What do you think?
Rate this book
What Remains True: A Novel
One woman wants to win a bet. One man wants to become a rodeo champion. One little girl may give them both something even better—from USA Today bestselling author Nancy Naigle.
“A commitment-phobic rodeo star and a divorcée with secrets find love in this wholesome romance. . . . As uplifting as it is sweet.”— Publishers Weekly
Working at a little shop on Main Street in a small town is exactly the break that executive Merry Anna Foster needs following her divorce. She’s made a bet with her ex-husband that she can live on the amount of money she’s giving him in alimony. If she can do it, then Kevin will have to stop complaining and leave her alone. But after three months of this new life, will she even want to leave Antler Creek?
Adam Locklear, bull rider and owner of the local feedstore, is having the best year of his rodeo career. He’s also a bit distracted by the pretty new neighbor living in his old bunkhouse. But Adam has no time for matters of the heart. He’s got his future all mapped out, and that future doesn’t involve a woman just yet. It doesn’t involve parenting a little girl either. However, Carly Fowler still suddenly leaves five-year-old Zan—the daughter Adam didn’t know he had—in his care.
Is it possible that the future holds a life even better than what Merry Anna and Adam had each dreamed of? One that includes both tenderness and even love—not just for each other but for Zan too.
“A commitment-phobic rodeo star and a divorcée with secrets find love in this wholesome romance. . . . As uplifting as it is sweet.”— Publishers Weekly
Working at a little shop on Main Street in a small town is exactly the break that executive Merry Anna Foster needs following her divorce. She’s made a bet with her ex-husband that she can live on the amount of money she’s giving him in alimony. If she can do it, then Kevin will have to stop complaining and leave her alone. But after three months of this new life, will she even want to leave Antler Creek?
Adam Locklear, bull rider and owner of the local feedstore, is having the best year of his rodeo career. He’s also a bit distracted by the pretty new neighbor living in his old bunkhouse. But Adam has no time for matters of the heart. He’s got his future all mapped out, and that future doesn’t involve a woman just yet. It doesn’t involve parenting a little girl either. However, Carly Fowler still suddenly leaves five-year-old Zan—the daughter Adam didn’t know he had—in his care.
Is it possible that the future holds a life even better than what Merry Anna and Adam had each dreamed of? One that includes both tenderness and even love—not just for each other but for Zan too.
336 pages, Paperback
Published May 3, 2022
48 people are currently reading
638 people want to read
About the author
Nancy Naigle
61 books2,198 followersNEW RELEASE: A South Hill Christmas Keepsake—out now!
USA TODAY bestselling author Nancy Naigle writes heartwarming small-town stories of love, faith, and second chances. With more than forty novels to her name, eight have been adapted for television on Hallmark Channel, Hallmark Movies & Mysteries, and FOX Nation. Her award-winning ECPA Bestseller The Shell Collector was also the first FOX Original Movie and is now streaming on FOX Nation.
Nancy’s newest Christmas novel, A South Hill Christmas Keepsake, is a heartfelt story inspired by her real-life hometown in Virginia—a tale of lost love, small-town wonder, and rediscovering the magic of community during the holidays.
Up next, she’ll return to the beloved Whelk’s Island universe in Home No Matter Where (coming May 2026), the third installment in The Shell Collector series—continuing her signature blend of coastal charm, healing, and hope.
After a successful career in the banking industry, Nancy followed her heart and took early retirement to write full-time. Now living in the small town of Franklin, Virginia, she crafts stories that celebrate the simple joys of life, the beauty of belonging, and the power of love to restore even the most fragile hearts.
When she’s not writing, you’ll find her browsing antique shops, painting, or weaving pine needle baskets—always on the lookout for the next small spark of inspiration to turn into a story you’ll never forget.
USA TODAY bestselling author Nancy Naigle writes heartwarming small-town stories of love, faith, and second chances. With more than forty novels to her name, eight have been adapted for television on Hallmark Channel, Hallmark Movies & Mysteries, and FOX Nation. Her award-winning ECPA Bestseller The Shell Collector was also the first FOX Original Movie and is now streaming on FOX Nation.
Nancy’s newest Christmas novel, A South Hill Christmas Keepsake, is a heartfelt story inspired by her real-life hometown in Virginia—a tale of lost love, small-town wonder, and rediscovering the magic of community during the holidays.
Up next, she’ll return to the beloved Whelk’s Island universe in Home No Matter Where (coming May 2026), the third installment in The Shell Collector series—continuing her signature blend of coastal charm, healing, and hope.
After a successful career in the banking industry, Nancy followed her heart and took early retirement to write full-time. Now living in the small town of Franklin, Virginia, she crafts stories that celebrate the simple joys of life, the beauty of belonging, and the power of love to restore even the most fragile hearts.
When she’s not writing, you’ll find her browsing antique shops, painting, or weaving pine needle baskets—always on the lookout for the next small spark of inspiration to turn into a story you’ll never forget.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 180 reviews
May 7, 2022
What Remains True by Nancy Naigle
Merry Anna finds peace and happiness in the small town of Antler Creek. She loves her job and the bunkhouse she’s renting. If only her ex husband would leave her and her family alone, she could move on with her life. Meeting the cowboy next door adds a bit of companionship.
A charming courtship.
One too many misunderstandings and backing away by both bit they get it right by the end.
Sweet and delightful.
4.5
I received a copy of this from NetGalley. I’m purchased a copy to keep.
Merry Anna finds peace and happiness in the small town of Antler Creek. She loves her job and the bunkhouse she’s renting. If only her ex husband would leave her and her family alone, she could move on with her life. Meeting the cowboy next door adds a bit of companionship.
A charming courtship.
One too many misunderstandings and backing away by both bit they get it right by the end.
Sweet and delightful.
4.5
I received a copy of this from NetGalley. I’m purchased a copy to keep.
January 25, 2022
Really it was a 3.5 stars. My NetGalley book for the week. The story of 2 individuals who don't want to fall in love because of life circumstances but can't help being drawn to each other. Life happens, he is a bull rider and discovers he is a father to a 5 year old and she wants to help but is he using her for help or does their friendship mean something more? I really liked the book minus the ending. I felt the ending rushed but the book was fun to read in general. Both characters were written well along with the supporting characters in the book. You really feel the main character wanting to become a part of a community and wanting to start over. Yes I did get frustrated with the main male lead. He is a Christian but admits of have many sexual relationship one leading to a 5 year old little girl. This is a Christian book and this is reality for many but it was written as a normal thing for people to do. So I found this frustrating. But in general a fun romance book that was an relaxing read for a day here with lots of snow! Would recommend it!!
January 8, 2022
Merry Anna is fresh from a hurtful and complicated divorce and has landed in a small North Carolina town that has offered her refuge and a job. She has a bet with her ex-husband that if she can live on what she's giving him in alimony for three months, she won't have to increase his payment. The problem with the ex is that he's lazy but a gold-digger and wants more. He's schmoozing his way into her parents' good graces in order to find her and demand more from her.
Adam Locklear is a rodeo cowboy who wants to make it to the finals this year and win big. He's Merry Anna's next door neighbor, the owner of the feed store, bull rider, and a romantic at heart. Because of his career choice, he is estranged from his parents who don't approve of the danger of his sport.
Merry Anna doesn't tell anyone in town about her divorce, her background, or where she's originally from; she wants to remain hidden, she wants to find out what she really wants in life, and she wants to be free from her ex forever.
Adam gets the surprise of his life when an old one-night-stand shows up with a little girl in tow, one that she claims is his. She leaves the girl in his care and immediately gets herself into a car wreck. Adam now has to reassess his priorities with his career, with his life, with himself. The opportunities that come disguised as problems make for some incredible food for thought.
I have come to appreciate Nancy Naigle's writings--she has characters with flaws that make them more realistic and likable. She has settings that are so beautifully described, it makes readers feel they are right there enjoying the scenery. Her plot lines move at a good pace and keep readers involved in the story throughout. I didn't find any places where the plot dragged, and I was so IN to the book, I lost sleep over it.
Five Stars, Two Thumbs Up, and a belt buckle the size of a dinner plate.
Waterbrook/Multnomah Publishing and NetGalley.com provided the copy I read for this review. All opinions expressed are solely my own.
Adam Locklear is a rodeo cowboy who wants to make it to the finals this year and win big. He's Merry Anna's next door neighbor, the owner of the feed store, bull rider, and a romantic at heart. Because of his career choice, he is estranged from his parents who don't approve of the danger of his sport.
Merry Anna doesn't tell anyone in town about her divorce, her background, or where she's originally from; she wants to remain hidden, she wants to find out what she really wants in life, and she wants to be free from her ex forever.
Adam gets the surprise of his life when an old one-night-stand shows up with a little girl in tow, one that she claims is his. She leaves the girl in his care and immediately gets herself into a car wreck. Adam now has to reassess his priorities with his career, with his life, with himself. The opportunities that come disguised as problems make for some incredible food for thought.
I have come to appreciate Nancy Naigle's writings--she has characters with flaws that make them more realistic and likable. She has settings that are so beautifully described, it makes readers feel they are right there enjoying the scenery. Her plot lines move at a good pace and keep readers involved in the story throughout. I didn't find any places where the plot dragged, and I was so IN to the book, I lost sleep over it.
Five Stars, Two Thumbs Up, and a belt buckle the size of a dinner plate.
Waterbrook/Multnomah Publishing and NetGalley.com provided the copy I read for this review. All opinions expressed are solely my own.
April 26, 2022
This new story by Nancy Naigle is a delightful trip back into the North Carolina mountains. A trip through Antler Creek gives Merry Anna Foster a new direction in life. She stopped for gas and decided to stay for a little while. She is on leave from work with her family business in DC. She made a bet with her ex-husband that she can live on less and he can too. He can get a job, so she doesn't have to give him more alimony. She is loving her simple life working in a small gift shop and living in an old bunkhouse. She never expected to fall in love with small town life nor a cowboy and little girl.
Adam Locklear is a rodeo bull rider on the course to win it all and then pursue a career in rodeo stock. He enjoys spending time with Merry Anna, but they are just friends. Then, he has surprise visitors from the past that changes his future.
This is a sweet endearing story filled with likable, realistic characters in a lovely setting.
I received a complimentary ARC from WaterBrook & Multnomah and NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. The thoughts and opinions expressed are mine only.
Adam Locklear is a rodeo bull rider on the course to win it all and then pursue a career in rodeo stock. He enjoys spending time with Merry Anna, but they are just friends. Then, he has surprise visitors from the past that changes his future.
This is a sweet endearing story filled with likable, realistic characters in a lovely setting.
I received a complimentary ARC from WaterBrook & Multnomah and NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. The thoughts and opinions expressed are mine only.
March 27, 2022
Merry Anna (that’s not a typo) has taken a leave from the family business following a rocky divorce from a cheating husband. She stops in the small town of Antler Creek, North Carolina to get gas. On a whim, Merry Anna decides to stay. She rents an old bunkhouse from her new boss, Krissy. The property used to belong to Adam Locklear. He runs the local feed store and has a degree in sports medicine. But his passion is rodeo. In fact, he’s got his eye on this year’s rodeo championship. And nothing else.
Determined to put her ex-husband and that past behind, Merry Anna just wants to remain anonymous. Adam is smarting over a family rift. Neither is looking for a relationship. Both have secrets. In fact, one shows up on Adam’s door step, unannounced. But then…
Oh, wait. You’ll have to read the book to find out what happens next.
And what a delicious read this is! Heartfelt and homespun, this tale of loss, regrets, and another chance at true love will make you want to stand up and cheer. It’s a vibrant and vivacious kind of “baseball, hot dogs, apple and Chevrolet” kind of story, with plenty of warmth and whimsy. Also the most dangerous eight seconds in sports. (You’ll get that if you know rodeo. If not, kindly look it up.)
A robust storyline, idyllic settings, and rich characterizations saturate this dynamic story that has more twists than Rocket Fuel (you’ll still get that if you read the book.) It’s replete with characters we want to know better. Sit down and set a spell and chat over a glass of sweet iced tea.
There’s a family rift between Adam and his parents. Their stonewall of silence make it clear just how much they disapprove of his rodeoing. He’s a whiz in the kitchen. But he’s also not the “borrow a cup of sugar kind of neighbor.”
Wait. Is that a strawberry pie?
Scene stealers: Shorty, Adam’s indomitable Corgi. Chips, Adam’s beautiful buckskin trail horse who loves tortilla chips. Also Tara, Merry Anna’s neighbor and geriatric dynamo.
This gently faith-flavored story and clean romance took me back to days of bits and bridles. Manes and tales. The creak of saddle leather. The tangy pungency of fresh hay. And a welcoming whinny. Loved it!
Determined to put her ex-husband and that past behind, Merry Anna just wants to remain anonymous. Adam is smarting over a family rift. Neither is looking for a relationship. Both have secrets. In fact, one shows up on Adam’s door step, unannounced. But then…
Oh, wait. You’ll have to read the book to find out what happens next.
And what a delicious read this is! Heartfelt and homespun, this tale of loss, regrets, and another chance at true love will make you want to stand up and cheer. It’s a vibrant and vivacious kind of “baseball, hot dogs, apple and Chevrolet” kind of story, with plenty of warmth and whimsy. Also the most dangerous eight seconds in sports. (You’ll get that if you know rodeo. If not, kindly look it up.)
A robust storyline, idyllic settings, and rich characterizations saturate this dynamic story that has more twists than Rocket Fuel (you’ll still get that if you read the book.) It’s replete with characters we want to know better. Sit down and set a spell and chat over a glass of sweet iced tea.
There’s a family rift between Adam and his parents. Their stonewall of silence make it clear just how much they disapprove of his rodeoing. He’s a whiz in the kitchen. But he’s also not the “borrow a cup of sugar kind of neighbor.”
Wait. Is that a strawberry pie?
Scene stealers: Shorty, Adam’s indomitable Corgi. Chips, Adam’s beautiful buckskin trail horse who loves tortilla chips. Also Tara, Merry Anna’s neighbor and geriatric dynamo.
This gently faith-flavored story and clean romance took me back to days of bits and bridles. Manes and tales. The creak of saddle leather. The tangy pungency of fresh hay. And a welcoming whinny. Loved it!
April 24, 2022
I fell in love with Adam, Zan, and Merry Anna. I loved the cowboy showing Merry Anna how to make homemade strawberry pies. Flipping flour on her was so cute. This was a fast fun read and I hope to see it on the big screen soon.
5 stars and I HIGHLY recommend it.
The Mary Reader received this book from the publisher for review. A favorable review was not required, and all views expressed are our own.
5 stars and I HIGHLY recommend it.
The Mary Reader received this book from the publisher for review. A favorable review was not required, and all views expressed are our own.
April 29, 2022
What Remains True by Nancy Naigle is a sweet story. I thought it contained good writing with realistic characters. It did, though, take me a little while to get invested in the story. I liked Merry Anna Foster who is discovering hidden talents. I like how she tried new things such as planting a garden, fixing up old items, and painting a barn quilt for her home. I felt bad for her with regard to her parents and her ex-husband. Her parents should have supported her decisions. Of course, it would have helped if Merry Anna had told them the truth about her ex-husband. Merry Anna was passing through Antler Creek and fell in love with the town. Merry Anna takes a break from her job at the family office supply company which has consumed her life. Merry Anna gets a job at a local store and rents an old bunkhouse. She falls in love with the town and soon finds hidden talents. Merry Anna’s neighbor is bull rider, Adam Locklear. He also owns the local feed and seed. Adam has invested everything in obtaining the top title this year in the rodeo circuit. He does not have time for romance. He did not count on meeting Merry Anna. Adam gets a surprise when he learns he has a daughter, and he is now responsible for her care. This certainly puts a kink in Adam’s plans. What Remains True is a charming story. I like reading this type of book during the summer. There is a great cast of supporting characters that includes Tara, Merry Anna’s new neighbor and Krissy, Merry Anna’s boss. I love the descriptions of the items at Krissy’s shop. There were many things I wanted to purchase including the barn quilt ornaments. Little Zan stole the show. She is a sweet little girl who is smart and happy. The Christian element is light (the characters attend church). I did feel the ending was a little rushed. One of the themes in the story is how not being truthful complicates relationships. It can lead to misunderstandings, the loss of trust, and even the loss of a friend. I liked the community of Antler Creek. The residents are friendly and welcome newcomers. The author really captured the sense of community and the small-town feel. There were fun events for people to attend. The residents are quick to help each other out and gossip flows faster than maple syrup on a hot stack of pancakes. It was interesting learning more about bull riding. It is certainly a dangerous profession. I had never heard of mutton busting (I do not know if I would let my child try it). I like how the title is tied into the story. I believe Tara needs a story of her own so we can find out what happens to her home. What Remains True is a great book to read while laying by the pool or in front of a roaring fire in the winter. What Remains True is a charming tale with a comfortable bunkhouse, beautiful barn quilts, a rodeo rider, a cheerful child, an incessant ex-husband, unsupportive parents, and new ventures.
July 3, 2022
I love Nancy's novels for when I want a good heartfelt, cozy read! Merry Anna has decided to attempt to start her life over. To try and live easier and to be happy and do things as she wants. Having been raised in the family business, that is all she knew. Work, work, work and with that came plenty of money, but is that really what life is all about. Newly divorced, her ex-husband does not agree with the amount of alimony he has been given each month and determined to prove to him that he can live off of that amount- she agrees to live for the next few months on that same amount - if she can do it, then things will stay as is, but if she really cannot live with that amount then they can renegotiate.
Merry Anne, having found a quaint little town, where no one knows her or who her family is has found a small safe haven that she has come to love. She has her own little place, enjoys the easy life of the small town and the friendliness of the neighbors. Everyone seems to help everyone else and life is simple here. But simple soon becomes complicated when the local well known famous cowboy returns to town and has his eye on Merry Anne meanwhile her ex-husband has done some digging to find out where she has been residing to see for himself if she is really making it on her own like she claims. Things are about to get a bit complicated for this little town, and as we all know - news often travels fast with local gossip of what is going on, and who is seen with who.
Thank you to Travelling Pages Tours for the invite and to the author for the free autographed novel. I really enjoy the easiness of reading her books. The storylines and characters often have a subtle reminder for us all, that things do not have to be so complicated.
Merry Anne, having found a quaint little town, where no one knows her or who her family is has found a small safe haven that she has come to love. She has her own little place, enjoys the easy life of the small town and the friendliness of the neighbors. Everyone seems to help everyone else and life is simple here. But simple soon becomes complicated when the local well known famous cowboy returns to town and has his eye on Merry Anne meanwhile her ex-husband has done some digging to find out where she has been residing to see for himself if she is really making it on her own like she claims. Things are about to get a bit complicated for this little town, and as we all know - news often travels fast with local gossip of what is going on, and who is seen with who.
Thank you to Travelling Pages Tours for the invite and to the author for the free autographed novel. I really enjoy the easiness of reading her books. The storylines and characters often have a subtle reminder for us all, that things do not have to be so complicated.
April 21, 2022
Merry Anna needs a fresh start and finds it - and herself - in Antler Creek, North Carolina. After her divorce, she takes a leave of absence from the family business and decides to stay in this little town she comes across when getting gas. She quickly falls in love with the town. The slower pace of life, appreciating the smaller things and making genuine friends, as well as attending church again all have Merry Anna feeling happier than she has ever felt.
Adam Locklear is a professional bull rider on the path to the championship this year. He has a big goal and hopes that by winning this year, he can retire to the back end of the sport with the livestock. He was the previous owner of the bunkhouse Merry Anna is living in and is her neighbor.
They're both going through so much and trying to find themselves and what matters most but also trying to avoid a relationship. However, these two are absolutely meant to be and can't seem to stop what God has planned. I loved the theme of following your heart, trying new things, and believing in the possibility of more.
I absolutely loved this book! The characters were the perfect small-town blend and the setting could not have been better. I fell in love with Antler Creek as much as I did Merry Anna and Adam. This would be an incredible start to a series. I for one would love to keep visiting Antler Creek. It would make a wonderful movie! The story had healing, love, and faith - all the elements that make your heart smile.
I received an early copy of this book and am voluntarily sharing my honest review. My opinion is not influenced in any way.
Adam Locklear is a professional bull rider on the path to the championship this year. He has a big goal and hopes that by winning this year, he can retire to the back end of the sport with the livestock. He was the previous owner of the bunkhouse Merry Anna is living in and is her neighbor.
They're both going through so much and trying to find themselves and what matters most but also trying to avoid a relationship. However, these two are absolutely meant to be and can't seem to stop what God has planned. I loved the theme of following your heart, trying new things, and believing in the possibility of more.
I absolutely loved this book! The characters were the perfect small-town blend and the setting could not have been better. I fell in love with Antler Creek as much as I did Merry Anna and Adam. This would be an incredible start to a series. I for one would love to keep visiting Antler Creek. It would make a wonderful movie! The story had healing, love, and faith - all the elements that make your heart smile.
I received an early copy of this book and am voluntarily sharing my honest review. My opinion is not influenced in any way.
April 4, 2022
This is a new-to-me-author and overall, I liked this story. It took me a while to really get into the story, but as I got to know the characters, I found myself more invested in the story.
There was a few turns of events I did not see coming which helped the story remain interesting.
There was one major problem I had which for me personally kept this from a 3-star. The male lead, Adam, acknowledged previous intimate relationships and he made a comment that he and Mary Anna did not sleep together very loosely, and at the same time he is a Christian and volunteers with the youth. I know we all are sinners, made mistakes, have a past and are forgiven, however, that promise comes with repentance and turning our back to sin. Through what I've read, I did not get that message/feeling that Adam is repentant and in fact turned his back to that life. God made intimacy to enjoy between a husband and wife, but the message I got through Adam is: just be careful, which is not in line with God's word.
*I received a complimentary copy from the publisher. All opinions expressed are my own.*
There was a few turns of events I did not see coming which helped the story remain interesting.
There was one major problem I had which for me personally kept this from a 3-star. The male lead, Adam, acknowledged previous intimate relationships and he made a comment that he and Mary Anna did not sleep together very loosely, and at the same time he is a Christian and volunteers with the youth. I know we all are sinners, made mistakes, have a past and are forgiven, however, that promise comes with repentance and turning our back to sin. Through what I've read, I did not get that message/feeling that Adam is repentant and in fact turned his back to that life. God made intimacy to enjoy between a husband and wife, but the message I got through Adam is: just be careful, which is not in line with God's word.
*I received a complimentary copy from the publisher. All opinions expressed are my own.*
January 11, 2022
What Remains True by Nancy Naigle takes place in Antler Creek North Carolina. Merry Anna Foster becomes enchanted with the small town as she drives through, takes a job and settles in after a nasty divorce.
Adam Locklear, a rodeo bull rider, makes plans to get to the finals. He is estranged from his parents because of his career choice, as they don't approve of his bull riding. Five year old Zan changes Adam's life and his relationship with Merry Anna.
This story is about new beginnings and relationships. Nancy Naigle has a way of communicating a Christian message as her characters face unexpected challenges.
I received a complimentary ebook copy from the publisher, through NetGalley. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
Adam Locklear, a rodeo bull rider, makes plans to get to the finals. He is estranged from his parents because of his career choice, as they don't approve of his bull riding. Five year old Zan changes Adam's life and his relationship with Merry Anna.
This story is about new beginnings and relationships. Nancy Naigle has a way of communicating a Christian message as her characters face unexpected challenges.
I received a complimentary ebook copy from the publisher, through NetGalley. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
January 23, 2022
An endearing story filled with hope and love. I received a complimentary copy of the book. No review was required.
May 2, 2022
Merry Anna stops in Antler Creek, North Carolina for gas. There was something about this place that called her name, and for the first time she was free to think outside the box and explore life not just live under the demands of her parents and their business. She takes a retail job in a small shop. There she connects with people on a whole new level. It’s liberating and fun to be away from the clutches of her x-husband and the demands of her parents’ family business.
She loves being anonymous, it’s a chance to discover what she likes, who she is, and what she was created to do. She would prove to her ex-husband she could live on the same budget he was living on; no more alimony for him.
Adam Locklear is a rodeo cowboy who wants to win big at the finals. He couldn’t be distracted by anything, including the new neighbor next door. He’s chasing a dream. A dangerous dream his parents cannot support.
Then an old friend comes for a visit. Things change dramatically. Both Merry and Adam quickly learn what is important. Who knew that meeting an old friend and sharing his recipe for strawberry pie, with a new friend, a non-cook Merry Anna would develop into something more these two goal seekers did not expect.
I enjoyed the rodeo backdrop and the small town feel of the story, with rich characterization and a storyline that draws readers in hook, line, and sinker. I’ve only watched clips of rodeos on TV, this is an in-depth view, from someone who loves the sport. I highly recommend this heartfelt, homespun, novel with themes of loss, regret, second chances, discovery, family, forgiveness with a splash of romance. It’s a great beach read and one that would be a fun book club pick.
Disclosure of Material Connection: I requested and received a digital copy of this book by the publisher/NetGalley. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255 “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising”
Nora St. Laurent
TBCN Where Book Fun Begins!
The Book Club Network blog https://psalm516.blogspot.com/
She loves being anonymous, it’s a chance to discover what she likes, who she is, and what she was created to do. She would prove to her ex-husband she could live on the same budget he was living on; no more alimony for him.
Adam Locklear is a rodeo cowboy who wants to win big at the finals. He couldn’t be distracted by anything, including the new neighbor next door. He’s chasing a dream. A dangerous dream his parents cannot support.
Then an old friend comes for a visit. Things change dramatically. Both Merry and Adam quickly learn what is important. Who knew that meeting an old friend and sharing his recipe for strawberry pie, with a new friend, a non-cook Merry Anna would develop into something more these two goal seekers did not expect.
I enjoyed the rodeo backdrop and the small town feel of the story, with rich characterization and a storyline that draws readers in hook, line, and sinker. I’ve only watched clips of rodeos on TV, this is an in-depth view, from someone who loves the sport. I highly recommend this heartfelt, homespun, novel with themes of loss, regret, second chances, discovery, family, forgiveness with a splash of romance. It’s a great beach read and one that would be a fun book club pick.
Disclosure of Material Connection: I requested and received a digital copy of this book by the publisher/NetGalley. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255 “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising”
Nora St. Laurent
TBCN Where Book Fun Begins!
The Book Club Network blog https://psalm516.blogspot.com/
May 1, 2022
Seemingly Destined For The Small Screen Via Hallmark or Up. Up front: For those that have issues with anything at all that mentions Christians/ Christian values/ actions (blessings before meals, childhood prayers before bed, attending church, etc)... you may as well skip this one and spare the author a negative review due to your own hangups. Similarly, those ultra-conservatives who think even a peck on the cheek kiss is scandalous... there's going to be things in this one you don't like too, though I think you'll find this book more palatable than those staunchly opposed to all things Christian.
For everyone who finds themselves somewhere in between those two extremes... this is a standard Hallmark type tale in book form. And thus, your enjoyment here will largely depend on how much you like those types of tales. The particulars of this one are ranching and rodeo, unexpected/ unknown parenthood / single parent, and escape from corporate life - but let's face it, for those that enjoy these types of tales, those particulars are largely irrelevant. :D
One of the more interesting things here, and a wrinkle that is genuinely rare in these types of tales, is the presence and even emphasis on barn quilts - which is just the thing needed to separate it from the pack just enough to say "go read it for the barn quilts" or "go read the barn quilt story". Very much recommended.
For everyone who finds themselves somewhere in between those two extremes... this is a standard Hallmark type tale in book form. And thus, your enjoyment here will largely depend on how much you like those types of tales. The particulars of this one are ranching and rodeo, unexpected/ unknown parenthood / single parent, and escape from corporate life - but let's face it, for those that enjoy these types of tales, those particulars are largely irrelevant. :D
One of the more interesting things here, and a wrinkle that is genuinely rare in these types of tales, is the presence and even emphasis on barn quilts - which is just the thing needed to separate it from the pack just enough to say "go read it for the barn quilts" or "go read the barn quilt story". Very much recommended.
March 28, 2022
You know I love a good read that has me engrossed and fully entertained as I go on the journey with the characters.I really loved Merry Anna and Adam's story. I really liked how the scenes of the rodeo played out , it was like watching for real.This story was full of hope , love and surprises .This will definitely go in my top ten reads of 2022.
March 25, 2022
Nancy Naigle writes the sweetest stories. This one doesn't disappoint. As always, her descriptions are so well woven that you can picture the sweet little town and all the colourful characters. A perfect curl up in your chair on a rainy-day kind of book. No spoilers from me. I would most definitely recommend this one
As always, Many thanks to Net Galley for the advanced reader copy in exchange for my honest review.
As always, Many thanks to Net Galley for the advanced reader copy in exchange for my honest review.
May 3, 2022
Merry Anna stops at Antler Creek and ends up staying. This is her new life post divorce and she couldn’t be happier.
She meets handsome rodeo star Adam and sparks fly.
This was an easy enjoyable book. I liked the characters and the story kept me turning the pages.
Thanks to the author for the early copy
She meets handsome rodeo star Adam and sparks fly.
This was an easy enjoyable book. I liked the characters and the story kept me turning the pages.
Thanks to the author for the early copy
May 3, 2022
4.5 stars
Thanks go to the publisher and Net-Galley for the complimentary digital copy of What Remains True by Nancy Naigle. I voluntarily agreed to read and review this novel prior to publication. My opinions are my own, and nothing has influenced my rating.
What Remains True is another well written novel with complex characters and a heartfelt plot. The pacing pulled me into the story right away and kept my interest until the end. The writing gives just enough description to allow my imagination the wander.
Merry Anna Foster is the heroine, and she has a bit of baggage from her past marriage. Her ex-husband expects her to continue to support him so he can skate by without working. This makes her distrustful of men and determined to remain heart whole.
Adam Locklear is a yummy hero, a cowboy who is determined to carry away the title as the best bull rider of the year. When life throws him a curveball, he must re-evaluate his goals. He accepts the arrival of Zan who he finds out is his daughter fairly well. I liked his willingness to accept the child and care for her when her mother has a mental breakdown.
The romance between Adam and Merry Anna is sweet as it usually is in Ms. Naigle’s romances. The couple are drawn to each other, even though each are fighting it all the way. I enjoyed their romance and wanted them to find their happy ending.
If you enjoy sweet, contemporary romance with engaging characters and a faith-based plot, then you will love What Remains True as much as I did. I always enjoy Ms. Naigle’s novels, and this is one of her best. Happy reading!
Thanks go to the publisher and Net-Galley for the complimentary digital copy of What Remains True by Nancy Naigle. I voluntarily agreed to read and review this novel prior to publication. My opinions are my own, and nothing has influenced my rating.
What Remains True is another well written novel with complex characters and a heartfelt plot. The pacing pulled me into the story right away and kept my interest until the end. The writing gives just enough description to allow my imagination the wander.
Merry Anna Foster is the heroine, and she has a bit of baggage from her past marriage. Her ex-husband expects her to continue to support him so he can skate by without working. This makes her distrustful of men and determined to remain heart whole.
Adam Locklear is a yummy hero, a cowboy who is determined to carry away the title as the best bull rider of the year. When life throws him a curveball, he must re-evaluate his goals. He accepts the arrival of Zan who he finds out is his daughter fairly well. I liked his willingness to accept the child and care for her when her mother has a mental breakdown.
The romance between Adam and Merry Anna is sweet as it usually is in Ms. Naigle’s romances. The couple are drawn to each other, even though each are fighting it all the way. I enjoyed their romance and wanted them to find their happy ending.
If you enjoy sweet, contemporary romance with engaging characters and a faith-based plot, then you will love What Remains True as much as I did. I always enjoy Ms. Naigle’s novels, and this is one of her best. Happy reading!
June 2, 2022
There are so many reasons to like this book. Characters that are imperfect but oh, so likable. Who doesn't love a cowboy, and who wouldn't sympathize with a woman who's been betrayed by a cheating husband? Add some special friends and throw in an adorable little girl who's a complete surprise to the man who fathered her. Mix in some twists and turns, stir in a lot of misunderstandings and place them among beautiful barn quilts in a small town in the North Carolina mountains. The result is a contemporary romance that will have you turning the pages!
Author Nancy Naigle has written a story that leaves readers yearning for a happy ending and hoping for a Hallmark movie! If you enjoy the 'friends-to-more' trope, you definitely want to read What Remains True.
I received a digital ARC of this book from the author and publisher. There was no obligation for a positive review. These are my own thoughts.
Author Nancy Naigle has written a story that leaves readers yearning for a happy ending and hoping for a Hallmark movie! If you enjoy the 'friends-to-more' trope, you definitely want to read What Remains True.
I received a digital ARC of this book from the author and publisher. There was no obligation for a positive review. These are my own thoughts.
April 27, 2022
Fall in love IN and WITH Antler Creek, a magical small tourist town.
Merry Anna has burnt out - of her marriage, high pressure job and her parents' expectations for her.
Her cheating husband added the final straw and won't quit, even after their divorce and her disappearance. She just needs a break and when she passes through Antler Creek something calls to her to stay awhile.
Adam Locklear has his life all planned out. Rodeo, specifically bull riding, is in his blood. He knows he can't do it forever, but it is the path to his larger goal. To follow this path he's had to alienate his family and avoid relationships. Until one special relationship comes knocking at his door - he discovers he has a five year old daughter.
Besides the swoony love relationship you'll discover here, and the growing up of two adults, you'll discover a community of marvelous characters. Antler Creek itself plays a major role, as do the hobbies and habits of the residents.
I loved reading about the improvements to Tara's house and the stories behind the barn quilts.
This is a fun escape read that will steal your heart.
Merry Anna has burnt out - of her marriage, high pressure job and her parents' expectations for her.
Her cheating husband added the final straw and won't quit, even after their divorce and her disappearance. She just needs a break and when she passes through Antler Creek something calls to her to stay awhile.
Adam Locklear has his life all planned out. Rodeo, specifically bull riding, is in his blood. He knows he can't do it forever, but it is the path to his larger goal. To follow this path he's had to alienate his family and avoid relationships. Until one special relationship comes knocking at his door - he discovers he has a five year old daughter.
Besides the swoony love relationship you'll discover here, and the growing up of two adults, you'll discover a community of marvelous characters. Antler Creek itself plays a major role, as do the hobbies and habits of the residents.
I loved reading about the improvements to Tara's house and the stories behind the barn quilts.
This is a fun escape read that will steal your heart.
November 23, 2025
What remains true is an emotional read. The author has brought the characters to life with realistic situations. Well plotted, I loved the characters and how true to life they were.
A read that had me questioning what is really important and wanting to reevaluate things. When we take a second look at somethings what may have seemed important no longer is.
Five stars all the way!
I was given a complimentary copy of this book.
All opinions expressed are my own.
A read that had me questioning what is really important and wanting to reevaluate things. When we take a second look at somethings what may have seemed important no longer is.
Five stars all the way!
I was given a complimentary copy of this book.
All opinions expressed are my own.
April 26, 2022
Another winner from Nancy Naigle. She sure knows how to hook you in the first couple pages and keep your attention until the end but also leaves you wanting more. This is a great story involving a new person in town that is making friends everywhere including the handsome rodeo rider aka neighbor. With the struggles of their choices in the past and a surprise visitor will they admit that they should give into their feelings or go on denying they are not interested in a relationship. Sometimes you just have to let your guard down, have some faith, and just go with the flow.
I read this as an ARC in exchange for my honest opinion which I have given.
I read this as an ARC in exchange for my honest opinion which I have given.
February 7, 2023
This is a clean story about a divorced woman starting over in a new town, finding a job she enjoys, and beginning a new friendship with a real-life cowboy. It was a light read that was a good escape into the world of rodeos, which I don't know much about, so that was fun. Some parts of the story went on a little longer than I wished, but overall it was a good read. It was much like watching a lighthearted Hallmark movie. If you're looking for that kind of book that's entertaining without being too heavy, you may enjoy this read.
May 2, 2022
Naigle has given readers a touching story of two people finding their way to being open to love. It is sort of an adult coming of age story. Both Adam and Merry Anna must work through many obstacles to consider the possibility of romance. While all of the characters are written well, my favorite was Zan. What a sweet girl. The plot is typical for romance, a budding relationship progressing with misunderstandings and hurt. The ending seems a bit rushed and is somewhat inconclusive. Perhaps we are to be expecting a sequel.
My frustration with the book is in the mixed messages it contains about sexual morality among Christians. Merry Anna divorced her husband mainly because he had an affair. She appeared to have definite convictions about sexual fidelity in marriage. When she learns Adam has had many sexual encounters outside of marriage, it seems to be of no concern to her. Adam's attitude toward his sexual sin is disappointing. While he admits he has had his share of women, he claims he has always done the “right” thing, I suppose meaning using condoms. (2464/4158) He never owns up to his sin nor is he ever repentant, even though he is depicted as a Christian. Adam's character is certainly not what I expected nor am pleased about.
This is a romance for younger readers who are of the opinion that causal sex outside of marriage is fine and not against God's will as long as one wears appropriate protection. For older Christians who still believe sex outside of marriage is sin and needs to be addressed as such, this novel will be a very frustrating one to read.
I received a complimentary egalley of this book from the publisher. My comments are an independent and honest review.
My frustration with the book is in the mixed messages it contains about sexual morality among Christians. Merry Anna divorced her husband mainly because he had an affair. She appeared to have definite convictions about sexual fidelity in marriage. When she learns Adam has had many sexual encounters outside of marriage, it seems to be of no concern to her. Adam's attitude toward his sexual sin is disappointing. While he admits he has had his share of women, he claims he has always done the “right” thing, I suppose meaning using condoms. (2464/4158) He never owns up to his sin nor is he ever repentant, even though he is depicted as a Christian. Adam's character is certainly not what I expected nor am pleased about.
This is a romance for younger readers who are of the opinion that causal sex outside of marriage is fine and not against God's will as long as one wears appropriate protection. For older Christians who still believe sex outside of marriage is sin and needs to be addressed as such, this novel will be a very frustrating one to read.
I received a complimentary egalley of this book from the publisher. My comments are an independent and honest review.
August 9, 2022
This book had me laughing with delight one minute and swooning the next. I was attached from the very start. I loved the storyline, very intriguing. The main characters were very relatable and
My only thoughts and reasonings for not giving a solid 5 stars…..
The ending felt very rushed.
SPOILER ALERT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
All of the sudden a flood comes and the strong, strapping Adam can’t wrangle his own distressed horses? I mean, he’s a livestock owner and like he’s nowhere to be found during a torrential downpour? So Merry Anna takes it upon herself to boat over to them and get her elderly neighbor caught up in the mess instead of just going in the bunkhouse and waiting it out? I want the horses to be rescued, don’t get me wrong but it’s pretty unbelievable that Adam didn’t take care of that, on his property, himself. Then, boom, Adam forgives her for lying. All is forgotten, everybody is fine as a frog hair and it’s rainbows and sunshine. Her parents see the light all of the sudden regarding her Ex. Oh Adam I love you. Oh Merry Anna I love you. I’ve got a barn quilt to make.
THE END.
Sighhhhhhhhh………..what in the name of all that is holy regarding book endings?
So, so close to 5 stars! A little more effort into that ending and it would have been 5+ !!!
This was my first Nancy Naigle book and I promise, it will not be my last because the 95% of the book that didn’t involve the odd ending, WAS SPECTACULAR!
I was given an eARC from NetGalley and the book’s publisher in exchange for my honest review.
My only thoughts and reasonings for not giving a solid 5 stars…..
The ending felt very rushed.
SPOILER ALERT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
All of the sudden a flood comes and the strong, strapping Adam can’t wrangle his own distressed horses? I mean, he’s a livestock owner and like he’s nowhere to be found during a torrential downpour? So Merry Anna takes it upon herself to boat over to them and get her elderly neighbor caught up in the mess instead of just going in the bunkhouse and waiting it out? I want the horses to be rescued, don’t get me wrong but it’s pretty unbelievable that Adam didn’t take care of that, on his property, himself. Then, boom, Adam forgives her for lying. All is forgotten, everybody is fine as a frog hair and it’s rainbows and sunshine. Her parents see the light all of the sudden regarding her Ex. Oh Adam I love you. Oh Merry Anna I love you. I’ve got a barn quilt to make.
THE END.
Sighhhhhhhhh………..what in the name of all that is holy regarding book endings?
So, so close to 5 stars! A little more effort into that ending and it would have been 5+ !!!
This was my first Nancy Naigle book and I promise, it will not be my last because the 95% of the book that didn’t involve the odd ending, WAS SPECTACULAR!
I was given an eARC from NetGalley and the book’s publisher in exchange for my honest review.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
May 3, 2022
Loved this sweet clean romance. Merry Anna needs a fresh start in life after her divorce, and finds it in the small town of Antler Creek working in a gift shop. She rents an old bunk house on the property of professional bull rider, Adam.
Adam is on his way to the championship this year but soon things will change the path of his life. A friendship develops between Merry Anna, loved the strawberry pie baking. Adam also finds out that he is the father of five year old, Zan. Adam, has no clue on how to raise a daughter.
Loved everything about this book, I had a hard time putting down. Adam or Merry Anna are not looking for love but God has his own plans. Loved sweet Zan, with developing relationship with her dad. I must also mention, Shorty the dog, a perfect secondary character. I highly recommend this book!!
Adam is on his way to the championship this year but soon things will change the path of his life. A friendship develops between Merry Anna, loved the strawberry pie baking. Adam also finds out that he is the father of five year old, Zan. Adam, has no clue on how to raise a daughter.
Loved everything about this book, I had a hard time putting down. Adam or Merry Anna are not looking for love but God has his own plans. Loved sweet Zan, with developing relationship with her dad. I must also mention, Shorty the dog, a perfect secondary character. I highly recommend this book!!
April 24, 2022
For me, cracking open a Nancy Naigle book always feels like coming home. The vivid descriptions and loveable characters have everything playing out right before my eyes, making reality disappear for a little while.
What Remains True contained all the feels I was hoping for, with little reminders tucked between the pages. I can always use a little nudge when it comes to not being afraid to try new things, or trying to see things from another point of view. Mixed into a beautiful storyline are a few of those little lessons.
I loved everything about this book, and look forward to visiting this town again in the future. I have not read the first book in the series, but I'm definitely going to, after falling in love with this one. If you are looking for a feel-good, small town read, with wonderfully complex and irresistible characters, give this book a try.
What Remains True contained all the feels I was hoping for, with little reminders tucked between the pages. I can always use a little nudge when it comes to not being afraid to try new things, or trying to see things from another point of view. Mixed into a beautiful storyline are a few of those little lessons.
I loved everything about this book, and look forward to visiting this town again in the future. I have not read the first book in the series, but I'm definitely going to, after falling in love with this one. If you are looking for a feel-good, small town read, with wonderfully complex and irresistible characters, give this book a try.
May 3, 2022
Thank you in advance to the author, Nancy Naigle, for providing an advanced review copy through her launch team. A positive review was not required nor requested, and all words are my own.
This is not the first novel I’ve read by the author. In fact, the book connected to this is the first novel I read, Christmas Angels. That was in 2019. I have since read Christmas Joy (one of the many standalone Christmas reads), and The Shell Collector (a standalone read as well).
In What Remains True, Naigle takes readers back to the small town of Antler Creek, North Carolina. And, this cover is a stunner! It brings out the vivid landscape and has a story initself.
While both Christmas Angles and What Remains True are standalone reads, I do recommend reading Christmas Angels before this one. There are some plot points from that references, shared places, and returning characters from that book as well. Some characters play prominent roles in this one too.
Krissy from Hardy House, Matt and Liz from Angel’s Rest (the inn that Liz bought in Christmas Angels), and Maizey from the diner all return in this book.
New characters: Merry Anna, Adam, Zan, Tara, Zan, and Kevin.
This has a sweet premise – Merry Anna is in Antler Creek to not only find herself, but also to prove to her ex-husband about their living expenses. In addition, there is the unexpected romance. While this is “sweet”, there are themes of infidelity, mental health issues, palimony (women paying men alimony), stalking. There is also Adam’s “promiscuity” that might be questionable to some readers of Christian fiction. These elements might go against some people’s beliefs. However, they are realistic in people’s lives.
That said …
Naigle has an uncanny ability to fuse real life issues and a heartwarming story together while still showing examples of God’s place, grace, and forgiveness for us. This story is NO exception. It does have a LOT going on in it despite only having Merry Anna and Adam’s POVs:
🐎 Merry Anna and her ex-husband Kevin
🐎 Adam and Merry Anna’s “romance”
🐎 Adam and his rodeo pursuit
🐎 Adam becoming a “dad” to Zan
Merry Anna is working at Hardy House Fine Linens and Gifts, though she doesn’t have to. She’s in Antler Creek for a reason. She stopped for gas and decided to stay. This she relates to a customer we can all likely relate to – the poor lady who goes in for one item and leaves with a ton. How many of us have done that?
From there, Merry Anna helps Krissy prepare for Spring Fling at Angels Rest, another stop on the Barn Quilt Tour. And, like Merry Anna, I’d NEVER heard of them or seen one.
Merry Anna is also working to prove to Kevin she can live on the amount she is giving him in their divorce. To be honest, I did “SLIGHTLY” agree with him – it was less than $1300. Where I live, my “base” rent (before common use utilities) is $1700. It truly depends on where you live as to whether you can “survive” on a certain amount. To be honest, where I live, you have to make about $4000-$5000 per month – sometimes just to qualify for an apartment, even buying a house. Though, if Kevin had a skill – getting a job to supplement what Merry Anna gave him was definitely in order, especially given the fact of his infidelity.
Getting back to Antler Creek …
While Adam owns the feed and seed store, he also chases his future in the rodeo. And, believe it or not, a lot of cowboys are businessmen. It, like NASCAR, isn’t just a sport – it is a lifestyle.
Adam is looking forward to the National Finals Rodeo (NFR) in Las Vegas (it’s a big event here). But, an older customer by the name of Jones warns him about ending up old and alone like he did. I really wanted Jones to appear more to see how things went. (Perhaps him and Tara in a book …).
There’s a sweet instant attraction between Merry Anna and Adam when they meet. He even offers to teach her to cook, starting with a strawberry pie. He even takes her horseback riding.
Merry Anna’s ex-husband Kevin is pestering her about wanting more money, even she finds it a bit difficult to not get certain things. They extend the bet into summer, but her parents want her home. Merry Anna feels at home, especially with her new “neighbor” – Tara, a feisty older gal that words cannot describe.
Everything proceeds well – that is until Carly shows up at Adam’s door with little Zan – his daughter. He’s in disbelief, but it is finally proven. Carly doesn’t want money – she leaves Zan with him. She’s “messed up” mentally and needs time to “get well” according to her parents.
That adds a complication for Adam and his rodeo plans – thus he asks Merry Anna for help. At first she’s agreeable – but then … things turn.
As the rodeo Doc tells him – other guys don’t have the options Adam does. Adam seriously weighs his options.
Merry Anna has to confront her ex-husband baggage in more than one way in order to move forward, and even a disaster comes calling.
And, like usual, Naigle tells a story that has a lot of heart, soul, and evokes multiple emotions at every turn. This was no different.
I truly enjoyed this book. Though in all honesty … I had the ARC for a while before reading it. I had a lot going on so I wasn’t able to read it when I got it. But, when I did – it was really hard to stop reading. Naigle has a way of pacing a story that flows without too many stops. It didn’t “slog” along at any point, at times I was even wondering how I managed to get as far as I did. She definitely kept me turning the pages, and kept the story going right up until the very last page.
I absolutely LOVED the small town feel of this book, and the connection it had to Christmas Angels. There was a slight moment in the beginning of this one where I had to go back to that book for reference. It had to do with Angels Rest and a barn quilt.
Krissy was by far my favorite character despite her “support” character appearance. I didn’t know quite what to make of Tara, but she was very entertaining, honest, and refreshing.
In the beginning I deeply liked Merry Anna, but after Zan came into the picture and Adam needed help with the little girl, Merry Anna changed. It was as if she wanted to believe the worst in Adam. Perhaps that was part of the story – Merry Anna’s progression/regression/progression and the ex-husband baggage. But, there were times her “he’s using me” attitude towards Adam was a bit offensive. Also, she had a tendency to jump to FAR too many conclusions.
Yes, what Adam did being a “professional rodeo cowboy” was dangerous, but there were times I don’t think he could just stop and quit. Some with sponsors do have obligations they need to fulfill (unless they are medically unable to), and his commitment to Zan was precious.
I did love what Merry Anna said about the relationship with her ex-husband (Kevin) – “that ship has sailed and is at the bottom of the sea. Shipwrecked” – it was an amusing take on a past relationship beyond salvaging.
Naigle also included the mutton bustin’ portion of rodeo in the story as a way for Adam to see how others around him felt about his choices. Those who don’t know about the event, the author pens a realistic portrayal of it. It is, depending on one’s point of view, harmless but fun. As of note the practice was banned in New York in 2012, and in Alameda County, California in 2019 due to cruelty concerns. The “sideshow” usually coincides with the main rodeo portion and is more of a pre-show family event.
There were a few loose ends, so I definitely can’t wait to return to Antler Creek. I’m hoping Naigle can take the readers back there sometime soon. I’m eagerly waiting to see what the future holds for Merry Anna and Adam, as well as little Zan. I also want to see how Carly progresses. In addition, there was Adam’s main reason for continuing to rodeo (at least until the end of that year), as well as Merry Anna’s job in D.C.
Fans of the author and genre will more than likely LOVE this newest release. I still have three (3) books of hers on my TBR stack: The Secret Ingredient, The Christmas Shop (aka: Dear Santa), and Hope at Christmas. Nancy Naigle is for sure one of my “must-read” authors, and I can’t wait to see what she brings out next.
The publisher, WaterBrook (together with Multnomah), is a primarily Christian publisher. As a result, there will be strong themes and expressions of faith. These are integral to the story.
This is not the first novel I’ve read by the author. In fact, the book connected to this is the first novel I read, Christmas Angels. That was in 2019. I have since read Christmas Joy (one of the many standalone Christmas reads), and The Shell Collector (a standalone read as well).
In What Remains True, Naigle takes readers back to the small town of Antler Creek, North Carolina. And, this cover is a stunner! It brings out the vivid landscape and has a story initself.
While both Christmas Angles and What Remains True are standalone reads, I do recommend reading Christmas Angels before this one. There are some plot points from that references, shared places, and returning characters from that book as well. Some characters play prominent roles in this one too.
Krissy from Hardy House, Matt and Liz from Angel’s Rest (the inn that Liz bought in Christmas Angels), and Maizey from the diner all return in this book.
New characters: Merry Anna, Adam, Zan, Tara, Zan, and Kevin.
This has a sweet premise – Merry Anna is in Antler Creek to not only find herself, but also to prove to her ex-husband about their living expenses. In addition, there is the unexpected romance. While this is “sweet”, there are themes of infidelity, mental health issues, palimony (women paying men alimony), stalking. There is also Adam’s “promiscuity” that might be questionable to some readers of Christian fiction. These elements might go against some people’s beliefs. However, they are realistic in people’s lives.
That said …
Naigle has an uncanny ability to fuse real life issues and a heartwarming story together while still showing examples of God’s place, grace, and forgiveness for us. This story is NO exception. It does have a LOT going on in it despite only having Merry Anna and Adam’s POVs:
🐎 Merry Anna and her ex-husband Kevin
🐎 Adam and Merry Anna’s “romance”
🐎 Adam and his rodeo pursuit
🐎 Adam becoming a “dad” to Zan
Merry Anna is working at Hardy House Fine Linens and Gifts, though she doesn’t have to. She’s in Antler Creek for a reason. She stopped for gas and decided to stay. This she relates to a customer we can all likely relate to – the poor lady who goes in for one item and leaves with a ton. How many of us have done that?
From there, Merry Anna helps Krissy prepare for Spring Fling at Angels Rest, another stop on the Barn Quilt Tour. And, like Merry Anna, I’d NEVER heard of them or seen one.
Merry Anna is also working to prove to Kevin she can live on the amount she is giving him in their divorce. To be honest, I did “SLIGHTLY” agree with him – it was less than $1300. Where I live, my “base” rent (before common use utilities) is $1700. It truly depends on where you live as to whether you can “survive” on a certain amount. To be honest, where I live, you have to make about $4000-$5000 per month – sometimes just to qualify for an apartment, even buying a house. Though, if Kevin had a skill – getting a job to supplement what Merry Anna gave him was definitely in order, especially given the fact of his infidelity.
Getting back to Antler Creek …
While Adam owns the feed and seed store, he also chases his future in the rodeo. And, believe it or not, a lot of cowboys are businessmen. It, like NASCAR, isn’t just a sport – it is a lifestyle.
Adam is looking forward to the National Finals Rodeo (NFR) in Las Vegas (it’s a big event here). But, an older customer by the name of Jones warns him about ending up old and alone like he did. I really wanted Jones to appear more to see how things went. (Perhaps him and Tara in a book …).
There’s a sweet instant attraction between Merry Anna and Adam when they meet. He even offers to teach her to cook, starting with a strawberry pie. He even takes her horseback riding.
Merry Anna’s ex-husband Kevin is pestering her about wanting more money, even she finds it a bit difficult to not get certain things. They extend the bet into summer, but her parents want her home. Merry Anna feels at home, especially with her new “neighbor” – Tara, a feisty older gal that words cannot describe.
Everything proceeds well – that is until Carly shows up at Adam’s door with little Zan – his daughter. He’s in disbelief, but it is finally proven. Carly doesn’t want money – she leaves Zan with him. She’s “messed up” mentally and needs time to “get well” according to her parents.
That adds a complication for Adam and his rodeo plans – thus he asks Merry Anna for help. At first she’s agreeable – but then … things turn.
As the rodeo Doc tells him – other guys don’t have the options Adam does. Adam seriously weighs his options.
Merry Anna has to confront her ex-husband baggage in more than one way in order to move forward, and even a disaster comes calling.
And, like usual, Naigle tells a story that has a lot of heart, soul, and evokes multiple emotions at every turn. This was no different.
I truly enjoyed this book. Though in all honesty … I had the ARC for a while before reading it. I had a lot going on so I wasn’t able to read it when I got it. But, when I did – it was really hard to stop reading. Naigle has a way of pacing a story that flows without too many stops. It didn’t “slog” along at any point, at times I was even wondering how I managed to get as far as I did. She definitely kept me turning the pages, and kept the story going right up until the very last page.
I absolutely LOVED the small town feel of this book, and the connection it had to Christmas Angels. There was a slight moment in the beginning of this one where I had to go back to that book for reference. It had to do with Angels Rest and a barn quilt.
Krissy was by far my favorite character despite her “support” character appearance. I didn’t know quite what to make of Tara, but she was very entertaining, honest, and refreshing.
In the beginning I deeply liked Merry Anna, but after Zan came into the picture and Adam needed help with the little girl, Merry Anna changed. It was as if she wanted to believe the worst in Adam. Perhaps that was part of the story – Merry Anna’s progression/regression/progression and the ex-husband baggage. But, there were times her “he’s using me” attitude towards Adam was a bit offensive. Also, she had a tendency to jump to FAR too many conclusions.
Yes, what Adam did being a “professional rodeo cowboy” was dangerous, but there were times I don’t think he could just stop and quit. Some with sponsors do have obligations they need to fulfill (unless they are medically unable to), and his commitment to Zan was precious.
I did love what Merry Anna said about the relationship with her ex-husband (Kevin) – “that ship has sailed and is at the bottom of the sea. Shipwrecked” – it was an amusing take on a past relationship beyond salvaging.
Naigle also included the mutton bustin’ portion of rodeo in the story as a way for Adam to see how others around him felt about his choices. Those who don’t know about the event, the author pens a realistic portrayal of it. It is, depending on one’s point of view, harmless but fun. As of note the practice was banned in New York in 2012, and in Alameda County, California in 2019 due to cruelty concerns. The “sideshow” usually coincides with the main rodeo portion and is more of a pre-show family event.
There were a few loose ends, so I definitely can’t wait to return to Antler Creek. I’m hoping Naigle can take the readers back there sometime soon. I’m eagerly waiting to see what the future holds for Merry Anna and Adam, as well as little Zan. I also want to see how Carly progresses. In addition, there was Adam’s main reason for continuing to rodeo (at least until the end of that year), as well as Merry Anna’s job in D.C.
Fans of the author and genre will more than likely LOVE this newest release. I still have three (3) books of hers on my TBR stack: The Secret Ingredient, The Christmas Shop (aka: Dear Santa), and Hope at Christmas. Nancy Naigle is for sure one of my “must-read” authors, and I can’t wait to see what she brings out next.
The publisher, WaterBrook (together with Multnomah), is a primarily Christian publisher. As a result, there will be strong themes and expressions of faith. These are integral to the story.
March 26, 2022
Set in Antler Creek, North Carolina, What Remains True is a heartwarming, emotionally rich story. This well-crafted, well-researched narrative features engaging characters, a smoothly flowing plot, a gentle faith element, and a sweet slow burn romance. I loved Merry Anna, and five-year old Zan captured my heart. I would love sequels featuring Krissy and Tara. However, to me Adam was a less than honorable hero especially in regard to the life-changing sin in his past that he was repeatedly trying to justify instead of showing repentance. On a lighter note, Ms. Naigle brings the rodeo to life with detailed descriptions that stimulate the senses. Her depiction of small town life is authentic and delightful. I think you will find this to be an inspiring, satisfying read.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher via NetGalley with no obligation to write a positive review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher via NetGalley with no obligation to write a positive review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
March 21, 2022
Merry Anna stops for gas in Antler Creek and ends up staying. It becomes her safe haven from the job she no longer wants and the ex who wants more alimony and is too lazy to get a real job. She rents a small bunkhouse and falls in love with the town and its inhabitants.
Adam is drawn to his new neighbor, Merry Anna, but he has big plans for his future and doesn’t have time for a relationship. He also wasn’t expecting the arrival of Zan, the daughter he never knew he had. How can he raise a child while her mother is recuperating and follow his dreams at the same time? Will a change of plans leave him resenting what he might have to give up? Can Merry Anna and Adam find happiness together?
A small-town story with gossipy but well-meaning citizens, family healing, new friendships, new beginnings, and a chance at a HEA.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Adam is drawn to his new neighbor, Merry Anna, but he has big plans for his future and doesn’t have time for a relationship. He also wasn’t expecting the arrival of Zan, the daughter he never knew he had. How can he raise a child while her mother is recuperating and follow his dreams at the same time? Will a change of plans leave him resenting what he might have to give up? Can Merry Anna and Adam find happiness together?
A small-town story with gossipy but well-meaning citizens, family healing, new friendships, new beginnings, and a chance at a HEA.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 180 reviews