I loved, loved, LOVED the Fablehaven series (though I was admittedly older than the target audience while I was reading it), so when I was scrolling through the Goodreads popular feed and saw this, I was SO. EXCITED. Did it live up to the hype? Well...
Short Version, Sans Spoilers: Not as good as the original series, but also not bad. I think it's a good pick for middle-grade students, but maybe only ones that are already pretty psyched about reading—I'm not sure it's an easy sell to kids who don't like to read. As for those of us who *ahem* might be a little old for the series but still enjoy it, it's a new adventure in a familiar universe.
Long Version, WITH SPOILERS:
I don't get the warm fuzzy feeling I got reading the original five Fablehaven books when I read this, but it's far from bad. Mull's writing has continued to improve so that some of the more challenging technical problems with his work (mostly the over-abundance of dialogue tags) are less noticeable. There's a lot of building on previous stories and lots of continuity nods. New magic, old characters, fun and adventure. It's hard to come back when the last story had the highest stakes imaginable (imminent doom for all of mankind at the hands of vile demons), and I wouldn't say this story rises to that level, but that's probably due more to this being the first of five novels, thus providing a lot of setup than it is Mull's fault. That said, I didn't enjoy this book as much as the original series, and there are a few reasons why...
In terms of characters, we unfortunately don't get to see many returning. The majority of the novel is focused on Seth and Kendra and their nearly-solo adventure. Most of the other characters are new to the story. I never realized how much characters like Warren, Tanu, Vanessa, Patton, and even Gavin/Navarog brought to the story. The new characters are generally fine (except Calvin, who's really only there for convenience's sake and is pretty bland in the personality department), but I miss the old crew. Seth and Kendra are not quite funny or interesting enough to carry an entire novel on their own. Furthermore, Seth seems to have taken three LARGE steps backward from the learned, strong young man who watched Graulas murder a friend and destroy his home sanctuary. He's back to his old habits and seems less mature than he was in previous books, probably because without his utter fuckups there isn't much of a plot and without his boyish rambunctiousness, he and Kendra don't have much to say to one another that isn't totally dull. It's nothing unforgivable, but it is just enough to grate on me.
There are some other things missing from this book that charmed me in the original series. Most of the action takes place at Wyrmroost, so we don't get multiple locations as we have in other books. I also found the detail a little lacking; there's no scrumptious descriptions of food or lush landscaping or creepy revenant groves; it's pretty basic, almost cliché fantasy settings with little to set them apart, which is why I found the original series so endearing—here, it's castles, open fields, elvin villages, and creepy dark caves. I guess that's all fine, I just miss the charm and attention to detail of the older books.
There's another problem here which is not new to the Fablehaven series—the action/plot is not quite up to snuff, and by that I mean a lot of things. One of the most damning things in my book is that this doesn't feel like a complete stand-alone adventure. Kendra and Seth do some crazy risky things, but unlike previous books I can't give you a quick five-word synopsis to explain the plot. There is not much of a climax or story arc; a lot of this feels like set-up for the adventures to come. Even the first Fablehaven book had a major crisis that was solved by the end, but this one just kind of ends after a minor victory for the good guys. I'm hoping subsequent books will remedy this. I also feel like the stakes aren't quite as high as they were before and it's hard to avoid comparing this to the last book, where the stakes were about as high as it gets. I think it is possible to do a smaller adventure after that, but the execution wasn't necessarily there on this one. We're left feeling a little unsurprised and disenchanted when things go well because duh, you've fucking killed demons before guys.
There are some other pacing issues I have, like certain parts of the book being summarized when it would have been nice to read them out, but that might have been due to the need to keep the book to a managable length for children, since it is nearing 400 pages as it is. I almost—no, I DEFINITELY wish Mull could have aged both characters up by about three or four years and turned this into a YA series, with darker storylines and more serious characterization, danger, etc. Oh the missed opportunities.
I think my biggest problem with the book is that its very premise goes against the innovative, provocative, philosophical moral nature of the series thus far. Choosing to make dragons the main enemy in your middle grade fantasy series is a bit of a low-hanging fruit, isn't it? Especially considering that the characters spend very little time considering the moral implications of their actions, and instead jump into action to subdue the dragons, without really considering whether it's the right thing to do. On one hand, yeah, it probably is, but this series has never taken that kind of thing for granted. We're meant to be questioning—is it right to lock up magical creatures in sanctuaries? Are creatures evil by nature or by choice? What about humans? Etc etc. But here, we've got the easy target of the dragons and no moral ambiguity or conundrums to ponder. It all feels a little rushed and lacks the sinister undertone of the previous books which were filled with characters who might betray Kendra and Seth at any moment, rather than enemies who were obvious and blatant and, to be honest, a little boring.
It sounds like I really didn't like this novel but I found it extremely readable. It's not my favorite in the series so far, not by a long shot, but I'm willing to get through it to get to some more interesting stories and writing in the subsequent novels. Overall, if you're a fan, I do recommend you give this a shot. If not, I wouldn't start with this book—come back when you've read the others. Otherwise, you'll miss out on a lot of charm and excitement.