Middle grade, time-travel novel
Nathan and his BFF, Ty, have done everything together for the past 7 years, since they first met in kindergarten. They are so close, mentally and emotionally, they finish each other's sentences. But all that changes when lovely, charming Ava arrives from New York City and joins their seventh-grade class. Nathan and Ty are shocked when Ava chooses to befriend the two of them, who are outcast, highly intelligent geeks, instead of the popular jocks and cheerleaders, who have reached out strongly to pull her into their smugly superior clique. But when, as always, the thoughts and emotions of Nathan and Ty run in the same direction, and they both fall for Ava, their rivalry for her affections destroys their friendship. Five years pass without the two boys speaking to each other, when suddenly, during their senior year, Nathan is knocked out in a car accident, and he is thrown back in time to age 12, right before Ava's arrival. He is shocked and disoriented to find himself once again in his scrawny, prepubescent body, but he soon decides that, since he has no idea how to get back to the future, to use his imprisonment in the past as a do-over opportunity to win back his friendship with Ty. He is convinced that the only way to do that is to not let Ava come between him and Ty this time around.
Unfortunately, though the premise of this story sounded like it was going to be a real winner, I did not personally find this novel as humorous as the other three novels by this author I have read and enjoyed. As is always the case in virtually every book by this author, the MMC is an underdog. Nathan is ignored by his parents, bullied at school, and socially anxious. He is also frequently overwhelmed by the demands of caring for, and cleaning up after, his family's poorly trained, constantly destructive sheepdog. Over and over again, we are presented with the dog's disgusting habit of drinking out of the toilet, and the fact that neither Nathan nor his parents ever does anything to stop him from doing it. This situation came across as boringly redundant scatological humor, which I was not expecting, because the author did not include gross-out comedy in his other books.
Sadly, when Nathan goes back in time and is living in his 12-year-old body as a 17-year-old, he demonstrates no more confidence or assertiveness than he did when he was actually 12. Almost until the very end of the book, he is just as downtrodden at school and at home as he was five years before. In addition, most of the things that happen to Nathan while he is time traveling to the past I did not personally find very interesting. And the means by which he is finally thrown back into his 17-year-old body I found unexpected, but not in a particularly intriguing way.
This story has a happy ending, but it is achieved by a means that I find frustrating in any novel, whether for children, teens or adults: all of the MC's dysfunctional relationships, which the story has focused on extensively, are simply declared over and done, due to a poorly motivated, 180-degree change in attitude, from foe to friend, of the people who have been treating the MC badly all through the book.
Finally, it is frustrating to read a book written in 2023 that utilizes central tropes of John Hughes movies from the 1980s: bullies run rampant in a school with no adult intervention, and Nathan endures multiple instances of physical assault at the hands of those bullies. Worse, his injuries would have landed a similar victim in the ER in real life, but each attack is treated as cartoonish slapstick, with Nathan hopping up unscathed, like Wile E. Coyote from underneath the anvil.