Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Their Secret Courtship

Rate this book
They have almost everything in common…

except the thing that could keep them apart.

Much to her Amish mother's exasperation, Bay Stutzman isn't looking for a husband. That is, until a buggy accident on a stormy night leads to meeting handsome greenhouse owner David Jansen—who might just be Bay's perfect match. The only problem? David is a Mennonite. Now Bay is torn between her life among the Amish…and the man she can't envision a life without.

From Love Uplifting stories of faith, forgiveness and hope.

368 pages, Paperback

Published January 25, 2022

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Emma Miller

90 books313 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
94 (59%)
4 stars
47 (29%)
3 stars
12 (7%)
2 stars
3 (1%)
1 star
2 (1%)
Displaying 1 - 16 of 16 reviews
Profile Image for Tina Loves To Read.
3,887 reviews1 follower
November 14, 2021
This is a Clean Amish Romance. This book is all about an Old Order Amish young lady, Bay that falls from a Mennonite young man, David. I have to say I love Bay so much. Bay is just trying to find her place that she fits in her Old Order Amish friends and family. She does not want what the Amish tells her she needs to be. I loved seeing Bay open up and become herself in this book. This was not a cute romance, but it was a great read with strong characters making hard decision. I think the last part of this book was packed with so much stuff, but it was great. I was kindly provided an e-copy of this book by the publisher (Love Inspired) or author (Emma Miller) via NetGalley, so I can give an honest review about how I feel about this book. I want to send a big Thank you to them for that.
Profile Image for Jeanie.
3,093 reviews1 follower
December 10, 2021
Bay Stutzman is an independent Amish young woman. She is not married because she believes in marrying for love and not convenience. She also loves working in the dirt and growing flowers. Unlike most Amish women, she wants to have her own business in what she is passionate about. Living with her mother and step father, her mother worries for her and her future. A argument ensues and in Bay's stubbornness she goes off on a fools errand and meets handsome greenhouse owner David Jansen.

David rescues Bay and a friendship ensues. David lives with his sister and her son. She is a single parent. Both brother and sister help each other out in many different ways. Bay develops a friendship with Annie's David's sister. In doing so, David and her develop a deeper relationship. What keeps their relationship from going deeper is that David is not Amish and lives an English lifestyle. His sister is Mennonite. Their story reflects on the differences and how family ties are so strong. Bay has to keep a balance in her relationship until she is forced to make a decision or lose the man she has come to love. It is a story about how love can overcome misunderstanding, prejudices, and sacrifice. Love is patient and looks to the good of others. Their story reflects the love chapter of the bible that are popular in weddings.

Love is patient, love is kind. It does not envy, it does not boast, it is not proud. 5 It does not dishonor others, it is not self-seeking, it is not easily angered, it keeps no record of wrongs. 6 Love does not delight in evil but rejoices with the truth. 7 It always protects, always trusts, always hopes, always perseveres. 1 Corinthians 13.

I heard in a sermon once to replace your name where love is written. It is an eye opening exercise and Bay and David passed that test. Highly recommend.

A special thank you to Harlequin and Netgalley for the ARC and the opportunity to post an honest review.
Profile Image for Lynda.
1,318 reviews36 followers
February 2, 2022
Their Secret Courtship by Emma Miller is a standalone novel with two central characters. Bay Stutzman is Amish; David Jansen was Amish but is now a Mennonite. The first sentence in the description is a perfect introduction: “They have almost everything in common…except the thing that could keep them apart.“

Bay is not your “typical” Amish maiden. She isn’t that interested in cooking and cleaning house isn’t on that list either. What she *does* like to do is work in the greenhouse with her stepbrother Joshua — so much so, she is half owner.

David Jansen owned and operated a commercial nursery in Wisconsin. He sold that business and has set up another when he moved to the community to assist his sister, Annie, a widow with a young son, Matty. Matty has not spoken since his father died. Annie is in her final trimester of pregnancy. When she and Bay meet, it’s like they have been friends forever.

Bay’s mam, Rosemary, seems determined about one thing — Bay must marry a good Amish husband. And soon. Bay is far more interested in plants. She is not husband hunting and won’t even to please her mother.

Bay has a buggy accident. David rescues her and they discover they have interests in the same thing. And the story takes off from there.

The pacing of the story good with side stories involving Annie, Matty, and Bay’s family — no cliffhanger ending. I really liked Bay; she knew what she wanted yet took other people’s feelings into account. I will admit it — I fell in love with Matty. The book was enjoyable. Good character development and enough “side” characters to make it interesting.

I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher, Harlequin – Romance, via NetGalley. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

Rating: 4.5 stars. I felt the ending before the Epilogue was just a bit weak. However, I have rounded the stars to five.
Cover rating: Loved this cover. Fit the book perfectly.
Expected publish date: January 25, 2022

#TheirSecretCourtship #NetGalley #EmmaMiller
Profile Image for Brittany .
3,049 reviews220 followers
February 5, 2022
What a wonderfully written story! This book is part of a series, yet is definitely its own stand alone novel, as well. I love this cover, too. It fits the story and the two main characters perfectly.

One of the things that I really appreciated about this book was the way the two main characters communicated. They were both such genuinely nice people and it was sweet the way they connected as friends with a common passion of gardening, even as their hearts wanted more than friendship. I liked the way that David was forthcoming in his feelings toward Bay and respectful of her at all times.

Bay’s friendship with Anne, David’s sister, was wonderful, as well. I loved seeing Bay bond with little Matty and help him as he opened up and healed after his father’s death. These characters all felt like real people to me.

I received a complimentary copy of this book. All opinions are my own.

You can read this review on my blog:
https://brittreadsfiction.wordpress.c...
Profile Image for Pamela Pavkov.
1,270 reviews23 followers
February 14, 2022
Their Secret Courtship is an inspiring story written by Emma Miller. This author never disappoints her readers and always delivers a story with meaning. Her characters are always spot on for her story. This story is filled with friendship, love, devastation, and forgiveness. At one point I was brought to tears it was so sad. With two different faiths at play within this story it makes for deceit on one person's part.

I was not given a complimentary copy of this book to read and review. I was not approached to post a favorable response and all opinions are my own. I have rated this story with five stars for meeting my expectations of a wonderful story that I can highly recommend to others.
Profile Image for Lynda.
1,318 reviews36 followers
November 22, 2021
Their Secret Courtship by Emma Miller is a standalone novel with two central characters. Bay Stutzman is Amish; David Jansen was Amish but is now a Mennonite. The first sentence in the description is a perfect introduction: “They have almost everything in common…except the thing that could keep them apart.“

Bay is not your “typical” Amish maiden. She isn’t that interested in cooking and cleaning house isn’t on that list either. What she *does* like to do is work in the greenhouse with her stepbrother Joshua — so much so, she is half owner.

David Jansen owned and operated a commercial nursery in Wisconsin. He sold that business and has set up another when he moved to the community to assist his sister, Annie, a widow with a young son, Matty. Matty has not spoken since his father died. Annie is in her final trimester of pregnancy. When she and Bay meet, it’s like they have been friends forever.

Bay’s mam, Rosemary, seems determined about one thing — Bay must marry a good Amish husband. And soon. Bay is far more interested in plants. She is not husband hunting and won’t even to please her mother.

Bay has a buggy accident. David rescues her and they discover they have interests in the same thing. And the story takes off from there.

The pacing of the story good with side stories involving Annie, Matty, and Bay’s family — no cliffhanger ending. I really liked Bay; she knew what she wanted yet took other people’s feelings into account. I will admit it — I fell in love with Matty. The book was enjoyable. Good character development and enough “side” characters to make it interesting.

I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher, Harlequin – Romance, via NetGalley. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

Rating: 4.5 stars. I felt the ending before the Epilogue was just a bit weak. However, I have rounded the stars to five.
Cover rating: Loved this cover. Fit the book perfectly.
Expected publish date: January 25, 2022

#TheirSecretCourtship #NetGalley #EmmaMiller
Profile Image for Anna Marie.
1,484 reviews2 followers
July 18, 2022
I have to be honest: I think the Amish vs. Mennonite vs. Christian thing is ridiculous. All three are 1) set apart from the world, 2) believers in Jesus, 3) Bible-centric, 4) careful what they have to do with the worldliness around them, and 5) seek a life of peace, kindness, and integrity.

((Okay, so not so much integrity with the Amish, since they're both delusional and hypocritical. Cellphones in the barn are okay, but not the house? Riding in a car is okay, but not driving? Wearing machine-made safety pins is okay, but not wooden buttons? Using generators is okay, but not electricity? Except they use that, too. And they drive, if work calls for it, and they bend EVERY one of their rules. It's ridiculous.))

Bay knows this. She knows of the hypocrisy. So when she meets David, his way of life isn't different from hers except in that he's *HONEST* about the things he uses to make daily tasks easier. But the thing is, she doesn't want to be a subservient housewife, tied to children and a stove, hearth and home. She loves the mystery of hydroponics, loves working in the greenhouse, loves having a business.

Amish women don't do that. Except they do - they have bakeries and quilt shops, and DON'T GET ME STARTED. So the whole thing is convoluted. Especially when David loves her for her independence, but then needs a wife/mother person - and Bay takes it as he wants to shove her in a box she hasn't wanted to be put in.

She really ought to have talked to her mother the whole way thru. It drove me crazy that she was 'independent' but so weak as to have hidden things, like any other girl would. It was annoying. Was she strong-willed/minded, or not?!

David was amazing, but it aggravates me that they dressed him as Amish-ite on the cover, when in the book he wears polos, aviators, puffy vests, and jeans. C'mon.

It also irritated me that Bay was TWENTY-SIX years old. I'm sorry, but if they only educate thru the 8th grade (age 14), then she wouldn't be single TWELVE YEARS, hello. Not if she wasn't averse to marriage/partnership. In the regular world, sure, but... not AmishLand.

Still. Their relationship was really good. I liked the friendship between Anne and Bay (before Anne dies, which... I wasn't sure Emma would do - I was hoping she wouldn't, actually. It feels like a cheat, to me). I liked the children.

I just have serious issues with the Amish. And Mennonites, for that matter... because honestly, what makes them *ANY* different from the way I live (TV-free, homeschooling, homesteading, recycling, gardening, canning/baking, etc.). Other than that I left christianity, I mean...?
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Lori Ann | Faith in Bloom.
38 reviews
June 3, 2026
Their Secret Courtship by Emma Miller is a heartwarming romance filled with faith, family, and the search for where you truly belong.

Bay Stutzman is an independent Amish woman, while David Jansen is a dependable and kind Mennonite man. Their unexpected meeting quickly blossoms into a friendship as they discover how much they have in common. As Bay and David grow closer, they must navigate the challenges that come with their different faith traditions. Their relationship felt genuine and natural, never forced. I especially loved watching their friendship slowly develop into something deeper.

As they face family expectations, questions of faith, and uncertain futures, I enjoyed following their journey toward a happily-ever-after. There were so many touching moments throughout the story that tugged at my heart. One particular loss was especially emotional, but it also served as a beautiful reminder that God brings beauty from ashes.

Bay and David were easy to root for, and I couldn't have been happier to see them find their way together. This uplifting, faith-filled story carries a wonderful message about following your heart, trusting God's plan, and finding your place in the world. Once again, Emma Miller has written a lovely story that delighted me to know end!
Profile Image for Maureen Timerman.
3,357 reviews500 followers
December 28, 2021
A chance meeting that changes lives. A new friend, and with a lot in common, except religion.

Bay's mother is hounding her to marry, but would she accept a Mennonite? Will she loose her heart, only to lose her family?

There are answers here, but will David be able to juggle everything as his family life seems to be stumbling. Yes, sparks are flying, and we are walking with them, but you also might want to have the tissues handy, there are some rough times ahead.

I have read many books by Ms Miller, and this will not be the last.

I received this book through Net Galley and the Publisher Love Inspired, and was not required to give a positive review.
Profile Image for Janice .
703 reviews10 followers
November 3, 2023
Something a Bit Different

I enjoyed this book as while you had the Amish elements it wasn't the typical read
I can't say full without giving the story away
Bay &David are seeing each other she is Amish he is ex Amish a Mennonite so can Bay give up her life in the Amish community to be with David
Bay says that she is going to see David's sister Anne who son Matty has stopped talking since the death of his father & Anne is expecting a baby
I think that you will enjoy this book I certainly did
Profile Image for Dali Castillo.
740 reviews22 followers
May 21, 2022
This is a very sweet and inspirational read. It totally tugged at my heartstrings. I loved how Bay and David's relationship evolved. While I knew it would be a happily ever after, I didn't know how Bay and Daniel would get there. The author included various surprise events that kept me guessing and made the end result that much more special.
Profile Image for Sherry Brown.
1,061 reviews116 followers
February 18, 2023
Bay Stutzman is Amish. David Jansen is Mennonite. This wonderful book has unexpected surprises, taking chances, hope, hard decisions, heartache, heart felt moments, with wonderful characters. My emotions were everywhere. So very very good!!!
469 reviews2 followers
May 15, 2022
I've read quite a few books by Emma Miller, and this one didn't disappoint! This is her latest stand-alone novel from Love Inspired.
52 reviews
March 10, 2024
Loved this book. Emma Miller had we right with her characters in this book, cheering them on.
Profile Image for Joyce.
277 reviews
December 27, 2021
a fun read! I thought I knew how it would end but Emma Miller kept throwing in surprises
Displaying 1 - 16 of 16 reviews