This story is told in several different timelines, incorporating the 2005 original murder investigation into the slaying of 14 year old Abigail Riley, 2016 when the killers are released and relocated to the far reaches of the planet with new identities, 2020 when Jimmy Riley receives anonymous help to locate them and the present day Canada and New Zealand where they are making new lives, not realising that their days may be numbered. The switches back and forth are well labelled and never become confusing, as we read about the shocking murder and the lasting effects it has on all those involved, family and detectives alike. After Abigail’s body is discovered in an underground bunker on waste ground in North London, the murder team, led by DS Fraser Harvey of the Metropolitan Police, believes they are looking for a man, a disturbed individual who has committed some form of crimes before, building up to this horrific murder. No one even thinks the impossible – that a child or children may be responsible for the brutal rape, multiple stabbing and mutilation of a sweet innocent girl. However the two young suspects are quickly found, and present a very odd couple. Of the two differing personalities, it is hard for the detectives to judge which one is the leader. One thing is for sure though – one of them is a very good actor, but as the storyline twists back and forth, will the truth ever emerge?
It was hard not to draw comparisons with a certain real life case where two children murdered another younger child. The shock and public outrage there is evident in this story too, as is the need to forge new identities and the knowledge that if ever the killers were outed, they would be in immediate danger from a large number of people wanting revenge and retribution. Also similarly present is the worry that they will offend again when released into the world. It is very interesting that the author can generate such a feeling of hatred for the original killers but not so for the vigilante – does that say more about the victim and type of crime than the killer themselves? A need for natural justice to prevail?
This isn’t so much a whodunit, as the reader knows the details of the case in 2005, also the identities of the culprits then and now, and also the name of the person hunting them. But who has divulged that all-important information? And will the true details of Abigail’s murder ever be revealed?
This story is skilfully told, making it easy to like, empathise and hate the various different characters in turn. The subject matter may be difficult for some readers to stomach but for those who can, this is a chilling and engrossing book with a very satisfying outcome for all. 5*