AN EXCELLENT OVERVIEW OF MUCH CURRENT RESEARCH AND ISSUES
Ingrid Newkirk (born 1949) is an English-born animal rights activist and the president of People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA), as well as the author of Free the Animals: The Story of the Animal Liberation Front; You Can Save the Animals: 251 Simple Ways to Stop Thoughtless Cruelty, etc.
She and coauthor Gene Stone wrote in the Introduction to this 2020 book, “people’s eyes are now opened to WHO animals are---and we like what we see. We have come to feel love, understanding, and respect for all animals and our delight in caring for them has entered a new era. The first part of this book is a celebration of that relationship, an exploration of who animals are… The second part of the book takes us to the next logical step---given our newfound understanding of all that is animal, how can we treat them in ways that respect their individuality and talents?... how can we conduct our lives happily and efficiently without having to exploit animals?... Be ready to learn as you find out all the many ways that you can help all animals live the fulfilling and happy lives they deserve---or at least, to be left unmolested.” (Pg. 3-4)
Later, they add, “In the following chapters we will explore … the amazing ways animals navigate the world… Next we will explore the world of animal communication… We next dive into life’s most powerful and mysterious emotion: love… Finally, we’ll examine perhaps the most universal activity on the planet: play… By learning about how animals move, chat, love, and romp, we learn more about who animals ARE… and how we humans can benefit from our greater understanding of what make animals tick.” (Pg. 14)
They explain, “We often consider intelligence as the only factor in determining which animals deserve compassion and which don’t. Yet we’re still so limited in our understanding of human intelligence that it makes little sense to calibrate our animal brethren based on how similar their brains are to ours… The goal in this book is not to merely question that superiority, or to show how animals think and act like us; it’s also to show how they do not, and to honor those differences… As we’ll see in this book, animals think, navigate, communicate, love, and play in extraordinarily unique ways.” (Pg. 8)
They state, “Fish … are aware of themselves as individuals. One way to test whether an animal possesses self-recognition is to place her in front of a mirror with a small section of her body painted. If she … then touches or investigates the mark, she likely recognizes herself in the mirror and is therefore self-aware… Japanese researchers placed a mirror in front of cleaner wrasses. At first they acted skittish and territorial---meaning they regarded their reflections as foreign fish… by the end of the study they could clearly recognize their own movements. The fish even used their reflection in the mirror to help remove tags affixed by the researchers to their bodies.” (Pg. 27-28)
They note, “dogs alter their tone to produce a striking variety of sounds---each with their own meaning. Dogs modify the pitch, timing, and amplitude of their barks, which is believed to be a method for communicating intentions to their canine cohorts. For example, it has been determined that dogs produce a ‘food growl’ when tussling over food, and a distinctly different ‘stranger growl’ upon spotting an unknown human.” (Pg. 40)
They say, “bird songs … serve a practical purpose. Birds employ their voices to call their mates, find their flock, claim territory, scare off intruders, warn others about predators, and for countless other functions.” (Pg. 55) Later, they add, “Initially the scientists expected the animal calls to be simplistic and random. It turns out that they more closely resembled human speech patterns… What may seem like noise to us may be an intricately language what we simply haven’t learned to decipher.” (Pg. 59)
They acknowledge, “While science explains why young lions and bear cubs play-fight, it’s less clear why dogs enjoy romps at the beach, ball games, and other seemingly useless activities. And unlike other animals, who tend to stop playing after reaching adulthood, even the most wizened old dog is up for a game of fetch.” (Pg. 97)
They also admit, “This has led to what some people have found a sadistic form of feline amusement: ‘playing’ with their not-yet-dead prey. Cats are … practicing a skill they acquired very early in their evolution… cats seem to play with their food to tire them out---say, by allowing a mouse to hobble away before clawing him back. When her prey is sufficiently dazed, a cat will deliver the death blow… Instead of experiencing amusement in the human sense, cats are simply following their predator instincts, however gruesome they may seem.” (Pg. 99-100)
They point out, “Coming soon is ‘clean meat’: actual flesh from animal cells in a laboratory under conditions that eliminate … dangerous bacteria, conserve water, and eliminate slaughterhouses once and for all. Ever more ‘taste-alikes’… are rolling off the production line… We are entering a new age of animal-free living.” (Pg. 117)
Against vivisection, they argue, “many of the loudest objections … are coming from within scientific community itself. Here are just a few reasons why: *Our fellow beings can never be reliable stand-ions for human research subjects… other species’ anatomy, physiology, and biochemistry are just not similar enough to ours… *More than 90 percent of scientific discoveries from animal experiments fail to lead to human treatments… *Animal research is extremely wasteful. Repeated experiments crippling dogs to mimic human muscular dystrophy have brought us no closer to a cure… *Drug testing on animals can end up harming people as well. The painkiller Viaxx had to be pulled from the market even after extensive animal tests because it increased the risk of heart attack and stroke in humans… Human clinical trials have led to the most important health advances.” (Pg. 129-130)
They suggest, “the vast majority of insects raised by the silk industry don’t live past the pupal stage; they are… gassed alive inside their cocoons when they are still adolescents. Because it takes … fifty thousand silkworms to make a single Indian sari, the number of insects killed each year by the silk industry is truly staggering. Silkworms might not be as easy to love as a cuddly sheep, but perhaps all living organisms deserve better treatment.” (Pg. 167)
They point out, “Nearly every moviegoer has seen the phrase ‘No Animals Were harmed in the Making of This Film’ in the ending credits. However… the truth is not quite what it seems. The group that provides this endorsement is American Humane (AH), a Los Angeles-based association… Unfortunately, AH does not have the authority to enforce its own standards: It is only able to grant any of six ratings… Moreover, AH is funded by the Screen Actors Guild, meaning it is paid by the very industry it monitors. AH bases its rating only on when animals are on set, but not when they are being trained or boarded… AH does not take into account a trainer’s animal-related offenses or violations of the federal Anima Welfare Act… Furthermore… AH doesn’t take into consideration living conditions or the disposal of animals after they are no longer of use to the exhibitor.” (Pg. 192-193)
They note, “To suggest an air of compassion, the chicken industry often employs labels such as ‘free-roaming,’ ‘free-range,’ or ‘pasture-raised’ and puts misleading pictures of the farm on the cartons that bear no resemblance to reality… Likewise, terminology such as ‘pasture-raised’ implies that the animal has ‘continuous free access to the outdoors for a minimum of 120 days a year.’ This raises the question: What happens the other 245 days of the year?” (Pg. 215-216)
This book will be of great interest to those studying animal intelligence, vegetarianism/veganism, and related topics.