Thank you to NetGalley, Ms. Quick, and Berkley Books for the opportunity to read an ARC of When She Dreams. An honest review was requested but not required.
When She Dreams features characters that I don’t remember reading about in previous Burning Cove installments: Sam Sage, private detective and disgraced former LA cop, and Margaret (Maggie) Lodge, assistant to and stand-in for the traveling celebrity advice columnist Aunt Cornelia, writer, and “lucid dreamer”.
The best part of this story was the mystery, or the multiple mysteries, I should say. Who was trying to blackmail Aunt Cornelia? Who killed Beverly Nevins and Virginia Jennaway? What is Doctor Oxlade up to? What roles do Arthur and Dolores Guilfoyle play in everything? Who tried to kill Sam? There was a lot going on and Maggie and Sam prove to be a very good detective team. I also enjoyed the 1930s setting, which is an underused time period in my opinion.
Unfortunately, the romance between Maggie and Sam (this is not a spoiler, if you’ve ever read an Amanda Quick book before) seemed abrupt and somewhat clinical. I never really got the impression that anything more was going on between them besides convenience – he was there, she was there, they were in the mood, etc. There was more “spark” between Raina and Luther in their single cameo scene together than in Maggie and Sam’s entire relationship. I also wish there had been a little bit more done with Maggie’s lucid dreaming talent. I kept expecting her to use it over the course of the story, but unless I missed it, I don’t think she did. That was a little disappointing.
I was mildly surprised by the whodunnit, although I will say I’m not a reader who typically tries to parse out all the clues in order to beat the main characters to the conclusion. I prefer being taken on the ride, so to speak. However, the star attraction of this book was definitely the mystery rather than the romance, so I’m happy to report that the mystery was a good one. Now: when are we getting Luther and Raina’s book?