**Many thanks to Minotaur and Camilla Sten for an ARC of this book! Now available as of 3.29!**
I've read three books now featuring prosopagnosia: two were 5 star reads...
and then there was this one.
Eleanor is the character in question, afflicted by this condition, but it held her hostage at a dangerous time. She walks in on the murdered body of her grandmother and actually SEES the killer firsthand...but since she cannot identify the person, this encounter is meaningless. The vision of the day in question haunts her every waking thought. However, her grandmother's death has set off a chain of events...namely, a house left to her called Solhaga, leading Eleanor, the lawyer who has clued her in on this inheritance, her reliable boyfriend Sebastian, and slightly snappy and bizarre aunt Veronika are all off to visit the estate and find out firsthand what remains. What they all find is a plethora of secrets and an air of unease that hangs about the grounds, and Eleanor begins to discover that perhaps the past will no longer lie in wait.
Once a body turns up, however, the group begins to realize that the dead might have more to say than anyone realized. Can Eleanor find the clues to help her piece together who targeted her grandmother Vivianne on that fateful day? Is the killer on the loose...and looking to add HER body to the growing count? And is there ANY escaping Solhaga?
This one starts with a flurry of activity, and lots of blank space for interpretation. The scene is set, giving the reader a glimpse of Eleanor's observation of the murder and her subsequent loss of memory, and interrogation later on where she can't recall anything useful. I was drawn in pretty quickly by this setup, and thankfully this book has very short chapters.
Unfortunately, the quick pacing I should have felt while reading this kept getting slower and slower. We are introduced early to a timeline from the past via found diary, and this timeline was not only overly convoluted, it felt very repetitive and sometimes predictable. Perhaps the 'action' from the diary was just lacking, or maybe it was just too many diary entries, but after a while I lost interest. Eleanor and her posse also showed a major lack of judgment over and over, allowing their cell phones to die at the worst (and yes, most unlikely) moments and everything fell into place a little too neatly at times.
I also didn't feel the connection to the PLACE, which should have been a foreboding and terrifying character all its own. Perhaps the last atmospheric, creepy-house read I had just did it better, but for whatever reason, Solhaga didn't scare me. This was incredibly disappointing, since atmosphere would have certainly helped to sustain the tension while I was reading, and everything mentioned felt a bit generic.
The author also chose to use not one, not two, not three, but FOUR names beginning with V: Vivianne, Victoria (actually Eleanor, who chooses to go by Eleanor, but it's still included frequently enough), Veronika and Vendela. This didn't add anything to the narrative at all, and I don't think it was even intended to muddle things...but did anyway.
I didn't guess the final twist, and I must admit I had an alternate theory (after reading tons of thrillers) that was completely wrong. Sad to say, however, that even though I thought the ending was clever enough, I didn't really enjoy it at all. It just felt a bit out of left-field and not as thrilling or fulfilling as I'd hoped.
This read might not have been what I anticipated, but I do feel I'd give this author another try. Fans of a somewhat spooky slow burn with lots of buried family secrets and drama might find respite at The Resting Place...but for now, I think I'd better keep looking.
3.5 stars