A solid and respectable 3.5/5
This is a pretty gritty YA angsty teenage love story with ghosts. It does not shy away from the topic of self harm, so be warned. I actually found its willingness to "go there" kind of refreshing.
Amy and Flynn are high school besties who are realising they want something more. But at the same time, Amy discovers the ghost of a Victorian blood-letter and his sister, who she can only visit by making herself bleed. She finds herself inexplicably drawn to these ghosts, even though it might cost her everything...
This is definitely a teen love story with a side of ghosts, rather than vice versa. I have to admit, I'd have loved the balance to have tipped a little more in the other direction. The concept of only being able to set the ghosts by making yourself bleed was really unique and the old timey practice of blood-letting is so intriguing with so much potential. Unfortunately we only saw the ghosts 3-4 times and Amy barely exchanges a few sentences with Marcel, so her obsession is hard to understand. He literally never asks her a thing about herself so how would seeing them make her feel "seen"?
On that note, Amy has a solid friend group, a good relationship with her mother and her mother's boyfriend, two hot dudes in love with her, and she kicks ass at parkour, so she doesn't strike me as someone who feels "invisible" or "not seen". "We moved a few times" as a sad backstory really didn't work for me with her characterisation as a confident, popular girl. I think we needed a lot more work on that aspect to be believable. It felt to me like the author had one intention for the story, and then this character walked on the page completely different so the author tried to make her original idea fit on her, but it just doesn't. Amy is a lot more "seen" in her blessed life already than she ever is with the ghosts.
The book spends a lot more time on the human relationships than the ghost story, which is a bit of a shame honestly, but on the other hand, I did quite enjoy that part of the story. The characters were quite well drawn and engaging. I think I was just expecting more of the ghost aspect.
I honestly felt more chemistry between Flynn and Sandy than been him and Amy, and kind of secretly shipped them lol.
Despite my picky quibbles, I did actually find this story quite enjoyable to read. It kicks off straight into action, the writing flows well and the dialogue felt like quite authentic late teen chatter. It has some unique ideas and doesn't tiptoe around hefty topics (or swear words for that matter!). I think if you're as interested in the young love as the ghosts, you'll have a good time with this one.