What do you think?
Rate this book
Killing Women
This true crime biography reveals the disturbing story of a serial killer who terrorized central Michigan—and now has a chance to go free.
As a former youth pastor who attended the Michigan State University School of Criminal Justice, Don Miller seemed like a decent young man. But in 1978, he was arrested for the attempted murder of two teenagers. Police soon connected Miller to the disappearances of four women. In exchange for a controversial plea bargain, he led police to the missing women’s bodies.
Now, thanks to the deal he was offered and changes to Michigan law, Miller is allowed to seek parole once a year. In Killing Women , author Rodney Sadler examines the crimes, the “justice” meted out, and the possibility that Miller could be unleashed on the world once again.
As a former youth pastor who attended the Michigan State University School of Criminal Justice, Don Miller seemed like a decent young man. But in 1978, he was arrested for the attempted murder of two teenagers. Police soon connected Miller to the disappearances of four women. In exchange for a controversial plea bargain, he led police to the missing women’s bodies.
Now, thanks to the deal he was offered and changes to Michigan law, Miller is allowed to seek parole once a year. In Killing Women , author Rodney Sadler examines the crimes, the “justice” meted out, and the possibility that Miller could be unleashed on the world once again.
486 pages, Kindle Edition
Published September 22, 2020
452 people are currently reading
1573 people want to read
About the author
Rod Sadler
6 books44 followersRod Sadler worked as a police officer in mid-Michigan for thirty years before retiring in 2012. He began researching his first book after discovering the story of a brutal 1897 murder in Williamston, Michigan, the town where he had spent his childhood. His great grandfather served as the sheriff at the time of the murder and was an integral part of the investigation.
After returning to college late in his law enforcement career, he discovered his love for writing, and he decided to write about what he knows best...true crime.
In Rod's books, you'll find an enormous amount of research and details that, often times, were never released to the public. His attention to detail allows him to craft intriguing accounts of Michigan murders.
After returning to college late in his law enforcement career, he discovered his love for writing, and he decided to write about what he knows best...true crime.
In Rod's books, you'll find an enormous amount of research and details that, often times, were never released to the public. His attention to detail allows him to craft intriguing accounts of Michigan murders.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 49 reviews
September 22, 2020
Don Miller was a quiet man, an unassuming man. Who could have guessed what atrocities he was responsible for?
Miller strangled four women, some whose bodies were not found at the time, assaulted a teenage girl and stabbed the girl's brother. It was the last two attempted murders that finally put him behind bars. Offered a still-controversial plea bargain, he led police to the bodies of the missing women.
Now, after forty years in prison, Miller has served his time and is due to be released into an unsuspecting population.
The author obviously did diligent research. He takes the reader into the mind of this serial killer .. and then gives the victim their voices.
What I found most interesting was the length the state went to to insure Miller did not leave the prison. Just months away from being released, a psychiatrist warned that Miller was a danger .... who would continue to stalk, kill, torture, while maintaining a perfectly harmless outward appearance.
I had not ever heard about this case, this killer. For anyone who is a fan of true crime, I highly recommend this book.
Many thanks to the author / Wild Blue Press for the digital copy of this true crime account. Read and reviewed voluntarily, opinions expressed here are unbiased and entirely my own.
Miller strangled four women, some whose bodies were not found at the time, assaulted a teenage girl and stabbed the girl's brother. It was the last two attempted murders that finally put him behind bars. Offered a still-controversial plea bargain, he led police to the bodies of the missing women.
Now, after forty years in prison, Miller has served his time and is due to be released into an unsuspecting population.
The author obviously did diligent research. He takes the reader into the mind of this serial killer .. and then gives the victim their voices.
What I found most interesting was the length the state went to to insure Miller did not leave the prison. Just months away from being released, a psychiatrist warned that Miller was a danger .... who would continue to stalk, kill, torture, while maintaining a perfectly harmless outward appearance.
I had not ever heard about this case, this killer. For anyone who is a fan of true crime, I highly recommend this book.
Many thanks to the author / Wild Blue Press for the digital copy of this true crime account. Read and reviewed voluntarily, opinions expressed here are unbiased and entirely my own.
September 25, 2020
Wow !!! I truly believe this is Rod Sadler's best book yet. A must read true crime account of a serial killer in the Lansing, MI area from the mid to late 70's. Rod does an incredible job of introducing all the personalities associated with the crimes from the victims, investigators, attorneys, and the perpetrator and their backgrounds while also doing a great job of giving the reader a lay of the land so to speak for the social climate of the day. From the moment I started reading it I didn't want to put it down. Rod makes you feel like you are a part of this investigation as you read along and become angered, outraged, disgusted, and empathy for all the victims. I do enjoy true crime stories but it's easy to forget that they are TRUE and that there are real people involved in these horrendous crimes. Through Rod's extensive, thorough research I was left feeling like I know these victims and I felt great compassion for them while being incensed that Donald Miller could be free some day. I am very much looking forward to the next project from this author. Thanks for a great read Rod and God Bless the victims of the crimes in this book.
December 16, 2020
2.5 stars. This was the most tedious true crime book I’ve ever read...
September 27, 2020
This is the first book I have read by Rob Sadler and it is a great book, and well written, It’s a gripping story that and captures your emotions and is very hard to put down and I look forward to more books from this author!
As you are drawn into this book You will feel like you are a part of this investigation as the author introducing you all the personalities associated with the crimes from the victims, investigators, attorneys, and the perpetrator. You will feel disgust and anger as you here of all the crimes Don miller has committed and he is only 25 when he is caught. Donald Miller could be free some day but thanks to the prosecution he is still behind bars.
Don manipulated the Psychiatrists that assessed him and admitted to pretending he was mad and seeing things. Although the attorneys had to make a deal to get Doon to confess where the bodies of his victims where they did a brilliant job on all the cases and eventually got Don incarcerated on the rape and attempted murder of a 14 year old girl and her brother. Don is an extremely dangerous criminal who should never be released as he will certainly kill again.
A must read for true crime readers and Many thanks Wildblue Press.
As you are drawn into this book You will feel like you are a part of this investigation as the author introducing you all the personalities associated with the crimes from the victims, investigators, attorneys, and the perpetrator. You will feel disgust and anger as you here of all the crimes Don miller has committed and he is only 25 when he is caught. Donald Miller could be free some day but thanks to the prosecution he is still behind bars.
Don manipulated the Psychiatrists that assessed him and admitted to pretending he was mad and seeing things. Although the attorneys had to make a deal to get Doon to confess where the bodies of his victims where they did a brilliant job on all the cases and eventually got Don incarcerated on the rape and attempted murder of a 14 year old girl and her brother. Don is an extremely dangerous criminal who should never be released as he will certainly kill again.
A must read for true crime readers and Many thanks Wildblue Press.
February 6, 2022
Ugh. I’m so glad to be done with this book. It is essentially just a retelling by way of reading court transcripts. So much repeated information and zero insight.
In addition, the audio version is TERRIBLE! The narrator is trying super hard to be dramatic but failed to do any research on the actual pronunciation of local towns. In Michigan we do not pronounce Charlotte like they do in North Carolina. It may be wrong, but the town here is Char-LOT. Creyts Rd is pronounced with an I sound C-Rights, not crates. Meijer is also pronounced with a long I, not an a as in Mayer. And for goodness sake, it is not Mackinack island - it’s is forever and always pronounced Mackinaw. I don’t understand how the author could approve this narration. If you are from the Lansing area, you would know this things and not allow your listeners to have to cringe all the way through the audio book.
In addition, the audio version is TERRIBLE! The narrator is trying super hard to be dramatic but failed to do any research on the actual pronunciation of local towns. In Michigan we do not pronounce Charlotte like they do in North Carolina. It may be wrong, but the town here is Char-LOT. Creyts Rd is pronounced with an I sound C-Rights, not crates. Meijer is also pronounced with a long I, not an a as in Mayer. And for goodness sake, it is not Mackinack island - it’s is forever and always pronounced Mackinaw. I don’t understand how the author could approve this narration. If you are from the Lansing area, you would know this things and not allow your listeners to have to cringe all the way through the audio book.
June 21, 2023
This book is comprehensive to the point of being tedious. For a criminal whose reign of terror lasted 3 years, this could have been an interesting read were the author to dig into the mind of this monster. instead, the book goes on for hours and hours about every single moment of his trials with little to no insight. I suppose if you wanted to know how every single moment of a murder trial works, leaving absolutely nothing out, go for it. I found it to be dry, too long, and fairly boring. Just not my kind of thing. No exposition, no point of view, no opinions, no personality whatsoever.
February 8, 2022
I love that this is a newer book. I enjoyed reading about a new case, I loved learning that the killer tried apply for parole again last year, and I found the last third of the book so intriguing and how desperate they were to keep him incarcerated.
The author did a great job, although I did find it to get too bogged down in unnecessary history in the beginning third of the book. But other than that, a solid true crime read.
The author did a great job, although I did find it to get too bogged down in unnecessary history in the beginning third of the book. But other than that, a solid true crime read.
July 23, 2022
I picked this up thinking I was reading a book about women to kill…That was not the case, however I did still enjoy the book. I had not heard of this serial killer before, so it was an interesting subject manor.
This is the first book I have read by this author, but I would definitely look into more. Nothing better than a true crime story!
This is the first book I have read by this author, but I would definitely look into more. Nothing better than a true crime story!
October 12, 2020
Some aspects of the case are barely touched upon while others are discussed interminably.
June 12, 2023
Overall: 3 stars.
The first half of this book was fascinating, but the second really dragged. I’m moderately familiar with the Lansing, Michigan, area, but I’d never heard of this serial killer before, so it was really interesting to learn about crimes happening in an area I sorta-kinda knew. The author excels at retelling the “action” scenes: the crimes themselves and the investigators discovering them for the first time. What he’s not so great at is the legal drama, which comprises the second half or so of the book. Miller entering a pea of not guilty by reason of insanity is really interesting (or could be) because it’s a pretty rare strategy, but the author doesn’t maintain momentum through the courtroom scenes as he had in the investigation ones. The author revisits the preliminary hearing testimonies and actual trial testimonies almost word-for-word in some parts, which is really repetitive, but he fast-forwards and summarizes the trial conclusion. I think it’s just a matter of editing and pacing which brings down the final parts of the book.
Still, if you’re a true crime nerd and are interested in obscure serial killers like I am, this is worth checking out: just be prepared for the loss of narrative momentum once the story enters in the legal drama phase.
The first half of this book was fascinating, but the second really dragged. I’m moderately familiar with the Lansing, Michigan, area, but I’d never heard of this serial killer before, so it was really interesting to learn about crimes happening in an area I sorta-kinda knew. The author excels at retelling the “action” scenes: the crimes themselves and the investigators discovering them for the first time. What he’s not so great at is the legal drama, which comprises the second half or so of the book. Miller entering a pea of not guilty by reason of insanity is really interesting (or could be) because it’s a pretty rare strategy, but the author doesn’t maintain momentum through the courtroom scenes as he had in the investigation ones. The author revisits the preliminary hearing testimonies and actual trial testimonies almost word-for-word in some parts, which is really repetitive, but he fast-forwards and summarizes the trial conclusion. I think it’s just a matter of editing and pacing which brings down the final parts of the book.
Still, if you’re a true crime nerd and are interested in obscure serial killers like I am, this is worth checking out: just be prepared for the loss of narrative momentum once the story enters in the legal drama phase.
October 11, 2020
If you like true crime books this is one to pick up or add to your to be read list. Well written page turner to say the least. This will make you wander why people can be so sick and do the things they do. This book will draw you in and make you feel like you are part of the real investigation that took place. One of the best true crime book I have read in awhile!
January 3, 2025
Good, but very dry listen.
October 17, 2020
I don’t typically read true crime books but this one caught my eye. I lived in the Lansing Michigan area during the time of the murders, I attended the same church as The Millers and Young families and knew many of the areas that were mentioned in this book.
I found this book compelling. I was interested in what happened after Don Miller’s conviction and incarceration. Although some of the courtroom scenes in this book were long for me, I learned a lot about the law. I recognized the names, of the legal team, of course, as well.
I think this is a well written book.
I found this book compelling. I was interested in what happened after Don Miller’s conviction and incarceration. Although some of the courtroom scenes in this book were long for me, I learned a lot about the law. I recognized the names, of the legal team, of course, as well.
I think this is a well written book.
November 10, 2023
2.5 stars. Overly repetitive to the point of tedious. Save some time and just read the court documents.
October 30, 2020
Meh... The book was good, but not great, and left a lot of questions unanswered for me. I started school at MSU in 1979 right after Don Miller was on trial. I’ve lived in the Lansing area since then and never knew anything about this case until this book. It was interesting to read about places that I have known and frequented many times over the past decades, albeit now with a macabre association.
As someone who likes true crime stories and television shows, and has a great interest in psychopathic and abnormal psychology, this book felt a little flat on that for me. There’s not much history about how Don grew up and what made him the way he was, nor is there a “reason” why he committed these crimes or how he went about them other than generalities. Not to be gruesome, but it would have been interesting to know how he killed these women, why he chose them, why were Marita’s hands cut off and why did her grave have an altar-like quality to it? Why were Martha’s clothes laid out the way they were yet her body was disposed of 2 miles away? Did he actually run Kristine down with his car before getting out and arguing with her and pushing her into the front seat? Did he actually “date” Wendy Bush before he killed her? And how did he end up out at a rural house on Canal Road attacking two young teens – was it random or planned? How do we know that? A few of these things you find out at the very end of the book when he’s talking about the trial for the garrotte, but by then the timing is off and you have to reconnect the dots.
Though there are some minor descriptions of people and places, don’t expect anything exceptional In terms of setting the scene or building tension. Much of the book is a dry retelling of court documents to the point that dozens of footnotes stating consecutive pages for court documents follow each chapter. That made the book very slow reading for me.
Finally, the author’s credibility was challenged by numerous instances of missing words, misplaced commas, a few verb tense issues, and the fact that he misspelled “Alaiedon Township” and “Town Courier”, things he should know if he’s lived here all his life. A couple instances even made me chuckle! Throughout the book, the killer is called Don or Donald, yet at one point he answers that his name is Don, not Donald. So why do the author and others keep referring to him as “Donald Miller” throughout the rest of the book? I found that irritating, though ultimately of little importance to the point of the book. I’m not sure who edited the book, but a good editor would’ve caught all those things. I have to say, in support of a budding author, I do appreciate his time and energy researching the topic and presenting it to us in this format.
As someone who likes true crime stories and television shows, and has a great interest in psychopathic and abnormal psychology, this book felt a little flat on that for me. There’s not much history about how Don grew up and what made him the way he was, nor is there a “reason” why he committed these crimes or how he went about them other than generalities. Not to be gruesome, but it would have been interesting to know how he killed these women, why he chose them, why were Marita’s hands cut off and why did her grave have an altar-like quality to it? Why were Martha’s clothes laid out the way they were yet her body was disposed of 2 miles away? Did he actually run Kristine down with his car before getting out and arguing with her and pushing her into the front seat? Did he actually “date” Wendy Bush before he killed her? And how did he end up out at a rural house on Canal Road attacking two young teens – was it random or planned? How do we know that? A few of these things you find out at the very end of the book when he’s talking about the trial for the garrotte, but by then the timing is off and you have to reconnect the dots.
Though there are some minor descriptions of people and places, don’t expect anything exceptional In terms of setting the scene or building tension. Much of the book is a dry retelling of court documents to the point that dozens of footnotes stating consecutive pages for court documents follow each chapter. That made the book very slow reading for me.
Finally, the author’s credibility was challenged by numerous instances of missing words, misplaced commas, a few verb tense issues, and the fact that he misspelled “Alaiedon Township” and “Town Courier”, things he should know if he’s lived here all his life. A couple instances even made me chuckle! Throughout the book, the killer is called Don or Donald, yet at one point he answers that his name is Don, not Donald. So why do the author and others keep referring to him as “Donald Miller” throughout the rest of the book? I found that irritating, though ultimately of little importance to the point of the book. I’m not sure who edited the book, but a good editor would’ve caught all those things. I have to say, in support of a budding author, I do appreciate his time and energy researching the topic and presenting it to us in this format.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
January 22, 2024
"Killing Women: The True Story of Serial Killer Don Miller's Reign of Terror" by Rod Sadler is a chilling and meticulously researched account that delves into the disturbing reality of a serial killer's reign. Sadler's narrative expertise and dedication to unraveling the details of Don Miller's crimes provide readers with a riveting, albeit haunting, journey into the darkest corners of true crime.
One of the strengths of Sadler's work is his commitment to accuracy and thoroughness. The author takes great care to present a comprehensive and well-researched account of Don Miller's crimes, ensuring that the book stands as a reliable historical document. This commitment to detail enhances the credibility of the narrative, offering readers a clear and unflinching look into the horrifying events that transpired during Miller's reign of terror.
Sadler's writing style is both engaging and empathetic, allowing readers to connect with the victims and their families. He navigates the delicate balance between presenting the gruesome details of the crimes and honoring the memory of those who suffered. This humanizing approach adds a layer of depth to the narrative, making it more than just a recounting of heinous acts but a sobering reflection on the impact of such crimes on individuals and communities.
The book also excels in its exploration of the investigative process and legal proceedings surrounding Don Miller. Sadler provides readers with a behind-the-scenes look at the efforts to apprehend and bring the serial killer to justice, shedding light on the complexities of criminal investigations and the challenges faced by law enforcement.
Furthermore, "Killing Women" stands out for its societal and cultural commentary, prompting readers to reflect on the broader issues surrounding crime, justice, and the vulnerability of certain individuals within society. Sadler doesn't shy away from addressing the systemic failures that allowed Miller to evade capture for an extended period, fostering important discussions about the need for reform and vigilance in preventing such atrocities.
In conclusion, Rod Sadler's "Killing Women" is a gripping and thought-provoking true crime account that skillfully navigates the complexities of a serial killer's reign. The book's meticulous research, empathetic storytelling, and insightful commentary on the investigative process make it a standout in the true crime genre. For those fascinated by criminal psychology, law enforcement procedures, and the human impact of heinous crimes, this book offers a compelling and sobering exploration into the depths of a serial killer's darkness.
One of the strengths of Sadler's work is his commitment to accuracy and thoroughness. The author takes great care to present a comprehensive and well-researched account of Don Miller's crimes, ensuring that the book stands as a reliable historical document. This commitment to detail enhances the credibility of the narrative, offering readers a clear and unflinching look into the horrifying events that transpired during Miller's reign of terror.
Sadler's writing style is both engaging and empathetic, allowing readers to connect with the victims and their families. He navigates the delicate balance between presenting the gruesome details of the crimes and honoring the memory of those who suffered. This humanizing approach adds a layer of depth to the narrative, making it more than just a recounting of heinous acts but a sobering reflection on the impact of such crimes on individuals and communities.
The book also excels in its exploration of the investigative process and legal proceedings surrounding Don Miller. Sadler provides readers with a behind-the-scenes look at the efforts to apprehend and bring the serial killer to justice, shedding light on the complexities of criminal investigations and the challenges faced by law enforcement.
Furthermore, "Killing Women" stands out for its societal and cultural commentary, prompting readers to reflect on the broader issues surrounding crime, justice, and the vulnerability of certain individuals within society. Sadler doesn't shy away from addressing the systemic failures that allowed Miller to evade capture for an extended period, fostering important discussions about the need for reform and vigilance in preventing such atrocities.
In conclusion, Rod Sadler's "Killing Women" is a gripping and thought-provoking true crime account that skillfully navigates the complexities of a serial killer's reign. The book's meticulous research, empathetic storytelling, and insightful commentary on the investigative process make it a standout in the true crime genre. For those fascinated by criminal psychology, law enforcement procedures, and the human impact of heinous crimes, this book offers a compelling and sobering exploration into the depths of a serial killer's darkness.
December 10, 2022
Was this book well researched, absolutely, extremely detailed. Was it extremely boring to read, again, absolutely. I’m an attorney, and even I was bored with the 200 some pages in the middle of the book which essentially recited word for word the court record on what comments and questions each attorney asked and what motions they made. Most folks don’t care about those technical details, just the highlights and the ultimate judgment.
Book would’ve been at least one more star if it was trimmed by 150-200 pages.
Book would’ve been at least one more star if it was trimmed by 150-200 pages.
March 28, 2022
I really liked all the details included as I think the author was trying to show balanced journalism but at the same time, I have loads of other questions such as why didn't his family charge him with the sexual assault of his sister? (mind-boggling that they still support him in prison as it seems to imply in the book) The whole hypnotism of witnesses - I don't even know what to make of that as it made me question so many things. Have there been no attempts to find the still missing women? But most of all, it barely covered down on the mind of the killer. Yes, we know he was a morally corrupt religious zealot (of sorts??) but barely know of his upbringing - especially since we are told he sexually abused (unknown in what sense) his sister. And that sister, a victim who protected her abuser so many times, sad as well as disgustingly tragic. His pathetic parents...if I believe what is written.
The difficult parts were the stale writing style & the lack of current police/scientific updates other than mentioning his parole hearings. About halfway through the book, I thought I was reading a novel written in 1980 and not one written 2 years ago. Who made the decision to not shed any new acuity on the trial, evidence, or persons? In one sense, it was like I was in 1978-1979 when the trial came to court. This is always enlighting to me as we all know now how nearly impossible it could have been because of a lack of DNA technology. So the fingerprinting, the hypnotism, the lie detector results mentioned in the book were almost as page-turning as the crime.
The victim blaming of the past was on show here too....ugghhhh, hard to read!!
I think half the trial transcripts were in this book...which tho I liked, I could sense they were cherry picked. I like to believe the insignificant transcripts were left out, but it hurt the story telling because I could sense pieces missing even tho I'm sure it was no value added if it had been included.
The difficult parts were the stale writing style & the lack of current police/scientific updates other than mentioning his parole hearings. About halfway through the book, I thought I was reading a novel written in 1980 and not one written 2 years ago. Who made the decision to not shed any new acuity on the trial, evidence, or persons? In one sense, it was like I was in 1978-1979 when the trial came to court. This is always enlighting to me as we all know now how nearly impossible it could have been because of a lack of DNA technology. So the fingerprinting, the hypnotism, the lie detector results mentioned in the book were almost as page-turning as the crime.
The victim blaming of the past was on show here too....ugghhhh, hard to read!!
I think half the trial transcripts were in this book...which tho I liked, I could sense they were cherry picked. I like to believe the insignificant transcripts were left out, but it hurt the story telling because I could sense pieces missing even tho I'm sure it was no value added if it had been included.
October 27, 2022
⚠️ TW: rape, sexual assault, physical assault, violence, murder, multilation, graphic content ⚠️ I first came across this case a few weeks ago when discussing the controversial plea deal that was given to Don Miller, and having never heard about it before I just knew I had to read this book! This book follows the life and crimes of Donald Gene Miller, a serial killer from Lansing, Michigan, who was known for being a quiet, reserved man who was a former youth pastor and a recent graduate of Michigan State University in Criminal Justice at the time of his arrest. He was arrested in 1978 for the attempted murders of two teenagers and during the investigation it was quickly discovered that he was likely responsible for the disappearances of 4 other women. Yet despite this he was offered a controversial plea deal that is still being questioned. And now after 40 years in prison he has served his time and is due to be released in 2031. This book is such an interesting read that examines the crimes, the 'justice' and Miller's impending freedom. We all know I'm a big true crime lover and this case has genuinely shocked me and left me with so many questions that I will be endlessly researching. This is such an unknown case, to my knowledge, and I think that's what makes it scarier because I've since read book reviews from people that lived in the area at the time or went to MSU in the same year but never knew of this case. It seems it was all kept very quiet until the full extent of the plea deal came out within the last decade. Overall, I highly recommend this read if you are into true crime and anyone that is aware of this case please message me 🙈
October 28, 2020
Don Miller's case is fascinating in that morbid way of true crime. It's easy to see in retrospect how disturbed and, yes, creepy this man is, but of course we already know he's a serial killer, and now we're looking at events through that special lens hindsight provides. Still, I can't help but think this guy must've given off an uneasy vibe, at the very least.
A lot of research and detail is provided within these pages. We get to know Miller and his victims, and we see how his strict religious beliefs shaped him. Then we follow the investigation, arrest, trial, and eventual conviction.
The writing is methodical, a straight forward account that sometimes lacks personality. This is more textbook than narrative nonfiction; the kind of book you read for facts rather than emotion.
Content, particularly in the second half, is often repetitive, as we're provided with an extensive account of the investigation, preliminary hearing, and trial.
For me, the most interesting aspect of the trial process was the psychological testing Don Miller was given by both the prosecution and defense. The psychiatrists' opposing conclusions, which so often happens in these cases, is troubling, and says more about our faulty justice system than about Miller's mental health.
Also included is a letter written to the author by Don Miller, which gives us a glimpse into this killer's mind. Is he crazy or a master of manipulation? I'm thinking both.
*I received a review copy from WildBlue Press.*
A lot of research and detail is provided within these pages. We get to know Miller and his victims, and we see how his strict religious beliefs shaped him. Then we follow the investigation, arrest, trial, and eventual conviction.
The writing is methodical, a straight forward account that sometimes lacks personality. This is more textbook than narrative nonfiction; the kind of book you read for facts rather than emotion.
Content, particularly in the second half, is often repetitive, as we're provided with an extensive account of the investigation, preliminary hearing, and trial.
For me, the most interesting aspect of the trial process was the psychological testing Don Miller was given by both the prosecution and defense. The psychiatrists' opposing conclusions, which so often happens in these cases, is troubling, and says more about our faulty justice system than about Miller's mental health.
Also included is a letter written to the author by Don Miller, which gives us a glimpse into this killer's mind. Is he crazy or a master of manipulation? I'm thinking both.
*I received a review copy from WildBlue Press.*
November 2, 2025
This book had the potential to be a gripping true crime account. The first half delivers exactly that; a fascinating, well researched look into a little known killer and the horrifying crimes that gripped the community. The author excels at capturing the tension of the investigation, the discoveries, and the shock of each revelation. Those early chapters are taut and engaging, and I found myself drawn in.
Unfortunately, the second half of the book loses all that momentum. Once the narrative shifts into the courtroom, the pacing slows to a crawl. The author seems intent on including every single detail of the legal proceedings, from procedural motions to witness testimonies. While Miller's plea of not guilty by reason of insanity could have been a fascinating focal point, it's buried under pages of repetitive and overly detailed trial transcripts that make the story drag painfully.
In the end, this could have been an excellent true crime read had it been more tightly edited. The lack of narrative flow and emotional insight in the later chapters really brings down what began as a promising, well written investigation. If you're deeply interested in courtroom procedure or rare insanity defenses, you may find value here, but for most true crime readers, the endless trial scenes make this one a three star read rather than the standout it could have been.
Unfortunately, the second half of the book loses all that momentum. Once the narrative shifts into the courtroom, the pacing slows to a crawl. The author seems intent on including every single detail of the legal proceedings, from procedural motions to witness testimonies. While Miller's plea of not guilty by reason of insanity could have been a fascinating focal point, it's buried under pages of repetitive and overly detailed trial transcripts that make the story drag painfully.
In the end, this could have been an excellent true crime read had it been more tightly edited. The lack of narrative flow and emotional insight in the later chapters really brings down what began as a promising, well written investigation. If you're deeply interested in courtroom procedure or rare insanity defenses, you may find value here, but for most true crime readers, the endless trial scenes make this one a three star read rather than the standout it could have been.
October 19, 2020
Chilling!
Sadler pens a chilling title in KILLING WOMEN: The True Story of Serial Killer Don Miller’s Reign of Terror. I am a fan of true crime stories, and this one chilled me to the bone. I wasn't familiar with Miller's reign of terror, but I will now never forget it. Sadler tells the story as he was familiar with it and in law enforcement. He certainly did his research and did the victims a service by telling the stories. It's not just about what Miller did, it's who he did it to. In the beginning, Jeffrey Sauter, prosecutor, is quoted, "his persona is a disguise ... the same disguise that he used before, both to get close to his victims, and to deny culpability. Miller's crimes identify him as a human predator, and there is no reliable basis to conclude he has changed." Miller is one of Michigan's notorious serial killers. I learned a lot from this story, and it probably helps others in law enforcement as a tool. I also want to mention the victim's names in honor of their terrifying story, so they will be remembered; Martha Sue Young, Marita Choquette, Wendy Bush, and Kristine Stuart. I look forward to reading more by this author. This book is a definite recommendation by Amy's Bookshelf Reviews.
Sadler pens a chilling title in KILLING WOMEN: The True Story of Serial Killer Don Miller’s Reign of Terror. I am a fan of true crime stories, and this one chilled me to the bone. I wasn't familiar with Miller's reign of terror, but I will now never forget it. Sadler tells the story as he was familiar with it and in law enforcement. He certainly did his research and did the victims a service by telling the stories. It's not just about what Miller did, it's who he did it to. In the beginning, Jeffrey Sauter, prosecutor, is quoted, "his persona is a disguise ... the same disguise that he used before, both to get close to his victims, and to deny culpability. Miller's crimes identify him as a human predator, and there is no reliable basis to conclude he has changed." Miller is one of Michigan's notorious serial killers. I learned a lot from this story, and it probably helps others in law enforcement as a tool. I also want to mention the victim's names in honor of their terrifying story, so they will be remembered; Martha Sue Young, Marita Choquette, Wendy Bush, and Kristine Stuart. I look forward to reading more by this author. This book is a definite recommendation by Amy's Bookshelf Reviews.
September 29, 2020
This book was so good that I couldn't put it down. I started reading this in the early evening and read straight through into the early morning. Rod has done an excellent job of telling this tale. His descriptions brought it all back, the horror and the fear that was felt in knowing that there was a serial killer so close to our homes. Rod's book takes you there, his book it fast-paced and told the tale in a realistic and descriptive way. He was precise and the story flowed easily, and it made you feel like you were there with the police and others who dealt with trying to find this man and to put him behind bars so we would all feel safe. I grew up in Eaton County and was a teenager when this happened. This was a crime that my mother held up as an example of what to be wary of as a young girl. I remember the news reports and my grandmother reading about this in the Lansing State Journal. We were all aware of this case and everyone felt great relief when this was over. If you are a lover of True Crime then this is definitely a book that you want to add to your library, you'll be glad that you did.
January 19, 2021
Don Miller is Up for Parole This Year (2021)
It is a well written and researched book on the Serial Killer Don Miller, who had murdered five women and was only caught because he attempted to rape and murder a teenage girl and her younger brother in broad daylight. Most of the book covers the multiple interviews he and the witnesses had with law enforcement, and the various legal proceedings culminating his conviction for the rape and attempted murder of the teenage girl and the attempted murder of her younger brother. I can’t understand how he is sentenced to 30 to 50 years but with good behavior he was going to be released in only 19 years. Fortunately, the authorities convicted hIm of making a deadly weapon in prison which revoked his good time and added additional time to his incarceration.
I looked him up and found that in 2016 the full parole board heard his parole application and rejected it and the next parole hearing would be five years later which is this year, 2021. I hope they again reject it now and again in 2026, so that he will only be released in 2031 at the age of 76.
It is a well written and researched book on the Serial Killer Don Miller, who had murdered five women and was only caught because he attempted to rape and murder a teenage girl and her younger brother in broad daylight. Most of the book covers the multiple interviews he and the witnesses had with law enforcement, and the various legal proceedings culminating his conviction for the rape and attempted murder of the teenage girl and the attempted murder of her younger brother. I can’t understand how he is sentenced to 30 to 50 years but with good behavior he was going to be released in only 19 years. Fortunately, the authorities convicted hIm of making a deadly weapon in prison which revoked his good time and added additional time to his incarceration.
I looked him up and found that in 2016 the full parole board heard his parole application and rejected it and the next parole hearing would be five years later which is this year, 2021. I hope they again reject it now and again in 2026, so that he will only be released in 2031 at the age of 76.
December 7, 2022
Fans of Law & Order will appreciate this book. This is a rather complete telling of the crimes committed by Don Miller, who in the late 1970's raped and/or killed several women and stabbed one young man which were committed around the Lansing/East Lansing areas of Michigan.
It goes into great detail of the crimes (as far as can told via witnesses and evidence), the court proceedings, and sentencing of Miller. Some parts were a bit repetitive (evidence and some of the eye witness testomony), but it was all crucial to understanding the background, circumstances, and timelines that all played critical roles in the trial and conviction.
It goes into great detail of the crimes (as far as can told via witnesses and evidence), the court proceedings, and sentencing of Miller. Some parts were a bit repetitive (evidence and some of the eye witness testomony), but it was all crucial to understanding the background, circumstances, and timelines that all played critical roles in the trial and conviction.
July 6, 2023
The story was well written and you could tell the author had done research on the case.
But the narration felt off to me at times and seemed to jump around a bit.
It could have been due to the timelines of everything and when the trial actually took place compared to the attacks, but it just didn't flow as I read it which made it tough to follow exactly what had happened at some times.
Overall, it was a comprehensive retelling of the cases and the trials, and gave the story of the girls who were murdered/attacked very well, without glorifying the person who did it in a weird way as some books do.
But the narration felt off to me at times and seemed to jump around a bit.
It could have been due to the timelines of everything and when the trial actually took place compared to the attacks, but it just didn't flow as I read it which made it tough to follow exactly what had happened at some times.
Overall, it was a comprehensive retelling of the cases and the trials, and gave the story of the girls who were murdered/attacked very well, without glorifying the person who did it in a weird way as some books do.
January 3, 2021
I'd split this book into two halves: the first half describing the nature of the crimes and the lives of the victims is engaging and well written, the second half drags on and reads like a court transcript. Well-researched book overall and a case that deserves the attention, just wish the retelling of what transpired in Miller's court hearings didn't get so caught up in the minutia of legal motions and detailed play-by-plays of every witness called.
February 27, 2022
A VERY CREEPY BOOK ABOUT A VERY CREEPY SERIAL KILLER! What made it very scary for me is that I live in the areas in the book. I graduated from Michigan State University with a Criminal Justice Degree. I am familiar with some of the police and prosecutors that cracked this case. BUT, this all happened back in the 1970's when I was a little kid living somewhere else in Michigan. Very well written and thorough!
May 29, 2023
Chilling
The telling of Donald Millers reign of terror is filled with the gruesome details of the murders he committed. The number of lives he changed forever was staggering. He had no concern for any of the victims or their families.
His grandiose tries to make people believe he could not have caused such violent crimes is unconscionable.
I would recommend this book for those that like true crime books.
The telling of Donald Millers reign of terror is filled with the gruesome details of the murders he committed. The number of lives he changed forever was staggering. He had no concern for any of the victims or their families.
His grandiose tries to make people believe he could not have caused such violent crimes is unconscionable.
I would recommend this book for those that like true crime books.
May 13, 2024
I was graduating high school and starting college in Lansing at the time Don Miller was committing murders of women. As I read the book I recalled the stories in the news of the missing women and of Lisa and Randy Garrett. The book presented the facts based on court records. I learned many facts about the court preceding that I didn’t have previous knowledge of. It is scary to think Don Miller could be released in May 2031.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 49 reviews