"Home Sweet Mess" is Allison Ashley's follow up to "Perfect Distraction," but I did not know that until I read the Afterward of the book. You do not have to read one to enjoy the other. This one tells the story of Jeni and Logan, and the backstory of Lauren and Andrew, though both books were about the same time period. Just do not let it stop you reading either one whenever you choose. They each work totally independently. Jeni and Andrews are twins. She has recently moved to Kansas City from rural Nebraska, where they grew up. Andrew had already lived in the city for far longer, and has a best friend, Andrew, though Jeni had not met him through Andrew. Instead, she all sort of shenanigans gooing on next door, early one morning, at the home of her neighbor, Cassidy, who was known for having multiple "suitors," and being quite loud in the process. The morning after all that so called noise, Jeni was outside with her morning coffee, and saw a good looking guy leaving the house next door, looking quite pleased with himself. She thought he was arrogant and the last man she would want to know any further than the minor "Good Morning" they exchanged as he left and got into his car.
When Jeni next sees Logan, they are in line at a sandwich shop, where he takes the meal that she was to buy, leaving her with no options as it was the only one without meat and she is a vegetarian. She is miffed, and this was insult added to injury as he had also stolen her parking space a few minutes earlier. Let the good times roll!
Jeni and Andrew meet again when Andrew invites each over to watch football, which became another bone of contention as Logan and Jeni each loathed the other's favorite team. When Andrew is diagnosed with cancer, Jeni is there for him, as she has been since they were born, as is Logan, as the best friend. The find comfort in one another during the long hours at the hospital waiting for test results. They seem to be together continually, but Jeni wants no part in a relationship. She was divorced at 25, and does not trust any man with her heart or her future. I found that a bit ridiculous. By 25, most women have not been married at all, and there would have been many breakups. A 25 year old is way too young to think all men will leave her, but this is fiction, so I had to go with the flow and just embrace the story and the romance that was clearly pre-determined. Jeni wants a friends with benefits situation, but Logan wants the whole package, and they find themselves at a standoff, while still spending a lot of time together.
There had to be a bigger reason that Jeni did not want a commitment, and I began to suspect what it was, and I was right, but it is not revealed for a long time. I ached for her, but also wanted to smack her and tell her it was not the end of the world and she could still have everything in life she wanted. Logan was a patient man, a good man, not really the type of man to want a life filled with women like Cassidy, but he felt unworthy until he got to know Jeni. The author reveals his back story and the heartache of his childhood. She knows how to pull at someone's heartstrings, which is why I keep reading her books. I cried happy tears towards the end, which is the best kind of crying!
The issue I had with the book, reducing it from a 5 star to read to a 4 star, was the fault of the editors. At one point, there was a glaring error where a necessary word was left out of a sentence, making it incomplete. There were punctuation and grammar errors, as well. We all make those, but we are not all paid authors with paid editors to make sure their works are not filled with those kinds of mistakes. Still, I loved the book, and am giving it 4 stars.