and profiting from these natural disasters, but this system is largely indifferent to the suffering caused by the subject of their study and uninterested in solving the problem permanently. The storm catchers 'tag and bag' the hurricanes, and while they will seek to minimize collateral damage, there's never even a pretense made of closing the dimensional rift or making a permanent end to the destruction they cause.
Structurally, McCloskey weaves a complex narrative, jumping quickly between up to four different plot perspectives at once, displaying a lot of thought given to parallel plotting and pacing. I could easily see this story adapted to an animated or leave live action film, it hits all the right beats. Also it's got incredible comedic timing.
The art is rich with creative detail about the world, and shine most in the faces of the characters, especially in their reaction shots. The visual style is so variable and rich it allows for any kind of style reference, and McCloskey takes full advantage of that. The strongest panels, the ones with extreme emotion or powerful action, remind me of the fantastic Paul Pope.
What really hooked me about this book was the central relationship of the two main characters. Their friendship felt genuine, warts and all, and I was really impressed with the nuance of their respective character arcs. Cloud Town is about coming to terms with not getting the future you want, but growing and finding purpose in the life you have.
There are some hiccups in pacing, storytelling and visual style that you can usually attribute to growing pains in a cartoonist still growing into their style. There were a few moments where the storytelling wasn't as clear as it could have been, and I had to slow down to follow the plotting or blocking. Heavy variation in line width from page-to-page, and a gradual refinement in the character design as the book progresses. This is the kind of thing you see in early work of any comic artist, from Eiichiro Oda to Bill Watterson.
Overall I was hugely impressed, especially now, a day after having finished it, I find my mind returning to think about the characters of Cloud Town. Really looking forward to seeing whatever Dan comes up with next. Here's hoping it's a spin-off series about the dolphin twins!