Even before reading this book I had the sneaking suspicion that Passion and Purity was not going to be among my favorite books. However, since I'm trying to read through and cull out books that we own, I wanted to give it a fair shake to make sure this was the case. The short story is that the book was worse than I had expected. I really didn't enjoy my time with it at all.
The long story about this book is that the book started out okay. The book mostly focuses on the relationship, if you can really call it that because it's very weird, between Elisabeth and Jim with some asides to give advice based on their relationship. It was kind of interesting to hear about their relationship, but at the same time their relationship is so bizarre and full of inconsistencies that it's hard to feel like they're a model to follow.
What do I mean by their relationship being bizarre and full of inconsistencies? It is bizarre for a bunch of different reasons. For starters its not exactly clear that they actually consider themselves "together" or not. Elisabeth seems to be holding out for him, but during this time he also goes off and dates and kisses other women even though he seems set on marrying Elisabeth (if he gets the okay from God which I'll get to later). It's just an odd setup from the beginning.
Add to this the fact that both are planning on going into missions and don't see each other for very long stretches of time, it just sets up a unique situation that I'm not sure that many people can really relate to. It's a strange relationship that has very unique circumstances so it's hard to really see them as this example to follow.
I've already mentioned one of the inconsistencies of their relationship. That is Jim's period of time where he dates and even kisses other women while leaving Elisabeth waiting. If that wasn't bad enough on its own this happens after telling Elisabeth that they shouldn't be too physical with each other. It's hypocrisy in its finest, and not necessarily a shining example. Which you know that's what grace is for, but with the tone of the book and even Jim's instruction to Elisabeth not really being super filled with grace it's a place the book's message falls flat on its face.
Another is closely associated with this, their relationship was supposed to be this beacon of purity, but many of Jim's letters were rather focused on the physical attraction he held for Elisabeth. Which just seemed counterproductive to the message of the book. It's like it is saying it's okay to think about these things and dwell on them for long periods of time, but not to do them or to actually just get married without needing the audible voice of God to give you the green light.
So yeah their relationship is just not exactly one I would look to and say hey I would want to build my relationship off of their example. It is not even a great example for what I would want my kids to follow.
I also haven't even started talking about stuff that I just straight up disagreed with in the book. The primary being this obsession with God giving permission to marry. I am fully behind seeking the will of God and taking ones time to decide if a man or women is of a godly nature to marry. However, the book takes this to a level that I felt was just unhealthy with Elisabeth waiting for God to give Jim the green light to marry her. I could be wrong, but reading it just felt like Jim was leading her on and making her jump through hoops and I'm not sure how much God really had to do with any of it. I say that particularly because you really don't see this method as the model for relationships anywhere in the Bible. While Paul does say it is better to not be married, he also adds that it is better to be married than to burn with lust and well I would say Jim fit that category.
The book is also full of garbage like men needing to be the ones who initiate and provide; and it basically equates stay-at-home dads to sinners. There are no deep justifications for this using scripture (besides a very surface presentation of the wives submit to your husbands passage), but there is an article she includes which says there have been no matriarchies, which seemed very out of place and having men and women be viewed as equal is not necessarily a matriarchy.
So while the book started out okay by the end it felt like a mess. I'm glad that everything worked out for them and they made it to marriage, even though it was tragically short lived due to Jim's death, but I don't really see much benefit from this book. She does have some points here and there that are worth thinking about, like how God does require us to wait and that purity and chastity are good virtues even today. However, I didn't really find much inspiring about their story and so much of how she views relationships, and the roles of men and women I just found plain wrong-headed so that the book's good points weren't worth the sum total of the book.