La Retòrica a Herenni és el tractat de retòrica llatí més antic i el que ha tingut més influència al llarg del temps. Escrit al segle I aC, no se’n coneix l’autoria, per bé que durant molt de temps va ser atribuït falsament a Ciceró o a Cornifici. Dividida en quatre llibres, la Retòrica a Herenni es continua fent servir avui dia com a manual per aprendre a compondre i pronunciar bé un discurs, i per conèixer millor els usos de la retòrica i de la persuasió.
Born 3 January 106 BC, Arpinum, Italy Died 7 December 43 BC (aged 63), Formia, Italy
Marcus Tullius Cicero was a Roman philosopher, statesman, lawyer, political theorist, and Roman constitutionalist. Cicero is widely considered one of Rome's greatest orators and prose stylists.
Note: All editions should have Marcus Tullius Cicero as primary author. Editions with another name on the cover should have that name added as secondary author.
I came to this book after reading Moonwalking with Einstein and taking an interest in the Art of Memory. I also read this after having read about half of Frances Yates "The Art of Memory" The version I read was a free version distributed by the University of Toronto http://archive.org/details/adcherenni...
For those looking to practice the Art of Memory, I think the Yates summary is superior in the sense that Yates's book gives more versions for how the Art evolved over time and thus gives options to work with.
Overall though, this is a great work on the art of Rhetoric itself as well as Memory and for anyone interested in public speaking and persuasion. It has a historical bent on how the court system worked in Ancient Rome but the principles apply in general today. As an attorney and one who did debate in school, I wish someone had handed this to me back when I was 14.
An interesting piece. The last paragraph will provide summary:
"Indeed I have shown how in every type of cause one ought to find ideas. I have told how it is proper to arrange these. I have disclosed the method of delivery. I have taught how we can have a good memory. I have explained the means by which to secure a finished style. If we follow these principles, our Invention will be keen and prompt, our Arrangement clear and orderly, our Delivery impressive and graceful, our Memory sure and lasting, our Style brilliant and charming. In the art of rhetoric, then, there is no more. All these faculties we shall attain if we supplement the precepts of theory with diligent practice." page 411
Can't believe I only gave this four stars when I first read it seven years ago. I've taught this text for more than five years now and my love for it continues to grow. It surpasses all other rhetorical handbooks from antiquity in terms of accessibility. Aristotle's Rhetoric is written for philosophers--insightful for the inquiring mind but not especially practical. Cicero's De Inventione is much more practical but underdeveloped and a bit disorganized--he only covers one of the five canons and presents some problematic views that he later renounced. Quintilian offers far richer exposition, but his book is many volumes, making it a bit unwieldy. The Ad Herennium is one volume and covers all five canons of rhetoric. Moreover, it is organized well and is written in clear and concise prose. The section on memory is particularly famous and was the main impetus for getting me interested in mnemonics. My only complaint is that it does not present as robust a topical system as Cicero's De Inventione or Topica and that it does not categorize stases in the traditional way, opting for "Conjectural," "Juridical," "Legal" instead of "Conjectural," "Definitional," "Qualitative," and "Translative." Oh, and Cicero was not the author. Goodreads is lying to you.
Although (1) Cicero didn't really write it, (2) it says nothing truly original, and (3) it was written over 2,000 years ago, this is an excellent trial advocacy manual.
Difficult at first but once I got the terms and the structure down it became easier to navigate. The book is thorough and the organization is superb. It is the most interesting text book I have ever read. As a reference book, it is indispensable and I will likely refer to it many more times in my life.
This is was not an easy read, more than 2k years ago it was written in Latin with lots of content translated from Greek, then it was translated again to English, my second language. It was a challenge but that is not to say that I didn't enjoy it. I will definitely use it as a manual to plan out speeches and presentations. Oh I also came to this book from "Moonwalking with Einstein".
In book three, you will find one of the most complete descriptions of artificial memory in classical literature. This is quoted and commented upon in Yates' Art of Memory.
Also in book three, is a treatment of what we now call elocution & gesture, which contains the inteteresting expression "vox depressa" which I assume means "lowered larynx" as in operatic singing.
It is easy to see why it was attributed to Cicero as the first two books are very similar to De Inventione. The fourth book is about style.
If you have read other books on these subjects it will mostly be of the same sort, i.e. it follows Aristotle's rhetoric or other lost Greek works in its divisions of the subject, and says mostly the same thing as all the other writers say. But it is a good text, and I see why it was rhe favourite in the middle ages. The latin is easy to read, aside from a few technical expressions; it is more interesting as a composition than Cicero's de Inventione, which is a very spartan text tacked onto two very well written prefaces; and it also contains everything one might want to know about rhetoric.
Having received this as a gift, there were no real expectations going in. A textbook of ancient Roman rhetorical practices is interesting but not much more. Attributed to Cicero (but no longer), this text offers itself as a comprehensive guide to the art of rhetoric.
For legal historians or those interested in law, it might have had more value. Even then, however, I think the content is too shallow for one to really gain. Each piece of advice/ each tactic is given an example and then we move on. There are discourses on delivery, memory, style, and arrangement but none really last in any meaningful sense.
The most interesting part of the text were the examples themselves. Pulling from ancient Greek dramas to historical Roman events, the examples were a collection of the classics we are aware of. Some of the examples are from works we no longer possess but it's surprising how much we do have from the Greeks and how much overlap there was between our own "Ancient Greek" Canon and the one employed in the textbook.
Una joya. Los consejos de memoria son muy buenos y completamente actuales, funcionan de maravilla, primer testimonio de el gran método de memorizar que es el de los lugares. Su organización de las figuras retóricas se sigue empleando hoy y como manual de retórica para introducirse en la retórica clásica es una joya, está muy bien expuesto, no es muy profundo pero queda todo bien expuesto y las distinciones principales como las partes del discurso, los tipos de discurso y los estilos quedan muy claros, en mi opinión mejor que La invención retórica de Cicerón, con el que se suele comparar.
Además de su gran valor intrínseco, siempre resulta interesante conocer los libros que han influido a lo largo de la historia, aunque solo sea para comprender mejor a otros grandes autores y este es, sin duda, uno de esos libros.
He has some good points and strategies for speaking which can be used probably very effectively. His approach, however, is not one I would find myself relating to, as he often relies on ad Hominum type devices to make his opponents look bad, or to make himself appear more credible. Still, in other areas, it's quite helpful, and not morally corrupt.
Something are timeless just the words change. Cicero calls a memory palace a background. The rest of what he says is only obscure when he references people never heard of in the 21st century. Vivid images and places in the series is the key to memorizing anything.
Difficult read but very interesting. The origins of law stem from this book. Was a sequel to moonwalking with einstein for me given the references to it in the book
Interesting look at classical techniques for developing argument, classifying and presenting information and for all elements associated with dialogue. Surprisingly well presented and easy to use.
As a guide to the acquisition of the fine art of public speaking and an outline of the constituent parts to employ to achieve various effects through language and delivery, Cicero's book, written ostensibly for his friend Herennius, is still the standard text.
I undertook reading this book for Cicero's treatment of memory as an oratorical necessity. Ad Herennium was mentioned several times in Foer's Moonwalking with Einstein, which I recently read, but Cicero's commentary on how to develop and how to use a well-trained memory is only a very short middle section in this book. I might have just combed through it for the bit on memory but I confess I would have missed much clever, entertaining and instructive writing and still be left without a serviceable idea of what this celebrated book is about, so I'm quite content to have read through it all.
The "Rhetoric for Herrenius" was probably not written by Cicero, although he most certainly used the text as a "handbook." Nevertheless, it is a brilliant, comprehensive study of rhetoric and oratory that contains advice and principles that are valuable to the modern writer.
I came across this book from Douglas Wilson. I would recommend his book, "The Rhetoric Companion" unless you want in depth details. This book nails everything on Rhetoric. I loved the section about Memory.