Following an absence of new Goosebumps books that lasted nearly a decade, R.L. Stine commenced publishing the Horrorland, Hall of Horrors, and Most Wanted spinoffs of the Goosebumps franchise, and there were noticeable differences between the original 1990s series and the revival that began in 2008 with Revenge of the Living Dummy. The cover art was much more intense, featuring creepier imagery than the '90s books. The action in the stories was more graphic and traumatizing for the characters, pushing the envelope beyond what the original Goosebumps series ever did. Perhaps R.L. Stine believed the average young reader of the twenty-first century to be ready for more intensive horror than kids of a decade before, and this heightened level of scariness is as evident in the Hall of Horrors series as other Horrorland offshoots. On this go-around, we're led to a dark, dismal corner of the Horrorland theme park known as the Hall of Horrors, to which kids who have survived terrifying supernatural ordeals find themselves inexplicably drawn. The Listener resides here, and offers kids a place to relate their horrifying stories where they won't be scoffed at. Enter Mickey Coe, an ordinary twelve-year-old boy with quite the harrowing yarn to unravel for his host. What happened to Mickey has shaken him badly, but he's ready to talk.
Mickey and his friend Amanda are pleased when their neighbors, Mr. and Mrs. Caplan, hire them to care for their black cat Bella while they're away on vacation. The short-term dream job turns into a nightmare when an instant of carelessness leads to the little cat being killed in the road under the wheels of a truck, leaving Mickey and Amanda in desperate straits over what to do next. Quailing at the prospect of taking responsibility for their lethal mistake, Amanda convinces Mickey to search for another black cat at a store called Cat Heaven. If they can find one that looks enough like Bella, maybe they can make the switch without Mr. and Mrs. Caplan ever being aware. Luck would seem to be on our protagonists' side when they spy a cat in the back room at Cat Heaven that's identical to Bella, but the salesman refuses to ring up the transaction. This is an employee-only storage area and these cats aren't on the market, he insists.
One crazy heist later, Mickey and Amanda have "Bella II" home, and are trying to teach the new cat how to behave enough like its predecessor to fool the Caplans. But the sweet, cuddly black cat isn't as docile as it seemed in Cat Heaven. Bella II snarls and snaps her teeth, her eyes glow unnaturally yellow, and she bites and scratches Mickey or Amanda when they come near her. Mickey's nerves are already frayed by the trauma of Bella's death and the deception he and Amanda are perpetrating on the Caplans, and Bella II's lack of cooperation only adds to the stress. Now he's hearing the incessant whining and yowling of cats everywhere, even hallucinating that he's seeing dozens of the animals and finding their disgusting "gifts" for him at school. Mickey is on the verge of mental collapse, but there has to be some way to rid his life of cats and set everything back to normal. Will Mickey survive this hellish world of monster felines long enough to figure out what is happening and put a stop to it?
Some twists in Claws! are easy to spot, but others are less obvious, and the story's end provides a surprisingly poignant moment that draws the threads of the narrative together nicely. R.L. Stine's writing is exciting, humorous, and clever, and he manages to slip a little time capsule in via the names of Mickey's three goldfish, Nick, Joe, and Kevin (named, I presume, after the teen idol Jonas Brothers). This start to the Hall of Horrors sub-series holds plenty of promise, and a writer of R.L. Stine's creativity and talent is a good bet to bring that potential to realization. I think I would consider giving Claws! two and a half stars, and there's no doubt I'll be reading the rest of the series. Goosebumps fans, rejoice; the master of juvenile horror is back in business.