What do you think?
Rate this book
The Secret Keeper’s Daughter
Holly Mayhew has the perfect family set-up. But when her seven-year-old daughter, Marley, begins to act strangely, refusing to speak and rushing off to hide in her room, she knows something isn’t right.
Desperate to understand why Marley has become so withdrawn, Holly creates a worry box, where Marley posts her thoughts each day.
At first, the messages seem innocent. But when Holly finds a note saying secrets make me sad, she begins to question everyone entrusted with her care…
Including her family.
Once the truth is out… there’s no going back.
An utterly gripping family drama about the perils of motherhood, and the dark secrets that lurk just out of sight. Fans of Susan Lewis, Kerry Fisher and Diane Chamberlain will lose themselves in this suspenseful page-turner!
Desperate to understand why Marley has become so withdrawn, Holly creates a worry box, where Marley posts her thoughts each day.
At first, the messages seem innocent. But when Holly finds a note saying secrets make me sad, she begins to question everyone entrusted with her care…
Including her family.
Once the truth is out… there’s no going back.
An utterly gripping family drama about the perils of motherhood, and the dark secrets that lurk just out of sight. Fans of Susan Lewis, Kerry Fisher and Diane Chamberlain will lose themselves in this suspenseful page-turner!
336 pages, Kindle Edition
First published September 10, 2021
143 people are currently reading
435 people want to read
About the author
Samantha King
5 books81 followersSamantha King writes psychological suspense novels and lives in west London with her husband and two young children.
As an English graduate and lifelong bookworm, becoming an author was always Samantha’s dream. This passion for storytelling led her first to a career in publishing, managing a commercial fiction imprint for a global publisher. After fifteen years, she abandoned office life in favour of working from home as a freelance editor for various publishers and literary agents.
Samantha has always loved books that explore the hidden depths of the heart and mind, and she decided to satisfy her growing interest in human psychology by qualifying as a psychotherapist. This deepened her fascination with the hopes and fears that make people tick, which again reawakened her writing ambitions. Working around – and inspired by – a busy family life, she finally sat down and wrote her debut novel, THE PERFECT FAMILY.
Samantha writes in a hut at the end of her garden with a very affectionate Cavachon dog for company, but she keeps in touch with the world through:
Twitter: @SamKingBooks
Facebook: @SamanthaKingBooks
As an English graduate and lifelong bookworm, becoming an author was always Samantha’s dream. This passion for storytelling led her first to a career in publishing, managing a commercial fiction imprint for a global publisher. After fifteen years, she abandoned office life in favour of working from home as a freelance editor for various publishers and literary agents.
Samantha has always loved books that explore the hidden depths of the heart and mind, and she decided to satisfy her growing interest in human psychology by qualifying as a psychotherapist. This deepened her fascination with the hopes and fears that make people tick, which again reawakened her writing ambitions. Working around – and inspired by – a busy family life, she finally sat down and wrote her debut novel, THE PERFECT FAMILY.
Samantha writes in a hut at the end of her garden with a very affectionate Cavachon dog for company, but she keeps in touch with the world through:
Twitter: @SamKingBooks
Facebook: @SamanthaKingBooks
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 109 reviews
September 8, 2021
I started out quite enjoying this family saga but my enjoyment turned to frustration half way through for several reasons: There were too many red herrings, there were too many incomplete conversations, there were too many unlikeable characters and there were no BIG reveals. In fact, reading in my online Book Club, as I did, many of us had already 20% in to the story concluded the BIG Twist.
This book goes back and forth from when Holly was a child and Amy, the child her parents take in, comes to live with them.
Holly, as a main character was frustrating to the point that I wanted to shake her. She is married to Jordan and they have two children Marley and BB. Concerned about Marley's sudden change in behaviour, Holly introduces a Worry Box for Marley to leave notes in, which Marley takes advantage of. Unfortunately Holly never clarifies what Marley means by her notes which becomes the main theme of this story. Conversations that start and never end in a satisfactory way. The story was filled with unlikeable characters, at the helm Adam, Holly's father and Amy, not to mention Amy's parents Isabel and Luke, and even Jordan, but this in itself never affects my rating as a really gripping and good story is often jammed with unlikeable people. In this book however I was left feeling deflated. A slow burn.
This book goes back and forth from when Holly was a child and Amy, the child her parents take in, comes to live with them.
Holly, as a main character was frustrating to the point that I wanted to shake her. She is married to Jordan and they have two children Marley and BB. Concerned about Marley's sudden change in behaviour, Holly introduces a Worry Box for Marley to leave notes in, which Marley takes advantage of. Unfortunately Holly never clarifies what Marley means by her notes which becomes the main theme of this story. Conversations that start and never end in a satisfactory way. The story was filled with unlikeable characters, at the helm Adam, Holly's father and Amy, not to mention Amy's parents Isabel and Luke, and even Jordan, but this in itself never affects my rating as a really gripping and good story is often jammed with unlikeable people. In this book however I was left feeling deflated. A slow burn.
August 23, 2021
Holly Mayhew has the perfect family set-up. But when her seven year old daughter, Marley, begins to act strangely, refusing to speak and rushing off to hide n her room, she knows something isn't right. Desperate to find out why Marley has become so withdrawn, Holly creates a worry box, where Marley posts her thoughts each day. At first the messages seem innocent. But when Holly finds a note saying secrets make me sad, she begins to question everyone trusted with her care, even her own family.
This story is a bit of a slow burner. The characters are will developed and believable. At times it could be heart-wrenching, dark and twisted. You will keep changing your mind with your suspicions. There were lots of secrets revealed but the book was a little drawn out in places. Overall, I did enjoy the book.
I would like to thank #NetGalley #HQDigital and the author #SamanthaKing for my ARC of #TheSwcretKeepersDaughter in exchange for an honest review.
This story is a bit of a slow burner. The characters are will developed and believable. At times it could be heart-wrenching, dark and twisted. You will keep changing your mind with your suspicions. There were lots of secrets revealed but the book was a little drawn out in places. Overall, I did enjoy the book.
I would like to thank #NetGalley #HQDigital and the author #SamanthaKing for my ARC of #TheSwcretKeepersDaughter in exchange for an honest review.
October 15, 2023
Holly Mayhay has the perfect family set up, married to Jordan they live in a little cottage by the sea with their daughter Marley and baby Benjamin. Everything seems idyllic in their lives until Marley starts to act strangely, refusing to talk and rushing off to hide in her room, they know something is not right.
Desperate to find out why Marley is acting this way, Holly creates a worry box, where Marley can post her thoughts each day. But when Holly discovers a note saying "Secrets makes me sad" she begins to question everyone involved with her care .... including her family!!
I was fully hooked with this family drama, I loved all the family secrets. The going back and forth in Holly's life, illustrating her childhood worked very well in this story.
Thank you to Netgalley for my copy in exchange for an honest review.
Desperate to find out why Marley is acting this way, Holly creates a worry box, where Marley can post her thoughts each day. But when Holly discovers a note saying "Secrets makes me sad" she begins to question everyone involved with her care .... including her family!!
I was fully hooked with this family drama, I loved all the family secrets. The going back and forth in Holly's life, illustrating her childhood worked very well in this story.
Thank you to Netgalley for my copy in exchange for an honest review.
August 8, 2021
4.5 stars
A lot of books these days claim to have big reveals and shock twists, yet they’re always disappointing. But The Secret-Keeper’s Daughter by Samantha King kept me guessing (and second guessing).
It plays out in a way that seems really dark and twisted, but I refused to believe my suspicions were true. I assumed the author wanted me to suspect certain people of certain things, so felt smug that I wasn’t falling for it. But as the story continued, I doubted myself. Again. And again. I kept changing my mind about which characters I trusted, which were hiding things and which were telling the truth. This is what I want in a book! I was hooked and read it in one sitting, way past my bedtime.
Characters are well-written and engaging, forcing you to change your view of them continuously. Are they evil, good, or just misunderstood? But maybe they are evil… or just mischievous? Ultimately none of them (except Holly maybe) were at all what I thought. I did guess one of the twists, but it didn’t detract from the story because there were so many I did not expect.
Holly is a loveable and pitiable character, torn between family and friends and trying to make sense of her own childhood, as well as daughter Marley’s. Marley’s perception of events is staggering and yet so believable, it really made the story. While we see the world through Holly’s eyes, we forget what it is to be a child and how things seem very different to how they really are.
A few readers have said the book confused them but I disagree and found it very easy to follow. This book is unique and engaging, with strong characters and plenty of twists, turns and shocks. It’s one that really surprised me, and I look forward to reading more of King’s books.
I was provided with an advanced copy from NetGalley. All opinions my own.
For more reviews, visit the blog: https://paradise-is-a-library.com/
Or follow us on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/paradise_li...
A lot of books these days claim to have big reveals and shock twists, yet they’re always disappointing. But The Secret-Keeper’s Daughter by Samantha King kept me guessing (and second guessing).
It plays out in a way that seems really dark and twisted, but I refused to believe my suspicions were true. I assumed the author wanted me to suspect certain people of certain things, so felt smug that I wasn’t falling for it. But as the story continued, I doubted myself. Again. And again. I kept changing my mind about which characters I trusted, which were hiding things and which were telling the truth. This is what I want in a book! I was hooked and read it in one sitting, way past my bedtime.
Characters are well-written and engaging, forcing you to change your view of them continuously. Are they evil, good, or just misunderstood? But maybe they are evil… or just mischievous? Ultimately none of them (except Holly maybe) were at all what I thought. I did guess one of the twists, but it didn’t detract from the story because there were so many I did not expect.
Holly is a loveable and pitiable character, torn between family and friends and trying to make sense of her own childhood, as well as daughter Marley’s. Marley’s perception of events is staggering and yet so believable, it really made the story. While we see the world through Holly’s eyes, we forget what it is to be a child and how things seem very different to how they really are.
A few readers have said the book confused them but I disagree and found it very easy to follow. This book is unique and engaging, with strong characters and plenty of twists, turns and shocks. It’s one that really surprised me, and I look forward to reading more of King’s books.
I was provided with an advanced copy from NetGalley. All opinions my own.
For more reviews, visit the blog: https://paradise-is-a-library.com/
Or follow us on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/paradise_li...
August 9, 2021
This book was an OK read, though I felt like the story was leading up to huge secrets and when the secrets were revealed, they felt like a let-down. It centers on Holly, whose daughter Marley starts acting out of character, causing Holly to investigate her relationships and interactions with those around her. There are also flashback chapters from when Holly was growing up.
There were a lot of twists, which made the book fast-paced, but there were almost too many red herrings, leading me to be underwhelmed when the truth finally comes out. I couldn't figure out of some of the characters were horrible people, or just flaky, and didn't really find any of them that likeable.
Overall, not my favorite but definitely held my interest. I was just a little underwhelmed when all was said and done. Thanks to Netgalley for providing me a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
There were a lot of twists, which made the book fast-paced, but there were almost too many red herrings, leading me to be underwhelmed when the truth finally comes out. I couldn't figure out of some of the characters were horrible people, or just flaky, and didn't really find any of them that likeable.
Overall, not my favorite but definitely held my interest. I was just a little underwhelmed when all was said and done. Thanks to Netgalley for providing me a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
July 19, 2022
Ugghh. Some books sound way better than they are - like this one. I was excited to delve into this audiobook based on the description but it was poorly executed.
I can't stand weak protagonists who know there's a problem yet bury their head in the sand to avoid it. They don't ask the simple questions that need to be asked. The whole story up until the end was like this. Super frustrating when the author uses this angle to try to draw out suspense as it backfires. It leads to reader frustration and the story loses credibility.
If that wasn't bad enough, the ending was a hot mess. The reveals were lame and I guessed the main twist at the start of the book. There were gaping holes in the resolution that were left unexplained or didn't seem plausible. I won't go into detail to avoid spoilers but super disappointing.
And another thing I don't like is when characters are written as wishy-washy. You know, when the story is initially built on them hating another character yet a couple chapters later refer to them as their best friend only to go back to hating them but then describe them a couple chapters later as their only true friend... wtf? The lack of continuity was confusing and again made the plot inauthentic.
Lastly the audio performance was annoying. Although the narrator was superb with her range of voices, she often yelled when portraying the child and sometimes the MC, which I found to be distracting and annoying. Like raking your nails down a chalkboard.
Not a winner for me.
I can't stand weak protagonists who know there's a problem yet bury their head in the sand to avoid it. They don't ask the simple questions that need to be asked. The whole story up until the end was like this. Super frustrating when the author uses this angle to try to draw out suspense as it backfires. It leads to reader frustration and the story loses credibility.
If that wasn't bad enough, the ending was a hot mess. The reveals were lame and I guessed the main twist at the start of the book. There were gaping holes in the resolution that were left unexplained or didn't seem plausible. I won't go into detail to avoid spoilers but super disappointing.
And another thing I don't like is when characters are written as wishy-washy. You know, when the story is initially built on them hating another character yet a couple chapters later refer to them as their best friend only to go back to hating them but then describe them a couple chapters later as their only true friend... wtf? The lack of continuity was confusing and again made the plot inauthentic.
Lastly the audio performance was annoying. Although the narrator was superb with her range of voices, she often yelled when portraying the child and sometimes the MC, which I found to be distracting and annoying. Like raking your nails down a chalkboard.
Not a winner for me.
September 26, 2021
Samantha King rewards the reader with a stylish family drama ripe with concealment, secrets and altering loyalties.
Holly and Jordan Mayhew live in a little cottage by the sea along with their daughter, Marley who is a lively and chatty seven-year-old. Yet Marley has suddenly become sullen and anxious. Holly is desperate to get to the root cause of this sudden shift in her eldest child. Is Marley struggling to adjust to the birth of her new baby brother, or is there something more sinister going on?
This is a slow burner about unravelling family secrets, both past and present, and the author does a wonderful job of building the characters while still maintaining the suspense. I was immediately consumed by this compelling tale and had a hard time putting the book down. The reader is taken down a meandering path of mystery as Holly tries to get through to her daughter whilst keeping her marriage afloat. The shifting dynamics meant I was unsure who could be trusted and many of the cast were of dubious nature. With dark and disquieting notes, The Secret Keeper’s Daughter is very highly recommended.
I received a complimentary copy of this novel at my request from HQ via NetGalley. This review is my own unbiased opinion.
Holly and Jordan Mayhew live in a little cottage by the sea along with their daughter, Marley who is a lively and chatty seven-year-old. Yet Marley has suddenly become sullen and anxious. Holly is desperate to get to the root cause of this sudden shift in her eldest child. Is Marley struggling to adjust to the birth of her new baby brother, or is there something more sinister going on?
This is a slow burner about unravelling family secrets, both past and present, and the author does a wonderful job of building the characters while still maintaining the suspense. I was immediately consumed by this compelling tale and had a hard time putting the book down. The reader is taken down a meandering path of mystery as Holly tries to get through to her daughter whilst keeping her marriage afloat. The shifting dynamics meant I was unsure who could be trusted and many of the cast were of dubious nature. With dark and disquieting notes, The Secret Keeper’s Daughter is very highly recommended.
I received a complimentary copy of this novel at my request from HQ via NetGalley. This review is my own unbiased opinion.
July 30, 2021
I thoroughly enjoyed this book. This is a slow burn about unraveling family secrets, both past and present, and the author does a wonderful job of building relatable characters while still maintaining suspense. I was drawn in immediately, and had a hard time putting the book down. It is the perfect balance between domestic fiction and suspense, reminiscent of Lisa Jewell or Liane Moriarty.
Holly’s lively and chatty daughter, Marley, has suddenly become sullen and anxious. Holly is desperate to get to the bottom of what has caused this sudden shift in her oldest child. Is Marley struggling to adjust to the birth of her new baby brother (BB), or is there something much more sinister behind her change in behaviour? The reader is taken down a meandering path of mystery as Holly tries to breakthrough to her daughter while also managing a seemingly strained marriage, and a best friend that has a flare for the dramatic. In her quest to uncover one mystery, Holly will find herself questioning everything she knows about herself and her family.
I appreciated King’s ability to tell the story through one point of view (Holly’s) while flipping between her childhood, recent past, and the present day (where hindsight is 20/20). The clever narration adds to the suspense and puts a unique spin on the genre. I found myself deeply invested in the characters and Holly’s own quest for answers. Holly’s inability to let anyone finish a sentence and her tendency to jump to conclusions was completely relatable (guilty as charged). It’s this consistent attention to detail that makes King’s character development flawless. The result is a satisfying and extremely engaging read.
This was my first Samantha King book, and I will definitely be reading more!
Thank you to HQ (Harper Collins Publishing), Samantha King, and Netgalley for a free copy of this book in exchange for a fair review.
Check out my blog for more reviews: https://thebooknerd679462600.wordpres...
Holly’s lively and chatty daughter, Marley, has suddenly become sullen and anxious. Holly is desperate to get to the bottom of what has caused this sudden shift in her oldest child. Is Marley struggling to adjust to the birth of her new baby brother (BB), or is there something much more sinister behind her change in behaviour? The reader is taken down a meandering path of mystery as Holly tries to breakthrough to her daughter while also managing a seemingly strained marriage, and a best friend that has a flare for the dramatic. In her quest to uncover one mystery, Holly will find herself questioning everything she knows about herself and her family.
I appreciated King’s ability to tell the story through one point of view (Holly’s) while flipping between her childhood, recent past, and the present day (where hindsight is 20/20). The clever narration adds to the suspense and puts a unique spin on the genre. I found myself deeply invested in the characters and Holly’s own quest for answers. Holly’s inability to let anyone finish a sentence and her tendency to jump to conclusions was completely relatable (guilty as charged). It’s this consistent attention to detail that makes King’s character development flawless. The result is a satisfying and extremely engaging read.
This was my first Samantha King book, and I will definitely be reading more!
Thank you to HQ (Harper Collins Publishing), Samantha King, and Netgalley for a free copy of this book in exchange for a fair review.
Check out my blog for more reviews: https://thebooknerd679462600.wordpres...
December 11, 2021
I started out completely gripped by this story. In fact I enjoyed it right up until the last 20%. But the ending and big reveal let's it down which is a shame.
The storyline is told by Holly and switches between the present and past as she tries to figure out why her daughters behaviour has dramatically changed. She creates or worry box for her daughter to try and communicate what is troubling her. The notes and messages seem dark and ominous and I was fearing the worst.
The majority of the characters are keeping secrets from each other. There are so many red herrings and twists that the ending became quite confusing. The big reveal wasn't all that much of a surprise.
I think this is still a good a book as I couldn't stop reading it especially at the very beginning.
I read this book on The Pigeonhole app in exchange for an honest review
The storyline is told by Holly and switches between the present and past as she tries to figure out why her daughters behaviour has dramatically changed. She creates or worry box for her daughter to try and communicate what is troubling her. The notes and messages seem dark and ominous and I was fearing the worst.
The majority of the characters are keeping secrets from each other. There are so many red herrings and twists that the ending became quite confusing. The big reveal wasn't all that much of a surprise.
I think this is still a good a book as I couldn't stop reading it especially at the very beginning.
I read this book on The Pigeonhole app in exchange for an honest review
August 12, 2021
I stayed up all night to finish this book, I simply could not put it down and turned the last page with tears in my eyes. Such a heart-wrenching, emotional and unfortgettable family drama. The characters felt so real to me and I can't wait to press this into the hands of everyone I know. The twist took my breath away. If I could give it ten stars I would.
August 15, 2021
This was a book about family secrets which were slowly revealed as the book progressed. Along the way we had a number of twists.
Whilst this was a good book and overall enjoyable I did find it a bit of a chore to read at points and felt it progressed too slowly at times. Whilst I liked the main character most of the time I did feel some of the other characters were hard to like and had brought some of their problems on themselves.
I do feel the book and the author had plenty of potential but justfelt overall that the book was lacking something but others might get more enjoyment from the book than I did.
Thanks to NetGalley, the author and the publishers for providing a copy of this book for me, for an an open and honest review.
Whilst this was a good book and overall enjoyable I did find it a bit of a chore to read at points and felt it progressed too slowly at times. Whilst I liked the main character most of the time I did feel some of the other characters were hard to like and had brought some of their problems on themselves.
I do feel the book and the author had plenty of potential but justfelt overall that the book was lacking something but others might get more enjoyment from the book than I did.
Thanks to NetGalley, the author and the publishers for providing a copy of this book for me, for an an open and honest review.
September 7, 2021
After reading the blurb of this book I was really looking forward to a tense and gripping read. It was a good read but not one that I was totally gripped by. I expected more from this book and found it a little bit slow at times .
September 15, 2021
The Secret Keeper’s Daughter is a little outside my usual genre of choice, however, this story rooted in family, secrets, and the need to do what’s best for those you love is a powerful read. What do you do when you know something is troubling your child, yet they do not want to or cannot voice their concerns? The author also explores how well we truly know our family members. Can you know someone when they do not share every truth with you? And do you want to know everything there is to know or are some truths best left unknown?
The author tells a remarkable story that draws you into the heart of a family filled with secrets. Her characters try so hard to do what is best for each other and end up keeping dark secrets which lead to nothing but confusion, pain and insecurity. Samantha King weaved a complex tale with The Secret Keeper’s Daughter that will keep you on the edge of your seat as you turn the pages trying to find the truth.
Holly has everything she has ever dreamed of. A loving husband, and two beautiful children. However, when seven-year-old Marley’s behaviour starts changing, Holly knows something is wrong. Even when her husband tells her that she is over-reacting and that Marley is fine. Holly makes a worry box and Marley’s notes appear innocent at first. When Holly receives a note saying “I do not like Secrets” she knows something is wrong. In her attempt to comfort her troubled daughter, she starts down a path that leads not only to her daughter’s concerns but also uncovers some secrets from her childhood. Leaving Holly questioning all the adults in her daughter’s life. Are some truths better not known?
This is a complex tale that had me reading late into the night as I eagerly tried to uncover the truth. I was so engrossed in all the family secrets and lies I battled to drag myself away from this one. I enjoy never knowing where the story was headed. The author created a family that never really knew each other while they deeply cared for each other.
Holly is a remarkable charactered. Struggling with a heart condition, everyone tries to protect her, afraid that the truth would send her to her grave. While the only time this poor woman had any peace at all was when she finally uncovers all the family secrets. Holly might be ill, but the stress of second-guessing everyone in her life is so much harder for her to deal with than the horrible truths everyone is keeping from her. The author created a brilliant group of characters and highlighted the importance of honesty within a family unit.
This was a fantastic read. I reached for this book during a rather hectic weekend which was not the best choice as I battle to drag myself away. This complex tale full of missing truths that lead to suspicions and confusion for Holly was beautifully told. I loved this book.
Mystery fans will find themselves glued to the pages as they eagerly race towards the end of this book. Do not try to predict this books’ ending, it is not what you expect. The author weaves so many twists into this one you are guaranteed to be surprised with every turn. This book was a gripping read that kept me guessing. You won’t be disappointed.
The author tells a remarkable story that draws you into the heart of a family filled with secrets. Her characters try so hard to do what is best for each other and end up keeping dark secrets which lead to nothing but confusion, pain and insecurity. Samantha King weaved a complex tale with The Secret Keeper’s Daughter that will keep you on the edge of your seat as you turn the pages trying to find the truth.
Holly has everything she has ever dreamed of. A loving husband, and two beautiful children. However, when seven-year-old Marley’s behaviour starts changing, Holly knows something is wrong. Even when her husband tells her that she is over-reacting and that Marley is fine. Holly makes a worry box and Marley’s notes appear innocent at first. When Holly receives a note saying “I do not like Secrets” she knows something is wrong. In her attempt to comfort her troubled daughter, she starts down a path that leads not only to her daughter’s concerns but also uncovers some secrets from her childhood. Leaving Holly questioning all the adults in her daughter’s life. Are some truths better not known?
This is a complex tale that had me reading late into the night as I eagerly tried to uncover the truth. I was so engrossed in all the family secrets and lies I battled to drag myself away from this one. I enjoy never knowing where the story was headed. The author created a family that never really knew each other while they deeply cared for each other.
Holly is a remarkable charactered. Struggling with a heart condition, everyone tries to protect her, afraid that the truth would send her to her grave. While the only time this poor woman had any peace at all was when she finally uncovers all the family secrets. Holly might be ill, but the stress of second-guessing everyone in her life is so much harder for her to deal with than the horrible truths everyone is keeping from her. The author created a brilliant group of characters and highlighted the importance of honesty within a family unit.
This was a fantastic read. I reached for this book during a rather hectic weekend which was not the best choice as I battle to drag myself away. This complex tale full of missing truths that lead to suspicions and confusion for Holly was beautifully told. I loved this book.
Mystery fans will find themselves glued to the pages as they eagerly race towards the end of this book. Do not try to predict this books’ ending, it is not what you expect. The author weaves so many twists into this one you are guaranteed to be surprised with every turn. This book was a gripping read that kept me guessing. You won’t be disappointed.
September 18, 2021
I really wanted to give this book a 5 star rating but just couldn't quite justify it even though I would recommend this book to others to read.
I loved the seaside location and small community and I really enjoyed the back and forth in timelines, between Holly as a young girl and Holly as a wife and mother with a daughter whose behaviour changes suddenly and alarmingly after her seventh birthday.
Holly lived a childhood filled with secrets and the menace behind the concealed truths grows bigger and darker as the novel progresses. The secrets become an entity all of their own and wield a power far greater than what is necessary, if only the adults, Adam and Olivia, Luke and Isabelle, could have spoken aloud.
Instead there is a pervading sense of dark deeds as the reader trips over the words in haste to unravel the reasons behind the unexplained arrival of Amy in Holly's childhood home, and the ominous withdrawal and anxiety of Holly's daughter Marley years later. Are the two connected?
Is history repeating itself? Are people unhappy in adult life because of misconceptions in their youth which fester and build in magnitude to create fear and mistrust, when in actual fact there is nothing to be afraid of?
I loved the way this novel invites the reader to ponder those bigger questions in life, perceptions, past history, half truths and misunderstandings which shape the way we learn, behave and interact with others.
Just who in this story has got their facts straight or is it a case of all the colours in the artist's palette mixed up until the only discernable shade is a murky brown?
I felt empathy as I read, mistrust, fear and a sense of loneliness and longing, and to top it off, regrets galore.
I was fortunate enough to read this book on Pigeonhole in daily staves alongside the fabulous and utterly delightful author Samantha King. Getting inside Samantha's head, hearing her views as a writer and her responses to us as readers made for a hugely rich reading experience.
I am keen to read more from Samantha King and urge you to do the same. You could just be about to meet a new favourite author!
I loved the seaside location and small community and I really enjoyed the back and forth in timelines, between Holly as a young girl and Holly as a wife and mother with a daughter whose behaviour changes suddenly and alarmingly after her seventh birthday.
Holly lived a childhood filled with secrets and the menace behind the concealed truths grows bigger and darker as the novel progresses. The secrets become an entity all of their own and wield a power far greater than what is necessary, if only the adults, Adam and Olivia, Luke and Isabelle, could have spoken aloud.
Instead there is a pervading sense of dark deeds as the reader trips over the words in haste to unravel the reasons behind the unexplained arrival of Amy in Holly's childhood home, and the ominous withdrawal and anxiety of Holly's daughter Marley years later. Are the two connected?
Is history repeating itself? Are people unhappy in adult life because of misconceptions in their youth which fester and build in magnitude to create fear and mistrust, when in actual fact there is nothing to be afraid of?
I loved the way this novel invites the reader to ponder those bigger questions in life, perceptions, past history, half truths and misunderstandings which shape the way we learn, behave and interact with others.
Just who in this story has got their facts straight or is it a case of all the colours in the artist's palette mixed up until the only discernable shade is a murky brown?
I felt empathy as I read, mistrust, fear and a sense of loneliness and longing, and to top it off, regrets galore.
I was fortunate enough to read this book on Pigeonhole in daily staves alongside the fabulous and utterly delightful author Samantha King. Getting inside Samantha's head, hearing her views as a writer and her responses to us as readers made for a hugely rich reading experience.
I am keen to read more from Samantha King and urge you to do the same. You could just be about to meet a new favourite author!
September 8, 2021
I was totally hooked onn this book at the start. I wasn't sure who to believe or trust (I completely misjudged)! My imagination conjured up many potential scenarios. The actual story reveal was more sedate and the book was more a family drama than a thriller. I enjoyed the concept of honest truth vs more palatable fiction within families and how childhood memories can distort adult realisations. However, I felt that the novel lost its way a little towards the end and the little who'd driven the whole story seemed to be overlooked a little in the finale. Still enjoyable if you like a family drama that is thought provoking.
November 26, 2021
Poignant
October 25, 2023
This book was a slow burn for me but I enjoyed it and got into it. The red herrings worked which lead me to try and work out who I could trust.
I was given a free copy by netgalley and the publishers but the review is entirely my own.
I was given a free copy by netgalley and the publishers but the review is entirely my own.
September 8, 2021
I read an advance publication of this via The Pigeonhole however unfortunately for me this was a very disappointing read. The underlying theme and behaviours of the main characters just did not ring true - emotional complexities run throughout but I feel that in spite of the author being a therapist, they were very poorly explored or explained. There were a lot of secrets with many of the the reasons behind them bordering on ridiculous, along with a lot of red herrings which gave us a few things to ponder but on the whole the ‘big reveal’ at the end was totally underwhelming.
October 15, 2021
Not a bad story however I did find parts of it to be a little long and unnecessary to the plot. I did really like the characters however so it wasn't a bad trade off. The book is all about our main character Holly who suddenly becomes very worried about her daughter. Her daughter Marley is usually super bubbly and wont stop talking and then all of a sudden she becomes forlorn and sullen, very out of character for her. Not knowing what to do and having her daughter be unable to tell her verbally what is going on Holly decides to make a "Worry Box" where Marley can write down what is bothering her without having to actually speak any words. What sounds
like a great idea suddenly turns dark when the worry box starts to fill up, and Holly starts to piece together the secrets. I loved the idea for this because it lets the reader try to figure out what is happening with the daughter at the same time as the mother. The only thing that I didn't like to much about this book was I wasn't that invested in the plot like I expected I would be. It was a little bit to long at parts that didn't matter and short at the parts that really did. I found myself putting it down a lot which I was very surprised about because the plot sounds like something I would devour in one sitting. I did like the dedication that the mother showed in trying to figure out what was going on. It made it very relatable and as the reader you were trying your best to guess
along with Holly on what was wrong with Marley. After every chapter I was guessing the worst but hoping not. I'm glad I got to read this book even though it was a slow start I enjoyed the rest of it. I loved the ending it was very unexpected. Great read and I'm so glad I gave it a chance, this is one book that you won't want to miss.
like a great idea suddenly turns dark when the worry box starts to fill up, and Holly starts to piece together the secrets. I loved the idea for this because it lets the reader try to figure out what is happening with the daughter at the same time as the mother. The only thing that I didn't like to much about this book was I wasn't that invested in the plot like I expected I would be. It was a little bit to long at parts that didn't matter and short at the parts that really did. I found myself putting it down a lot which I was very surprised about because the plot sounds like something I would devour in one sitting. I did like the dedication that the mother showed in trying to figure out what was going on. It made it very relatable and as the reader you were trying your best to guess
along with Holly on what was wrong with Marley. After every chapter I was guessing the worst but hoping not. I'm glad I got to read this book even though it was a slow start I enjoyed the rest of it. I loved the ending it was very unexpected. Great read and I'm so glad I gave it a chance, this is one book that you won't want to miss.
September 10, 2021
Holly and Jordan Mayhew live in a little cottage by the sea, along with their daughter, Marley. Everything seems idyllic in their world until one day Marley becomes withdrawn and begins to act strangely. Holly decides to create a ‘worry box’. And this opens up a whole can of worms.
This is an absorbing and compelling story about family secrets and how we can often get the wrong end of the stick when coming across something we don’t understand. At first I thought it was going to be a psychological thriller with something dark and sinister at its core. However, it’s not as menacing as that and the end reveal could appear to be a little anti-climatic for some. Personally, I think it’s a beautifully written and gentle story about love and forgiveness in a world where hope is all we have. I very much enjoyed it.
This is an absorbing and compelling story about family secrets and how we can often get the wrong end of the stick when coming across something we don’t understand. At first I thought it was going to be a psychological thriller with something dark and sinister at its core. However, it’s not as menacing as that and the end reveal could appear to be a little anti-climatic for some. Personally, I think it’s a beautifully written and gentle story about love and forgiveness in a world where hope is all we have. I very much enjoyed it.
October 1, 2021
I received an arc copy of this book from Net Galley in exchange for my honest opinion of it. This is another book that kept my interest and not much of an ending. Holly is an only child until she is seven years old and her parents take in their best friend's daughter, Amy. What is suppose to be a few weeks of living here turns into a lifetime. Holly feels second to Amy as she shines in everything and makes problems that look like Holly caused. Holly marries Jordan and they have two children together. When 7 year old Marley starts acting withdrawn and not speaking much, Holly makes a "worry box" for Marley to leave a message in everyday. Holly starts to suspect Amy is having an affair with her husband and as secrets start to come out they are just family secrets. I was waiting for some big reveal. It was just okay for me.
September 11, 2021
I have given this 5 stars as although we guessed quite early on what the big secret was it was still ann enjoyable read.
Yes conversations half started and not finished were frustrating at times but I suppose you don't want the big reveal too soon.
Adam and Olivia are Holly's parents. Holly is married to Jordan and has two children Marley and BB.
Marley's behaviour changes the day of her seventh birthday so Holly sets up a worry box for her.
The story goes back and forth to Holly's childhood and the day Amy came to stay and didn't go back to her parents Luke and Isobelle.
None of the characters are endearing especially Adam who blamed every misdemeanor on Holly. Amy could do know wrong.
Thanks to Pigeonhole and Samantha King who engaged with us all through the book
Yes conversations half started and not finished were frustrating at times but I suppose you don't want the big reveal too soon.
Adam and Olivia are Holly's parents. Holly is married to Jordan and has two children Marley and BB.
Marley's behaviour changes the day of her seventh birthday so Holly sets up a worry box for her.
The story goes back and forth to Holly's childhood and the day Amy came to stay and didn't go back to her parents Luke and Isobelle.
None of the characters are endearing especially Adam who blamed every misdemeanor on Holly. Amy could do know wrong.
Thanks to Pigeonhole and Samantha King who engaged with us all through the book
August 19, 2022
I really liked the first half of the book, but the “big reveal” seemed to be too dragged out and fell a bit flat.
September 20, 2021
Lovely immersive writing that has you hooked from the start. Highly recommend.
August 28, 2021
Holly and Jordan live happily with their two children, 7 year old Marley and baby Benjamin. When Marley starts acting uncharacteristically. Holly gives her a worry box in the hope of learning what is troubling her daughter. Instead, she finds a whole plethora of secrets and lies that threaten everything she’s ever known.
This book could have been a great deal shorter. There’s a lot of unnecessary dialogue and it rarely gets to the point.
I didn’t really take to any of the characters and parts of the story didn’t ring true at all. There’s no way Holly wouldn’t have known about Jane for a start! There were so many twists and turns it was tricky to keep them straight in your head, but they weren’t exactly a surprise.
It’s not a bad book, but it’s too waffly for my tastes. Thank you to NetGalley and the publishers for my copy of this book.
This book could have been a great deal shorter. There’s a lot of unnecessary dialogue and it rarely gets to the point.
I didn’t really take to any of the characters and parts of the story didn’t ring true at all. There’s no way Holly wouldn’t have known about Jane for a start! There were so many twists and turns it was tricky to keep them straight in your head, but they weren’t exactly a surprise.
It’s not a bad book, but it’s too waffly for my tastes. Thank you to NetGalley and the publishers for my copy of this book.
March 23, 2022
Hard as I tried, this book was completely underwhelming. Nothing important or eventful actually happened and more importantly, there was a lot of dialogue and thought which didn’t actually say or mean anything. Far too long with dreary, self-obsessed and overly dramatised ruminations that would go on for what seemed like forever. The crux of the story (as on the back of the book)? Turns out this was largely irrelevant and a mountain out of a molehill scenario.
Far too many red herrings which, in the context of a good story, might have been tolerable. But the writing wasn’t deft enough to make me believe these tangents were necessary to the story. There were far too many of them that just served to confuse. I felt the book tried to pray on our fears by throwing in story arcs that hinted at the depth of human depravity. But all this served to do was make the reality, when it came, a non-event.
The number of interrupted conversations was ludicrous to the point that, even if there was a sniff of a small reveal (and I use the word “reveal” loosely), I could predict the conversation was going to be interrupted. This happened almost to the end of the book, to the point it was quite comical. Ultimately one of the characters seemed to have had enough (I certainly did) and everything came out in 1 big “blurgh”. Although what came out wasn’t particularly exciting. I found myself looking for a plot summary online but, not easily forthcoming, I forced myself to finish the book.
I think the problem here was that the book misrepresented itself. The synopsis advertises the story as a thriller, but in essence it’s a family drama. Sadly, for me, not a very good one.
Far too many red herrings which, in the context of a good story, might have been tolerable. But the writing wasn’t deft enough to make me believe these tangents were necessary to the story. There were far too many of them that just served to confuse. I felt the book tried to pray on our fears by throwing in story arcs that hinted at the depth of human depravity. But all this served to do was make the reality, when it came, a non-event.
The number of interrupted conversations was ludicrous to the point that, even if there was a sniff of a small reveal (and I use the word “reveal” loosely), I could predict the conversation was going to be interrupted. This happened almost to the end of the book, to the point it was quite comical. Ultimately one of the characters seemed to have had enough (I certainly did) and everything came out in 1 big “blurgh”. Although what came out wasn’t particularly exciting. I found myself looking for a plot summary online but, not easily forthcoming, I forced myself to finish the book.
I think the problem here was that the book misrepresented itself. The synopsis advertises the story as a thriller, but in essence it’s a family drama. Sadly, for me, not a very good one.
May 9, 2022
This started so well. A fear that a child had been abused hooked me immediately. The reality that it was an overheard conversation was a bit of a let down and one thing that really struck me as unrealistic was the husbands response. We are supposed to believe in the end that they are soul mates and yet when he knows a secret he doesn’t want to tell her his response is the avoid her for weeks on end leaving her with two children and a serious heart condition! Rubbish 🤨
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
February 18, 2022
Wow! This is what I felt as I finished reading The Secret Keeper by Samantha King. This book cannot completely be classified as a mystery-thriller per se; it's more of a domestic mystery and suspense.
The story is about Holly Mayhew as she struggles to understand what has suddenly become wrong with her daughter Marley. Holly feels her daughter has suddenly become very withdrawn, not at all her usual self. She has given birth to a son very recently and it was both a difficult pregnancy and birth for her. Both she and her son almost didn't survive it. This makes her think it might be a case of sibling jealousy. But there are no explicit signs from her daughter which point towards it.
She also has been at home taking care of the kids not able to go back to her job as elementary teacher at her daughter's school. Her health still hasn't recovered from her pregnancy and all these have lead to a gap in the relationship between her husband Jordan and herself. Due to her health issues, her husband doesn't take it seriously when she conveys her doubts and fears about their daughter. He thinks she is just overcome with all her difficulties. Her attempts to help Marley open up have also not been fruitful and she tries to help her by asking her to use a worry box. Her distance from her husband also leads her to think her husband might be in an affair with her friend Amy who had grown up in her house and with whom she has a sometimes contentious and sometimes amiable relationship.
All these struggles combined together come to a head and force her to confront many of her childhood hang-ups and baggage. Her daughter's messages in the worry box also raises more questions about people closest to her rather than answer her concerns. Her efforts to find the answers finally leads to a lot of secrets, that had long been buried, to come out.
The story actually carried a dark tone throughout and the author has a rather descriptive, terse prose which manage to pulls the reader into the life of the main characters. The characters had been given enough depth for us to see them as real people - people with their own faults, virtues and struggles. The author has managed to weave a clever story around the limited, literal take of a child about certain happenings around her. There are so many twists in the story many of which you can never see coming. The story was so very interesting that I read through the book in one go without ever laying it down. This is excellent writing by Samantha King and I would definitely be sure to check out all her future works as well.
The story is about Holly Mayhew as she struggles to understand what has suddenly become wrong with her daughter Marley. Holly feels her daughter has suddenly become very withdrawn, not at all her usual self. She has given birth to a son very recently and it was both a difficult pregnancy and birth for her. Both she and her son almost didn't survive it. This makes her think it might be a case of sibling jealousy. But there are no explicit signs from her daughter which point towards it.
She also has been at home taking care of the kids not able to go back to her job as elementary teacher at her daughter's school. Her health still hasn't recovered from her pregnancy and all these have lead to a gap in the relationship between her husband Jordan and herself. Due to her health issues, her husband doesn't take it seriously when she conveys her doubts and fears about their daughter. He thinks she is just overcome with all her difficulties. Her attempts to help Marley open up have also not been fruitful and she tries to help her by asking her to use a worry box. Her distance from her husband also leads her to think her husband might be in an affair with her friend Amy who had grown up in her house and with whom she has a sometimes contentious and sometimes amiable relationship.
All these struggles combined together come to a head and force her to confront many of her childhood hang-ups and baggage. Her daughter's messages in the worry box also raises more questions about people closest to her rather than answer her concerns. Her efforts to find the answers finally leads to a lot of secrets, that had long been buried, to come out.
The story actually carried a dark tone throughout and the author has a rather descriptive, terse prose which manage to pulls the reader into the life of the main characters. The characters had been given enough depth for us to see them as real people - people with their own faults, virtues and struggles. The author has managed to weave a clever story around the limited, literal take of a child about certain happenings around her. There are so many twists in the story many of which you can never see coming. The story was so very interesting that I read through the book in one go without ever laying it down. This is excellent writing by Samantha King and I would definitely be sure to check out all her future works as well.
December 24, 2021
This family drama follows Holly Mayhew (the mum) appears to have the perfect family. A loving husband and two children - a daughter who is seven and a new-born son Benjamin. However, if you take of the rose tinted glasses all is not as it seems.
When Holly's seven year old daughter Marley begins to act out of character, becoming withdrawn, mother's instinct kicks in and she just knows something isn't right. As any parent would be, she is desperate to discover why her daughter has changed, so Holly makes a worry box where Marley can posts her thoughts each day (good or bad).
The messages begin with a drawing of a birthday cake, innocent enough. But when Holly finds a note saying secrets make me sad, she begins to question everything and everyone.
Who can be trusted? Her husband, her closest friend Amy, even her dad, all appear to be holding something back. The question is what.
This is a novel filled with suspense.
The main story happens over seven days with seven notes from Marley forming one hell of a revelation.
Most books these days have the formula of a big build up and a shock twist at the end but Samantha really went all out because the reveals just kept coming and with each one came more mystery.
I, along with Holly, was second guessing everything. Combing back through previous chapters for clues that I might have missed.
Each character seemed guilty of something but it was never obvious as the truths and lies seemed to cross over so closely.
What worked well was the dual time lines. This gave the main cast an extra depth and made it more clear as to why they acted in the way the did. I also found that as we were taken from present to past the tension was constantly and consistently building. I was on tenterhooks waiting for the next secret to be divulged.
There was a great amount of information written without giving too much away.
The Secret Keeper's Daughter is a book that builds slowly (with a terrifying atmosphere) but this steady way of forming the story didn't lessen my usual fast reading pace.
I won't divulge any of the major points, spoilers would definitely lessen the novels impact. I'll just say that this story is a highly satisfying read that is at times dark but always maintaining a brilliant uncertainty throughout.
When Holly's seven year old daughter Marley begins to act out of character, becoming withdrawn, mother's instinct kicks in and she just knows something isn't right. As any parent would be, she is desperate to discover why her daughter has changed, so Holly makes a worry box where Marley can posts her thoughts each day (good or bad).
The messages begin with a drawing of a birthday cake, innocent enough. But when Holly finds a note saying secrets make me sad, she begins to question everything and everyone.
Who can be trusted? Her husband, her closest friend Amy, even her dad, all appear to be holding something back. The question is what.
This is a novel filled with suspense.
The main story happens over seven days with seven notes from Marley forming one hell of a revelation.
Most books these days have the formula of a big build up and a shock twist at the end but Samantha really went all out because the reveals just kept coming and with each one came more mystery.
I, along with Holly, was second guessing everything. Combing back through previous chapters for clues that I might have missed.
Each character seemed guilty of something but it was never obvious as the truths and lies seemed to cross over so closely.
What worked well was the dual time lines. This gave the main cast an extra depth and made it more clear as to why they acted in the way the did. I also found that as we were taken from present to past the tension was constantly and consistently building. I was on tenterhooks waiting for the next secret to be divulged.
There was a great amount of information written without giving too much away.
The Secret Keeper's Daughter is a book that builds slowly (with a terrifying atmosphere) but this steady way of forming the story didn't lessen my usual fast reading pace.
I won't divulge any of the major points, spoilers would definitely lessen the novels impact. I'll just say that this story is a highly satisfying read that is at times dark but always maintaining a brilliant uncertainty throughout.
September 6, 2021
Holly Aitken, snug in her cottage in a holiday village on the Suffolk coast of the North Sea, loves her husband Jordan, her new baby Benji, and her seven-year-old daughter Marley, absolutely and unconditionally.
So when Marley, typically a bright and bubbly chatterbox, begins to exhibit strange and unsettling behaviors, Holly finds it hard to quell her rising panic, despite her husbands assurances to the contrary. Holly, who suffers from a congenital heart defect, is used to being “handled” - after all, extreme stress in her condition can be dangerous, if not downright deadly - but Holly knows, deep in her heart with all the certainty a mother can bring, that something is just not right.
In trying to coax answers from her troubled and uncommunicative child, Holly decides on a strategy allowing her daughter to post pictures and written messages day by day into a “Worry box” - a modified shoe box they set up together - that she’s hoping will serve as a safe and controlled release-valve for Marley’s self-generated fearful messages.
The process, as it unfolds, is both fascinating, and terrifying, - without giving the plot away (no spoilers here!), it soon becomes apparent that Marley has a story to tell, and one that is brimming with “secrets”. The challenge of course, for Holly and the reader, is how to interpret Marleys cryptic and childlike messages. Parsing out Marley’s story becomes all the more intriguing when set against the backdrop context of Holly’s complex and unusual family - including her enigmatic husband Jordan, her dramatic and beautiful foster-sister Amy - and her somewhat sinisterly handsome neighbor Phil.
The author has several tricks up her sleeve and I enjoyed the twists and turns as the plot unfolds, as well as the themes interwoven throughout the narrative. In particular, the very interesting thought that, although it may not always be apparent to the adults around them, children are always watching. And as to what exactly they may be seeing, well, that’s a whole other interesting thought.
A great big thank you to the author, NetGalley and HQstories for an arc of this book. All thoughts presented are my own.
So when Marley, typically a bright and bubbly chatterbox, begins to exhibit strange and unsettling behaviors, Holly finds it hard to quell her rising panic, despite her husbands assurances to the contrary. Holly, who suffers from a congenital heart defect, is used to being “handled” - after all, extreme stress in her condition can be dangerous, if not downright deadly - but Holly knows, deep in her heart with all the certainty a mother can bring, that something is just not right.
In trying to coax answers from her troubled and uncommunicative child, Holly decides on a strategy allowing her daughter to post pictures and written messages day by day into a “Worry box” - a modified shoe box they set up together - that she’s hoping will serve as a safe and controlled release-valve for Marley’s self-generated fearful messages.
The process, as it unfolds, is both fascinating, and terrifying, - without giving the plot away (no spoilers here!), it soon becomes apparent that Marley has a story to tell, and one that is brimming with “secrets”. The challenge of course, for Holly and the reader, is how to interpret Marleys cryptic and childlike messages. Parsing out Marley’s story becomes all the more intriguing when set against the backdrop context of Holly’s complex and unusual family - including her enigmatic husband Jordan, her dramatic and beautiful foster-sister Amy - and her somewhat sinisterly handsome neighbor Phil.
The author has several tricks up her sleeve and I enjoyed the twists and turns as the plot unfolds, as well as the themes interwoven throughout the narrative. In particular, the very interesting thought that, although it may not always be apparent to the adults around them, children are always watching. And as to what exactly they may be seeing, well, that’s a whole other interesting thought.
A great big thank you to the author, NetGalley and HQstories for an arc of this book. All thoughts presented are my own.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 109 reviews