Not bad, but still missing a little something. I read this book because the premise intrigued me, as the author mentioned VIPsOnly was inspired by OnlyFans. All I know about OnlyFans comes from an article I read where content creators told their stories of how they came to use the site and got into sex work, some of whom are students who need a way to pay for their education. It’s an interesting subject, and I appreciated discussions of sex work/the porn industry in another romance novel I’ve read (The Roommate Experiment by Rosie Danan), so I was curious about this book.
Up front, we do get an author’s note that mentions this wouldn’t be a deep dive into the topic, so that set some expectations, which I appreciated. In that sense, I wasn’t disappointed, as we did get a positive view of VIPsOnly in the opportunities it provided for Callie and Emma to make money. I liked Emma’s friendships with both Callie and Ty, although I feel like they could have been developed and fleshed out more on page, since we’re told that they were old friends and Emma used to be good friends with both of them growing up; however, we don’t really get to see that beyond the glimpse of the old home movies Ty and Emma watched together. I wanted to really believe that they were once close and knew a lot about each other back in the day, or at the very least got to know each other well in the present.
For instance, the book tells me that Emma feels comfortable around Ty, more comfortable than she feels around anyone else. But why is that? Is it his approachability? Their old friendship? How he doesn’t judge her? I feel like it was missing something; we get a peek at why Emma didn’t hear from Ty for years after he ghosted her because of his old girlfriend. But what happened there? That felt like a set-up for a conflict that never happened. At the very least, I expected Emma and Ty to talk about it, because it felt like some of the uncertainty she felt about getting in a relationship with Ty came from there, but it was mentioned once or twice and then never brought up again. The conflict we did get, about Ty not having told Emma that he was moving at the end of the summer for that job, also felt kind of sudden. I believe early in the book Ty mentions that Emma needs to stick around because he’d like to stick around in their hometown even when the summer ended. Sure, maybe it was said offhandedly, but it felt inconsistent. Like way before they were confessing to each other, Ty was talking about staying because there wasn’t anything in New York for him, and then after they have sex and say they like each other he’s just bringing up that job offer? When he didn’t even enjoy the photography job at the Hamilton? Perhaps the book would’ve benefitted from having Ty’s POV as well.
Another thing the second POV might have helped with was building the sexual tension, since we don’t really get to see what Ty felt about being Emma’s photographer and how he felt editing her photos and flirting with her via text. It’s a trade off when you have one vs two POVs. I did like getting to see Emma’s growth, learning to be more comfortable in her own skin, finding out that identity isn’t so clear cut and most definitely doesn’t have to be the same as one’s occupation, and that people and circumstances change. Her confusion over how to adult felt relatable and sincere. I appreciated the bits we did get to see on that front, although it did feel a little mood swing-y in terms of how Emma came to do some introspection. Not unrealistic, but it didn’t quite flow as well as it could, I guess?
Callie and Ty weren’t as multi-dimensional of characters as I’d have expected them to be as well. After reading the book, I can’t say much about either of them, except that Callie likes clothes and her independence, and Ty likes… films? Photography? Running? And why does he like Emma? That’s not something I feel like I know by the end, either. The dialogue is sometimes a bit awkward/clunky, but for the most part I didn’t mind, otherwise I likely wouldn’t have finished.
Overall, it’s not bad, but it lacks the depth in character development/growth/romance development and even friendship development that I think would make it great. It could also use a few more rounds of editing for some grammar mistakes and extra words that didn’t get deleted/corrected. I did appreciate the clever title, though! I love some good wordplay. It did make me wonder if other people Emma knew would find out about her VIPsOnly account, too, but I’m not upset that that didn’t happen.