Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Garden of Witches

Rate this book
Hidden in the wild forests of the Appalachian Mountains is a school of magic…and mystery.

Ezra Bishop’s life crumbles apart after a devastating loss, sending her and her twin sister across the country to a prestigious boarding school for bloodline witches.

Atwood Preparatory Academy seems like an ideal place for the sisters to attempt to restart their lives, but it isn’t long before peace at the school is broken when one of the students goes missing.

One of many...

When someone close to her is threatened, Ezra is forced to face a mystery that has haunted the school for centuries. Unraveling the truth of the disappearances goes deeper than Ezra is prepared for, until she finds herself digging the grave of a terrorizing secret.

Forging a tense alliance with the Headmaster’s sons, Ezra may be better off on her own as she discovers the boys are harboring dangerous secrets of their own. But the enemy is already here, and as children continue to go missing, Ezra realizes that she has to lay everything on the line to protect those she cares about…even her life.

257 pages, Kindle Edition

Published October 29, 2021

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Salem Sinclair

26 books272 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
50 (40%)
4 stars
37 (29%)
3 stars
31 (24%)
2 stars
4 (3%)
1 star
3 (2%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 53 reviews
Profile Image for Leonie .
567 reviews238 followers
August 1, 2024
Minus points for killing the dog and that one weird smut scene
Profile Image for Laura Fabian.
736 reviews55 followers
October 26, 2021
ARC provided in exchange for an honest review

Salem Sinclair did an excellent job creating a magical world for Garden of Witches! With a story full of secrets, shocking truths and mysteries, complex, wonderful and endearing characters that I really enjoyed reading and the most unexpected relationships and situations I could imagine.

To begin with, I LOVED the universe that the author created for this story, I loved how detailed every aspect, holiday, landscape and component of the witch world in her story was, and the ease with her writing made me interested in knowing more about Ezra and all her characters. This was very important to me since I'm not a big fan of fantasy, but after this book I'll be looking forward to the next books by Salem Sinclair, because her style completely immersed me in the history.

I'm also not a fan of books told exclusively from the girl's point of view, but Ezra was a very interesting character, with a very complex mind and feelings, she's the protector of her twin Noa, and they both face a big change after a sudden loss, and that change is not easy at all, because from the first moment Ezra arrives at Atwood Preparatory Academy becomes the target of constant attacks and prejudices. But she's a strong girl, willing to defend herself and take care of those she loves, even if she has to hide her true feelings, but despite that side of Ezra, what I liked the most about her character was the crude way in which Salem wrote his feelings and showed his most vulnerable side.

Alder is a boy who unexpectedly enters in Ezra's life, is kind, flirtatious and cocky in the best of ways, from the first moment his attraction to Ezra is evident, but Alder hides some things that make it a bit difficult for Ezra to trust him and let himself be carried away by him. At the other end is Asa, a model student, just as mysterious as Alder, serious and always in control of his emotions. These two guys share a special and unexpected bond that I loved reading, shocking truths, and funny & amazing interaction between with Ezra.

One of the things that I loved the most, surprisingly, was that, as the preface says, this is not a love story, but Ezra 's processes through grief and towards recovery, but seamlessly intertwined with the mysterious disappearances of Atwood's students, the secrets and lies its characters hide, and the hottest, most unexpected, and cuddiest relationships. I can't say more because I don't want to ruin the experience, but I can assure you that this book earned a place on my 2021 favorites list and its characters a huge place in my heart, so I highly recommend it.

🇪🇸
ARC proporcionada a cambio de una reseña honesta

Salem Sinclair hizo un trabajo excelente creando un mundo mágico para Garden of Witches! Con una historia llena de secretos misterios y verdades impactantes, personajes complejos, maravillosos y entrañables que disfruté mucho leyendo y las relaciones más inesperadas que pude imaginar.

Para empezar, AMÉ el universo que la autora creo para esta historia, me encantó como explicó cada aspecto, festividad, paisaje y componente del mundo de las brujas en su historia y la facilidad con la que su escritura hizo que me interesara en conocer más sobre Ezra y todos sus personajes. Esto fue muy importante para mi ya que no soy una amante de la fantasía, pero después de este libro voy a estar esperando con ansias los próximos libros de Salem Sinclair, pues su estilo me sumergió por completo en la historia.

Tampoco soy fan de los libros contados exclusivamente desde el punto de vista de la chica, pero Ezra fue un personaje muy interesante, con una mente y sentimientos muy complejos, ella es la protectora de su gemela Noa, y ambas se enfrentan a un gran cambio después de una perdida repentina, y dicho cambio no es nada fácil, pues desde el primer momento en que Ezra llega a Atwood Preparatory Academy se vuelve el blanco de constantes ataques y prejuicios. Pero ella es una chica fuerte, dispuesta a defenderse y a cuidar de los que ama, incluso si tiene que ocultar sus verdaderos sentimientos, pero a pesar de ese lado de Ezra, lo que más me gustó de su personaje fue la manera tan cruda en la que Salem escribió sus sentimientos y mostró su lado más vulnerable.

Alder es un chico que entra de manera inesperada en la vida de Ezra, es amable, coqueto y engreído en la mejor de las formas, desde el primer momento su atracción por Ezra es evidente, pero Alder esconde algunas cosas que le hacen a Ezra un poco difícil confiar en él y dejarse llevar por sus sentimientos. En el otro extremo está Asa, un estudiante modelo, igual de misterioso que Alder, serio y siempre en control de sus emociones. Estos dos chicos comparten un vinculo especial e inesperado que me encantó leer, verdades impactantes y amé cada interacción entre ellos y Ezra.

Una de las cosas que más me encantó, sorprendentemente, fue que, como lo dice el prefacio, ésta no es una historia de amor, si no el procesos de Ezra a través del duelo y hacia la recuperación, pero se entrelaza a la perfección con las desapariciones misteriosas de los estudiantes de Atwood, los secretos y mentiras que sus personajes esconden, y con las relaciones más calientes, inesperadas y tiernas. No puedo decir más porque no quiero arruinar la experiencia, pero sí puedo asegurar que este libro se ganó un lugar en mi lista de favoritos de este 2021 y sus personajes un lugar enorme en mi corazón.
Profile Image for Dee Garcia.
Author 43 books897 followers
May 13, 2022


Buckle up, friends, 'cause this is going to be a LONG ass review.

Firstly, I'd like to start off by saying I have one hell of a bone to pick with all the romance-loving, Harry Potter fans of Romancelandia. I'M LOOKING AT EVERY. SINGLE. ONE OF YOU. 👀

My question is: WHY DOES THIS BOOK NOT HAVE MORE REVIEWS THAN IT DOES? 👀

WHY AREN'T MORE PEOPLE READING IT? 👀👀😤

WHY HASN'T THIS BOOK BLOWN TF UP? 👀👀👀🤬

Okay, so that's more than one question, BUT STILL. WHY to all of the above? 👀👀👀👀👀

Garden of Witches is pure and utter MAGIC, and I'm not just talking about the occult/paranormal theme within the story. No, the whole thing is a magical masterpiece. 😭🙌🏻 Now, I'll warn you, this isn't a true romance novel. There's romance *in* it (and scorching spice I was not expecting, but pleasantly surprised to find 😏🥵) but the main premise of the story is not the romance. If you *need* the main plot line to be centered around two characters falling in love, this *may* not be the story for you. Even then, I beseech you to pick this up and give it a chance, especially if you're a Potterhead. You will *not* be disappointed.

It's right about here I'd like to point out that there is no way in hell this is Salem's first book. No. Way. In. Hell. Her writing style enthralls you, captivates you, literally transports you to this vivid world she has so intricately woven together. She literally had me from the very first page, held me captive all throughout, and when the story was over, I was not only in shock from the ending, but wanting to cry because that's it, there weren't any more pages to turn. It was like reliving my childhood reading the Harry Potter books, only more mature, more sinister, and dirtier. I'm OBSESSED. Want more—no, NEED more of this world and these characters. I know there's no plans for an expansion given the ending, but OMG, I need more, Salem. CAN YOU HEAR ME SCREAMING AT YOU, LADY? I NEED MORE, PLEASE, I BEG YOU.

For the Potterheads wondering how their beloved world fits into this equation, allow me to explain. It's all in the characters and the scenery. Ezra, who's a twin and the FMC in which the full story is told by, gave me Hermione mixed with the Weasely twins vibes. Aza exuded Draco vibes. And Vale (Alder) had all the Harry vibes.

Intrigued yet? Let's discuss! ☝🏻

As aforementioned, Ezra's sole POV takes us on this mysterious, tragic journey, one that includes great loss—which I have, unfortunately, experienced myself—many a tribulations, ostracism and bullying, the beginnings of one epic love story, secrets, betrayal—the list goes on and on. She gave me huge Hermione vibes in the sense that she's a good student and wants to learn, with a hint of the Weasely twins throw in there since she herself is a twin. But this is where Salem made Ezzie her own. There's a deep-seated rage constantly bubbling within this young witch's veins, courtesy of the cards life has dealt her. Sometimes she can control it, but most of the time, she fires back. She's not a doormat and holds her head high as best she can, even when her inner-demons threaten to best her. There wasn't a moment where she felt two-dimensional or where she said/did something that seemed out of character. Her character was just so...beautifully multi-layered and flowed through each page of the story, developing little by little as it went along. And in the end, I was so proud of far she'd come. Ezra is most definitely someone I'd want to be friends with in real life. 😭😍

Now onto the boys, Aza and Alder. 🤤 I went back and forth on these two for a while, trying to guess who she'd "end up with." Remember, this isn't a true romance, so it was personal speculation based upon things that unfolded throughout the pages. At first, I thought Alder. Then I thought Aza. IMAGINE MY SURPRISE WHEN IT TURNS OUT TO BE BOTH. 🤯 When I tell you I initially did *not* see that coming, I did not see that coming. The first hint had my heart hammering and my stomach fluttering, like omg is this really happening right now?! Each man offers her something different. Aza gives me all the broody Draco vibes with his dark eyes, grim expressions, gruff remarks, and icy blond hair, while Alder is all Harry with his dark hair, light eyes, and friendly (but also deliciously cocky) demeanor. Watching her slowly start to fall for them was absolutely intoxicating. I couldn't get enough of them on their own, and all of them together, especially finding out certain details and secrets. 🤭

I also thoroughly enjoyed reading about Eunoia, who ends up becoming Ezra's bestie. She's such a free-spirited witch with her cheery attitude, piercings, and colorful hair. I literally adored her and was so happy she became such a vital character to the plot, especially at the end.

Now back to world-building because 💋🤌🏻 Marvelous, it's freaking marvelous. All the different descriptions of Atwood—which at times felt like modern-world Hogwarts—made me feel like I was right there. I could close my eyes and see it all perfectly, and let me tell you, once again: magical. And the descriptions of the foods? Dude, I was salivating! This book made me so hungry. Like, Salem, send me these recipes, girl, 'cause I must consume almost everything you wrote about. 😂 The rich history of the witches was detailed and so intriguing, down to how they practice magic. A lot was so similar to modern-day techniques (I won't tell you how I know that, though if you know me personally, then you already know what I'm getting at 😜🙃🔮🧿) while others were more fantasy-fueled. Either way, it was fascinating to read about. Also, can we talk about the spicy scenes? 🥵 BRUH. Did not see them coming, just like I wasn't expecting the background romance. My smutty romance reader heart was friggin' REELING in all the best ways possible. And the overall plot... BRUH AGAIN. There's so many things I didn't see coming. So many twists and turns that had my mouth gaping open. The secrets and suspense 🤌🏻 The mystery 🤌🏻 The ending 🤌🏻 SOLID 24K GOLD. JUST PURE GOLD. I can send you the millions of highlights I made if you need another layer of convincing.

If you're still here after reading all that—thanks for tuning in to my obsessed reader ramblings. 🤪 I'm utterly devastated there's not more to this world and will gladly head a petition for an expansion if enough of you jump on this train with me. ✊🏻 This book is simply a Potterhead turned smutty romance reader's dream and I just...I need more. Period. Point blank. And if you haven't read it, PLEASE GO GRAB THIS IMMEDIATELY AND THANK ME LATER. ✨

Overall: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Spice: 🌶🌶🌶
Drama: 🔥
Dark/possibly triggering content: 🖤
Profile Image for Chey.
458 reviews9 followers
February 1, 2022
Slow burn, witches, mystery, MFM… this book definitely surprised me, and i loved it for beginning. This is debut for Salem Sinclair, and even i didn't like the most first books form authors, this makes me fall in love immediately. The story turns on about Ezra and your twin when them go to live with their father after death their mother. Ezra finds herself in a middle from people that mistreat her, and envolving with mistery that’s stubborn discover. Furthermore, with two guys (Asa, love of my life kkk) and Alder, she needs to work every chaos she find herself. The author knows work with some themes so well (like depression) that makes me fell envolved with the characters and like them most. Although the end resolve itself a little quickly, this book is so amazing that i give 5 stars anyway. I just love it and definitely read more books from author.
Profile Image for Mandyloves2read.
1,864 reviews178 followers
November 2, 2021
This was such a good read perfect for the month of October I loved the spooky witchy vibes it’s dark it’s amazing I can’t believe this is this author’s debut! I loved it and I loved the twists and turns the mystery the attention to detail was amazing I just can’t recommend this story enough especially if you are looking for a dark academia romance with supernatural vibes than look no further and give this story a go ! I can’t wait to see what Salem Sinclair does next !
Profile Image for Melissa (thereaderandthechef).
536 reviews200 followers
Read
November 18, 2021
I received this book for free from Author, MTMC Tours in exchange for an honest review. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review. You can also find this review at The Reader and the Chef.

"There’s a mother-shaped hole in my heart now and I’m not sure I’ll ever be able to breathe again without feeling the ache of her."

Garden of Witches is a haunting tale about loss & the strength you need to move on. It is steeped in magic and witchcraft, full of mystery and darkness in every corner. And at its core, you can find two sisters desperately trying to survive in the unknown after your entire life falls apart the moment when you lose someone you love.

It’s a fantastic read & set in a magic school which will always be a setting hard not to love!

Oh, and this book is so full of amazing book quotes? Like every turn of the page I found myself highlighting so many passages to the point that I very much think half of the book is highlighted. Author Salem Sinclair has such a way with words and I wanted to share with you a few of the MANY passages you will find in Garden of Witches:

"It was the dream that woke me.
I sensed the vestiges dwelling in the back of my mind but was unable to remember the details. It was akin to a sepia photograph burdened by time, barely visible in my mind’s eye."

"Growing up with a person—watching them grow and age and become someone—you became as familiar with them as if they were a piece of you."

"She wore lines gracefully around her mouth, for laughter found her easily and often despite her hardships."

"Our house felt like its own brand of magic."

"I wanted to take these days and press them between the pages of a book. Keep them safe, locked away in my memories forever. These perfect, beautiful summer mornings where nothing bad could go wrong."

"Me feelings toward Noa were easy, simple, like breathing. I needed her the way I needed air to survive. She was sunny skies after a rain shower and flowers blooming in winter—impossibly pure and beautiful. Where I was the cloud, she was the silver lining."

"This is it, I thought. This is where we began. This is where Mom ended."

"Grief is a demon that controls you if you let it. No matter how hard you fight against the raging entity inside, it always finds an exit point eventually… and not always in ways you’d expect."
Profile Image for Kera’s Always Reading.
2,253 reviews95 followers
October 23, 2021
If you are looking for a dark academia romance with seriously spooky themes, this book is absolutely the one for you!

Atwood Preparatory Academy is an elite school for witchcraft and they only take students of pure magical bloodlines. When their mother dies, twin sisters Ezra and Noa go to live with their father who is the groundskeeper at Atwood, earning them attendance to the exclusive school. If the move from Washington to Kentucky wasn’t enough of a change, being part of this new school is a bit overwhelming for Ezra at first. Still fully mourning her mother, she is thrown into a group of students who shun her and bully her, while Noa seems to be thriving.

When students start to go missing, Ezra has something to sink her teeth into and is determined to find out what is going on at this ancient school. She has caught the attention of Alder, the headmaster’s son and Asa, the headmaster’s ward. And trying maneuver through her interactions with these two boys is a feat all in itself. It doesn’t take long for Ezra to being to unearth the dark and twisted past this school holds onto and the old magic that it and the surrounding woods are harboring. When the safety of people she loves is threatened, she is even more determined to stop this dark evil.

Let me tell you, the story that Salem Sinclair crafts in this book is absolutely ensnaring. I love the world of witchcraft and how it is used and studied by the students. I love the deep, rich history we get to see and the atmospheric setting. But most of all, the romance that I didn’t see coming in this book is what completely grabbed a hold of me. It was pure perfection and I loved every single minute of it and every direction it took.

Ezra was a great heroine with a strong and steadfast love for her family. There was nothing this girl wouldn’t do to protect them. She faced trauma, bullies, depression and anxiety with a brutal sense of self. Even when she was unsure of herself, she was brave. Just an incredible book and I am so thankful to have received a copy.
Profile Image for Irma *Irma The Book Whisperer*.
1,809 reviews152 followers
October 28, 2021
My first book by this author (I believe this is her debut) and I'm deeply enchanted by her storytelling!

Picture yourself when you were little, lounging by the fireplace with hot cocoa in your hands, sorunded with siblings and cousins, all while listnening to your grandmother telling a spooky story. Spooky enough for a child, but not too scary. Your eyes are trained on her and your ears are soaking up every single word she says.
Hypnotising! This is how Salem's storytelling looks like.

Garden of Witches is a dark, occult horror story. Extremely fitting for this time of the year. It is written in first person and that magnifies the reading thill.

After their mother's death Ezra and her sister, Noa, move across the country to attend Atwood Preparatory Academy, a school for bloodline witches. They hope for a fresh start but soon Ezra realises that something strange is happening when students start to go missing.

Add two striking boys, a girl who instantly becomes a best friend; she's that cool, strange happenings at nigh and a little bit of magic and spells and you've got yourself a winner!

This one was an absolute delight!
Profile Image for Annie (_anniereadsbooks).
238 reviews25 followers
September 21, 2023
this book needs to be talked about more! it’s Salem Sinclair’s debut novel and the writing on this… you would never know it’s a debut because it’s incredible! almost poetic. Salem is super talented! i wish the series was longer because it absolutely could be, the story was so good. they’re rereleasing this Oct 12 with extended scenes and an extending ending, which im very happy about because the ending needed more and I cannot wait to read the updates! i think the changes will make this a 5 star read for me. side note - the book is mfm but does have mm kissing. I do not know how the changes will affect it being mfm vs mmf.
Profile Image for Syrennn.
12 reviews
October 26, 2023
Ok first, that stunning cover is just ohmygod.

What I liked
The world building was amazing, the magic was detailed and descriptive, the rhyming spells was kinda cool, the mindblown ending and THEN the chemistry and sexual tension and smut between Ezra and Asa *internally screaming* (sorry Alder, if it’s you I just can’t

What I disliked
Alder. No offence, he’s ok, but like, he’s just OK.
I’d prefer Ezra to be with Asa only, yet when I’m around idk 90% of the book Alder joins as he and Asa was a thing too. Idk. Not that I’m against MFM with MM in (ok I usually don’t like it but I’m not against it), but Alder just ain’t it. He was potentially giving something at first but when Asa came into picture, I don’t find any chemistry between Ezra and Alder anymore.

Then there’s the last 8%. It was rushed. Very RUSHED. Like, everything just ended like that, too goddamn fast and easy it’s anticlimatic. The world building and plot was promising until it was rushed (like it just wants to end ASAP).

Overall, I enjoyed it so 4 stars, actually I’d make it 3.75 but since it’s near Halloween and I’m feeling the vibe, imma make it 4.
Profile Image for D.
178 reviews15 followers
November 5, 2021
Bought this book based off the teasers and blurb alone! I was NOT disappointed this is an incredible read! The books draws you and you can't put it down! Perfect for the fall season, an eerie read! Who does not love witches, an academy full of them, who have an elitist idea of bloodlines, toss in some bully and then two handsome guys and you have a mix for a can't put down read!
Profile Image for Libby Fowler .
668 reviews3 followers
January 24, 2022
3.5 stars

3.5 stars, it was an okay read. The storyline had so much potential but the author just didn't exceed it. It all seemed rushed, their were no real connections, their was no real romance and unfortunately it was just disappointing. The epilogue was rather short also.
I did however like the shock ending.
Profile Image for chelsea reads.
648 reviews223 followers
October 31, 2021
i’ve tried so many times to write out this review, and every time i’ve deleted everything to start again. i can’t seem to get my thoughts in order and write a clear, concise review. to put it mildly, i lOVED THIS BOOK.

i know for a witchy story, there’s bound to be familiars. witches familiars are easily one of my favourite things about them. i just love animals. and this book didn’t fall short. there were so many emotions for these characters, and they didn’t even have speaking parts.

the characters themselves were fun. ez was a great main character. she held the story well, although she had her “typical mc” moments (some things i disagreed with). asa and alder were extremely loveable. there’s hints towards a love triangle, but garden of witches handled it really well. (where i’d normally roll my eyes and stop reading, i actually loved it).

there were plenty of plot twists, which i found exciting and unexpected.

overall, garden of witches was a fun read and i can’t wait to see what’s going to happen next.

please note: there are a few steamy scenes in this book, and a mmf sex scene.
Profile Image for Macabre Rose.
56 reviews5 followers
November 3, 2021
Garden of Witches is the debut novel by Salem Sinclair, and it brings witches, a wolf shifter, and all the eerie vibes you need to supplement your spooky season. The prose this author brings is so rich, you can see, smell, and taste her world so easily. This book shows a promising start for Salem's publishing journey.

The storyline focuses on Ezra, a young, protective witch. Ezra has spent her life looking after her twin sister, Noa, and helping her mom keep their house running after her parent's separation. After her mother's tragic passing, Ezra and Noa move across the United States to live with their father and finish out their schooling at Atwood Academy, a prep school focused on honing the most prestigious witches in the US. Only the pure-bred, best of the best bloodlines are admitted at Atwood. While Noa seems to be thriving in her studies with Necromancy, Ezra finds herself subjected to some bullying for their family's murky past and struggling to find her niche.

Asa and Alder are two parts of Ezra's story that she spends the most time trying to puzzle out. Asa is mysterious and standoffish, for the most part, but shows the occasional inclination to protect Ezra. Alder is the headmaster's son and pseudo brother to Asa. While he starts off very friendly and accommodating to Ezra, he's got some secrets of his own he's keeping close to his chest. When young students begin to disappear as the autumn equinox approaches, Ezra becomes more determined than ever to solve the mystery of the disappearances and figure out what makes Atwood so dang creepy.

While the above-mentioned beautiful prose of this book is an absolute joy to read, there were several elements that were very rushed or underdeveloped. Ezra's personal mental struggles were one key point I feel wasn't really resolved. The ending had an amazing twist that I honestly didn't see coming, but again, was very rushed. I don't feel like I got enough time with the villain, and I would have loved to see more of how Ezra was able to move forward from how the end played out. I would have liked more background on Asa and Alder's origins as well, but I do understand the bigger focus of the storyline was on Ezra and the overall mystery as opposed to the romance development her, Asa, and Alder had going on. As Salem grows in experience, I see amazing potential in subsequent books.

I received a free copy of this book and am leaving an honest review voluntarily.

Character development: 3/5
Dark elements: 4/5
Steamy scenes: 4/5
Overall storyline: 3.75/5
Triggers: Yes, indeed - murder, bullying, self-harm
493 reviews9 followers
November 7, 2021
Salem has created something dark, emotive and captivating. The detailed and intricate world building morphs the worlds into something physical you can feel the wind on your face and feel the hairs on your arms stand on end. This isn't just a delicious dark romance it is an exploration of the stages of grief, acceptance and recovery.

Ezra is haunted by nightmares of darkness that plague her mind, body and soul. She has such a pure heart full of love that when a feeling of foreboding settles in her she knows everything will change. One night shatters her heart and soul leaving her destitute in her grief, filled with anger she resents the world she is trust into at the prestigious Atwood Prep Academy.

Ezra has to battle her spiraling control on her grief and anger with every step. It's impossible for her to understand the events that happened the night that crushed her world, when she is tormented by the hatred of the witching elite, ridiculed every day and heart breaking events are replayed for everyone to see.

Alder and Asa call to Ezra on a deeper level, they have a connection with her that she can't comprehend but in order to absolve herself of her anger and ultimately her guilt she must open herself up like never before. Alder and Asa are trouble themselves, they understand her pain like no one else and are kindred spirits there there guide her.

Together they take on the darkness that is ingrained in atom of Atwood, its grounds and the surrounding forest. They uncover hidden truths and betrayals you'll never see coming, they take on forces far greater than them but ultimately their bond is strengthened by every deadly step.

This book is beautifully dark, immersive and emotive. The agony experienced through Ezras grief makes something so fantastical utterly relatable and each character calls to you on an emotional level because they become real.
Profile Image for Lauren.
717 reviews
June 4, 2022
interesting story

It seems from the author’s note, this is the first book she has written and published. I am always nervous to read an author’s “first” book because I’ve read some really bad ones that definitely needed a lot of editing and a lot of work. This one read like a well seasoned author. Minimal errors, interesting story, excellent character developments, and plenty of drama and mystery.

This book may be hard for some readers because the female lead is struggling with her mental health. It’s a big part of the book so there are a lot of moments of self loathing, hopelessness, panic attacks, and ptsd. There is also some bullying. I think the author did an excellent job showing how Ezra lived with her difficulties and how she managed them. And even at times when her “monsters” won and took over.

I did find it a little less convincing of the redemption aspect of Asa and Alder. They said some pretty mean and hurtful things in the beginning but I didn’t feel as if they redeemed themselves enough for me. I think the explanation of their behavior at the end was more of an epiphany of Ezra rather then both Alder and Ada explaining and apologizing for what they had done. It wasn’t a deal breaker but I do wish that would have been done definitely to make it a little more “swoon worthy” to me.

I would encourage anyone who enjoys a well crafted story about witches, academies, MMF romance with a mild to moderate amount of steam, macabre plot, with a heavy focus of mental health. If suicide, bullying, depression, murder, and betrayal isn’t a no fly zone for you, then I highly recommend this book.
Profile Image for Lizs.book.nook ||Elizabeth||.
1,435 reviews48 followers
November 3, 2021
Absolutely phenomenal! I never wanted this book to end! I fell hard and fast for these characters, their stories, and their struggles. Garden of Witches (GoW) is one of the best books I have ever read! You would never know this was Salem Sinclair’s debut novel, it was so beautifully written.

This book brought out so many emotions in me. Salem wrote about mental health so eloquently, so raw, real and authentic. To capture the struggles and make you feel connected on such a deep level whether you have experienced it yourself of not, was truly outstanding. Ezra was such a genuine character. I loved watching her journey through life’s ups and downs, seeing her break down her walls, and finding true love and friendship.

These characters and this storyline had me completely enthralled from beginning to end. Ezra, Alder and Asa have my heart and soul on a platter y’all and I never want them back! These characters are so special and truly one of a kind. There was just something so deep and authentic about them that drew me in wanting to know anything and everything about them past, present and future. This storyline was so unique and original! I was captivated at every twist and turn. Wanting desperately to know what would happen next but also sad to see the pages coming closer to an end.

This book was truly outstanding! From beginning to end it was a journey in the truest sense. Everything about this story pulled you in and made you never want to let go, allowing you to be a part of this journey with the characters.
Profile Image for Erin.
3,581 reviews85 followers
November 1, 2021
Outstanding Debut Story!

WOW! I can’t believe that this is Salem’s debut novel. It’s absolutely outstanding! I was enchanted and drawn into this story right from the very first page and I could not put it down. It’s dark, thrilling, spooky and utterly twisted. The imagery that is woven into this story transports us readers to another world filled with witches, magic, darkness and evil. A definite page turner!

Ezra pulled me into her whirlwind story that kept twisting and twisting with every chapter. She is strong, fierce and will do anything to protect those she loves. She forges some amazing friendships and even some toxic ones.

Asa and Alder are mysterious, intriguing and secretive characters that you just wanted to learn more about. The interesting relationship they forge with Ezra takes us on one hell of an emotional rollercoaster ride. I love the three of them together and hoped that they could work out their differences.

Brilliantly written story that captivates us readers and keeps us guessing at every turn. The characters are complex and damaged and will have you falling in love with most of them. And the storyline is filled with mystery, unbelievable imagery and dark occult worldbuilding. The story will shock you at every turn and have you begging for more from this amazing world.

I loved every second of this story and can’t wait to see where this new author takes us next!
Profile Image for Siobhan (Bookish Vibes).
947 reviews37 followers
October 30, 2021
Garden of Witches is such a beautifully written story. Of heartache and healing, learning to love your whole self and letting other's in. It was the perfect October read with all of it's witchy magic, spooky vibes and sinister characters.

After the death of their mother, Ezra and her twin sister Noa are sent across country to Atwood Preparatory Academy for witches. It becomes clear that something is not quite right at the prestigious school when students start to go missing. Ezra takes it upon herself to investigate and soon uncovers something frightful truths.

I loved the way Ezra's character developed and the slow burn way her relationship built with both Asa and Alder. Asa with his broody, mysterious ways and Alder with his cocky, flirty persona both had me intrigued, especially as they are hiding secrets of their own.

My only fault was that it seemed to end quite abruptly and felt a bit rushed towards the end. Apart from that, it would have been a 5 star read for sure. This was a story full of mystery, secrets and a touch of romance and I was well and truly invested for the whole story. I am looking forward to reading more from this author.
Profile Image for Marcie.
1,123 reviews61 followers
February 22, 2022
I am in utter awe over this story. Salem has woven a tale that will stick with me and I am left with huge book hangover.
Ezra is one of the most relatable heroines I have ever read. The hardships of grief, bullying, and mental health that she battled hit home with me so hard. I found myself rooting for her as she refused to give up and kept the good fight going. Her persistence, curiosity, strength and sass is what made me love her.
Alder and Asa are two young men forced to grow up too quickly at the of someone else’s evil ways. I loved seeing how they balance each other and how they grounded Ezra. I adore their courage and willingness to protect Ezra.
This wasn’t a quick/fast paced romance - this was a journey of a young woman who is learning how to heal and that she doesn’t have to fight alone. The suspense, gritty rawness, twists and phenomenal character growth kept me glued to my kindle and on the edge of my seat. Salem built this story flawlessly, with characters that have etched their places onto my heart and I will definitely plan on adding this to my personal library of books I love.
373 reviews1 follower
November 3, 2021
I reeeeeally enjoyed this book!
When I first began reading it, I personally thought it had started off a bit slow. But after finishing, the more I think about it, the more I believe it was necessary to have that slow build up for the story. The way this story unfolded was perfection!
After a terrible tragedy, Ezra and her twin sister Noa have to move from their home and transfer to a new prestigious boarding school for witches, where only witches with a pure, ancient bloodline are allowed to attend. Shortly after arriving, a child goes missing and Ezra is determined to find answers regarding the mysterious disappearance. But the more she investigates, the more questions she ends up with. She eventually has to decide if it’s worth the risk digging for information she might not want the answers to.
This story is a little dark and chock-full of magic and mystery! And while this is a standalone novel and wraps up pretty nicely overall, that ending will blow your mind and leave you thinking about it long after you’ve finished! 🤯
Profile Image for Breen.
1,595 reviews
November 1, 2021
“If you love all the witchy and gothic vibe this book is definitely for you. For a high school story it was definitely captivating. I’m more a romantic kind of girl meaning that I prefer all the love, romance and happily ever after rather than the action but there are some stories that the storyline is just amazing. Ezra and Noa move across the country for a fresh start and this is where our story beginning. There’s lot mystery, suspense and twits that had me glued to the pages. The thing with dark romances is that you love or hate them. It’s weird but that’s how it works at least to me. I’m not so into the bully trope because the girls tend to be her the top pathetic with lack of bold attitude but there are some that are the exception and ended up being good stories. Leaving the bully behind the story was really interesting for a debut novel. Not only what I said but the chemistry was off the charts and so burning hot. It was indeed an incredible story.”
Profile Image for Lauren.
151 reviews5 followers
November 2, 2021
Garden of Witches is a book I’ve been waiting impatiently for ever since I heard about it, and it definitely did not disappoint! This book made me feel a whole range of emotions that I was not ready for and kept me hooked from start to finish. The themes of loss, adversity, friendship, and healing are all very prominent in this book and Garden of Witches hold a very special place in my heart. Dark academia and enemies to lovers romances are and always will be a vibe. Don’t worry spice lovers, this book also has plenty to keep you entertained, between the tension and the build up, to the teasing and the climax (ha, get it?). I highly recommend this book for lovers of (cinnamon) spice, dark academia, unsolved mysteries, enemies to lovers, and for those who want a book you won’t be able to put down.
Profile Image for Teresa Juckett (Love Dark Reads) .
2,567 reviews38 followers
November 2, 2021
What more could your ask for in the month of October than a fantastic read of witches, gothic vibes and vanishing's and romance that's sprinkled around in the mix. For this to be a debut for this arthur I'd say she did a awesome job, because this book kept me turning pages I couldn't get enough.
Twin sisters Ezra and Noa go to live with their father in Kentucky after the loss of their mother he's the groundskeeper at Atwood Preparatory Academy it's an elite school for witchcraft and they only take students of pure magical bloodlines..
Ezra is being picked on while Noa is thriving when Ezra catches the attention of Alder who's the headmaster’s son and Asa, the headmaster’s ward. That's all I'm saying you'll need to read it & find out what happens inside the pages. I'd definitely recommend reading.
Profile Image for Christine Hutton.
179 reviews32 followers
December 20, 2021
Garden of Witches Salem Sinclair
5/5
Garden of Witches is a wonder to read. This book is literally magical and I stayed up until 1 am to finish reading it. I LOVE THIS BOOK.

Sinclair’s writing is beautiful and so descriptive. The way she weaves imagery into the story is almost hypnotic. I honestly felt like I fell into the book at times and was walking around with the MC.

Ezra is the main character of the story. She is a young witch just learning about her powers. After a drastic event occurs there she and her sister Noa are forced to move with their father and go to an exclusive school for witches. Ezra is not a very talented witch but she does her best to study and stay out of everyone’s way. There is some classic dark academia bullying with a magic spin and then enter Asa and Alder.

Asa and Alder have a unique relationship with Ezra, there are for sure enemies to lovers vibes ( my FAVORITE trope). I am so happy Sinclair included a couple of LGBTQ scenes as well. These three form a tense relationship with a lot of back and forth. Meanwhile, there are creepy and mysterious events happening at the school.

Another aspect I enjoyed was the ending. The ending took me completely by surprise and I freakin loved it. Sinclair thinks outside of the box and is not afraid to cross boundaries.

Overall, if you are in the mood for a spooky, fun, sexy, and witchy read this book is for you. Garden of Witches is Salem Sinclair’s debut book and I could not be more impressed. I will now be reading EVERYTHING she writes and fangirling out!
Profile Image for Charlene.
258 reviews1 follower
December 28, 2023
where do I even begin with this... the premise sounded so good so i decided to pick it up but i think i had too high expectations going into this. The start was promising! i was interested and getting into the story but alas...

1) the plot really was good, i just felt that more could have been done in regards to the plot rather than the romance, honestly IMO i felt that the romance could have been toned down and this book would have still been good
2) i didn't get the appeal of both the male leads - not for me
3) certain sentences made me go ??

I did like the ending a lot though! the epilogue and plot twist was great, came out of nowhere and shocked me, but again the story just ended abruptly after - epilogue was like 1-2 pages before it ended?

however again, i can see the appeal of this book and why people here did like it, i think personally it just was not something i enjoyed.
Profile Image for Emma.
346 reviews
October 29, 2021
What better book to read at Halloween than a book about witches at a magical school.

And even better yet a book that give off Harry Potter feels but for adults?!

I really enjoyed this book and I liked Ezra and the huffing friendship she developed with Adler and Asa.

I liked that the book doesn’t focus entirely on the romance aspect and instead the main plot is the mystery surrounding Atwood.

My only little gripe is that the story took a long time to build up which was very atmospheric and in my eyes the story ended rather quickly and almost abruptly. I also wanted a longer epilogue.

I still really enjoyed it and would recommend it.

I received an arc of this book in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for Chey.
1,499 reviews50 followers
October 30, 2021
After the loss of their mother, Ezra and her twin Nora are sent to live with their father in Kentucky. As the groundskeeper to an exclusive school for only pure bloodline witches, the two are enrolled. Nora thrives while Ezra is bullied. But when bad things start happening, Ezra plans to figure out how to make it stop.

Ezra was a strong character from the start. She's the oldest twin so takes on more responsibility to protect Nora. She gets bullied, but still comes out strong, and she gets the attention of two men. The writing was great, and detailed enough that you could picture everything without being overwhelmed.
Profile Image for Amanda Anderson (Beauty.and.the.bookies).
1,538 reviews63 followers
November 2, 2021
I really loved this book. Right from the beginning, seeing how this author wrote already with it only being her first book I can see that the journey and growth this author will have will be EXTREMELY HIGH with the next book she writes and many more after. The detailed scenes, like wow I could practically smell them. I loved the strength Ezra hsd during this entire book with ALL the trials and tribulations she went through. And those boys. Asa and Alder. Shewww. They were mouthwatering, mysterious and perfectttt for her. The SHOCK at the end of this book was A-MAY-ZING. It caught me off guard and I was surprised with that twist. I cannot wait to see what Salem Sinclair writes next!!!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 53 reviews